I have never been a fan of traditional pie crust, as a kid I would eat the filling and leave the crust and I had two grandmother's who were top notch bakers. As an adult I rarely even eat pie outside of Thanksgiving. That being said there is magic in Mama Toledo pies, best tasting crust I've ever had, I could eat it by itself.
The Pot Roast Pie OMG! as for dessert pies I've only had the chocolate cream and banana, both delicious. Looking forward to expanding my pie universe thanks to this place.
Very very tasty. The cherry was spectacular. Can’t wait to try some of their new (to me anyhow) breakfast dishes. Their pot pies smelled incredible but we were there for dessert.
Kimberly Dunlap Burleson
+5
I love the bacon and cheese breakfast pie and I love the pot roast pie!!!!! "Highly recommend!!!!!"
Awesome fruit pies and chicken pot pie as well!!! Very small place but great service and you will walk away happy you visited for sure!! I'll be back...
I love having this place in my neighborhood. Great option on busy nights when you still want a home cooked meal (and dessert) instead of-take out. I can't wait to try their breakfasts too.
Two visits in one day! Lunch green chile pot pie. Excellent. Perfect crust with chile verde inside as good as it gets. Second trip for slices of coconut cream and peach. Delicious and generous slices. Will definitely return. Love the fact that I could walk there. Mamma Toledo is so cordial and provides great service.
Yum yum yum!!! I haven't had a pie here that I didn't like!!! And the savory pies are amazing!!! Sometimes bakers don't season savory pie filling enough for my tastes-but she nailed it!!!
I have never really been a pie person- but let me tell you - these are delicious. I have had the chicken and it was so good! My husband has had both their chicken and roast beef-
loves them both. Their apple pie with ice cream is also one of my favorites!
Great coffee, Expresso! Some wonderful pies and delicious chicken pot pies too.
Yum, yum!!! Love this place. Breakfast, coffee and best dessert in town. Love to hang out and chill.
Delicious coffee and the pecan pie is amazing. Just ordered my Thanksgiving pies from them!
Great pie, but I have been in 4 times and they have not had cold brew coffee one time even though it is on the menu (they have now written when available under it, which I assume means never). It would be the perfect pie shop if they actually had this.
Update: there is cold brew. Thanks Tonya!
Ryan N Kara Hill-Duran
+5
OMG!! Slap yo momma in the face GOOD!! The triple chocolate is 👍🏼👍🏼And the Banana Cream is my favorite! It is the cutest little shop and the service was very friendly!
Love love love the Green Chile Gringo. Awesome place and atmosphere. Great service as well. Thanks for bein so good.
My husband surprised me with the best carrot cake I've ever had for my birthday! Thank you!
Great pies!!! Love the raspberry cream cheese pie!
So good!!!! We found a (new to us) pie place today and it is SO SO SO GOOD!!! We chose apple crumble, brought it home and slapped some vanilla ice cream on it. They have thriftys ice cream there at the shop but we're not big thrifty ice cream fans. Do yourself a favor and check it out!!!
My husband is a stickler with his lemon meringue pie. He is only a fan of his moms lemon meringue pie recipe so when I went to mama Toledo and saw all the great reviews I knew it would be great! I got a few of the mini pies to include the lemon meringue pie and my husband said it was amazing and tasted exactly like his mom made! Thank you for making his Father’s Day one to remember! We will definitely be back!
This place is incredible! I was looking for a cherry cheesecake for Mother’s Day, called several bakeries and nobody would do it for me. During my search I stumbled upon this bakery and was immediately drawn to them by their slogan “We’ll shut your pie hole” hahaha! Long story short, even though it’s not in their menu they were willing to make it for me and it tasted absolutely delicious. The cheesecake was perfect and the wife couldn’t be happier. Before this experience, I had never been to or had ever heard of this place but now it’ll be my go to for personal or work events. Not only is this place fantastic, they are also friendly and are willing to go the extra mile to help customers. Thank you Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole! You are a gem in the desert!
Loved it, the pie was wonderful well worth the drive. Friendly staff, lots to choose from, individual pie slices or whole pies. Wii definitely go back. The coconut cream pie was so yummy. The chocolate cream pie was one of the very best we've had in 50 years.
I stopped around lunch time on a Sunday. I came for the pie and was NOT disappointed. The strawberry rhubarb pie was delicious and the mini pie was enough to share. This place is small, a true "hole in the wall" but there was a counter with stools, which was just enough space to eat our pie.
We love Mamma Toledo's! Honestly, I wasn't even much of a pie person until coming here and now I crave their pies (favorite is the raspberry cream cheese and the coconut cream). It's always such a treat and on weekends we come by to make sure we get our favorites before they're gone!
Such a cute place! So many amazing desserts it’s hard to choose just one. As you arrive you will be greeted with the aroma of fresh baked goods. What satisfies memories of happy childhood memories than home cooked pies?? A must go to location for your sweet tooth.
UPDATE 10/28/23.
Went for breakfast. And was there when doors opened. Since I attempted this same trip 2 weeks ago and failed.
My mission is sausage gravy and jalapeno biscuits.. the amount of sausage WOW. Melt in your mouth...
Mission accomplished, and it was delicious .
I ordered the plate, which had 🥚 eggs and 🥔 potatoes.
Also, huge portion for price is totally worth the 💰 money.
I also picked up a mini pie. Like if you go there, you can't leave without PIE !!
The smell of fresh baked pies….
Do I really need to say anything else
I have gotten 5 pies here in the last 9 months for different occasions and all have been outstanding. The price may seem high but quality ingredients and they are large. Definitely better than some store bought generic pie. Banana cream is my favorite!
We stopped for a quick savory bite on 3/14 aka Pi Day. The spinach mushroom feta quiche and biscuit sandwich were delicious! The portion sizes are just the right amount of comfort food since we went hiking afterwards. I would highly recommend this spot, and we plan on visiting again during our next visit to the Phoenix metro area.
Literally the best coconut cream pie I have had in my life. When does a 10 inch pie weigh more than 4 pounds? When it has been crafted with love by Mamma Toledo. This was like the wedding cake of pies. As others have mentioned, the crust is a thing of beauty. Light, flaky, and definitely not soggy. A deeply appreciated nuance: this pie was not overly sweet. It's great when you get to taste the fine ingredients and not overwhelmed with sugar. Going back to taste their savory stuff next.
First time having Mamma Toledo's, and I am hooked! My husband picked up 2 mini pies for my birthday, one raspberry cheesecake and one apple crumb. The crust of the pie was probably the best pie crust I've ever tasted. No more birthday cakes for me, this will be my go-to sweet treat for any occasion. Thank you for making such amazing pies!! Definitely made return customers out of us!
This place is so good. They made me the best Lemon meringue pie I ever tasted. My husband I enjoyed it, and the cherry pie is good also. I will be coming back. Thank you for making my husband birthday special.
We did a to-go order for my son's bday. Pie was excellent as always. What really surprised me was the breakfast we got when we picked it up! The quiche and hand pies were delish. The green chili burrito was seriously the best I've had! I'm going back this weekend for that burrito!
I had a craving for some pie so I wanted to check out mama toledo's. Someone brought a pie over for a dinner once from there and it was exquisite (chocolate one?) I was greeted warmly and enthusiastically by the girl up front and she recommended the raspberry cream cheese omg so good! I'll go here more often :)
Great Pot Pies and Coffee! Friendly staff as well! Answered all my questions patiently and demonstrated knowledge in her craft, very professional! My girlfriend and I only wanted one pie to go, but ended up eating it completely before my coffee was finished. It was delicious! My coffee is bold and strong yet soothing. They will definitely get my money again! 5STARS!!! As of 5Nov
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes