Great food, extremely talented live band, a great spot to eat and hangout! We got the alligator, chicken strips, mahi tacos and roadhouse burger and they were all amazing!! If you eat inside you may have to shout to hear one another over the band- but it's great music and a great vibe if you don't mind it! Definitely will recommend this spot to others 👍🏼
AN UPDATE :______
this week’ dining experience at Fish on Fire was totally different than last week.
All the fish meals were on par, with the seared tuna and the catfish nuggets being standouts. The wings were surprisingly good for a seafood restaurant. Again, the hush puppies and gator bites were also excellent.
For dessert, the “ homemade “ banana crèam pie was superb. The key lime pie was also very delicious. Although personally I would have enjoyed a touch more key lime taste.
Again not the place for burgers. Although it is a great place for some good seafood dishes.
Glad we gave this restaurant a second chance. We well be back again.
I recently dined at "Fish on Fire," a charming local seafood restaurant. The grouper fish and alligator bites were delightful, and the burgers also hit the mark. However, I couldn't help but notice that the interior felt a bit dated and had a lingering smell. If they can address these issues, it would be an excellent dining experience. I'd rate it 8/10
We were looking for some fresh seafood after flying in from St Louis. The immediate service with a packed house was impressive. Very attentive waiter with a great recommendation for the grouper. It was phenomenal! The atmosphere was upbeat and fun with live music. We didn't care for the banana cream pie though. It had a funny flavor. Would return for the amazing grouper!
Went based on a Google review. They were right! Great place. Our waiter was very personable and made great recommendations 👏! There was Live music. And the food was awesome! Highly recommend!!
Great visit, we enjoyed the service and tasty food. The blackened Mahi sandwich was delicious! Alligator bites were interesting, never had gator before- the texture and taste is like a cross between chicken and fish.
Met one of the employees who recommended me stop by, and I was not disappointed. Live music, friendly staff, and great food. One of the BEST burgers I’ve had all year. We also ordered Key West shrimp skewers which were great. Value for the food was good, will return in the future.
Cool place. I had lunch ($15)there and need to go back for drinks and dinner. The food was absolutely delicious. Fresh and refreshing. Love it.
Great place, awesome vibe, friendly people and good food. Try the gator bites or shrimp tacos!
Jay Herrington is great and it shows in the way his restaurant is run. I went to a special fund raiser for hurricane relief. I had a great time, the food and atmosphere were perfect
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes