We arrived to the ferry with just a small window of time and empty stomachs. I was thinking of just getting a few of the ready-made slices, but then my partner asked about getting a fresh pie and how long that would take. We got an estimate of 15 minutes, but as soon as he read our hesitant looks, he vowed, "10 minutes." We agreed, and within 10 minutes we had a fresh pepperoni pie, plus two impulse-buy Jamaican beef patties that were fresh out of the oven, and it all hit the spot when we enjoyed it on the ferry not long afterward.
This place was exactly what we needed, and then some! If you also find yourself waiting for the ferry and in need of good food in a hurry, this is the place to go.
I grew up on LI, went to Our Last of Wisdom (Catholic School just up the street), and went down port every couple of weeks.
I've since moved to Arizona, where we aren't exactly known for our pizza. Every year, my husband (also from LI) & I go visit family back home in Lindenhurst and Merrick.
I brought him to Port Jeff Pizza on a rare putting to show him down port, and now... EVERY YEAR we go home, we will drive all the way out to Port Jefferson for the best pizza on the island!
The memories, the flavors, the service.... THANK YOU! A million times over- THANK YOU! see you in a few months!
If you’re looking for a cheap quick slice, go here. Nothing fancy. Had a regular cheese slice and pepperoni slice. Serviceable pizza
Great location, always open late, but i think its a bit over priced.. hopefully i was just over charged.. no bad vibes here.. 15 $ for 2 special slices and 1 drink seemed a little steep.. had no change for tip jar.. lol.
Their garlic knot crust pie is amaaaazing.
Not bad! Pizza better than youde expect in a little place like this, kinda like a gem in the rough. Only draw back was the lobby was tiny and theres no seats or anywhere to sit at all except a few shelf areas to place your pizza on the sides, i would imagine it wouod be rather akward to eat your pizza there when theres a large line of people standing 2 feet from you. But honestly what do you expect when your given so little room to work with. Good job!
Service was quick and friendly, nice it you just want some quick food on the go as you walk around Port Jeff and do some shopping or etc.
Oh and the Crust is perfection!!!!!
Good pizza, fast service; just what you would expect from a hole-in-the-wall type of place. Grab a slice and enjoy walking around town as you eat. Easily the best pizza in the area.
Amazing. Great pizza. Quick service. Perfect if your in a hurry and need a quick slice or a whole pie. When all else is closed PJ Pizza will be open.
Their pizza is really good. Their service is excellent and the employees are so friendly. Love this place!
We ordered a pie and it was amazing!! So fresh and so delicious.
Clinical Care Solutions
+5
Friendly, convenient true NY style pizza. You can't go wrong stopping by this neighborhood gem!
The best pizza place in town. It's the only 1 in town other than the PIE. But the only place to get just a slice of pizza.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes