Best Extra Cheese New York Style Pizza in Pensacola Beach

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Papa's Pizza
Papa's Pizza
84/100 (1827 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salad
Papas Pizza
Meatballs
New York Style Pizza
Pesto
Calzone
Stromboli
Half Pepperoni
Meat Pizza
Quiche
Peppers
Hawian Pizza
Extra Cheese New York Style Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
White Veggie Pizza
Slice of Pizza
XL Cheese
Bud Light
Cheese Pizza with Artichoke and Jalapenos
Sausage Pizza
Slice of Cheese Pizza and Breadsticks
Pasta
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The XL is huge. For only $2 more than the large, it's a substantial size difference. The marinara sauce is way too runny for the bread sticks, and..."
Alicia Campion
"OK, so I am usually not a pizza girl, but OMG, the calzone is to die for!! From jump, you have this amazing buttery crust that just is so devine....."
Shari Nitz
"Visiting from Chicago and probably the best pizza you can get in this area. Girl at the front register was on her game with the orders and the food..."
donna Lacognata
"Great pizza on the boardwalk area. Able to customize pizza to cover what the kids and adults wanted to eat. One extra large pizza was enough for..."
Loan Phan
"Steaming hot, oven fresh handmade pizza at an affordable price served promptly! Enough parking space available. You can sit indoors or outdoors...."
Tarang S
"We drove 600 miles to get a taste of Papas Pizza. We haven't found anything that compares to the flavor in the 8 years that we have been away from..."
Christy Love
"The pizza, the calzones, the Stromboli and the service and the great. Super friendly, generous & super fresh! Definitely a place you should visit if..."
Steven Clements
"Great location, easy to access. The pizza was wonderful thin crust browned to perfection. It didn’t have a lot of sauce which I liked. It was carry..."
Sherry Rylander
"Small place at the beach boardwalk. Has pizza by the slice and by the pie. Husband and I got a slice and a Greek salad. Both were actually very..."
Lori Landin
"Hey, this was pretty dang good and I’m not even a pizza lover. I liked how crispy the crust was and I liked the balance and the taste. 1 less star..."
Natalie Brasher
"We picked up pizza to go and it was delicious! We got the Frank..."
Lauren Blackwell
"I really liked this pizza. It was super thin and delicious, just the way we liked it. The staff were awesome and friendly. Couldn’t ask for more...."
Shaun Smith
"Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Almost everything was handmade; seating inside was suspended due to Covid-19, but seating outside was spacious...."
Aaron “Mayhem” Miles
"Friendly staff and good pizza! After looking for a late dinner and everything closed we Found this place on the boardwalk. We ordered the xl pizza..."
Michelle Gomez
"It’s probably not the best pizza in the Panhandle, but after a day on the beach it does fit the bill for charging you back up. The NY style is..."
Brian Crandall
"This place a nice and cozy place to have a bite of Pizza. The pizza was tasty. The dough was tossed by a skillful cook. There are not many tables..."
Saleh Babazadeh
"Absolutely love this place, so much we went twice during our visit. The pizza was delicious and the service and staff were great. Thanks for a great..."
James Menzies