Best Pepperoni Pizza in Patchogue

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Giovanni's Pizzeria & Gelateria
Giovanni's Pizzeria & Gelateria
82/100 (1107 ratings)
Restaurants
Fettuccine Alfredo
Baked Clams
Caesar Salad with Shrimp
Is a Great Slice of Pizza
Flatbread
Hazelnut Spumoni
Pepperoni Pizza
Just a Mouthful of Goodness
Chicken soup
Lobster ravioli
House Salad
Eggplant Parmesan
Seafood Medley
Cheese Calzone
Stuffed Pepper
Mussels
Meatballs
Risotto
"Come out here for THE PIZZA 🍕. Peroni Beer, desserts and more. Comfortable booths and outside seating. So good I even ate the crust..."
FREDDYG_NY
"I have gone there twice now. I was hesitant the first time given some of the reviews, the second time, no hesitancy at all. Both times the food was..."
Mindy C
"Nice and tasty pizza 🍕 😋. Slices are big and loaded with..."
Cool Dude
"This was our first time eating in this casual sit down pizzeria. We ordered a Caesar salad with shrimp (which should have had more than three shrimp..."
S7
"Highly anticipated and finally open! Everything we tried was delicious. Love the giant rice ball. The pizza isn't heavy or oily. Fresh ingredients..."
Food Done It?
"Went in for pizza... ended up trying the chicken soup and pasta faglioli, Calzone, and a panini. Everything was..."
Louise Tedesco
"Pretty good little family pizza spot. Food is decent, nothing was bad there but nothing was blow you out of the water good. You won’t be..."
karven parham
"Had a margherita pizza to go and it was absolute perfection! Can’t wait to go back and try more of the menu. The. Marinara sauce was out of this..."
Koko M
"Awesome restaurant with friendly people and great food . I eat there at least once a..."
Doris Romano
"We order from here once a week. It’s usually great but tonight i ordered a soup with spinach and tortellini and there was about 3 pieces of..."
P W
"They actually cook their sauce, and for a very long time. The best home made fully cooked sauce I have tasted in 20 years. Just like my Mom and best..."
Alecia Carroll
Gino's Pizzeria
Gino's Pizzeria
81/100 (832 ratings)
Restaurants
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Garlic Knots
Pizza by the Slice
Grandma Pizza Slice
Regular Slice
Pepperoni Pizza
Grandma Pie
Sit down
Italian
Fast food
Pizza
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Staff was attentive and food was great. I was in a hurry and they were on..."
Tami Lee
"Very friendly when I picked up my food. Asked how my experience with ordering on the app was. Very thankful for my business. The pizza was so..."
Sabrina Barthold
"This is what it’s all about. The best pizza for the best price. You won’t find a better place that’s more about the people than the profit. The..."
Nick The local Guide
"The pizza here is 🔥. Sauce 10/10, Cheese 10/10, Crust 10/10, Flop 10/10. A classic NY slice at its best. The staff here is friendly too and makes..."
Varun Batra
"I’ve had this pizza a few times over the years and was reminded today how great it is. The perfect NY..."
Erin S.
"PIZZA is best in area.. but I really hope he fires that guy he hired with the smart mouth. well those things work themselves out still the best..."
B c54
"Food was SO good!! Me and my little sister went and she couldn't stop saying how good it was. Staff was also incredibly kind when there was a mistake..."
Cheryl marsh
"Ordered the thin crust. How do you get it to be crunchy and chewy at the same time with a buttery taste. Wow was so good. But I ate too much. If..."
Tim Tarantino
"Super fast delivery and very good!! Great for a rainy..."
Missy M.
"It is probably the Last original old school family owned & run pizza shop in the town of Patchogue, NY. Very warm environment! You can talk with a..."
Richard Mulvey
"Gino's doesn't offer much, but what they do offer is perfect. The menu is limited, but that's a good thing because it's an old-school pizzeria and..."
Chris Curry
"best pizza around, been going here for 30 years, they accept credit card now if you order..."
Evan Knutson
"Best regular pizza I have ever had and I eat pizza a lot in my travels for work. This place is local for me so I go there a lot. Unfortunately..."
NY Pigskin
"Ginos is great!! Good NY pizza. Price wise, they are the fairest in Patchogue. I have them at 2nd best cheese slice in the village behind Del Fiore...."
Mikey O
"Nice old skool pizza parlor. I had 2 slices OUTTA this world had to get 2 more! Listen this pizzeria is the last of it's kind authentic ITALIAN..."
Michael Bottalico
"I might have already wrote a review. However today I ordered and I spoke to the owner. He was so nice and the food is amazing. I’ve been living in..."
Stacy Greco-McDowell
"Just ordered through doordash. Got a regular pie, garlics knots & the spinach pizza pop. SO GOOD! better than the other pizza places in Patchogue..."
Jeb Dee
"Friendly workers. Amazing food & great prices. My 1st time going here & will definitely be..."
Chobits