Great food, prices, and service! Best diner in the area!
Was told from a friend about this place and that it was really good. So had to check it out for myself . It didn't disappoint. I ordered the Dogtown plate. My friends ordered the mushroom swiss burger and double dog plate. The Dogtown plate was good. It's kinda like a garbage plate with macaroni salad,two hotdogs with hot meat sauce and french fries. My friends said the mushroom swiss burger and double dogs were good. This place has such a unique menu. I will definitely be back
The have so many different kinds of loaded Mac and cheeses & baked potatoes I want to try. They also had something with a pulled brisket that sounded delicious. On Sundays they have a no wait brunch buffet from 9am-1 pm . Definitely recommend and will definitely be back. They have ample parking.
We go every Wednesday and the food and the staff are absolutely amazing. I recommend the chicken parm and macaroni and cheese special on Wednesdays. You won't be disappointed.
We were driving by on I-90 and needed breakfast, so my wife picked Potters and we are so glad we stopped! This is one of the best diners we've ever stopped at from Batavia to New York City.
Everything was great, from the eggs, omelettes, and toast to the service and atmosphere of the diner itself inside and out.
We didn't see any, and just wish they had outdoor seating while we were there—like picnic benches so we could enjoy the beautiful flowers and summer weather outside. Regardless though, this place is now a go-to whenever we drive from Rochester to NYC.
The photo here is half of my veggie lovers omelette with rye toast, I saved it to eat again later on our road trip!
Edit 07/31/23: Thank you for letting us know about the outdoor seating! There's simply nothing left for us to nit pick over. Loved it and will return whenever we drive by to NYC.
I was almost nervous about the food when it got to the table so quickly, but everything was delicious, and the portions were more than generous.
Our server was friendly, fast, and on top of refills.
We sat inside, and the atmosphere was tidy and a little bland, but who goes to restaurants for the decor?
Overall, this is a great place, and I would definitely recommend.
Hidden gem! The inside is very charming and the food is fantastic! We ordered the pulled pork loaded baked potato and the fried chicken and mac. Would love to try breakfast next!
Portion sizes were generous (popcorn chicken appetizer could have been a meal!) and the service was pretty good. Wasn't a lot of cheese on my mac and cheese but the chicken was very moist and tasty.
We will certainly give this place another opportunity...
Awesome Food! And yes that's a soft shelled crab. Byron NY. I went to college with owners aunt. And even visited the farm back in the.late 70's!
Birders, not far from Montezuma. Found this treasure but not the Pink-footed Goose!
We had brunch here today and it was so nice. We had our baby and puppy with us. The outdoor seating was perfect - shady and comfortable. We both got the brunch buffet and shared a mimosa flight. There was fresh fruit on the buffet and many options. We usually order takeout but this was great. Also - the brisket baked potato is a must have (the potatoes are huge!)
A great diner in Port Byron, especially if you like potatoes. They sell a 1 pound baked potato with a variety of topping combinations. If you don't like baked potatoes, they do a mashed potato bowl with the same topping combos. The brisket with Bbq sauce is delicious. The fried fish dinner was also very good.
They are now selling icecream cones and more at a separate building, and a patio for outdoor seating.
Had lunch at Potter's. It was the first time I've visited since it used to be Brenda's. The inside hasn't changed but they now have a side patio for eating outside. They have live music on Friday nights. They also put in a small building to serve ice cream. The waitress was attentive and the food was great.
We had a baby shower here. My first visit. A nice private room, the food was excellent and the staff went above and beyond. Looked like a great place to just drop in and eat 🙂
Potters did a soft opening & OMG the food was amazing! They made some serious remodeling outside the building, painted the inside & replaced the flooring. My favorite part about the newly renovated is their scattered photos, mainly the one of an old local Savannah farm, Jackson Farms. Trevor passed away a few years ago & to see a small tribute to him was very heartwarming. Our waitress was beyond friendly. The food was great & very responsibly priced.
Just had our first visit to Potters and we will definitely be going back when we are in the area! My wife loved her Greek salad and my Garbage Plate was excellent! I asked to have it with brown gravy instead of the normal hot sauce and they were happy to oblige. Our waitress was great and so were the prices and portions!
They really should address the entrance door that slams as people are leaving. I let it shut slowly as to not slam. Guess some of us are more noise and vibration sensitive than others. They really should have an advertisement for the Sunday breakfast buffet in the front area also. We weren't aware of it until we seen a couple next to us making their way from the back room and inquired.
This is our go to breakfast spot when road-tripping (it’s an hour from where we live and we make sure to add it into our map on our way to our destination). Their breakfasts are delicious! I hope to stop by during their lunch time someday to try their lunches! Their pancakes are mouth watering by the way!
Quiet place to eat good food in Port Byron. The smothered grill chicken with balsamic vinegar and bell peppers was tasty, good size portions and French fries
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes