Reviews Caffiend's Pizzeria & Eatery

5
Dawn Knoepfler (The Dawn)
+5
Mmmmm 16" Pepperoni, Extra Cheese done perfectly! FRESH dough and sauce, pretty damn close to NY style. πŸ• Francesca was very sweet and can definitely throw some dough!! Check out this lovely local family owned hideaway when you can. The Calzones are HUGE and the prices are extremely reasonable!! $24 for 16" 2 topping and 2 fountain drinks. They also make some great looking cheesecakes, tiramisu, cannoli's, and other desserts. πŸ˜‹ No they do NOT deliver to the beach. Yes there is inside dining. No they are NOT pet friendly (except REAL service animals) No patio or outdoor seating.
5
Lori Sagehorn
+5
I will not eat pizza anywhere else. The supreme pizza was amazing!! The large was perfect for 4 of us. I loved that the food is freshly made. The tiramasu and cannoli were out of this world.
4
Jonathan Buchanan
+4
Drove by this place as long as I can remember but I finally stopped in on a Sunday afternoon, it was very quiet and pretty dead inside but the young woman behind the counter was very friendly and personable and made ordering and asking about the items a nice experience. The pizza we ordered came out very quickly and was extremely good! while it was not the most flavorful pizza I've ever had, I have yet to have a pizza that was as well balanced in ingredients as this one. It was a bit thin but thats how I like it, the ingredients tasted very fresh and the put the perfect amount of sauce on it for me(some may think its too little). My girlfriend and I couldn't stop talking about how non-greasy the pizza was and how it tasted great without being too "heavy" with toppings and crazy stuff. I'm very picky about pizza crust but they have definitely found the "just right" middle ground between too crispy and too doughy. We will certainly be back and I am exited to try the other things on the menu! My only complaint would be that I had hoped the garlic knots would have had more garlic on them, honestly I dont think there was any on them at all, though the dough seemed very fresh and well made. Besides that The only suggestion I have would be to liven the place up a bit, the display fridge was completely empty and the place seemed stagnant at first. Play some music, have some fans running, etc.
5
A. Strickland
+5
My son loved it! He said it tasted like mac & cheese! Personally it was to dry for me but everyone has thier own opinion. We had an XL PEPPERONI PIZZA. As far as service they were wonderful, fast and reasonably priced.
5
Lara Braddock
+5
Just finished dinner, we did carry out so it was a bit cold when I got home. We all enjoyed the meat lovers the most. The desserts looked amazing, will try those next time. Good service, decent price. Will definitely go back.
5
Alec Young
+5
Good food, great dessert. We had a cheese calzone that we added pepperoni to for the kids, and a large supreme pizza for us adults. Cost $30 or so with drinks and everything. The crust was really good, The toppings were really good, they only complained about the food I had was it was a lot of moisture from the vegetables. Kids said the calzone was good but too cheesy, was just shows that they don't know what they're talking about because there's no such thing. We had a slice of the Oreo cheesecake for dessert. it did cost $6 but personally I think it was worth it. It tasted phenomenal nice and rich.
4
Sapphira Wolf (Saiya)
+4
I order a gyro and a small 16' pizza veggie pizza. Only thing that could be improved on the veggie pizza was loosing the onions and having spinach instead. The gyro was near perfection just a dab more sauce and add some spice we are perfection! The wait was only 10 maybe 15 mins not at all that bad.
5
Michael Daniel
+5
The food is very good, and the cheesecake is magnificent!!!
4
y2kiki
+4
Real NY style pizza SO GOOD! They also have other Italian options and subs and burgers and fries. The dessert counter looked yummy! I love a place with red and white checkered tablecloths and Italian music. One of my new favorites. They have pizza by the slice prior to 4pm. They also deliver.
5
Kim Stovall
+5
I stopped by yesterday for my first visit. I sure wish I'd had enough time to sit down and enjoy one of their pasta dishes, but I had to rush back to work, so I ended up getting a gyro and fries to go. Since our local gyro cafe was destroyed by hurricane Michael, I had feared it would be a long time before I could get a good gyro again...I'm glad to say that Amore served me a perfectly delicious one, and I ate every bite. They've got appetizers, salads, subs, pasta, pizza and an INCREDIBLE selection of homemade deserts, like massive New York style cheesecake and seriously sexy Tiramisu. I may go back just to try the desserts, but I will definitely be going back again. Support our locally owned businesses...Amore Pizzeria won't disappoint you.
5
Trina Bigham
+5
The food here is amazing!!! This is the best Italian restaurant in Bay County!! I ordered the Francesca shrimp and mushroom dish with a side of scallops.. cooked perfectly. Garlic knots were the best and the chicken parm melts in your mouth!!! I will definitely be back to this hidden gem!!
Clicca per espandere