Best Mexican Quesadilla in Port Jefferson Station

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Margarita’s Cafe
Margarita’s Cafe
78/100 (1086 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Pub
Mexican
Mexican
Latin
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Parrillada Ala Mexicana
Full Pitcher Mojito 1
Margarita
Empanadas
Chimichangas
Sopa Azteca
Chicken Fajitas
Chips and Salsa
Guacamole Dip
Mexican Quesadilla
Nachos
Tres Leches
Jambalaya
Homemade Tamales
Pastel de Banano
Mexican
Bar
Pub
Latin
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We have been dining in and ordering take out for years. Management and servers are attentive and honor reservations. Food and drinks are conistlantly..."
Mack Vismusic
"A great spot. Me and my wife went out for dinner and the food was so fresh and delicious. Drinks were great and service was extremely fast and..."
Ryan M
"The food was really good and I would love to go back!!! Stop on..."
Gregory Barbera
"Besides the service being slooooow (we may have arrived after a big rush), the portions were large, food was really good (recommend the steak..."
David Ryan
"Henry was awesome! $6 sangrias, tableside guacamole, great service, fajitas were excellent, steak quesadilla was so good! Steak was tender and juicy...."
Gina Patterson
"06/17/2023 Very nice place. Port Jefferson Station. Seated immediately. Appeared to be lots of staff. Live music. All staff was friendly and warm...."
mitchell rakita
"Energetic ambience...tasty food suitable for vegetarians...spicy enough. Tried fajitas, quesadillas and Pina Colada's were good! Will come back..."
Nakul Tyagi
"The ambience was great! The owner was friendly and on point. Staff was great! They will dance on my next visit. Good music.The food was delicious. I..."
Randy Rocha
"Nice spot. Food was delicious, and house margarita was perfect. Friendly..."
Christine Ross
"Margarita's has excellent cuisine! Every bite is incredibly flavorful and a joy to eat. The portions are generous as well. Everything tasted..."
Allister McGuire
"Service was pleasant, prompt and attentive. The Margarita pitcher delicious and plenty for three. Every meal was sizzling and exceptional. Not our..."
Richard Towler
"They're nice and delicious food amazing margarita drinks also the service..."
Christine Starkey
"What a great place! Great food, nice atmosphere, just delicious!!!! Great staff..."
Dawn
"Food was great. Best guacamole I have had in a long time. Made table side! Big portions. Lots of vegetarian options. Server could have been..."
Andrew Anker