Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Pittsford
7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Great pizza as always. Very unique selection for..."
Dan S
"They have expanded over the years but the Basin remains to be the best of them all. Classic NY style pizza that has been around forever but hasn’t..."
M Sheff
"Ordered pizza today ahead of the Bills game and wow- do they have a system at this location. I was impressed. Even with the insane amount of orders..."
sierra dawson
"Just got a med pepperoni. Outstanding. This location is known for its quality and it didn't disappoint.
I definitely recommend..."
Chris Lockemann (Flacco)
"The BEST pizza in the area. I used to drive out here from Rochester just to eat this pizza. And they never stress you about (or charge for) taking..."
Michael LeCesse
"Best Pizza on the east side of rochester. It is like a well oiled machine. They just rip pizzas at a pace that would make your head spin. Even though..."
Michael
"The most reliably good of the local Pontillo’s locations. A good assortment of slices available most of the time, and they pump out a quality pie...."
William Kalish
"I’m not from NY State and I know locals tell me a chain type joint. But service efficient friendly. As for the pizza. I loved it. Best I’ve had..."
Todd D
"I came here because I saw that they had the old school pizza oven. The reason why I like the pizza ovens is because a produces a crusty bottom. Due..."
D P
"Pizza is delicious as always. It's cramped in there at lunch, they never have hot slices ready to go, they always have to warm it up. When in a hurry..."
Daniel Amos
"The best pizza in Rochester. I’ve been coming here my whole life. Out of all the other pizzas I’ve had, it remains my favorite pizza. Ingredients..."
Willy Marello
"Best buffalo chicken hands down, staff are usually rude, though. Don't get me wrong, I'm still gonna keep ordering pizza from..."
Matt Johnson
"I have been to all the tillos, I have had pizza all over the world. For me this is the best pizza on the planet, hands down my favorite all around..."
Anthony Carapezza
"Been around for forever great pizza grab a slice special on your lunch you won't regret..."
Robert Crowley
"Definitely the best pie in the general area. It is always busy and always crowded, but that's what happens when you're the best around.
The only..."
Frank Saccone
"Some of Rochester's best pizza! Bushnell's Basin location pumps out the best quality. They were busy and their store is tiny, but they got me in and..."
Melissa Volentine
"It had been 20 years since I had a Pontillo’s Pizza until this weekend. It is still just as amazing as it was back in the..."
"Came here today with my daughter to grab a slice while she had the day off. Neither of us were disappointed by the slices.
The cheese was perfectly..."
Ryan Bates
"The best pizza in town. Our family’s favorite pizza, we have been customers for over 13..."
Daylin “Mommy of 4 kids & 3 birds” Pecora
"This is the closest to authentic New York pizza that you can get by far in the greater Rochester area! The place is very nicely decorated and always..."
Sami Eddy
"Stop in for a couple slices at lunch. I was the a bit before noon and it was pretty quiet, but when the lunch crowd came in it got pretty busy!
I..."
Josh Newby (chem_newby)
"Ordered delivery- pizza arrived quickly and hot. Generous amount of toppings, reasonable price. Not too greasy, good flavor— though not a sweet..."
MD062010
"Best thin crust pizza I've had anywhere in the area. Service quick & friendly. Decor very cool graffiti art representing the 5 boroughs. Highly..."
Brett Leader
"The pizza was not shy of toppings we ordered the medium county sweet chicken and bacon. There was enough for two people we had a few slices left..."
Lyrek McConnell
"By far the best pizza in the area. I grew up outside NYC and it's the closest thing to real NYC pizza. Good variety too- kid loves the calzones. Only..."
Racheal Colom
"The best gluten-free crust ever! The Italian smell hits you when you walk in and makes your mouth water for their food. The pizzas tasted amazing,..."
Brenda Lowrie
"Perfect place to pick up slices while in the Pittsford Plaza. Lots of variety in their whole pizzas (Love the chicken sesame). Prices for slices are..."
Paul Van Orden (Videoboy324)
"My daughter and I shared an order of Garlic Knots and a small Country Sweet Chicken &Bacon Specialty Pizza. Both were excellent! We brought home 2..."
Hank Ciniglia
"Loved it. I finally had the opportunity to try this pizza, I heard a lot of it and they were right. I tried pepperoni bacon and garlic cheese. Thin..."
Yessica Arvizu
"Bless pizza stop. Perfect pizza, great cookies too. Staff is always nice. I stop in multiple times a..."
