Best Lobster Roll in Port Jefferson

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Twilight Cafe Pj
Twilight Cafe Pj
84/100 (1070 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Firecracker Calamari
Lobster Tail Scampi
Blackened Chilean Sea Bass
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish Salad
Creamed Spinach
Fish and Chips Platter
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Seafood Paella
Cheeseburger
Lobster Roll
Waffle Fries
Bucket of Mussels
cold brew
Hot Lobster Roll
Crab cakes
Shrimp Francese
Fried calamari
Steak & Lobster Dinner
All You Can Eat Snow Crab Legs
Dinner
Lunch
"The fried clam strips were delicious! The lobster roll was stuffed with meat. The ice cream sundae was delicious. The cappuccino was well made. The..."
Sarah Tobin
"THE PJ LOBSTER HOUSE, PORT JEFFERSON NY 👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍 For our 60 Wedding Anniversary, I..."
JOE GULA
"We were waited on by Sandy who was hospitable and welcoming. We ordered the firecracker calamari, lobster roll with a side of fries and cole slaw and..."
Danak D
"Visited Pj's Lobster House in the heart of downtown Port Jefferson and was completely captivated! The atmosphere is adorably charming, capturing the..."
Lawrence Silver
"Yummy yummy yummy 😋 best lobster place on Long Island or quite possibly in New York for that matter. Staff is friendly and prompt, and the food is..."
Benjamin
"Great place for fresh seafood, the restaurant has nice decor and the staff are friendly. The portions are good . My favorite was the lobster rolls..."
N R
"So good! We came for lunch and had the prickly pear margaritas, which we added jalapeño to, and they were amazing. Not too sweet and very fresh..."
Samantha Sullivan
"Yesterday my husband and I had lunch at PJ Lobster House for the first time and we had an excellent experience! The restaurant is beautiful, and the..."
Alessandra Bagno
"Hi me and my 2 sisters went to your PJ Lobster House yesterday, Wednesday. We decided to go out to Port Jefferson to look around. I haven't been..."
Lisa Burke
"Excellent all around. We sat at the bar, and they were slammed with business. Everyone was nice even though it was very busy. Sandy at the bar was..."
Chet P
"Dined in. Ordered surf and turf for $85 and burger with fries for $18. Both meals were equally enjoyed by each patron. Considering that this is a..."
Maria Kay
"A combination of excellent food and great service. Try the lobster sliders, fried clams, fried mozzarella and calamari. The sea bass, tuna,..."
Lawrence Porcari
"Great family friendly place, make a..."
Mike Collier
"Nice day in Pt Jeff. Not humid ( finally) . Asked for outdoor seating. Food was amazing. Killed 3 loaves(round) of the bread, served warm..always a..."
besser lee
"I forgot to update after my last visit. The food was great! Fresh oysters, beautiful big shrimp, the fish and crab were very good as well. Everyone..."
Matthew T.
Nantuckets Port Jefferson
Nantuckets Port Jefferson
82/100 (812 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegan Options
Bar
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Fish
Crab and Lobster Hash and Eggs
Cornmeal Dusted Fried Calamari
Shrimp
Martini
Country Style Eggs Benny
Buttermilk Pancakes
Pan Seared Swordfish
Grand Marnier Creme Brulee
Malibu Coconut Crème Brulee
Breakfast Tacos
Raw Oysters
Salad
Blackened Swordfish
Seafood Paella
Crab
Lobster Roll
Duck
Mahi Mahi Tacos
Tuna
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Salmon
Peach Salad
Burger
French Toast Bites
Crab Crusted Salmon
Signature Lobster Bloody Mary
Duck Confit Egg Roll
Sit down
Bar
American
Seafood
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Dog Friendly
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Accepts Discover
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Located in the heart of Port Jeff, there's a delightful and adorable restaurant with a charming nautical ambiance, strategically positioned by the..."
Niti Shenoy
"Super adorable little spot in Port Jeff. The food is great, pricing isn't bad and you get plenty of food. The service is slow but I think they want..."
Annie Pham
"The food is ok but pricy. We ordered salmon, duck, mussel and salad. In general good quality is good and better than regular restaurants. However..."
Ke Hu (Kevin)
"The staff at this restaurant understand what outstanding customer service means. They are very accommodating; our server, Sierra, is an asset for..."
Vin Geraci
"Ate here for lunch two days on the trot as it was that good! Staff were very friendly and helpful - the crab burger, chicken sandwich, grilled peach..."
Michael
"Excellent outdoor dining experience! The staff was very friendly and attentive. We had martinis and the crab cake (Hands down the best I've had!)..."
Ryan O
"Our food was tasty. Service was lacking. We were there early too. Dining room is very nice and they have a nice..."
J V
"everything at brunch was delicious & perfectly cooked. they raised prices recently but the portions are generous, which I appreciate (some..."
Mary Elizabeth
"Review updated from 3 to 4 stars after one more visit . Please read updates and whole review . 2nd visit and just underwhelming. Bartender is nice..."
august west
"Andreas, food, atmosphere, fireplace. Special decor. Just go! Grand Msrnier Creme Brule was spectacular. Wow. So relaxing and peaceful!! Crab covered..."
Debbie
"My party was waited-on by Andres. Service was great. The Lobster Bisque was the best I ever tasted and the steamed oysters were excellent. My..."
Donald Abrew
"Been here a few times and I have enjoyed it more with each visit. We love the outdoor seating as the Sun shines over the patio really nicely. Drinks..."
Joseph Tloczkowski
"We enjoyed a nice brunch. Food was fresh and delicious. I had the shrimp and lobster hash and my friend had..."
Jacqueline Rowe
"Food was delicious and good quality. Was a bit crowded for us but other than that we had a great..."
N S
"2nd time dining here. So far everything has been delicious 🤤. Service 🌟 wonderful. It was my birthday in the pic and they brought me a..."
karla cabrera