The best Restaurants in Oconomowoc ranking of February 2025
109 restaurant menus in Oconomowoc, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"I went to a tasting event at Sobie’s restaurant in Oconomowoc tonight and found it to be a delightful experience from start to finish. The..."
Patricia Groves Jahr
"Bryant and I went last night for our first time and everything was outstanding! Caribbean jerk broasted wings were the best flavor ever! The tomato..."
Kimberly Stark
"My wife and I sat at the bar for a couple drinks. Bartender was great. Loved the walnut bar top and local beers.
We got crab cakes which I liked..."
Mark Mullarky
"I’ve gone their twice. Both times food was excellent!!! Service was great also. Highly recommend this..."
Aaron Abraham
"Lydia and Mike plus the staff are amazing. Have to say that this was some of best food I’ve ever had. Anything they offer is beyond delicious..."
Janine Chatfield
"We went to Sobie’s our first time for date night this past weekend....the food is incredible! We shared 6 broasted wings over a glass of really..."
Cindy Nauertz
"My son and I went to dinner, this eve. We ran into good friends, and shared a table. We arrived early, and by the time we left, the room was full...."
Karen Schlender Trepton
"If you are in Oconomowoc make sure to check out this great new restaurant. Very cute. The food was delicious...all fresh and local ingredients. Our..."
Ryan McAdams
"First time dining here this evening and I will look forward to returning again soon. Our waitress (Amy) was very knowledgeable and attentive. The cup..."
Lori Loessin
"Went here this past Friday with my wife, son and a friend. We had a reservation and we were seated right on time. The staff was extremely friendly..."
Chris Williams
"My sister and I went mid-May for lunch. We the first people in at the time but it filled up quickly. We both had the lump crab salad. It was..."
Torey Pritchard
"We came here for a Friday Fish Fry. We did make reservations and I would highly recommend making reservations! We had attentive service. We ordered a..."
Heather Rathjen
"Stopped in for a few appetizers before a wedding! If you like food on the spicy side this is the place to go. The smoked Manhattan was outstanding!..."
Ms.Z
"We sat at the bar and she ordered the Scallops and I got the Steak Poutines.
The Scallops and Risotto were perfect... buttery. My steak was also..."
Mike
"When it comes to consistency Sobie's takes the cake! It is so hard to review a restaurant because one day its delicious and the next day it is so so...."
Tristan Brock
"Food and cocktails were great! Staff was friendly, however, during the afternoon our server was sweeping floor with broom and bringing glass ware out..."
B R
"What a pleasant dining experience. Temperature was well regulated. Menu is very interesting. The food was quality and very flavorful. Reservations..."
Kevin Keller
"Went on mother's day which was super busy and normally the food and service isn't good at most places on those days but they knocked it out of the..."
"I've lived in Hartland 29 years & always knew what a staple of a place The Kiltie was but for some reason our family never tried it. Anyway after..."
Luann CK
"The food is always great but this visit, the server found out it was our son's birthday, put a candle in his sundae and recruited 3 other servers to..."
Sandra Schoenherr Uttech
"An Oconomowoc rite of Spring! First night open. Great food and service. Observation: The Kiltie is cash only. In years past, the wait staff would..."
Lauren Wilke
"Nice little drive in restaurant. Chicken tenders and cheese curds are great! The burger is not so great. And the vanilla ice cream has an odd flavor..."
Michelle Long
"Always enjoy The Kilties food, custard and ambiance 🤗 Birgers, chicken, bbq sandwich, homemade custard for sundaes, gloats and mixers …how can..."
Kristine Nelson
"Unique place to drive in and eat. You pull in. Park. Look up to choose the dishes. And place the order through helpful team members always available...."
Sanjay S
"Burger was good the fries awesome with a large amount and she strawberry malts was awesome nice pieces of strawberry that couldn't make it thru the..."
Lori Tiegs
"I was in town visiting a friend who recommended the Kiltie. Was waited on by Natalya who was very attentive, quick, and knowledgeable. She was the..."
Jeff
"Came with an entire soccer team after our last game and the staff was great. Our food arrived fast and everything was..."
"WOW! I hope when they open the new location all the baristas will follow! Great staff, very friendly, HARD WORKING, smiling faces! Shout out to a..."
Nichole Wright
"You hopefully already know what Starbucks is. Therefore read these five stars as a full endorsement of the fun staff, well designed space and..."
Joe Cavanaugh
"Very friendly staff and the inside is nicely decorated. Coffee was served reasonably. Exactly what we ordered even after changing the order a couple..."
Keith Williams
"The 2 girls working were Rachel and addie they were super nice made the drinks fast. They were 10/10 for customer..."
Lucy Rockteacher
"Addie and Rachel were my servers today and they were very nice, easy going, and overall amazing they created my drink first.they gave me great..."
Khloe Kerr
"Staff was friendly and area was clean. Got my order right the first time. Only downfall is it is a smaller location with no..."
"Went in to order since the drive thru was super long. The lady helping take our order seemed frustrated and confused, but the food came out quickly..."
Me
"Good food. Smaller Culver's. Was busy but still got our food out..."
Scott R
"It's always a good place for burgers and custard. The food is always hot and fresh. It comes out ASAP, and customer service is always 5 stars. This..."
Andrew Davis
"We are doing low carb and got the pot roast dinner without gravy, onions, bread, and potatoes but got 2 sides of broccoli. Big portions and it was..."
"Crafty cow is one of the best places I have been too in a long time. Not only are the burgers great but the most recent special additions have added..."
Christopher James Newton
"Called ahead for a reservation for 5 people at 6:00 pm since I know the German Market was taking place. We arrived right at 6:00 pm and were seated..."
Joshua Rewasiewicz
"First time eating tonight. Was worth every single penny! Our server Hadley was amazing!!!! Everything from the taste of the food to the service was..."
Ashley Marie
"By far the best burger in the area, and ooohh those fries!! Finally a place that is actually doing real cooking. Hand cut fries and fresh ground..."
Connie Schwartz
"We go here all the time and love it! The staff is always super friendly and how can you not love the food! Their drinks and food are..."
Jenifer Marie
"This place is great. Went on a Friday and received immediate seating. Friendly staff. Great burgers and beee. I have also went with a group of 12-15..."
Tanya Meiter
"Absolutely love The Crafty Cow’s menu. They are always trying new combos. They also have one of the best seasoned burgers in the area. There are a..."
Cory Peters
"I was Impressed. Some Fried Pickles, A Blackberry Old Fashioned (shared), I had myself a chicken sandwich Peaches Please. The food was delicious,..."
Linda Fisher
"This place is one of a kind, even in a crafty and cow state place like Wisconsin! They recently won a Bloody Mary contest and I can tell why. Between..."
Miah Furness
"Waitress was attentive, helpful (with beer and food selection), and genuinely friendly. Very comfortable evening casual atmosphere. I had to give the..."
James Ganiere
"Service was beyond outstanding and even while the whole place was packed, our server still managed to make my lady and I feel like the only couple..."
Matt Duehring
"Great food, prices are pretty high though so just go here every once in awhile. The loaded cheese curds were pretty awesome though. But for one..."
"It seems as though this location has struggled with quality employees but I think they have rectified the issue because our service was great! All..."
Nick Westfall
"Had the best tacos ever! The young man at the window was very courtesy and friendly.
Fast great food. Thanks guys...."
Marcia Turner
"I was out salting roads all day and... I don't usually stop at ANY fast food place much after the dinner rush if I can avoid it. You understand what..."
"Met a couple of friends for dinner there on a Thursday night at about 5. It was relatively busy and they were seemingly understaffed. We sat at the..."
Jennifer Elkins
"An all around great experience! Although the place was busy on a Friday night we got our food relatively quickly. The server was energetic and very..."
Malachi Dornfeld
"Rode the bike to breakfast and was not disappointed.
Kayla was our server and she was quite possibly one of the most personable waitresses we've ever..."
Carrie Zylka
"I had the steak sandwich with fries. My friend had the French onion soup and a Reuben and both were really good and served hot. Service was good...."
Helen Miller
"Food was great! Bartender was wonderful! Would go back 100% They even sang happy birthday to my..."
Kayla H
"Stopped in for a drink. Place was very comfortable atmosphere. Employees were very efficient. Saw one of there burgers and fries. We will be Going..."
Kathy Cottone
"Food was delicious! Waitress was very friendly. I would recommend this place as a fun place to eat with good food. I had the Baron Beef Sandwich..."
"This is one of our favorite places to go in Lake Country. We haven't had anything less than delicious off of their menu yet, but our favorites are..."
Taylor Poehls
"Great bar food! We dined on fried shrimp, jerk pork and fried pickles. Everything was hot and tasty. The fried pickles were some of the best I've..."
Stacy K
"Fantastic fish fry!
Great potato pancakes, German potato salad, slaw, homemade fries, great fish.
Well worth the 12.95..
Will be back, great..."
Dave Goetzel
"Stopped in tonight to watch the Badger game and have a quick bite to eat. Jeff the owner suggested I try their Gluten free pizza. I was so..."
Jennifer J
"I was dying for a fish fry to go. I haven't been here in over 10 years but I remember they had an amazing bluegill fish fry. I checked online and..."
Shaun Dailey
"I love this place very much. theres a different mood. The food is exeptionaly good. the service is effective and the waiters are trained. The pay is..."
Thomas Shellman
"I've been getting wings there on the occasional Tuesday for the past 6 months. Does not disappoint. The beer is cold too. Would..."
"I've lived in Hartland 29 years & always knew what a staple of a place The Kiltie was but for some reason our family never tried it. Anyway after..."
Luann CK
"The food is always great but this visit, the server found out it was our son's birthday, put a candle in his sundae and recruited 3 other servers to..."
Sandra Schoenherr Uttech
"An Oconomowoc rite of Spring! First night open. Great food and service. Observation: The Kiltie is cash only. In years past, the wait staff would..."
Lauren Wilke
"Nice little drive in restaurant. Chicken tenders and cheese curds are great! The burger is not so great. And the vanilla ice cream has an odd flavor..."
Michelle Long
"Always enjoy The Kilties food, custard and ambiance 🤗 Birgers, chicken, bbq sandwich, homemade custard for sundaes, gloats and mixers …how can..."
Kristine Nelson
"Unique place to drive in and eat. You pull in. Park. Look up to choose the dishes. And place the order through helpful team members always available...."
Sanjay S
"Burger was good the fries awesome with a large amount and she strawberry malts was awesome nice pieces of strawberry that couldn't make it thru the..."
Lori Tiegs
"I was in town visiting a friend who recommended the Kiltie. Was waited on by Natalya who was very attentive, quick, and knowledgeable. She was the..."
Jeff
"Came with an entire soccer team after our last game and the staff was great. Our food arrived fast and everything was..."
"Really good pizza! Excellent service! Pizza was out quickly and he kept checking on us to make sure we were happy or if we needed anything. Also very..."
Angela Drayer
"Delicious as always! Food was excellent and the service was great..."
Travis Sawyer
"2 of us ordered fried scallops, 1 ordered fish fry. The fish fry was very good. Both orders of scallops were heavily coated and slightly over done...."
Barbara Olson
"Oh I love Pizza Hut. I haven't been there in years and I had it last week. Tasted just as good!! My..."
Margaret W
"The cheese stuffed crust was very satisfying at this fine joint we call Pizza Hut. It isn't just fun and games when they say nobody out Pizzas the..."
It'sEv
"Delivered faster than the estimated time noted when I placed the order and the food was fresh and still..."
Riley Bat
"Kate was very sweet. Food was nice and hot. Fast..."
"I had dinner here last night with my friend. The service was incredible. The restaurant was very busy but the wait staff was friendly and efficient. ..."
Judy P
"First time here, really good. Really REALLY good service from the man at the bar, and fast. Appropriate wait time for food.
We ordered the thin..."
Emily Fischer
"Excellent pizza! New to the area, and have driven over from Watertown twice to pickup, since it seems the Watertown location is no longer in..."
Joe Phillips
"We had a booth right in front of the door way which was kind of cold sometimes. It was a Wednesday night so it wasn't very busy but there was..."
Linda Fisher
"The hosts and servers were very pleasant and good to deal with. The food is as good as any other Rosati’s location. A good place for families, date..."
"Always love coming too this location. Staff is always friendly, orders are usually always made correctly, and most importantly the food is normally..."
Brian Fahrnow
"They did an awesome job on my brisket sandwich. Love Arby's in general, one of the best fast food chains.
Just have to note the location is showing..."
Bradley Hall
"Me and my family had a delicious meal on Saturday afternoon. We wanted to go back on Sunday (yesterday) but thought they might think we were stalking..."
Carmen G
"First time there last night for fish sandwich deal and they had 2 sandwiches that were on the warmer for just a couple minutes and the manager???..."
Scott Smith
"The food is fantastic. Service friendly. Something for everyone's taste. Sliders answer a family appetites. I had 4 sliders, beef n cheese,..."
Bonnie Von Rueden
"Amanda was AMAZING! Very rare to walk into a fast food restaurant and get such a warm welcome and such OUTSTANDING customer service! Kudos to her it..."
"Oh man, G-webs hits different at 3 AM. That’s all I gotta say. 3 star restaurant during the day, after 12 AM it magically turns into 5 stars...."
Samantha Taylor
"Omg we absolutely love love love the Oconomowoc Webb. Never been to many others , but Robert is amazing! Hands down the most amazing cook , server..."
BW Duke Studios
"Food and service were both great. Very quick too - order to table less than five..."
Jacob Wandsnider
"The guys running the place at the time were super friendly. It's my first time eating at one of these places in a while.
I suppose it's a good..."
Daniel F
"Service quick. Food good. It is basic coffee shop/diner atmosphere. Great if you are in a hurry and know that it is nothing fancy but great..."
Chandra B
"Food was nicely cooked & waitress did her job. A few tables were left uncleared the whole time we were there. We were the only ones in..."
Lisa Larsen
"Friendly Service, bean soup was good. First time I've been in a George Webb in quite a few years. They are..."
Jimee Stewart
"If they served real butter with their great pancakes GW would hit it out of the..."
"Manager Nick was awesome, greeted me when walked in, cooking, stocking getting orders ready for delivery, all at the same time taking my order and..."
"Absolutely amazing! Great atmosphere, fantastic selection of delicious desserts, the pizza & pinsa are seriously awesome! Our family dines there as..."
Heidi Nielsen
"This place rocks!! The new pizza oven is very cool and the stuff coming out of it is out of this world.
They have one of the best and affordable wine..."
Rob Obradovich
"Loved that it’s locally owned & operated. You must try the Italian sausage, it’s fantastic! High marks for creating an authentic Italian cafe..."
Craig Husar
"We stopped in today and ordered a great bottle of wine at a very reasonable price. I asked if they had a cheese tray to go with the wine. Our..."
David Kwarciany
"Great food and Great people! Love this place the special of the day never disappoints. Would recommend this awesome deli to..."
Ryan Priegel
"Tried the Pinsa tonight....so yummy and the crust was perfection!!! The place looks great Renee & Tom!!! Cheers to continued..."
Vickie Rock
"Beautiful Italian place right out of Hallmark movie. They have delicious food, an extensive wine list, and some of the best cannolis and..."
Dora Hernandez
"I'm from Chicago Illinois. I have not found a place like this since I moved up here in 2001. These owners should be so proud. I've only been able to..."
Darren Becker
"Was there for my first-time at our work xmas party.
Very nice inside...great hospitality...good food..lasagna..chicken parm..
Desserts were to die..."
Joanne Cook
"All I can say is amazing food amazing service and amazing atmosphere I recommend this to any one in town or visiting town. They never..."
Troy LeFebvere
"We are fairly regular customers and tend to order our same favorites each time, they never disappoint. But with dinner options like the spaghetti and..."
Shelly Flaten-Moore
"Seriously! One of the best beef Sammy's i have ever had! Food is always consistent! They have indoor and outdoor seating. Keep up the great work..."
Jolyn Damrow
"Best Caesar salad I've ever had. Compliments to the chef. Accompanied with kind, genuine service to make for a lovely lunch. Highly..."
Jessica Decker
"We visited for dinner on July 9. The Italian beef was amazing!! We loved the service, loved the food and loved the..."
Diane Lund
"We have been to Bella Gusto many times and the food is always good. If the owners are there they will engage in conversation with you. Tonight I..."
"We went here for dinner. We thoroughly enjoyed our experience. We went mid week later evening so it was quiet- we had great service, very attentive..."
Heather Rathjen
"It was a busy fish fry Friday evening. We had a little wait to get seated. Our drink orders were taken immediately. The service was warm and..."
Cheryl Songer
"Stopped in at Ron's for their fish fry. I had the deep fried Walleye, husband had the combination platter and grandson had the fried cod. Each meal..."
Carol Schmuki
"Delicious broasted chicken. Waitress was awesome. Only one server and she ran it like a boss. No complaints about being busy. Just did a great job...."
brenda A
"Had another wonderful fish fry with the family! Call ahead reservation is a must since SO many people greatly enjoy a Rons fish fry. We have been..."
Kim Arellano
"We just traveled to oconomomawac for this weekend to see friends. On our way home and got some great lunch. We got gyros, burgers and pizza. Staff..."
"I believe that Amalia's is top of the line, for the pass ten years we have ate there several time . At no time have we ever been treated with..."
Debbie Zirnhelt
"We have been to Amalia's a few times when they weren't very busy and always had a superior meal and excellent service. Yesterday was different only..."
Jody Tocco Probst
"I've been to Amalia's several times for lunch during the work week and had great food and service. Saturday morning we stopped in for breakfast for..."
Gary Strobach
"One of the best breakfast we’ve had in a while. Superior staff..."
Carol Varnell Gegner
"We went for breakfast at about 9am on a Saturday, so obviously busy...we were greeted with coffee and water and a high chair for our almost 2 year..."
Jessica Guenther
"Awesome breakfast! Great Service! Friendly staff and bottomless coffee!!! This will definitely be our go to Breakfast restaurant!!! The homemade..."
Athena BigMountain
"Everything, whether it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, is phenomenal! You haven't lived until you have tried their triple berry stuffed French toast..."
Aubrey Anton
"My parents and I had breakfast at Amalia's on 12/22 and we just loved the food! It's our pre-Christmas tradition to go to Amalia's for breakfast and..."
Katherine Michalets Beck
"We totally enjoyed our breakfast!! All the servers are extremely friendly. We will be..."
Kat Renz
"We stopped into Amalia's shortly before they were scheduled to close on a Sunday. We sat down at the counter, and were prompty greeted by Amalia. Her..."
Gabriel Hicks
"Good food, good service, friendly staff. Order came quick--on a busy..."
John L Hoh Jr
"Great food and wonderful service. Will be back!..."
Debra MammaBlue YoungTroutman
"I've eaten breakfast here 3 times for breakfast and lunch once. Each time the restaurant was very busy but the staff kept up with the pace. Menu is..."
Peter
"Small town diner feel, with yummy eggs benedict and servers that keep the coffee..."
Kelsey
"Wide variety of foods, prepared well, modest prices, in a family diner..."
Senufu
"Homestyle food at a decent price. Good for..."
Pixie
"Ordered the stuffed French toast. The cream cheese filling was more like a powered sugar frosting. Overly sweet and very gritty. Most of the..."
SFaye Kachikis
"I'll start this review by saying our son stated the restaurant should be named, 'Best-aurant'.
We came in from out of state and were hankering for a..."
Robert Hazen
"This is one awesome restaurant. We were 4 people in our party and were served all our meals in 7 minutes! This in my eyes is a world record! The food..."
Daleen Pommerel
"Love this place! Always great service! The food comes out quick and delicious! Also very reasonably priced 👍 Family owned and ran. This is ALWAYS..."
Me
"Fresh, delicious food, friendly staff, good prices, and incredibly fast service. Our food always comes out of the kitchen less than five minutes..."
James Westhoff
"Amalia's is local restaurant right in the heart of downtown Oconomowoc. It certainly isn't 'fancy' however, I can guarantee you won't find a better..."
Dianne Wardinski
"The staff are the kindest people I have ever met. Personally have had great experiences with Amalia and Sam. The food is great always, but especially..."
"We were in Oconomowoc around lunchtime on Sunday. We saw Mantra had really good reviews so decided to give it a try. I tend to be partial to Indian..."
Rick Leed
"Mantra is definitely the best Indian food I've ever had, anywhere. Absolutely everything is great, but personal favorites are both the..."
DW
"First timers- we will be back.. My family is very impressed by the quality of their food. We were hesitant to bring the kids here but our 11 year old..."
Daegonsma
"Lamb masala, chicken curry, tandoori chicken, naan, jasmine rice. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Restaurant was a bit un kept but the food will keep me coming..."
Acheever14
"The food was really good, but the service was terrible! The waiter was a teenage boy, so perhaps he was new and inexperienced. I will give the..."
Bethany Frost-Peters
"EXCELLENT. I have never had much Indian food until I ate at Mantra. The food is excellent and their home made breads are out of this word. I now eat..."
Barbarajane12
"Authentic Indian food with exceptional service. The restaurant could have been a little cleaner but the food made up for..."
Angela
"As an Englishman who recently moved over here I've been in dire need of a great Indian restaurant. Mantra Indian Bistro was our first try and I've..."
Vikorz
"Love all the vegetarian options! The vegetable samosas were incredible and I wish I would have gotten two orders! The mixed vegetable curry was..."
Emily Greene
"This is my favorite place in oconomowoc. The food is on point every time. I wish they opened their dinning room and cleaned up the outside. If this..."
Scott
"I was super hungry. Tried their Sweet corn soup and chicken madrasa with tandoor bread. Over all satisfied. Can't say amazed. Being Indian I tried to..."
Kunal Mitra
"I finally tried this place out, and I'm so glad I did! This is the best Indian food I've ever had. The butter chicken entrée will be at least two..."
Edee Jen
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes