Best Banana split in Pittsburgh

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Page's Dairy Mart
Page's Dairy Mart
95/100 (3048 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Fast Food
Soft serve ice cream
Nancy B's Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae
Banana split
Yinzer Sundae
Pumpkin Cheesecake Maple Soft Serve
Arctic Swirl Oreo
Burnt Almond Cake Sundae
Turtle Delight Sundae
Large Marge Sundae
Strawberry Sundae with Nuts
Apple Dumpling Sundaes
Brownie Sunday
Blueberry Soft Serve
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
Burger
Cheese Cake Sundaes
Gelato
Maple Waffle
Hot Dog
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwiches
Turtle Sundae
Hot Cinnamon Roll Sundae
Ice Cream
Soft Serve with Rainbow Sprinkles
Fast food
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Family run shop with the Best ice cream anywhere in Pittsburgh. Most nights there is a line, but it moves quickly since there is enough staff to wait..."
Carol Funtal Rockenstein
"Just moved to Pittsburgh from Indiana and finally decided to try this place after seeing lines around the corner every night. We were completely..."
Luna Velasquez
"Even with a lengthy line, waited only 10 minutes. Ice cream is fantastic, huge variety of items, very inexpensive. No reason to go anywhere..."
Ron Crouch
"I have lived in Pittsburgh for about 15 years and all I ever rave about is your amazing food and friendly staff. I will continue to send new people..."
Tabitha Jennings
"The best everything! Such a wonderful place. The locally baked confections in your sundaes are the..."
April Clisura
"Hands down best place in Pittsburgh! Cant beat the ice cream, food is amazing, prices are good. Ive been going there since I was a kid. Even after I..."
Andy Rarick
"I live in another state when I come to town to visit family we always make a point to stop for ice..."
Brian Chancio
"Ice cream of historical proportions! A great landmark in Pittsburgh. They are old school. Options you may never find elsewhere. Busy but well staffed..."
Grant Rumford
"The best ice cream I have been going there since I was a kid and I won't go anywhere else for ice cream there ice cream cake is awesome..."
Theresa Geyer
"Love Pages! We have gone there for years! Cookies sundae and flavored ice cream is to die..."
Jean Kroll
"Last August, I visited from Perth, Western Australia with my friend Pittsburgh local Denise Schreiber. She wanted to share this wonderful place with..."
Andrea Whitely
"Great place for ice cream. If the line is long be patient. The line will move..."
Andy Kumm
"Milkshakes Yummy!! Burgers fries Yummy! Blonde brownies nice and hot Yummy with an extra Yummy on..."
Akiba Rakilam
"I'm a Pittsburgh native, from the south hills in fact; but I just tried Page's for the first time this week. I must say, I was pleasantly surprised...."
Erie
"Best banana milkshakes ever!!! Chocolate chip cookie sundaes made with Nancy b cookies can't be beat!!! I've had a lot of different things always..."
FoodFather
"Tastes like classic!!! Just classic. As good as it gets .....it just tastes classic!! Possibly the greatest ice cream..."
Food Critic
"I have passed this place at least a hundred times and always to know why they were always packed. Well I finally stopped and it was so worth it...."
Hungryblnde88
"I Scream for...... Ice Cream!Great place. Passed it a million times, but today I figured I'd give it a try. Great selection of soft serve..."
Ken Petri
"My husband's favorite. This is my husband's favorite ice cream store. He always get a south side shake, which is a shake and a sundae in a drink cup...."
8isenuf
"Summertime in Pittsburgh wouldn't be the same without Page's. Its been a tradition in my family since as long as I can remember and my 2 year old..."
Nico's Momma
"DQ who?!. Since I moved to Baldwin 5 years ago and discovered Page's, nothing else compares. The sundae portions are so big that 2 people can share..."
Sgarv81
"Sooooo Good. 1,000 times better than DQ. We both got Swirls (Blizzards) and both thought they were very good. The menu is huge and will likely cause..."
Jason
"Best Ice Cream ever!. This is the best place to get ice cream, when in season its a must do on a hot day or any day :) they have like a millon of..."
Bryan Terrill
"Mmmm. Great ice cream. I used to come here all the time when I lived closer. The ice cream is great and the food is pretty good as well. Just your..."
Matt Sinopoli
"Since forever. I've been going to this place as long as i can remember. I don't have much of a sweet tooth, but on a hot summer day there's nothing..."
Jozak78
"I absolutley love Paige Dairy Mart! I have gone there for the past 10 years because it is that..."
Adison
"Back in Time. Chances are your grandparents used to come down here on a hot summer night for their treats. Relive that sort of thing and create the..."
Beyond Yummy
"Page's is a Pittsburgh institution when it comes to ice cream. I ordered the oat milk soft serve. It was very soft and was melting quickly. It wasn't..."
Stacy D
"I have been here probably a dozen times now and always leave extremely happy! My current favorite is a custom arctic swirl of black raspberry ice..."
Hailey Showers
"Some of the best ice cream in Pittsburgh. They have a ton of different treats and sweets to choose from and also a ton of different ice cream..."
James
"There is always a line and is super busy, the service is kind and quick. It just goes to show how dedicated people are to the best ice cream stop..."
Sarah_ H
"Always a pleasure to visit pages. The sundaes here are absolute amazing. The cold ice cream with warm brownie is a great combo. Must try. The lines..."
Moonyoung Lee
"The wait wasn’t that bad at all and definitely worthy and considered as part of the experience you would feel as if you time traveled years ago..."
Ahmed Emam
"I love this place and stop in every time I am in Pittsburgh. My parents went here in the 50s on their first date. Don't let the huge line that..."
Billie Jo Grassinger
"Ice scream you scream, we all scream for ice cream! Had to head to a new place for us that is listed on the "55 of the Best Ice Cream Shops in the..."
Dede King
"I can see why it’s considered one of the best ice cream places in the country. The sundaes are..."
Joey Bagofdonuts
"Generations of Pittsburghers have come to Paige Dairy Mart on the South Side. It is hands down the best ice cream period. Come park your car and..."
Pens Fan
"Pages has the best ice cream and shakes and steak sandwiches ever!!!. You can put whatever on your ice cream or in your shake. The freckled..."
KM G
"This place is ranked 16th in the nation and did not disappoint! They have a large selection of menu items. There is a parking lot. There is no drive..."
Chelsea D
"Waited probably 30-45 minutes in line and it was 100% worth it first of all the prices are unbelievable for 2023. I got an ice cream cone, mozz..."
Amanda McHugh
"The only ice cream shop worth crossing over a railroad! Best ice cream shop in Pittsburgh. I wish Page’s was open all year round. All of the..."
Ummey Karim
"Typical ice cream stand. The menu has a lot to offer, much more than just desserts/ice cream. Of course, we had to try the ice cream. It was good - I..."
Sk Md
"The best ice cream in Pittsburgh 😋 Love this place and it's only gotten better (or stayed consistent?) over the years! They accept cards now..."
Chelsea Roeser
"Pages Dairy Mart is the best ice cream in Pittsburgh, and has been for decades. There was a period in my life that I didn’t even know it existed,..."
Justin Blumenfeld
"This place has amazing ice cream! The wait is usually about 30 minutes and always packed but worth it. They do take credit cards. The line moves..."
Fernando Ford
Bruster's Real Ice Cream
Bruster's Real Ice Cream
91/100 (633 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Frozen Custard
PB Cup Sundae
Homemade Waffle Cone
Kids Dino Sundae
Ice Cream
Banana split
Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
American
"My husband and I went to Bruster’s today, in the hopes of being able to have a gender reveal cake created quickly for us. Although the cake we..."
Valentina Ward
"*Update: owner took my review seriously, reached out, and remedied the experience. This is 5 star customer care. Increased rating from 3 to 5..."
Connor Wagner
"On our way home from WV was looking for any place that sold REAL ice cream - was pleasantly surprised to find this place as we went through..."
Rachael Sommer
"This place is awesome because it's open year long. They have a variety of flavors and they have different ones daily. They make fresh cones, waffle..."
Ms Miller (Amanda)
"This place is great with homemade ice cream and cones. Service is always friendly and prices are fair. We come here several times a month. Highly..."
Grace S
"Love their ice cream. Variety of flavors to choose. Friendly staff. Taste..."
Joy
"i’ve been going here since i was little. always great service and great ice..."
Erin Coran
"Friendly staff! Good ice..."
Haley Colaizzi
"There is no better ice cream in the world. Bruster's IS a scoop above the rest. 10/10. Don't waste your money on anything else. ❤🍦..."
Sarah Schroeder
"Great ice cream in all types of servings. Their Blast is a version and Much better than Dairy Queens Blizzard. More stuff in..."
Ken Kubala
"The service was great. The young lady that waited on me was very accommodating and pleasant. Five stars for service and cleanliness. The chocolate..."
Iron Feige
"Great ice cream! I've eaten more White Raspberry Truffle ice cream on their freshmade waffle cones than I'd care to measure. Summer and winter... I..."
Brandon Cahall
"Awesome staff and service! With the quarantine, I had a difficult time finding an ice cream cake. This bruster’s did an outstanding job! They..."
Shawna Kane
"This is a really great ice cream shop. They offer cones, shakes, mixers, and sundaes. BYOB (bring your own banana) on Thursdays for a bargain on a..."
Chris B
"Three generations enjoyed ice cream cones and cups in a variety of flavors - and some with sprinkles yesterday evening. The staff was friendly and..."
David White
"It was great. My wife had a chocolate shake and I had the coffee ice cream on a sugar..."
Giovanni Notte
"Their workers are kind. They give free ice cream to your furry friends you bring with you. And their ice cream is delicious. The only downside is..."
Breeann Spack
The Scoop Ice Cream
The Scoop Ice Cream
88/100 (567 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Mai Tai
Strawberry Shortcake
Soft Serve Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip Cookies and Ice Cream
Georgia Peach
Funnel Cake Sundae
Apple Dumpling Sundae
Nancy B Ice Cream Sandwich
Small Waffle Cone w Rainbow Sprinkles
Nut Roll Sundae
Muffin
Banana split
Cookie Dough
Gift Cards Available
Lunch
Dinner
"Delicious 😋 fast friendly service, they even have a drive up window so you don’t have to get out of your car which is great for my handicapped..."
Erika Bonacci
"I have driven past The Scoop a number of times, but never stopped. Today, however, was the perfect day to stop. It was early enough to miss the..."
John Harvey
"Nice little shop. Tons of crazy options of things I've never seen done. Will be back for..."
matt ondrey
"Absolutely delicious! Such a sweet lady that waited on us. Not sure if she's the owner. I got the nut roll sundae and my son got the fried oreo..."
Denise Gonzales-Foster
"I went here for the first time today. I ordered the Lincoln Place Sundae (warm blondie with vanilla ice cream and warm carmel topped with whipped..."
Kellie P.
"Phenomenal ice cream, great service and atmosphere, amazing variety of flavors, and decent prices. We loved it and will definitely be..."
Lynn Werkheiser
"Best ice cream place in the south hills. Comparable to Page's, without the long waits. Large servings for the..."
J D
"We stopped for ice cream on our way through. Simple soft serve with sprinkles was reasonably priced and good quality. Kids were happy. Given the..."
Morten Kristiansen
"Drive past here for years and never stopped until today. Met up with my family here and we all had different things, everything was so good and..."
Bev Thomas
"It was wonderful! Make sure you add to Madison's college fund when you stop. Portions are large and every flavor we tried was better than the last...."
Jason Sacramento
"My family shared the strawberry shortcake sundae, a chocolate chip ice cream sandwich, and a waffle cone. The ice cream was average and the..."
Kate Yonko
"The ice cream is super good, the menu is large - you will definitely find something you like. The employees are so friendly and service is quick. We..."
Jessica Novakowski
"We love to walk here often (and yes, catch pokemon on our way since this is a pokestop!) they have delicious ice cream and a great selection of..."
Elaina Schran
Custard's First Stand
Custard's First Stand
88/100 (603 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Dessert
Dinner
Lunch
Banana split
Strawberry
Sundaes
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
Hot Dog
Peanut Butter Sundae
Pumpkin Roll
Oreo Glacier
Ice Cream
Turtle Sundae OH My
Milkshakes
Café
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This has been a business that I have been going to since 1988 (as a baby). It has always been amazing but Kirk McConnell is currently the owner. And..."
Brooke Keith
"Always great service and a fun place for a quick treat, or even lunch/dinner... and they always have my favorite flavor ice cream: cappuccino crunch..."
Gail Brown
"The good lovin ice cream sandwiches are ridiculously huge but magnificent! Can't believe I've lived in Pittsburgh practically my whole life and have..."
Sarah Norris Gyening
"My parents took me there as a child, now I take my children there. Great place to..."
Jim Niggel
"I seriously go through milkshake withdrawal when they close for the season. Other shakes just don’t cut it! Very satisfied..."
Dyanna Eakin
"Excellent food , delicious ice cream and service with a smile .my favorite place to go in the summer for evening dinner or lunch followed by a..."
Sandra Hatherley
"Great Custard Burger! Nice and messy!❤❤ just the first of the season! I wish they would put the Grand Slam back on the menu. Awesome place, nice..."
Dave Buskirk
"We love it , my family eats here all the time. The fresh cut French fries are the..."
Shardai Bryant
"I loved going there when I was a kid. And now full circle, I love taking my kids there! Great burgers and awesome..."
Stacey Leech
"Yummy place with great ice cream and friendly..."
Jennifer Zimmerman
"A great mom and pop ice cream stand. My kids and I love going there. And the prices are good..."
Michael Pajewski
"Good things about Spring...warm sunsine, flowers, and Custard's..."
Connie O'Connor
"We're kind of obsessed with Custards. Cheesy hot dogs EVERY..."
Megan Jamison
"Nice classic ice cream stand! Covered outdoor seating, decent prices and cute location. Just down the road from Avonworth park. They also have 2..."
Benjamin Williams
"Great ice cream, lots to choose from, staff was friendly, and dog friendly as..."
Kris Wilder
"Custards is my choice for local ice cream stand. They may not have the selection of other competitors but their prices are better and they are..."
Andrew Seay
"Custard's is a great local spot for ice cream. The prices are reasonable and the staff are always friendly HS kids working for the summer. There is a..."
Adidaspgh
"I first saw this place a couple weeks ago while heading to the animal ER. I had bigger things going on so food wasn't on my mind. While hunting for..."
Bridgette Turner
"Absolutely loved this old-school ice cream shop. Set close to the Ohio River Blvd with easy parking and outdoor seating. Neighborhood hangout with..."
Domenic Leo III
"Custards is the best tasting. Every time I drive pass this place I have to stop by and get me a delicious banana split. I tell you its so delicious..."
Geogina Maid
"Great ice cream at a very affordable price. I HIGHLY recommend the Chocolate Peanut Butter Explosion Glacier it was amazing and PACKED with candy. I..."
Chase E
"Really yummy custard, I got a slushy float which was a slushy with ice cream on top and it was delicious! My husband got a cone of orange creamsicle..."
Madeline Spruill Cononge
"Love getting the chance to stop here. Ice creams good. Staff is efficient and helpful. Always clean. Some parking is right off the street- be careful..."
rowanda thystlemeijer
"My wife and I got the twist cone, our son got an all chocolate. As good as the twist was, that chocolate was the real winner. One point for the..."
Ralph Godfrey (teamRAMP)
"Classic. Timeless. 2019 season brings changes to the menu. You simply have to stop by for yourself. My recommendation is black raspberry and..."
Jennifer D
"Great selection of ice creams. Great service. They do take debit/credit cards but you cant tip with them. Make sure to take some..."
Chris Roule
"Great ice cream stand with a sizeable picnic area to enjoy your sweet..."
C N
"Favorite ice cream shop in the city. Despite the name there is no custard sold here (bummer). Soft and hard ice cream. They have great homemade ice..."
Margot Dale
"Best custard stand north of the burg. Nice selection of frozen treats And a nice covered patio area in which to enjoy them. Prices are on par with..."
Tom Lohr
"Really good ice cream and the prices are even better. Just kidding. They are definitely cheaper than most ice cream places. The girls that work here..."
Melissa
"Weekly flavors in rotation and love the fact the serve liter milkshakes 🤣 Staff is always pleasant and worth the..."
Chris Ebert
"Friendly service and yummy ice cream treats. Selection is..."
Pamela Hydress