"Went In for the first time ever this week! The couple who owns the store do it all and the are the kindest, genuine people. Cookies were yummy...."
Kelli Kniss
"Every year we go to the Ocean City NJ shore we spend time feasting on the various culinary delights. Crazy Susan’s cookies are one of our..."
Mark S Smith
"Crazy Susan makes some amazing cookie varieties! You don't want to leave the beach without paying her shop a visit...."
Malcolm Diggs
"Crazy Susan's cookies are crazy delicious! I love all of them. The butterfinger one, the sugar one, the Reese's one, but my favorite is the Mayor...."
Max Dee
"Honestly the best cookies I’ve ever..."
Trinity K
"I ordered a cookie cake for my granddaughter‘s 15th birthday. The whole family absolutely loved it! Susan was wonderful. We also tried a couple..."
Jean cherry
"Try the “hot chocolate” chocolate chip cookie. So soft and moist and melts in your mouth. Tastes just like hot chocolate. Chocolate chip cookie..."
Steve Pierantozzi
"Just had THE best cookies in my entire life. So good I had to post about it. 💖 Crazy Susan's is adorable. The inside smelled out-of-this-world..."
Seth Martin
"Susan Holender: customer, Ocean City, NJ
Eleven years ago, my husband and I discovered Crazy Susan Cookies in Ocean City, New Jersey. Once you walk..."
Jack Holender
"Please support this business! With all the ice cream and pastry stores around, we were excited to find this place and give something different a try...."
Kim S
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes