Best Burger in Oyster Bay

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Wild Honey Restaurant
Wild Honey Restaurant
89/100 (1074 ratings)
Restaurants
Gastropub
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Wine Bar
American
Wine Bar
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Salmon
Burger
Halibut
Shrimp
Ribs
Crawfish
Salad
Catfish
Scallops
Bouillabaisse
Clams
Fish
Oyster
Calamari
Mussels
Calamares
Sit down
American
Wine Bar
Seafood
Gastropub
Seating
Gift Cards Available
Table Service
Free off-street parking
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Reservations
Dinner
Drinks
Mid-range
"Had a few appetizers. Baked oysters, calamari and lobster crab cakes. Nice outside atmosphere. Welcomed our dogs on the outside patio...."
Donna Jean
"I give this Restaurant a 5 star The food the presentation the service the decor ...We went with 2 other couples and we all loved it ... We will be..."
Christina Tabano Mooney
"We came here for our anniversary dinner(this is our special place). Great food and romantic atmosphere; don't forget to leave some room for dessert...."
Yev Romanoff
"Never had a bad meal here, always consistent, quality food, usually always get the spicey prawns unless a great special like last eve, halibut over..."
Sissy Albergo
"The food was amazing !! I would totally keep going back here. My 3rd time there. They always accommodate us. The service was also 5..."
Jason A Martello
"Based on food, bar, service, ambiance and cost, its the best restaurant on Long Island. always exceeds expectations, and everyone there will treat..."
Mitchell Brookstone
"Love this restaurant always treated well had a large party and they accommodated us, food is always delicious wonderful service I truly appreciate..."
Malachi Davis
"Traveling all the way from Brooklyn through the slow moving traffic of the Belt Pkwy was well worth it. The food and service lived up to the..."
Thomas Taylor
"Have never had a bad time or meal at Wildhoney, always the..."
Mike O'Brien
"Good food and a nice atmosphere, a great spot for dinner, drinks or a lottle..."
Noreen Fitzgerald-Makar
"Great food, strong drinks and friendly staff- they make you feel like..."
Daryl Ranaldo
"My other half and I visited Wild Honey on our first date. It seemed like the perfect place to go after the the Planting fields. Especially on our..."
John H.
"We had a delicious dinner and good evening with outdoor dining at Wild Honey for my Daughters Birthday. The service was outstanding with an attentive..."
Bruce W
"My wife and I are just ate here, and it was such an excellent choice, we can’t wait to come back! I had the Baby Back Ribs and she had an oyster..."
Devin _NYC
"What a treat! This is a very special place. Great ambiance, warm, cozy, intimate, inviting and delicious....just wonderful! The service was fast and..."
Paul Vetrano
"My fiance and I decided to stop by after our photoshoot nearby. This came up on our suggestions and it was great! The food tasted fresh and it was..."
Patsy Pichardo
"Great food and atmosphere. Staff are very attentive to anything that may be..."
Jim Holland
"Upscale and attractive Oyster Bay restaurant with sidewalk seating available in most seasons. Although it is certainly fine dining, it is also..."
Keith Friedlander
"Decided to try this place for a birthday celebration, and was primarily a nice evening with a little disappointment. The service was very good and..."
M Scotto
"We happened upon this charming gem after visiting Sagamore Hill. Had the Mexicali Shrimp wrap which was delicious. Super fresh ingredients and the..."
Jane Page
"This is such a great restaurant. The atmosphere was very cozy, the service was wonderful and the food was impeccable. Maria and joey were so..."
ed hoffman
"We loved this place! They were very nice and make sure they could take us as we did not had a reservation. Food was delicious! We sat at the bar and..."
Ilia Galguera
"The photos really don’t do the food justice. I wish I had captured photos of more than the desserts, but we enjoyed everything too quickly! The..."
Jennifer Royall
"One of the last warm evenings to dine outside with great service and wonderful food! The ribs and cat fish were nice. Pet friendly..."
John Hatalovsky Jr
"Came in for an early dinner and everything from the food to the drinks were A+! To start, we had the Tuna Tartare, Fig-Balsamic Glazed Burrata,..."
Ashima Thomas
"Everything was delicious. Edit: I was just going through reviews and found this one and I don't think my five star rating and one sentence was..."
Lindsay Heller
"I have been here numerous times, and it’s always sensational. It’s dark inside so it’s a bit difficult to get a really great picture of the..."
Eric Berman (Eric Berman Real Estate)
"I arrived with my gf just before 5PM while they were doing outdoor dining due to Covid. There was one couple enjoying drinks at a 4 person table and..."
Vin D
"The restaurant provided exceptional service, with a courteous and friendly waiter. The decor and seating were both pleasant, and the variety of food..."
MORTIZ
"Lovely little restaurant that has a very nice menu, quality food and drinks and is in the middle of the town and convenient. Great wine list and..."
Annamae Mckerns
Coach Grill & Tavern
Coach Grill & Tavern
85/100 (382 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Seafood
Grill
Pub
American
Grill
Seafood
American
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Salad
Clams
Duck
Oyster
Sit down
American
Pub
Seafood
Grill
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We found Coach Grill and Tavern on Google when we were looking for a place to eat in Oyster Bay. We’ve eaten there twice already. The place is..."
Dale Cernuda
"Very good service. Food was very good. One meal was not done properly, but overall excellent. Parking..."
M N
"Server was nice and it was good to bring my dog sitting outside. Happy hour is every day 4:30-6:30 that ordering appetizer will be double..."
Julie Jerome
"Had PEI Mussels with Andouille Sausage for my starter... huge serving and perhaps the BEST I have had to date; broth was so delicious. For my main..."
Louis Pritchard
"This place is a hidden gem! The owner came out and made it s special event for our family. The food is great! The service is great! You won't be..."
Daniel Ritchie
"Delicious seafood linguini, fresh oysters and codfish. And most importantly friendly and attentive staff. It is also a dog pet friendly..."
Athena RC
"Hidden gem for a dog friendly restaurant!! Good and service is..."
Na Song
"Whoever the chef is, does one amazing job. Food was all cooked perfectly and tasted great. Very surprised with this place. From the first piece of..."
Colin
"Local neighborhood joint. Great food. Fun..."
Patrizia's Palate
"Ordered the Onion rings and shared the Crab cake for appetizers. For entree, ordered the Crusted salmon and for drinks had a Mojito. Everything that..."
vishal thapa
Taby's Burger House
Taby's Burger House
81/100 (1155 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
American
Diner
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Hamburgers
Beef
Salad
Oyster
Gyros
American
Diner
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The Oyster bay burger I ordered was cooked well to my preference, tasted good, and was decently priced. All burgers here have 1/2 lbs (!) of meat,..."
Can N
"A local favorite serving very good food. More like a diner with a large menu. I had to try their burger. I ordered the Taby's Famous 1/2 lb Burger..."
Richard Schagrin
"I'm the manager at the Hope for Long Island Thrift Store. I recently had a luncheon at Tabby's for my staff. The service could not have been better...."
Joe Scibelli
"Fast service,hot food, great hamburgers, always friendly atmosphere, always a table open. There fried zucchini sticks are fantastic. Gyros are..."
Robert Fitzpatrick
"My hamburger was juicy and flavorful. The lettuce was crisp and the tomatoes were sliced nice and thick. Service was a little slow but the place was..."
Joseph Weser
"I ate lunch here yesterday, and it was just as good as I remember it was when I was a little kid! I ordered a junior Oyster Bay burger with a side of..."
Victoria A
"I ordered the Texas burger and was impressed. The meat portion is huge, and fresh. Very tasty and well prepared. Decor was a bit on the outdated side..."
Ludwind SantaCruz
"We really enjoy coming here the Food is good so is the staff & we definitely like the..."
Colette Santini
"Excellent Burger and fries here. Can’t believe I’ve never been here before...."
steve reinberg
"An Oyster Bay institution. This smallish coffee house/diner is the place everyone in town goes for good breakfast and lunch..."
Edward Orlando
"Ordered a bunch of burgers and a kids meal. A bit pricey for diner food, but maybe that's everywhere these days. The burgers were really tasty and..."
Louisa Jauregui
"Oh my god, amazing food, great atmosphere, friendly service. Don't forget to check in with them weekly for their specials they are so..."
Gand E Power
"Very nice restaurant for all 3 meals. Terrific burgers, sandwiches and desserts. Unfortunately I am always full from my meal to not get to dessert at..."
Sean Burnett
"Just ordered the prime rib, it is by far better than any high end steak house . Thank you for a delicious meal, oh and the mashed potatoes were real..."
Pamela Jensen
"we just happened to be in the neighborhood and decided to try it. Very good burgers. Will definitely go..."
michael frisch
"Gyros to die for!! Oh yum!! Excellent service and delightful ambiance...."
Sue Morgan
"Was visiting Glen Cove and was hungry for lunch. Wife and I decided to give this place a try as it was packed with people. Boy are we glad we did. ..."
Jeff Schnee
The Homestead
The Homestead
80/100 (588 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Salad
Wings
Oyster
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"The Homestead has the best burger that I've had in a while. We stopped by during our trip to Oyster Bay and couldn't have asked for a better..."
Jasmine Cha
"Hidden little gem . We Sat in the courtyard in the sun.. the homestead salad was huge and really good. Loved the baked clams..it contained the whole..."
Dana D'Amico
"Excellent big pretzel! Nice and warm and soft and tasty! This is off the main strip in Oyster Bay with all the stores and restaurants to check out!..."
Marion NYC
"We visited when they were a somewhat rushed for service and therefore had to wait a little, but the staff were friendly and understanding (we had..."
Howard
"Great food, great waitress. Good beer selection. Solid neighborhood restaurant. Everyone enjoyed their food and we felt right at home. I can't..."
Mara Leonardi
"My fiance and i had a wonderful time there. There atmosphere was cozy even at the outdoor tables. The food was excellent (definitely get the..."
ed hoffman
"The best oreo martini I have ever..."
Vivian M
"Food was delicious and the drinks were even better! Our waitress was super welcoming and..."
Ana Cruz
"Very friendly bartenders and atmosphere. The bacon cheeseburger actually knocked my socks off. The meat was definitely quality. Highly recommend..."
Clara Samuels
"I've been to the homestead on multiple different occasions and have really enjoyed their food and hospitality. Recently this past weekend I was there..."
J K
"Lisa was fabulous and the calamari was even more fabulous. I was very surprised to have such great tasting food at a restaurant/bar. Diego was..."
Rob Thies
"The food was surprisingly delicious (no offense) and the server was very resourceful and..."
Gabriel de oliveira
"I always knew that the Homestead had great food, great service and great music. Now I know they have an amazing event venue in the back. Thank you..."
Gina V
"My first time at The Homestead was for a celebration in the private back room. I was so impressed with the room itself - beautifully decorated! We..."
Diane Valenze
"First time in the area. Heard a few great things about this place so we decided to stop by for lunch. Doesn’t look like much from the outside but..."
Donna Viola
"We just moved to the area recently, and have found our "go to place"! The prices are very reasonable and the food is amazing! We paid almost double..."
Sarah Gleason
"Cute restaurant/pub with great drinks and..."
Toby Music
"I'm was there a few months ago, the service and the food was simply and slowly. But now! Everything was really good, amazing. I'm hungarian guy, ..."
Laszlo Petrucz
The Homestead
The Homestead
80/100 (44 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Pizza
American
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Wings
Oyster
Burger
American
Bar
Pub
Pizza
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Canterbury's Oyster Bar & Grill
Canterbury's Oyster Bar & Grill
79/100 (760 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Seafood
American
Late Night
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mussels
Tuna
Burger
Calamares
Crab Cake
Chowder
Shrimp
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Crab
Clams
Oyster
Calamari
"This place was amazing! From the food to the service to the atmosphere! Our waiter, Tommy, joked with us and was top notch. The po' boy oyster..."
Kenneth M Piper
"What a special place. It was raining out so we popped in to have lunch. The grilled lobster was amazing. The little neck steamed clams excellent...."
Shawn Nachtrieb
"Had a terrific shellfish and craft beer lunch with friends yesterday. Food and beer was wonderful. Service was friendly and..."
Kevin Worgul
"Delicious seafood, tremendous craft beer selection. Stop what you're doing and head to..."
Richard Fendrych
"We had a wonderful supper for five on the Fourth. Great food and drink all the way around. Lobster was excellent. Shrimp was perfect. Excellent..."
Joe Wiegand
"It's home away from home. Friendly, cozy atmosphere with a great menu. There Oysters are the best, hands down. Shrimp cocktail awesome. Try there..."
Geraldine Byrne
"Was very happy with everything from steamers to lobster roll ! Waitress was very nice and also helpful ! Look forward to our next visit..."
Raymond Groll
"Absolutely delicious food. Nice place, will go..."
Sabrina Chantell Best
"Friendly place with some good food. Interesting to see all the pictures of..."
Han Bae
"Got the steamers... they were real steamers or as some people call them “pisser clams”. Most restaurants outside of Connecticut have steamers on..."
Brian F
"Great food & friendly staff! Plus minutes from Sagamore Hill after our visit. This place has Roosevelt & Oyster Bay histoey here that is very cool as..."
Alicia Altieri
"Great service, food and just plain ole' FUN! Celebrating moms 84th birthday with her four daughter's. We had an absolute DELISHOUS time. Thank..."
Jeanne Kremnitzer
"Great food with lots of history. Ordered oysters, fish tacos and seafood..."
Alan Liu
"Environment was decked out in Theodore Roosevelt, very cozy feel. The service was excellent, very above average. Food was very good and did not take..."
Alex Reyes
"I had the fish and chips and my granddaughter and her girlfriend had the chicken tenders and fries. We all agreed that they were delicious; done..."
Ray Kuryla
"Great food! The menu had a lot of variety. Definitely would start with the pretzel. Service was excellent. Decor was cool, made the place feel very..."
James Gabriels
"This place is AMAZING! Good beer, fantastic good and the staff are super friendly and polite. After our meal we went next door to the lackluster..."
K. M. Piper
"Went here for a casual dinner and was casually surprised by the food. The menu is extensive, everyone should beable to find something they want. Laid..."
Ryan Hope Ross
"It was amazing. The service is nice and everyone is so friendly. The food is so magic and delicious. Grilled Swordfish and Crispy Salmon are..."
Stanislav Panov
"Just went here for a date tonight. Staff were super nice, sangria was excellent, and the menu was really unique. The lamb lollipops were really..."
Sarah Strum
"I go here as often as possible (it’s a trip from Long Beach!). The food is really VERY good and the place is fascinating! Books everywhere (you can..."
Elsa Haupt
"Had an outstanding burger maybe tastiest in the area. Beer selection rocks too. Staff very attentive and eager to please. Very much recommend giving..."
Andrew Ross
"Had some really nice oysters and fish n chips here. Great beer list as well and service was efficient and friendly. Manager was on top of everything...."
Mark Dimont
Mcdonald's
Mcdonald's
70/100 (3402 ratings)
Restaurants
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Sit down
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Very clean and well maintained. Staff were very friendly and helpful. Service was fast and friendly. Food was delicious and..."
Haris Muhammad
"I was surprised that this McDonald's was furnished so nicely. It was very modern! I could order off the touch screen, which always makes a happy..."
Kevin Michalski
"Pretty quick and always gets my orders..."
Tyler C
"Manager Manuel provided great customer service..."
Arielle
"The inside was much cleaner than the last time I was here. Food was..."
Tamara Moultrie
"I have been a regular customer of the Oyster Bay branch for a number of years now. I would say despite of this new normal of embracing the take out..."
Ron 23
"The manager and staff are friendly and accommodating. The food is fresh and served promptly. It's a McDonald's so there are no surprises but when..."
Gordon Roschko
"The food actually looks like the pictures at this McDonald's and the staff is polite. The drive-thru and curbside is a bit slow but at the time of..."
Chris Jelley
"It's a McDonald's... pretty clean, decent service, handicapped entrance, parking and drive..."
Doug Nuccio
"At 5:00 on July 16 ,a supposed manager told me to leave ! Yesterday was a mad rush and they gave me single burgers in the bundle ! We used the app !..."
Shawn Lee
"Very nice place, great food and great..."
Eddie Calli