Best Sandwiches in Port Jefferson

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cest Cheese
Cest Cheese
93/100 (458 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Grilled cheese
Salad
Baguette
"This place is a gem! I eat there almost everyday, the atmosphere is great, food is delicious, and the people that work there are absolutely..."
Shannon Walker Perry
"I never leave this place disappointed. Everything from the cheeses to the sandwiches, salads, olives, prosciutto, drinks, and of course the baked..."
Heather Fiore
"A must visit...highly recommend it! Don't forget to visit the craft beer shop in the back. ..."
Edison Apolo
"From the atmosphere to the food & drink selection & the service this place is a must if your in the port Jeff..."
Amanda Lynne
"Great little place. Enjoyed the appetizer I ordered. Enjoyed the beer selection. Enjoyed the live..."
Eric Johnson
"My husband and I had such a nice relaxing Sunday evening at C'est Cheese! Super delicious grilled cheese sandwiches and apps, good beer, and such a..."
Kristen Teague Montpetit
"Great place for cheese, wine and craft beer. Has a great grilled cheese and sandwich selection, as well as small plates to..."
Paul Martorano
"Had the most amazing grilled cheese ! Never thought something so simple would be that amazing with a little extra kick with it !! Great glass of wine..."
Lauren Zanni-Esposito
"Best Ruben sandwich. And nice place not to crowded. Service was good. Not to pricy and just a nice..."
Trisha Wilson Glaser
"If I could eat here every meal every day of my life I would be a happy girl. Favorites: baked Brie, spicy goat cheese bites, Ruben sandwich, any..."
Jessica Benedict Vanacoro
"We love it here! Great food, great beer selection and the staff is really..."
Danielle Moore Butler
"Great food & Great Beer...friendly staff, warm and inviting..."
Todd D Thrasher
"Out on a beautiful spring day in Port Jefferson and decided to duck in because my daughter loves cheese. Good call. Love the clean open layout. Staff..."
Big Joe
"As a lover of cheese, this place is awesome. You can pick from more than a dozen grilled cheeses you can get on different slices of bread. We had..."
Michael Perez
"Bistro style. The beer and wine cheese pairing was excellent! The brie listed on the pairing card is a must! We bought a pound to enjoy at..."
Mary Lucca
"C'est Cheese has the some of the best sandwiches, soups, salads and of course cheese. Everyone that works there makes the experience even better. I..."
Sibel Yolalan
"Usually not a fan of the Port Jeff area because of the crowds but this little gem of a place makes me want to go back again. Love the atmosphere but..."
J P
"Delicious selection of cheeses and Salumi. Grilled cheeses are to die for. Would definitely recommend for trying all sorts of combinations of flavors..."
Ari “Don” Sagiv
"This place has a huge selection of cheeses. The staff is very knowledgeable about the variety they have, and are very good at giving recommendations...."
Morrighan Moran
"Came here on a recommendation and it did not disappoint. The baked Brie appetizer was huge and delicious! Beck was our server and she was cheerful,..."
Terrence Huie
"This place is really great if you time it right and get a table. Usually we've been lucky and haven't had to wait. We have always just bought the..."
Leo Frıdley
"C'est is an amazingly little spot. A blend of high end cheese and food pairs with a proper craft beer bar in the back. They always host amazing long..."
Nicklas Avery
The Secret Garden Tea Cafe & Gift Shoppe
The Secret Garden Tea Cafe & Gift Shoppe
88/100 (327 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Lunch
Brunch
Sandwiches
Salad
Sit down
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Mid-range
"We visited the Secret Garden for my Birthday celebration and enjoyed the Full Afternoon Tea.  The atmosphere was very charming, and the food, all..."
Regina Demasi
"I went for the first time today and had a wonderful experience! The staff and owner were extremely friendly! They do not host children's parties so I..."
Christine Knoche-Becker
"Attention to detail is amazing. Menu and decor changes monthly so visit often!! You will not be disappointed. Call ahead for a reservation. Delicious..."
Liz DeLio
"Absolutely Amazing!!. I went here with my friend, her daughter, and her other friend and it was absolutely wonderful. The Cinnamon scones and..."
Lauren MacElveen
"Truly Victorian. After coming in off the ferry from Connecticut my wife and I were looking for a place to lunch. We have a favorite place to eat..."
The Taster's Choice
"I am visiting from Texas and this was hands down the best experience I have at a tea room in a long time! Even after close you could hear the manager..."
Cheyenne Goodson
"While limited hours, this tea room is the best one in Suffolk County. Before you enjoy your tea, make sure to go back toward the bathroom and grab a..."
Carolyn De Melo
"Eating here was an amazing experience! Such a cozy, beautifully decorated tearoom with such a warm ambience. The waitress was super attentive and..."
Reema Patel
"Such an amazing tea shop with an extraordinary and quaint tasting / sit down area. The tea options and flavors are exquisite. We go there every..."
Darren Person
"Nestled on Maine St of Port Jefferson awaits an oasis of tranquility known as The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shop. It's here that many women, and..."
Joy Wechter
"The atmosphere is so much fun! I've always wanted to have a tea service experience and this felt a bit like a dream come true 🫣 I've been here on..."
Stephanie Carroll
"I LOVE going to the Secret Garden Tearoom. Definitely the best on Long Island. They have an adorable atmosphere, delicious tea and delicious food. I..."
Taylor Jensen
"What a beautiful place. So aesthetically done ❤️ A tea cafe and gift shop. Just so lovely. What a variety of teas (and most of it is imported..."
Dr. Raina Jain
"The Secret Garden Tearoom is a lovely place and I highly recommend it! Beautiful atmosphere and settings. The service was impeccable. The food was..."
J Kudyan
"We brought my Mom here today to celebrate her 100th birthday. the atmosphere was just lovely. The staff was very attentive to my Mom, they all came..."
Janet Winship
Tiger Lily Cafe
Tiger Lily Cafe
82/100 (1325 ratings)
Quick Bites
Cafe
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Juice & Smoothies
Falafel
Juice & Smoothies
Sandwiches
Veggie Burger
Burger
Salad
Sit down
Café
American
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"If you love veggies and flavorful combinations of fresh, healthy ingredients, this quirky little spot is for you. The smoothies were good too. I’d..."
J P
"The vibes in this cafe are unmatched by the decor and the friendly staff. Menu options can't be overlooked with a wholesome and healthy bunch of..."
Luis Diaz
"my absolute favorite cafe. since relocating to port jefferson a year ago and discovering this hidden gem from my co workers 6 months ago, i have been..."
Peyton Hanko
"This place hands down has always been one of my favorite places to get lunch. I no longer live in NY but whenever I come home to visit Tiger Lily's..."
Emily Recchia
"Love Tiger Lily! They have such an extensive healthy menu with so many options. The prepared food in the cold case is delish to take home and makes..."
Sam Vander Wielen
"This place was wonderful! Delicious chai and really yummy wrap (I got the smoked turkey). Even though there is currently no indoor seating, the..."
Gianna Greco
"Whether you're a vegan, vegetarian or carnivour, Tiger Lily Cafe does not disappoint. The artsy, eclectic decor and cozy atmosphere -- combined with..."
Kevin Simms
"Their food and drinks are BOMB!!!! Healthy, FRESH made to order that are flavorful!!!! Gluten free options available don't be afraid to ask. They're..."
jus jaz
"I had the most amazing falafel wrap! The place is unique and very inviting. They also have the most amazing coffee And frappes. Watch out..."
Christine Fader
"I have not tried their food but their frappuccinos are amazing. I always get their East India Chai and i really like it. I like the decor. It is a..."
Sonali Gera
Ruvo Restaurant East
Ruvo Restaurant East
81/100 (4170 ratings)
Restaurants
Italian
American
Vegan Options
American
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Pasta
Ribs
Salad
Cakes
Crab
Pesto
Scallops
Fish
Bass
Clams
Meatballs
Duck
Sandwiches
Cheesecakes
Calamari
Burger
Bolognese
Risotto
Ice Cream
Mussels
Shrimp
Gelato
Tuna
Beef
Calamares
Salmon
Lobster
Crab Cake
Eggplant
Cheesecake
Sit down
American
Italian
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Brunch
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"This place is perfect for restaurant week! I highly recommend it for any celebration. The service is quick and friendly, the atmosphere is cozy, and..."
Natalia Ilina
"Ruvo is the perfect restaurant for Southern Italian food! Not on the busy main street, parking right outside the door, beautiful building... but the..."
thrillcats
"It’s a yummy experience. The ambiance is very welcoming and charming. Amazing martinis, food and service. Staff is attentive and make great..."
Danielle Gilberto
"We had a fantastic birthday dinner at Ruvo. The food was incredible and the service was friendly and professional. Their price fixe menu has so many..."
George L.
"Amazing place for dinner. Had the duck and calamari. Both were..."
Kevin Armato
"Good restaurant. Service was decent, quiet and efficient. Atmosphere was good as well for a Sunday lunch. Cocktail were not exceptional but good. We..."
Ludovic MASSON
"Wonderful service, great food, made reservations same day for 530. The scallops and shrimp were amazing. We had calamari as appetizer and it was very..."
Katherine
"So pretty! Excellent food and service. Came for brunch. Will return to check out dinner. Husband and I very..."
Holly Ferruso
"I came here for my birthday dinner, there were 4 adults (plus my niece who orders off the adult menu), and 3 additional kids. Our waitress was..."
Danielle Porrazzo
"A well curated menu and delicious experience from beginning to end. We left feeling satisfied without feeling like we ate too much. Both sauces I..."
Courtney Thompson
"Excellent food, especially their brunch menu. The service was adequate but nothing to write home about. A well decorated and heated venue with..."
Peter Devlin
"Always Fabulous, I get served at the bar great food!! I love the scallops,duck ,veal chop when they have it ,I always order from the specials..."
Deena Giardina
"Excellent Sunday Brunch! Normally I enjoy a Sunday Brunch buffet but if you are looking for a great sit down Sunday Brunch, you must try Ruvo! The..."
Christopher De Francis
"Excellent food and service. We thoroughly enjoyed everything we ordered. Our server Josh was outstanding. First time there, and we will be definitely..."
Stamatis Koutouzis
"If you’re looking for a nice sit down restaurant I highly recommend Ruvu East . The food was delicious. My guests and I did the dinner special and..."
Tstarr Crafts
"Lovely Italian recommended by owner of local b&b. Baked clams were excellent as was the gnochi, crab cakes and fish special. Staff were prompt and..."
Michael