Best Stuffed Shells in Pittsburgh

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pizza Milano
Pizza Milano
83/100 (802 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Pizza
American
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Buffalo Wings
Fettuccine Alfredo
Seafood Alfredo
Pasta
Small Cheese Pizza
Salad
Pepperoni Roll
Hoagie
Stuffed Shells
Cheesy Breadsticks
Pesto
Milano's Special Pizza
Calzone
Pepperoni Half Mushroom Pizza
Beer
Fish Hoagie
Pepperoni Pizza
All Meat Pizza and a Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Greek salad
Broccoli Chicken Alfredo
Mousaka
Medium Milano Pizza
Vegetable Pizza
Garden Salad
Sit down
Italian
American
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"My wife and I were on a eastern American road trip and arrived in late to town. We called and ordered take out from Cafe Milano and the food did not..."
Chris Schellang
"WOW the seafood pizza was absolutely AMAZING!!! The wings were just good, that's why not 5 stars (and considering it was a takeout order, no utensils..."
Diann Lovejoy
"The pizza is exceptional, with a thin and crispy crust that perfectly complements the flavorful toppings. The menu offers a delightful range of..."
M Saffar
"This pizza was awesome, and we got it at 1 AM after we had been traveling all day. We saved the leftovers and reheated them two days later ans it was..."
Mike Edwards
"chill place with very pretty food, and helpful staff, got an Italian hoagie that was worth every penny, the view out the door is lovely too, and in..."
Robert Sage
"Came in town later then expected and found this place that was a short walk from the hotel. We had a large group with a bunch of kids. I think the..."
James Gregory
"Garlic knots are pleasantly doughy. The steak hoagie was surprisingly good- mushrooms were tasty and the steak was surprisingly moist and well..."
Angela M.
"We visit Cafe Milano's during each of our visits to Pittsburgh. Their Buffalo chicken pizza is wonderful; it comes with chicken and sliced potatoes...."
Discount Vacation Planner
"This is such a delicious place! The people are super friendly and all the food we got was amazing. They pay attention to everything when it comes to..."
Nina Kneuer
"Stopped in before pirates game, good food, great service we were upstairs and the waiter was very nice and attentive, price wasn't bad. We had a..."
Scott
"Food was great. Got the Ranch pizza, and very..."
Ryan L
"It ain't gourmet, but it's decent quality, seemed fresh, and tasted good. Can't really ask for much more from such a place. Would..."
John
"So good! Made with quality ingredients, and the crust is fragrant and..."
Yuan-Ching Chang
"Favorite downtown pizza place. They are always quick and courteous, even when super busy. Servers are very nice. Best..."
Grayling Manson
"Came in after the ball dropped. The employees were were quite festive and in high spirits. The pizza was good but certainly isn't the best I had in..."
Julius Jacob
Zarra's
Zarra's
79/100 (921 ratings)
Restaurants
Asian
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Vegan Options
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Calamari Di Julia
Baked Alaska
Pesto
Cappuccino
Noodle
Hand Made Noodles
Tomato Sauce
Red wine
Ravioli Di Filomena
Tiramisú
Antipasto Di
Full Rack of Lamb
Eggplant
Stuffed Shells
Pasta
Salad
Risotto
Stuffed Banana Peppers
Spumoni Ice Cream
Cheesecake
Stuffed Mushroom Caps
Beans and Greens
Ravioli w Eggplant
Judy's Homemade Ricotta Noodles
Tiramisu
Zarra's Sampler
Meatballs
Don't Forget the Cannolis
Lasagne
Linguine Di Contosta
Cannoli
Sit down
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My husband and I with our friend Ron had been looking forward to visiting Zarra's on our trip to Pittsburgh and it did not disappoint. It was a..."
Tracey Whitcomb Balowski
"We we're staying at the hotel across the street from the restaurant and just happened to stumble in for dinner. We were immediately greeted and..."
Susan Youshaw Cashner
"We just left five minutes ago but my family and I all agree this was possibly one of the best meals we have had. Food was delicious, decor was..."
Sarah DeGeorge
"We have never been to Pittsburgh and really enjoyed our meal at Zarra’s! The eggplant and ricotta noodles were..."
Erica Tabbert Blouin
"We were in town for the Tool concert last night, and stayed in the hotel across from Zarra's...the hotel didn't have a bar, so we walked over for a..."
Lesley Spangler
"I went for the first time two weeks ago. I can't understand why I hadn't been here before. I totally loved it and will be a regular there in the..."
Gary Streiner
"Go here, NOW!! Excellent!! Don't waste your time and money going to any other Italian restaurant in town. Superb food, friendly ownership and staff...."
Thomas Eger
"This place is just like Grandma's house. The dining room could have been hers...And the cooking, Oh My God. Just like my grandmother's. Donnie..."
Paul Martino Kdka
"Fabulous staff & atmosphere personable, inviting & friendly!!!! Would highly..."
Clarissa Figueira-Smith
"My wife and I come to Pittsburg, from Cleveland, to go to Zarra’s for our anniversary dinner. The food is wonderful and the atmosphere is..."
Richard Bagger
"Thanks Again for the Wonderful time we had at Zarra's. Lauren & Donny really made it special for us. Food was amazing . A hidden Gem for..."
Steve Hardy
"Closest thing to Grammas kitchen there is! Great atmosphere and amazing food with even better people. True gem in Pittsburghs Italian..."
Rick Borowski
"Great place, food, and owners. Didn’t know this was the electric banana before. So awesome to know the..."
Pete Plutch
"Gorgeous place to eat. Absolutely fantastic rack of lamb. Will make any Aussie / Kiwi homesick for home. Beautiful family and so welcome to a lone..."
Angela Tuffley
"This place is a unique Pittsburgh gem. My now-husband took me here for our first date (surprising me with a rare PGH restaurant I hadn't been to)...."
Abby Fudor
"This was a GREAT FIND AND AWESOME Italian food. I felt like I was eating at my grandmas house. I loved the place and suggest eating here if you have..."
James Major
"I have eaten steaks around the world and the steak I had at Zarras was the best piece of meat that has ever touched my mouth. Although it is pricey..."
Mr Smith
"Great food great place will return and highly recommended best food in the..."
Paul Black
"Authentic Italian. My friend and I stopped at Zarra's on a whitewater paddling trip a couple of weeks ago. Please be warned... this is not your..."
Jonathan Dzielak
"Great Food. Zarra's is by far the best Italian restaurant I have ever eaten at. Not the same old boring menu as most Italian restaurants have, but a..."
Keith F
"Yum!. Went to Zarra's for dinner last night for the first time. Everything was absolutely delicious. I had cavatelli with spinach and garlic, and my..."
Bunny
"Wonder Italian cuisine with an equal atmosphere! We sat out on the patio and enjoyed the view. Thanks..."
Eric
"Zarra's is awesome!!!!!!!. My gf and I travel for a living and are constantly looking for great local family restaurants of all ethnic cuisine...."
Manny C.
"Best Date Ever. I took someone to Zarra's for our first date and all I could say was Wow! Beginning with what's most important, the food was..."
Randy Paul
"The Ricotta Noodles are AMAZING!. I wandered into Zarra's for no reason other than the fact that it was across the street from my hotel, but I am..."
Borzou Motlagh
"AMAZING!!!!. This place is GREAT!!! I went my first week of school at Pitt and it was the most delicious meal ever! The place is truly authentic..."
Kourtney B
"Best Italian in Pittsburgh. We first ate at Zarra's about 5 years ago, and we were immediately impressed by the food. My husband is Italian and his..."
Kelly
"Best Italian in Pittsburgh! Marinara to die for, awesome balsamic dressing and homemade pasta, will definitely go..."
Mac84
"Best italian food****ever!!!. Zarra's restaurant. is the best! not only the atmosphere great...the food and people is awesome too. when u go..."
Mel
"OUR FIRST BUT NOT LAST VISIT. Our first visit to Zarra's was on June 17,2008 after an 8 hour drive from the Philadelphia area. Our daughter was..."
Lydia
"From the moment you walk in, you are instantly immersed into an old Italian family dining atmosphere. It's unique, and your eyes gravitate to the..."
Marianne Schafer
"It felt like a friend had invited me for dinner at her mom or grandmother’s house. The woman who took my order was also the famous “Judy” on..."
Kelsey Cunningham
"Our dinner was amazing authentic Italian food. Family owned for 52 years. The price was more than reasonable. I live in Ohio and I will be back!!!..."
Allison Ickey
"The food was delicious. The whole atmosphere was warm and cozy. We really enjoyed our waitress Kelly this was our first visit to Zarra’s and Kelly..."
L
"Absolutely everything about this place is amazing, from it's history, to the owners, to the present day wonderful menu. What a great place to visit,..."
Carole Vankirk
"Really excellent and friendly service. Wonderful appetizers to pass around and share:. stuffed banana peppers, calamari antipasto, rollatini..."
Michael Conway
"Had a wonderful evening and dining experience! The food was delicious, the atmosphere relaxed and the owner was gracious and welcoming! Homemade..."
Linda Monteleone
"Best Italian food I've ever had. The Italian sausage was phenomenal. Very spicy, but I loved it. I had the Zarra's sampler plate and I can hardly..."
Joe Joslin
"Had a fantastic experience here. Excellent atmosphere, very friendly owners, and incredible good. We started with the dumpling soup, which was gooey..."
Jennifer OConnor
"This place is a hidden gem. It should be packed, the food and atmosphere are Italian to the core. Even the Italian mom cooking upstairs. It feels..."
Shawn Lucas (Red)
"Lovely experience. I was worried that my Italian husband would not like it because he is used to homemade food from his mom. He loved it. Fun decor..."
Elizabeth Liz Cioffi
"Had dinner with my father here, really nice place! Solid food and service, couldn't ask for any..."
Cameron Caruso
"Our kids took us to Zarras for dinner last night. A unique place! We wanted to eat outside. Nice little area to do that since the weather was..."
Donna Pauley
"It was easy to find and the interior is worth a look at least once. The staff were friendly and the food is good. I wasn't overly impressed but I..."
Elaine Smearman
"The food is homestyle southern Italian American and delicious. The atmosphere is eclectic and more like immersive theater. Baked Alaska is not on..."
Renee
"Looks nice, owner and servers are nice. Very helpful and take care of you while there like you are family. Food is expensive. Go to enjoy a slow..."
Brandon Potter
"Upon approaching the door I noticed a NRA sticker! I was very happy to see the business is owned by a freedom loving owner! Besides the fact the food..."
R W