Nadine
"The pizza is pretty amazing here and the service is always great too. I recommend trying them out if you haven't just yet. Their pies are that..."
"Just had an excellent Sunday dinner with colleagues. We each ordered different dishes (fish, pasta, and pizza) and everyone was full and happy...."
Aaron Jeanotte
"Beautiful restaurant with kind staff. Food was out of this world. Had the Gnocchi - goat cheese, cranberries and some sort of seafood... Was not..."
Kenneth Clark
"Great food, great service, great atmosphere, decent prices. I couldn't ask for a better date for me and my wife. It was amazing. We come back every..."
Nicholas Maggi
"Stopped in for appetizers n cocktails, the calamari, butternut burrata, and the roasted garlic with homemade ricotta were all super tasty, the..."
Larry Clinton
"Started with the housemate ricotta and calamari. Both did not disappoint. I would say the crostinis for the ricotta should be thinner, by the roasted..."
Michael Fallen
"Reliably good. Whether enjoying the 1/2 price Happy Hour, or enjoying a nice meal at our table, they are always reliably..."
Jeff Barteld
"We sat outside on the patio and ot was beautiful! The service is excellent, our ricotta board was delicious, and my seared lasagna was so flavorful!..."
Jamie H
"Impeccable drinks. Bartender Claudia is amazing!! The food is to die for! And the owner, Danny, is the best. He is professional, friendly, helpful..."
Tori Cummings
"Amazing food, cocktails, and atmosphere! Definitely the best happy hour around. Highly..."
Bridget
"Overall a good vibe. The food is tasty but could benefit from some more seasoning ... bit of salt greatly improved things. Portions are large. If..."
Tim
"My wife & I went to Branca for dinner. The pizza is hands down the best in Monroe county! The sauce was fresh & flavorful. The prosciutto de parma..."
David DiMora
"Great experience! Delicious drinks and food! Best part was Claudia Hoyser..."
"Mark's Pizza 🍕 is still good. I love my mild wings 😋. Meatball pizza is the best, because of less oil that the pepperoni..."
RAY Ortiz
"We stopped here to pick up a sheet pizza on our way to our son's house. We were promptly greeted by one of their friendly workers, (Erin, she is..."
James Taylor
"Always order delivery and always on time. Delivery is fast and heatedt! I appreciate a company that cares about the customer and services put out...."
Timothy Lynd
"The staff is nice. Very delicious pizza and wings. The orders came fresh from the oven, very..."
Migdalia Pagan Cruz
"Food is great and the staff is very friendly! Love the fried dough bites & Garlic knots! Great job..."
Craig T
"The best Garlic Parmesan wings ever! Excellent double cheese pizza! I highly recommend..."
Aleana “GoingHome” Goodman
"Five star mostly for their customer service. Typically we pick up in good weather, occasionally I order in the morning for an evening pick up or..."
Rita Brunelli
"A quick and easy visit for lunch. Plenty of space in their dining area, or eat outside at
the tables right out front!! Recommended.
Excellent pizza..."
Brian Bauer
"Grew up on mark's pizzeria but sadly they moved out from where I grew up. But we found one again on vacation and it was just as I remembered. Awesome..."
carrie harp
"Loves Marks! Great pizza & service..."
Jenna B
"Best pizza I had in years bar..."
Carla Stalcup
"Usually we order takeout or delivery. The atmosphere in the store Is reminiscent of the old Bay & Goodman OizA in..."
Bill Czora
"Young lady on register had no idea of what she was doing. Food was very..."
Les Gales
"I was visiting from GA and had to order from my favorite pizza place in the world . Unfortunately the wings were not well done and they forgot the..."
"Ordered a Large Veggie pizza for the first time from here. Honestly one of the best pies I have had. There was a lot vegetables it tasted fresh...."
Jeffrey McQuay
"Classic pizza from Rochester’s own hometown pizza shop. Gets you a slice right away or load up for the whole..."
Kevin Markman
"Pizza is reasonably priced and average in taste. They have indoor and outdoor sitting. My husband ordered a steak sub. He said that it is not as good..."
Grace Soong
"Pizza is great, as most any Pontillo's are. The location has a great layout inside, very unique to this one in particular, and an arcade game to kill..."
