Best Sandwiches in Port Jefferson Station

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Chick-fil-a
Chick-fil-a
88/100 (3543 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Fast Food
Fast food
American
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Waffle Fries
My Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Chicken noodle soup
Pulled Pork
Chick-Fil-A Chicken Nuggets
Fruit Cup
Strawberry Milkshake
Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Raclette
Cobb Salad
Market Salad
Chick-Fil-A Cool Wrap
Chick-Fil-A Waffle Potato Fries
Grilled Nuggets
Sandwiches
Spicy Deluxe Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Club Meal
Salad
Medium Coca Cola
Chick-Fil-A Deluxe Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Nuggets
Chicken Sandwich
Chick-Fil-A Nuggets Meal
Fast food
Fast food
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Drive Thru
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This is one of our favorite "fast" food places to get a quick meal. The service is always very friendly, though due to how busy it gets, there is..."
Paul Mallia
"It is the first time to visit Chick-ful-A, and it is an awesome experience to be here and enjoy the food. Recommend to being here and helping..."
Steve Im (YouTunnelTV Steve)
"Service aas a bit on the slow end but they were very busy with drive through orders and counter orders. It looked the staff worked well together and..."
S O
"I love Chick-fil-A. But the medium fries really stacked..."
Riotsociety90 S
"2 drive through lines and employees being trained are guided efficiently to move the line without too much pause. Food was ready quick and service..."
Erin Hookim
"Outstanding is pretty much all I can say. Service, selection and delivery all rate an A+. Now the flavor is something I will never forget. So yummy...."
pauline jenkins
"Great fast food place. Even tho they fell off a bit recently, they're still great. Not open on Sundays tho so keep that in..."
Shane Drisgula
"Food is amazing and my boy miles the manager is mad chill one of the reasons i go to the Huntington Station location all my peeps at that location..."
Drew Demarco
"Have never had any issues with this Chick-fil-A! Staff is kind, and even during busy hours, they manage to stay kind and work quickly. I do recommend..."
Kate Rose
"Good food, it's exactly what you'd expect. Everyone who works there is professional and polite. The wait was very long for a fast food restaurant...."
Colin
"What's there to say about Chick-fil-A?? It is one of the best fast food places. For the number of people that show up at this place.... it's always..."
MARIA OLSON
"I may not agree with some of the corporate policies, but the staff at this location is diverse, gracious, and supportive. And the food is..."
Matt Healy
"Service is always amazing, food was DELICIOUS they even gave my puppy a pup..."
Jada
"Food is always great but the drive-thru situation can be..."
Iva G
"Food,cleanliness,service.. excellent. Special thanks to Manager Ruth who was extra..."
Tom Barberio
"Its Chick-fil-A there’s no need to say anything else. I just wish they had more stores but I still drive 30 minutes to get it sometimes. Try doing..."
YKK
Toast Coffeehouse
Toast Coffeehouse
84/100 (2259 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Cafe
Vegan Options
American
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Tapas
Burrito
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Sandwiches
Breakfast Burrito
Burger
Toasts
Omelette
Beef
Corned Beef
Waffles
BLT
Pancakes
Salad
Cakes
Café
Café
American
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Mid-range
"I love Toast im Port Jeff..Been there 4 times and every time is a pleasure..Friendly welcomes and the staff is amazingly efficient� I drink tea and..."
Judith Mauriello
"Courteous, conscientious dedication to customer service! And my coffee snob granddaughter did a cupping and approves the coffee. "Bold flavor,..."
Carol Mannarino
"Awesome hipster atmosphere, tasty inventive food, diverse menu, and great service - especially since they are always very..."
Madison McLaughlin
"Awesome breakfast food highly recommended one of my 2 favorite places to eat breakfast at here and glens in Bablyon, they have some amazing mimosas..."
Rich Sineno
"Love eating here. When ever I’m in town from Florida i eat here a few times each visit. Yes, there’s always a wait but well worth..."
April Droscoski Ferrera
"Friendly staff.. nice atmosphere/music .. great..."
Tom Rochford
"One of the best spots on Long Island!! Great food! Great service! Warm, cool decor. Truly a..."
Eric Noel Perez
"I love Toast!! � my suggestions are: the bandito burrito, the crunchy raspberry French toast and the Nutella French toast � the lattes are super..."
Catherine Sandstedt
"First time here. Ample parking and the restaurant is more spacious than the old location. Full menu of classic breakfast options. Food is fresh and..."
N W (Helen)
"Toast was something my girlfriend has been wanting to take me to for awhile for brunch. I like the modern atmosphere. Something interesting I..."
Deathrus
"First time trying toast after hearing about it for a long time. Decided to try this location on our way out east. It looked packed but we waited no..."
Jj Prete
"My friends recommended this place for breakfast. Fast, friendly service, nice cozy atmosphere, delicious coffee. I'll definitely come back for lunch..."
Natalia Ilina
"Delicious looking forward to returning. My meal tasted very good but I was disappointed that the chicken was dark meat, I would have preferred..."
Vanessa Leggard
"I'm so glad they moved from down port. The food is still amazing and the staff is always running around. We had mimosa flights, they are holiday..."
Robert Papp
"One of the best breakfast places around. I have tried so many of their dishes, and they were all delicious. They do not disappoint. Highly recommend...."
Darice Dennis
"Delish!! Signed up for the waitlist option. Not bad at all our wait! I’m so happy for the owner, bigger location, it was buzzing! Server was..."
karen sullivan
"Love this place. Food was amazing, staff was friendly. We drove 1 hour to get here and it was definitely worth the trip and 30 mins wait time..."
L&L
"Crowded and huge new location but no wait time. The food was amazing & also they have a vegan menu..."
Isabel Flores
"IT’S BACK! And at a huge location with so much space!!! The port Jeff location was definitely tiny and cramped compared to this one, so congrats on..."
Kimiko
"It will of been a 5-star service, but the server messed up and charged me for two coffee. It was correct after pointing out the extra..."
Echo Five Photography
"Great food! Update 6/2023: They've moved to a bigger space, and it is fantastic! The atmosphere is fantastic. I love the whole vibe. The food is..."
Allister McGuire
"We love coming here when we can get in. Food is great, service is friendly. Both Port Jeff and Patchogue have a cool dining room feel. Definitely add..."
Keith Morano
"Delicious food! New location in PJ is huge! Great menu! Great..."
A Rod
"First time coming here and we liked what we saw. Everything..."
imran syed
"We meet friends every few months. We used to rotate the restaurants but we've come to use Toast. The menu selections are varied so it really is hard..."
Barbara Nelson
Wunderbar Deli
Wunderbar Deli
81/100 (440 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Soups
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Breakfast Sandwich
American
Soups
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Stopped there late this afternoon just before closing but we had not realized how late it was (4:48 and they close at 5 pm on Saturdays). I worked at..."
Jim Flanagan
"Excellent deli! My husband has been going to Wunderbar for over 30 years! Chris always makes my sandwichs PERFECT! Their rice pudding is delicious..."
Denise Carman
"Born & raised Catholic, but I think I just converted to WUNDERBAR! I’ve had a million B. E. C. sammys, but this one was somehow like no other! ..."
John O' Connell
"Super friendly staff, exactly what you should expect from an authentic Long Island deli, the BECSPK was the best I’d ever..."
RON BOUGHEY
"Old school German deli in the heart of Port Jefferson over stuffed sandwiches. At least a half a pound of bacon on an egg sandwich at reasonable..."
Tommy James
"Awsome. BEC... Possibly best on the island.... Very clean, first class deli, glad I found it, check it out, u won't be..."
Timothy Cullinan
"The most incredible breakfast sandwich bar none!! Slap on the feedbag when coming here for..."
Joe Milone
"I've gotten many people addicted to their German potato salad - soooo good. They make great sandwiches here and also a multitude of salads - all..."
Stefanie Ehrlein
"I wish more than anything we had a deli like this where we live! Came to visit Long Island from Virginia and fell in love with Wunderbar. Absolutely..."
Sarah Silvius
"This place has some of the most incredible lunch food I have ever tasted. They have great prices and the portions are almost 3 meal quality. I..."
Matt Old-z
"Worth the wait. I just had the best veil hero ever! Just the right amount of tender veil, a little cheese and the best German gravy. Mouth..."
Jeff Schnee
"The best hungryman on the island! So much crispy bacon, this was a well made breakfast..."
Davis Aragones
"Great German potato salad and awesome Cole slaw. Friendly staff, hot foods very good, can't wait to try breakfast. Served daily till 11:30am...."
Kathy Pupino
Wahlburgers
Wahlburgers
75/100 (1846 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Mac and cheese
Chicken Sandwich
Sandwiches
Burger
Tater tots
Hamburgers
"Husband and I stopped by for first time ever yesterday while in the area. Restaurant was pretty empty but it was an early weekday afternoon and most..."
Vanessa Waters
"Very cool to go into the place after watching it on tv. We sat and ordered and the food took forever to come to our table. The waitress was really..."
Matthew Hart
"Amazing food, terrible wait times. Was told it would take 20 minutes to get a table, but we were seated in 10. Great looking menu. Burgers are..."
Mark Lang
"The bartender JP is an awesome employee and turned my negative experience into a positive one! Wait 40 minutes for my takeout order to be ready and..."
Kelly-Anne Kratz
"Delicious food, great drinks, and the atmosphere made me feel like I was back..."
Tracey Thompson
"First time here! The food was good and our waitress was..."
Theresa
"Had a great time, the Melt was great. Loved the onion straws. The shakes looked great, but I had a beer instead. Will be back..."
Keith Hinkley
"Burger was great. We wanted it to go and it was quite a wait, and it wasn’t really busy. Staff was very..."
Pat B
"Decent spot for a burger. Love their Peanut Butter..."
DarkSidesHero
"Great burgers! Friendly bartender everything was amazing! Definitely coming back for those shakes and..."
Maria Flores
"Had to wait for about 10 minutes because there was no one at the hostess station when I came in. But had a great waiter who checked on me several..."
Lisa Perry