Thomas Waterhouse
"i ordered a pizza from here and the service was very fast. the girl who placed my order was very polite as well as the other girl who delivered...."
isabelle med
"I love the pizza here, always cooked correctly. The pepperoni is crispy and the dough is cooked all the way through. The staff has always been polite..."
Leaving ASAP
"Ordered on a busy Saturday night. Delicious pizza, cooked perfectly and fresh..."
LT
"Excellent pizza! Excellent wings! My favorite Pontillos hands down! Sorry to say I live on west side of town and I can’t find anything close to..."
richard ferrari
"This is my favorite Pontillo's pizzaria in Rochester. The way they make their chicken wing pizza! It's always the same PERFECT. Plus I can get a..."
Pistol Pete Luciano
"Have never had a problem. For being the only pizza place that will deliver to me they are pretty quick and the food arrives pretty..."
John Stranko
"Best fries of my life! This flakey exterior is to die..."
"First time at this place, excellent experience. Someone at work told me to check it out. The pizza selection was awesome. Ancient grain crust, gluten..."
Rich Northrop
"While it's not a vegan restaurant, they DO have vegan options! Yay! The crusts are all vegan, they have vegan cheese, and offer a nice big selection..."
Heather Paris
"Excellent pizza, amazing atmosphere & wonderful staff!! Definitely a place I’ll come back to time & time..."
KiKi Gelke
"Vegan options on point � endless veggie toppings and vegan cheese! Outdoor seating is nice too, the dog gets to join..."
Coco SA
"Fresh pizza and a surprisingly good selection of beer on tap and bottle. Friendly..."
Dave Farrands
"Wonderful pizza! Best crust, many different sauces, a huge variety of fresh toppings...plus build your salad, a large range of things to drink, 6..."
Marion Serns Owen
"Wonderful restaurant, amazing pizza, tasty salads, great drinks... I haven't had the dessert their yet because I always end up eating all my pizza..."
Ronald Poffenvis
"What a fantastic experience custom designing a pizza. Excellent service and locally sourced vegetables. Definitely recommend visiting ..."
Steven Miller
"The pizza la-vodka had a great combination of ingredients which worked with each other. It was fantastic. I wanted the pizzas my companions..."
Alison Squiers
"My cousin and I tried Favo's out for dinner. It did not disappoint. We loved making our own pizzas. The pizzas did not take long to arrive at our..."
Ileana Arbelo Keltz
"Perfect place that needs to have a location in NJ! I tried 4 different styles of their pizza and all of them were..."
Jeremy Caparas
"Pizza was great the staff are amazing. They are so enthusiastic and genuinely care..."
Amanda Kelly
"My kid loved this place. She could choose the flavor combinations she wanted for her pizza. They offer some fun drink for kids, like lemonade and..."
Jen Groot
"Put an order in to be picked up at 730, work ran a little late . ended up getting there an hour late, 15 mins before they closed hoping the cold..."
Jordan Brown
"This is my favorite pizza place making personal pizzas just the way you want them. All fresh ingredients and all the types of veggies you want!..."
David Sherburne
"Favo makes good pizza for Rochester (I've been spoiled by NYC and the Jersey Shore). Lots of choices and even gluten free crust option and vegan..."
Ilona Remenicky
"Interesting restaurant in a somewhat bad location I think... Nestled in a plaza that is not overly busy. From the outside it looks like a typical..."
David Muth
"One of our fave spots for our family dinners. Staff is always amazing, pizza is delish, salads are yum, and beer and wine always hit the spot. Our..."
Lily Abdulina-Habgood
"Delish, totally customizable pizza and housemade soda combined with a fun atmosphere and great service! Plus there's dessert..."
Allison Giordano
"Family and I have been coming here for quite a few years. And every time we have had a great experience. This is my 12 year old sons favorite pizza...."
Kimberly Faulkner
"My family and I traveled from Canada for a couple days. We researched pizza for supper and decided to come here. We were not disappointed. We had a..."
Todd Fagan
"The lead with the Deadpool hat is really attentive to detail. There was a slightly darkened ‘Za in front of us that justice had more errors and was..."
Cormac H
"I've been going here consistently for years and it's my go-to for pizza here on the East Side. It's been consistently delicious and if you ever want..."
Emily Yoon
"Made to order delicious and diverse personal pizzas! Variety of topping options, including different cheeses, two different crusts to choose from and..."
Alyssa Fox
"The most delicious brick oven pizza in Rochester with locally grown produce and I love the salad that's made with homemade white French..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes