34 restaurant menus in Put in Bay, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Every visit has been wonderful, but the New Year's Eve party blew us away! It was incredible! The decorations were great, the atmosphere felt very..."
Terri Kelley Stanley
"We found our new favorite place to eat on the island!! Try the shrimp tacos!! The service was also great!! If you are ever on the Island you will..."
Andrea Francis
"The food was excellent!! We had a table of 6. Everyone was very pleased. Shrimp tacos, perch tacos, mussels, nachos, deep fried pickles... beer was..."
Tonya Christine Good-Heuring
"There is something about the Reel Burger that makes the trip to Put In Bay worth it! The food is..."
Eric McNeil
"Best burger I’ve had in years. Great waiter, and..."
Mark J Cummings
"One of my favorite places to hang out on the island. The fish tacos are delicious, the beer selection is great, service is always friendly. The Ray..."
Brittany Lougheed Warren
"Love the place !! Great food and exceptional staff !! Reel Bar is the Reel Deal for PIB entertainment..."
Darron Docie
"This is a great place with great food & the best..."
Wendi Porter
"Shrimp tacos were AMAZING! The best I’ve ever had, 2 wasn’t enough..."
Regan Flinn
"Best bar on the island!!!! Awesome food, friendly staff!!!! Can't wait to go back!!!! 25 Blow Jobs and they didn't blink..."
Nathan Eaton
"Great Place, Great Entertainment, Great Food and an amazing..."
John M. Sabella Sr.
"Great people.food and entertainment.....Highly..."
Scott Tullius
"We always stop in when we visit PIB. The food and drinks are..."
Léage Marie Moore
"10/10 Best burgers in the island. Personally the best choice is the Fire-In-The-Hole burger but we did try the Sweet Bourbon, Black Bean and the kids..."
Daniel Smith
"Really great find and drinks! The pickle shot was so fun! The server was really knowledgeable about gluten allergies as..."
Cassandra Mercedes Broadwater
"Great food great service. Bria was superb wonderful. Anytime I'm in town will come..."
Jeff R
"YUM! Definitely stop in to Reel Bar! You won't regret it! We are so glad we stopped and tried it! The nachos were loaded... Delicious! & The burger..."
K. Gunny
"Little over priced, but the service was amazing! The fries were..."
"Absolutely delicious breakfast/brunch place!! The staff is so kind and helpful. The atmosphere is cute and the bathrooms are clean! Would 100% eat..."
Sushi
"Everything was amazing! Love the cinnamon roll! Mimosas hit the..."
Dustin M
"Great little spot to grab breakfast! Friendly and welcoming..."
Lindsey Phillips
"Didn’t have enough menus for the restaurant, and not a lot of vegetarian options. Other than that the food was really good as well as the service...."
Heylea Allan
"Breakfast Food. Is. Amazing. Walk in, wait in line and put your order in at the counter. Get a seat and wait for your order to be ready. They will..."
Heather Overstreet
"Awesome home town feel, was very busy when we went. No day or slowdown with service. One shared bathroom is kind of annoying but what can you..."
Bryon
"Best breakfast ever! They also have the best diner coffee I have ever had! Came camping for the weekend and the food was so good, we went back the..."
Alex Andria
"Absolutely incredible restaurant! Just went there this morning for breakfast and could not have been better! The new counter ordering made service..."
"It was the best lobster we have ever had. The New England lobster roll was full of lobster meat and excellent. We sat on the outside deck and enjoyed..."
Julie Bulboff DC
"The best lobster bisque anywhere. Awesome lobster rolls. Ice cold beer. Friendly staff. Gorgeous view. A little corner of heaven in..."
Tim Mejia
"Lobster poutine with lobster grilled cheese and a Mojito was a top five meal for sure, highly recommend..."
John Hayes
"This was by far the best place that we ate while on vacation here. The other places were good as well but the Lobster bisque was delicious!! Down..."
Tracy Combs Hudson
"Upper deck is the nicest restaurant on the island. I love the atmosphere. The food is good. And they serve the most beautiful hot pink prickly pear..."
Stephanie Young
"The very best lobster bisque I have ever had! In the bread bowl,..."
Sherry Petrick Wright
"Great food great atmosphere and Lilly our wait person was so awesome. I will recommend this location to friends coming to..."
Joe LaFerier
"Great Atmosphere. I had the Lobster Roll w the handmade chips. Really gooooood. Ther drink menu is awesome as well. Best Drinks on the island. A..."
Shannon Mayer
"Absolutely delicious. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. Good service and atmosphere. A must go in..."
Kaitlyn Ream
"Food was amazing and the view was even better. The shrimp was scrumptious and my husbands walleye sandwich was so fresh! Can’t wait to go..."
Heather Long
"Wonderful experience each visit. The food is great, especially the Mussels. Can’t beat the atmosphere. My favorite place on the..."
Denise Collins
"Great place, views. As advertised, Lobster Bisque is amazing. Crab legs fresh, hot, and plenty. Highly recommend..."
Randy Horton
"4 hours of dockage $30, $15 dinner coupon, 2 hour golf cart ride $16, 2 huge Lobster Mania dinners for $38 after the coupon discount, late afternoon..."
Dan Traetow
"Yummy Lobster Bisque!! Big chunks of Lobster Meat!
And the lowering of the flag at Sunset was the best Show on the Island!❤️
The singing of the..."
Tammye Delk Van Clief
"Lobster Bisque Is the best. I have a big bread bowl every visit to the bay. It's always my first stop for..."
"Great Irish Pub with authentic Irish food, beer, and spirits. I had the Patty Melt with Pork, slaw, and Mac n Cheese and it had to be the best..."
JOHN HAEUPTLE
"Our server was very receptive and friendly
The food was delicious, the Irish nachos are essentially over loaded potato skins but they are soooo good...."
Jhovy
"We were planning on going to the Boardwalk for lunch. As we wandered by Hooligans, we saw they had a lunch special of chicken salad on a croissant..."
Jackie Costantino
"Truly a great experience, we started with the Irish Nachos which are absolutely delicious, potatoes instead of tortilla chips and shredded beef. I..."
joehammer75
"Megan, the GM, is an absolute pleasure. My husband's burger was slightly overcooked, and she took care of it immediately. She was just absolutely the..."
Apryl Pocse
"The waiter did a great job ( he has an Irish accent & a perfect match for the restaurant) ,and was very patience with our young grandchildren when..."
Jersey Digmore
"Good food. Great service. The waitress went above and beyond for us. Great little pub. Took the kids and they really enjoyed it..."
"I'm from Port Clinton, I had my sisters family from SC here, 4 kids /4 adults! I asked Boardwalk Bisque or Great Food , great service and In..."
Amy Dee Maytham Below
"Absolutely the best bar on the island. Excellent food and the best drinks. Superb service and atentative staff. It doesn't matter if 2 or 50 people..."
Michael W. Hoffman
"PIB burger was delicious as well as the mild bone in wings. Great atmosphere and great..."
Adam Etherton
"Great food and wow, the location. It is right on the water! One of our favorite places to stop every time we visit the..."
Guy Guidone
"BEAUTIFUL VIEW
This spot is right on the water with amazing sunsets
And fantastic food! Must get the..."
Kayla Johnson
"We love this place. Good food and drink with a friendly staff, and right next to the..."
Lezlie Whaley
"Friendly wait staff, great Bloody Marys, and of course a great view of the..."
Sandra Belt
"A great little island bar. A nice little getaway from the crowds. Awesome views and a great brandy..."
Sherri Hudson
"A must stop for Brandy Alexanders! We like the atmosphere and the view!..."
Dawn LaFountain
"Great food and drinks and the nicest server..."
Sandi Anderson
"Best caramel macchiato on the island.... Love this place, such a great hang with great..."
Elizabeth Lawrence
"Discovered yesterday! Had to go back today. Great food! See ya next..."
Jessica Rieth Fairweather
"Great service and food plus the Brandy Alexander will give the Pump a run for their..."
Mel N Sylvia Burns
"brandy alexanders our the bomb
must try one great food and great..."
Brent Cooper
"Friendly service. Quaint location on the bay. Best perch platter and price on the island. Home made everything. Hidden gem on the..."
Robin Pennell
"Pretty cool bar with a good view of the water and cool atmosphere. Good drinks and friendly staff, I would recommend giving it a shot. No pun..."
Chad Helms
"Great food and service. The young lady who served us was very polite and attentive. The chicken bites were delicious as was the pulled pork. Would..."
Bill Hickok
"I wrote a wedding proposal on the back of my receipt. If that gives you any indication on how amazing the food and service was. I proposed to my..."
Devin Walsh
"First time ever visiting here!! Had an awesome time.... very clean 😁 The staff was extremely friendly and helpful with the menu.. they were also..."
lorilynn aldrich
"Cuban sandwich, fries and even potato chips were above par...delicious. Nice setting and view. All around nice experience, thank..."
"Absolutely best time at this pool bar! Bartenders were 💯 on point! Crowd was fantastic 🎶🎶🎶 DJ off hook!!! Had a great time..."
KL Puleo
"Best swim up bar on the island ! Biggest and cleanest pool by far ! Fast service, great drinks and best music..."
Erin Bunn
"It was a lot of fun the djs were cool kept the music popping and the drinks were good. It had swim up bars that you be in the water and keep cool and..."
Jeannette Martinez
"Best place on the island !! Great drinks nice pool really fun..."
Gale Nusbaum-Henry
"Great place to play giant jenga in a tropical setting. Staff is very..."
Jon J Morgan
"Hidden gem. Best bartenders and sound on the..."
Tara Slingerland
"Best pool bar in Put In Bay and the staff are amazingly friendly! More than that though, the pool is always clean unlike all the other..."
Jason Silk
"Great place . Great staff . Can't wait to return . Very good..."
Paul Vallone
"I love it !!! Amazing place..."
Nellia Hristov
"Always have great time there. Good dj and fun..."
Mary Lou Campogni McNamee
"Perfect summer bar! I can't wait to come back and visit..."
Tara Langstrom
"A fantastic time with my family and a lot of fun at the swim up..."
Jo Jo Gelonese
"My family reunion weekend visit to the Sand Bar was fabulous. All 8 grandkids had a blast! The pool was perfect and beautifully landscaped. The..."
211Baw 56
"This was such a cool spot. Lounge chairs and sandy beach area with corn horn. Tiki bar in the middle with a very nice, large pool with a swim up bar!..."
Jessica Drohan
"We had a great time at the Sand Bar🌴 We played the giant Jenga game and corn hole. It’s a great place to relax and bring the family too. Great..."
Susan Hurd
"Loved this place! Made me feel like I wasn't in Ohio anymore. No cover! Volley ball, corn hole, music, drinks, food & swimming! What more could you..."
Hannah
"Awesome place to have cold drinks on a hot day. The swim up bar is awesome,.they have pool volleyball and the music is always..."
Todd Foss
"Nice place to cool off in the pool with a frozen drink or..."
Cake Made by the Manager's Sister in Law for Our Party It Was Dynamite
Philly Cheese Steak
Fresh Blue Water Perch from Lak Erie in Michigan
Fish and Chips
Walleye Salad
Chicken Sandwich
Naturday and Bud Light Seltzer
Key Lime Pie
Shark Shooters
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"What a fun bar and grill! Highly recommended for the live music and beverages on the left side and great food on the right side in the restaurant. We..."
Michael Stiers
"Best burgers in the Island hands down! Clean, neat place, attentive wait staff. Always a great..."
Steve Costa
"Love this place. The atmosphere and the food are both very good. Always happy with the fried food from here (onions rings and fish). Always light and..."
Tiffany Menosky
"The best Walleye Filet I have ever had! I had the Walleye Basket, and it was most excellent. My wife is Polizh and ordered the Brats and Perogis...."
Edward A Milliron
"Great food and ambience. Was not as crowded as other restaurants but its the best in the area. Try their grilled chicken..."
Soumya P
"Amazing food, nice staff. The perch here is to die for. I would definitely recommend eating here if you are a tourist, or a resident of..."
"Best pizza I have ever had!! We had the chicken bacon ranch. But the crust was my favorite so any kind of pizza would be delicious!! Very friendly..."
Heather Webb
"Awesome place! Great atmosphere! Great beer selection! Amazing staff! So fun! Andrew makes a killer martini! Nicest guy and easy to talk to. ..."
Janine Marie
"Great food! Perfect Long Island with their own vodka and rum. Clean and good..."
Shannon O'Loughlin
"Food was delicious, and we left with several crowlers of the strawberry basil and watermelon wheat beers. Fun place, staff were all..."
Laurie Lee
"Our waitress Sarah was incredible, she set us up with great drinks ,and wonderful food. Food was hot and fast, and our drinks never got halfway gone,..."
Randall Eckstein
"We wait all winter to make to back for summer brew, burgers, and perch! By far, our favorite place to eat on the island...."
Nikole Maddin
"The shrimp basket was on fleek!! Loved the watermelon wheat beer also. Great atmosphere and very friendly and helpful staff. Wish we had one here in..."
Jamar E Steger
"Excellent food, great staff and the best brews anywhere. A must see on your Put In Bay bucket..."
Bill Kehoe
"The Stouts are outstanding!!! The food hit it out of the park with taste and price...hope to see..a German or Belgium next summer Was quick..."
Jody Eidt
"All of the beer and food were really good, and our server Andrew did an excellent..."
Josh Chambers
"Wayne and had dinner and some drinks here we loved it , Great place , good food ! Great..."
Melissa Yutzy
"Great service our burger was delicious!! We recommend keep up the good..."
"Beautiful location for an afternoon ice cream. Matt was so nice. ..very friendly and helpful. Great music playing and a great place to relax in the..."
"Our favorite place on the island! Super friendly staff and the best Bloody Marys around...."
LeeAnne Crawford
"Love joes!!!! Best place to go if you want to hangout outside and have some grilled food😊 Great..."
Angel Michelle Slater Keane
"Great place! Bartender Nick was awesome. He told us a lot about the island and where to go when we come back. Definitely be..."
Christi Diehl
"What a great place those jalapeño jammers were amazing all covered with bacon . The ladies behind the bar were pretty good too. That Robin playing..."
Derek Menard
"Don’t tell anybody about this place. If you’ve found it, keep it a..."
"It was the best lobster we have ever had. The New England lobster roll was full of lobster meat and excellent. We sat on the outside deck and enjoyed..."
Julie Bulboff DC
"The best lobster bisque anywhere. Awesome lobster rolls. Ice cold beer. Friendly staff. Gorgeous view. A little corner of heaven in..."
Tim Mejia
"Lobster poutine with lobster grilled cheese and a Mojito was a top five meal for sure, highly recommend..."
John Hayes
"This was by far the best place that we ate while on vacation here. The other places were good as well but the Lobster bisque was delicious!! Down..."
Tracy Combs Hudson
"Upper deck is the nicest restaurant on the island. I love the atmosphere. The food is good. And they serve the most beautiful hot pink prickly pear..."
Stephanie Young
"The very best lobster bisque I have ever had! In the bread bowl,..."
Sherry Petrick Wright
"Great food great atmosphere and Lilly our wait person was so awesome. I will recommend this location to friends coming to..."
Joe LaFerier
"Great Atmosphere. I had the Lobster Roll w the handmade chips. Really gooooood. Ther drink menu is awesome as well. Best Drinks on the island. A..."
Shannon Mayer
"Absolutely delicious. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. Good service and atmosphere. A must go in..."
Kaitlyn Ream
"Food was amazing and the view was even better. The shrimp was scrumptious and my husbands walleye sandwich was so fresh! Can’t wait to go..."
Heather Long
"Wonderful experience each visit. The food is great, especially the Mussels. Can’t beat the atmosphere. My favorite place on the..."
Denise Collins
"Great place, views. As advertised, Lobster Bisque is amazing. Crab legs fresh, hot, and plenty. Highly recommend..."
Randy Horton
"4 hours of dockage $30, $15 dinner coupon, 2 hour golf cart ride $16, 2 huge Lobster Mania dinners for $38 after the coupon discount, late afternoon..."
Dan Traetow
"Yummy Lobster Bisque!! Big chunks of Lobster Meat!
And the lowering of the flag at Sunset was the best Show on the Island!❤️
The singing of the..."
Tammye Delk Van Clief
"Lobster Bisque Is the best. I have a big bread bowl every visit to the bay. It's always my first stop for..."
Katie Darnell
"After seeing photos of the food that this restaurant had made I knew that this was the restaurant I needed to eat at. And I'm so glad that we stopped..."
Britteny Osiecki
"Great place to grab a bit to eat. They have quick seafood downstairs and casual dining upstairs. Great atmosphere and good staff. I would recommend..."
Chad Helms
"Very crowded so we sat at the bar for lunch.
The Lobster mac and cheese was very good but wish I had ordered the salmon dish. My friend had a..."
Joan Marie Stevens Talbert
"Great décor with wonderful views of the water on the upper deck. The food was a little pricy but very worth it. Service was good. We had the..."
Morgan
"This restaurant is a gem! There are several restaurants inside the boardwalk, but we actually sat down and ate in the boardwalk. We were seated right..."
Amber Hensley
"Amazing food drinks and service! All of the food was great, we sat on the upper deck by the outdoor bar. I didn’t get his name but the bar tender a..."
Briel Komma
"The lobster bisque seems pricey until you get it and see that it's not little pieces of meat in some Campbell's tomato soup with some milk added but..."
Robert Sommer
"Excellent service! Beautiful place and very little wait considering we were there on Labor Day weekend with a party of 8. Walleye was amazing! My..."
"It was the best lobster we have ever had. The New England lobster roll was full of lobster meat and excellent. We sat on the outside deck and enjoyed..."
Julie Bulboff DC
"The best lobster bisque anywhere. Awesome lobster rolls. Ice cold beer. Friendly staff. Gorgeous view. A little corner of heaven in..."
Tim Mejia
"Lobster poutine with lobster grilled cheese and a Mojito was a top five meal for sure, highly recommend..."
John Hayes
"This was by far the best place that we ate while on vacation here. The other places were good as well but the Lobster bisque was delicious!! Down..."
Tracy Combs Hudson
"Upper deck is the nicest restaurant on the island. I love the atmosphere. The food is good. And they serve the most beautiful hot pink prickly pear..."
Stephanie Young
"The very best lobster bisque I have ever had! In the bread bowl,..."
Sherry Petrick Wright
"Great food great atmosphere and Lilly our wait person was so awesome. I will recommend this location to friends coming to..."
Joe LaFerier
"Great Atmosphere. I had the Lobster Roll w the handmade chips. Really gooooood. Ther drink menu is awesome as well. Best Drinks on the island. A..."
Shannon Mayer
"Absolutely delicious. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. Good service and atmosphere. A must go in..."
Kaitlyn Ream
"Food was amazing and the view was even better. The shrimp was scrumptious and my husbands walleye sandwich was so fresh! Can’t wait to go..."
Heather Long
"Wonderful experience each visit. The food is great, especially the Mussels. Can’t beat the atmosphere. My favorite place on the..."
Denise Collins
"Great place, views. As advertised, Lobster Bisque is amazing. Crab legs fresh, hot, and plenty. Highly recommend..."
Randy Horton
"4 hours of dockage $30, $15 dinner coupon, 2 hour golf cart ride $16, 2 huge Lobster Mania dinners for $38 after the coupon discount, late afternoon..."
Dan Traetow
"Yummy Lobster Bisque!! Big chunks of Lobster Meat!
And the lowering of the flag at Sunset was the best Show on the Island!❤️
The singing of the..."
Tammye Delk Van Clief
"Lobster Bisque Is the best. I have a big bread bowl every visit to the bay. It's always my first stop for..."
Katie Darnell
"After seeing photos of the food that this restaurant had made I knew that this was the restaurant I needed to eat at. And I'm so glad that we stopped..."
Britteny Osiecki
"Great place to grab a bit to eat. They have quick seafood downstairs and casual dining upstairs. Great atmosphere and good staff. I would recommend..."
Chad Helms
"Very crowded so we sat at the bar for lunch.
The Lobster mac and cheese was very good but wish I had ordered the salmon dish. My friend had a..."
Joan Marie Stevens Talbert
"Great décor with wonderful views of the water on the upper deck. The food was a little pricy but very worth it. Service was good. We had the..."
Morgan
"This restaurant is a gem! There are several restaurants inside the boardwalk, but we actually sat down and ate in the boardwalk. We were seated right..."
Amber Hensley
"Amazing food drinks and service! All of the food was great, we sat on the upper deck by the outdoor bar. I didn’t get his name but the bar tender a..."
Briel Komma
"The lobster bisque seems pricey until you get it and see that it's not little pieces of meat in some Campbell's tomato soup with some milk added but..."
Robert Sommer
"Excellent service! Beautiful place and very little wait considering we were there on Labor Day weekend with a party of 8. Walleye was amazing! My..."
"Amazing food! Delicious! Love the Bruchitta!
The owner and the staff are all loving and..."
Kathryn Cooke
"Food was delicious and our server Jamie was a joy! So grateful they stayed open in the..."
Terri Kelley Stanley
"I love this place! Wonderful food, service and..."
Caroline Conrad
"Love the food and can't beat the atmosphere....."
Mark David Bennett
"We visited on Saturday. After a phone call to make sure they were still open. Spoke with Jamie, she assured me they would be able to meet my dietary..."
Stephanie Puertas
"Love the bisque!! Best on the island! Recommend that and the..."
Sherry Syders Warner
"Beautiful atmosphere in the shadow of Perry's Monument. The food has an Italian flare, and the Chicken Picatta is..."
"I have been coming to this island paradise getaway for many years .. the Boathouse is the primary stop for us! Kathleen behind the bar as well as the..."
Jeremy J Griffore
"I visited The Boathouse last week for lunch, drinks and some relaxation on the patio. I had the pool party and deep blue punch drinks. They were..."
Stephanie Bone
"Great place, awesome food,live music and the friendliest staff! Make sure you ask for Shelby on your visit, she is the..."
Cindy Mezget
"This place is awesome!!! Jami is fantastic ����
I had the mozzarella sticks and tried fried green tomatoes for the first time - both were..."
Stephanie O'Neill
"Love this place! The whole staff is amazing especially Kathleen! Great food and drinks a must see while you're on the..."
Deirdre Heffernan
"The food and drinks were awesome! & Jami our server was a amazing! She was the..."
Justine Bush
"This is always our lunch stop when we're on the island. Food is always delicious and the staff is always great. And to my surprise they had my..."
Traci Burns
"I’m a very big fan of Walleye. With that said, today my family and I ate here and I had the Walleye Po - Boy. It was literally the best Walleye I..."
Jeremy Tuttle
"I had the walleye with fries and coleslaw. It was delicious! Probably some of the best walleye I've ever had. The batter was light and crunchy, just..."
Lori Evans Focht
"The blackened walleye and perch were Sooo Delish! Thank you Taylor K for the great service and food suggestions! We will be back..."
Beth Simboli
"For the first time being on the island I will come to the boathouse every visit the food and service was..."
Traci Jackson
"Jami is amazing! We had great service two nights in a row. Highly..."
"This place is awesome. The service was fantastic the food was hot I did not have to wait long for my food. I had the walleye fish it melted in your..."
Damita J Pannell
"Fish Bowl definitely has some talented musicians play and the staff are great at drink mixing, The ambience is so up beat and I thoroughly enjoyed..."
Jenna Lynn Wilford
"As always this place does not disappoint! Good food, cold Bev's and a friendly..."
Melissa Gibson Simon
"The ONLY shock was the price. The food was absolutely magnificent. If you have not tried the Walleye Nuggets it is definitely worth the try. We..."
Karen Garmon
"Fast friendly service...ice cold draft beer...a great open face prime rib sandwich...and I loved the sauerkraut balls and Walleye bites..."
Mike Corson
"We come here every day we are on the island.Great food and service...love the perch and..."
Karla Ray
"Food was great and not over priced. The 64oz fishbowl was amazing and well priced. The guy that waited on us was friendly even though they were super..."
Nick Keaton
"Always fast and friendly service. Great price for the amount and strength of drinks you get there. Food is also good..."
Scott White
"Excellent atmosphere, great food and staff was..."
Melinda Borczuch
"What a fun bar and grill! Highly recommended for the live music and beverages on the left side and great food on the right side in the restaurant. We..."
Michael Stiers
"Best burgers in the Island hands down! Clean, neat place, attentive wait staff. Always a great..."
Steve Costa
"Love this place. The atmosphere and the food are both very good. Always happy with the fried food from here (onions rings and fish). Always light and..."
Tiffany Menosky
"The best Walleye Filet I have ever had! I had the Walleye Basket, and it was most excellent. My wife is Polizh and ordered the Brats and Perogis...."
Edward A Milliron
"Great food and ambience. Was not as crowded as other restaurants but its the best in the area. Try their grilled chicken..."
Soumya P
"Amazing food, nice staff. The perch here is to die for. I would definitely recommend eating here if you are a tourist, or a resident of..."
"What a great place on the island. The food was so good! Even the chips and queso was amazing. The service was also great and the atmosphere was full..."
Ian Anderson
"I can't choose what is better, the hand-crafted cocktails from the excellent bar staff or the flavor-packed food from the fantastic kitchen..."
Jimmy Olsen
"Feels like you’re on a tropical island (when your on the Ohio island)! Great friendly staff and fun outside deck but the drinks are what make this..."
Heather Krismer
"Amazing new addition to the island!!! Scorpion margarita was the right amount of spicy and the Buffalo Chicken Patatas are to die..."
Sarah Ingram
"Awesome place, great environment and killer friendly..."
Troy Thrash
"A perfect addition to the island. Perfectly crafted margaritas, inviting atmosphere &..."
KT Miller
"Really nice place! I..."
Кирил Хаджиколев
"Had a wonderful time here while visiting with family and friends from near and far. Fast service, great vibes, no..."
Taylor Chandler
"What can possibly go wrong with fresh squeezed lime, nice tequila and good atmosphere...."
"The entire staff went out of their way to make for a top notch dining experience. Not overly expensive but above average prices, worth every cent...."
Greg Wood
"Great brunch! Exceptionally family friendly! The owner brought out some sliced bananas for our daughter, as we had to wait a bit to be seated (I..."
Sara Mankins
"This place is on point! From the ambience, the service, the food, the presentation. Everything was perfect!
I had the smoked salmon crepe with lemon..."
Anne Spettel
"Great service, great food, and great atmosphere. Love the decor. The breakfast burritos were phenomenal and the fresh squeezed orange juice was so..."
Jodi Wright
"They served what was perhaps the best breakfast I've ever eaten, the salmon, eggs Benedict. The sweet crepes are also amazing! You will not be..."
Daniel McDermitt
"Our party of 4 had an excellent breakfast. We loved our selections, especially my MGB Eggs Benedict. Coffee was best at PIB. Great esthetic /decor...."
Liz Pollick
"Amazing staff. Exceptional food and drinks. Highly recommend..."
Lisa Sheldon
"Went in to relax with friends, had an amazing Caramel Cappuccino and really, really good hummus. Could not have asked for better service, such a..."
Renee Market
"We went for brunch and sat outside on the patio. The food and drinks were delicious and the service was great too! Will definitely go..."
Shay Roseman Matasic
"Top notch. Best crepes around - such fresh ingredients and the coffee is the best on PIB. Will return- and the staff is very attentive and fast. ..."
Betty Oinonen
"Nutella crepes are to die for! Service is so prompt and sweet, definitely one of the best food stops on the island..."
Tiffany Raver
"Of course I have always loved and recommended The Forge over the years, but I had to check in and say things continue to be great.
Sydney was a..."
Steve Wherry
"Had the most amazing breakfast ever and had the most amazing woman next to me ! Definitely gonna return my new found breakfast hot spot..."
Paul Easley
"The best crepes I ever had. Stoped for breakfast and we liked it so much that we went back late afternoon for some of their sweet crepes. We also..."
Pat Kelly
"We wanted to go somewhere that wasn't one of our usuals. Great food and friendly..."
Richard Feezle
"Lovely, lovely restaurant. A must come to destination when in Put-In-Bay...."
Tim Webber
"Love this place, consistently the best service and..."
Suzanne Krupp Chrysler
"One of my favorite places to eat. Breakfast, lunch, dinner or I even just love to stop by for coffee and a..."
Katrina Marie
"With a party of 9 we enjoyed an amazing breakfast! Kelli did a great job taking care of us and was friendly. Savory crepes were so good my husband..."
L Purdy (LJoPurdy)
"Fantastic service and food! Highly recommend for breakfast or lunch on the island. Also, please check out there crepes, they are..."
Danica Haverty
"Came during lunch time and it was quiet and relaxing.
No long wait for the food and the waiter was kind.
Just amount of gravy on the fries and bread..."
Kaleena Morgan
"We stopped to have breakfast/brunch. Staff was friendly even with being overwhelmed with a huge waiting list. Food and drinks were great! Highly..."
Kim Moomaw
"Delicious, slow but taste great and yummy..."
Shawnda Edwards
"Outstanding service and great coffee. This is probably one of my now favorite spots to have a meal and get coffee from. I highly recommend checking..."
"Bartender was great and the beer was fantastic. Was a little bit late night so I don't remember all the details but they let us eat our pizza that we..."
Jeremy Berman
"Best beer and as long as you are a customer of theirs you can bring your own food no other place does that!!!! One of a..."
Anthony Brown
"Hands down best beer on the island, tons of Ohio craft..."
Chase Mohr
"Great beer selection, friendly bartenders, a cool little place to hang out and enjoy a delicious..."
Brittany Lougheed Warren
"Had a great time! Energy and people were tops as was service and drinks! Loved the atmosphere, it is true island style and WELL WORTH your time! We..."
Francine McClellan
"Best place to stop for a good drink and a good price and always changing the..."
Jeremy Price
"Owner is super cool. This will be the coolest place on the..."
Bridgette Hooper
"Awesome place to be, can't beat it out there on the..."
Jonny Fickert
"Best bartender (Eddie) in town. Spend the day there and you will not be disappointed. Do yourself a favor and get the cheesy bread from next door..."
Jodie McGrath
"Great little find a cross between a dive bar and an authentic local on your way in to crazy town.
The bar staff are tentative, friendly and..."
Shaun Carrier
"Great back stop bar, strong drinks and good crowd. Nostalgic "dive bar" scenery. Would recommend the..."
Chad Helms
"This IS the place to go to meet the local Islanders and get great prices on beer, drinks and food! Say hello to Jerry. Just a character who was fun..."
Dennis Derichs
"Fun dive bar. Great décor. 1800's cemetery across the street. Smaller menu. I had Eddie's Bid Bad Bratwurst and my friends had the fried pickles,..."
Morgan
"Good bar to chill at. Good vibes there. When I went it had a limited menu and no liquor for another couple weeks just beer. Probably because it was..."
OSO
"Great dive bar. Food and service were great. Have the Sloppy..."
Tim Martin
"Always always go to Joe's bar great margaritas bloody Marys are good cheapest beer on..."
Randy A. De Luca Sr.
"Wonderful day plenty of eye candy 😳
if you know what I mean..."
"Huge bar, "longest bar in the world" may be a misnomer...it is a long bar inside that basically goes at right angles through the bar. Kind of cheesy..."
William DeArmon (Bill)
"Amazing live music that plays cover songs. Great dancing floor. Great drinks on tap. Small bar menu. We had the nachos and popcorn shrimp which were..."
Morgan
"Bar tenders were nice and friendly, service was fast, great atmosphere, drinks were good but a little on the pricey side. Would definitely recommend..."
Kat Nabours (Colin)
"The place is large and has a great band stage. Plenty of entertainment. The bartender, Tyler, was friendly and took great care of..."
deb Kopczynski
"This is a very unique bar. There is plenty of space at the bar. I ended up going around labor day and this place seemed to be pretty lively. There..."
"The chicken is simply the best. Can't beat the chicken dinner, it all tastes so good!! Fast and a great place to people..."
Amy Johnson-Taussig
"It's where we eat every time we go to Put-In-Bay and we compare all other chicken against theirs!! It is definitely THE..."
Cindy Akins- Thornton
"As always, just the..."
Deb Stout Sinwald
"The chicken is juicy and flavorful and the corn on the cob is sweet and..."
Valinda Rodriguez Aguirre
"Best Chicken East of the Mississippi. It's a must have at the..."
Kevin Schultz
"Awesome chicken and fast service. These guys know their..."
Jennifer Balok
"Chicken Patio...a..."
Nicholas Draginoff
"Food was really good and employees very..."
joehammer75
"Super delicious food. Good quantity, reminds me the chicken with mole sauce from Mexico. Really enjoyed the food and will come back again when visit..."
Santanu Basu
"Hands down the BEST chicken dinner around. Grilled to perfection with that BBQ wine sauce!!! The corn, potato salad and roll are good too. Friendly..."
S L
"By far this is one of the best meals that is a must have while visiting put in bay. The chicken is grilled to perfection, the wine sauce is out of..."
Adam & Austin
"It's good! It's expensive! They put wine sauce on the chicken to cook the chicken. They cook on a huge grill outside in the open-- it's under a roof..."
T
"Great place to eat fresh grilled chicken, price is decent and a big portion, you can sit on the patio and enjoy your..."
"Great pizza. Anytime of day. Especially late night..."
Danny Nicolino
"The pizza was awesome as usual. The price was outrageous...$32 chicken bacon ranch. Had to give 4 stars due to..."
Steve Costa
"Giving 5 stars for the great pizza! If you like a super cheesy pizza this is for you. Side salad was lacking and cheesy bread was disappointing. But..."
Julie Ratliff
"We loved Frosty's! We went for breakfast every morning while on the island. The waitresses are sweet as they could be. They gave us are drinks to go...."
"They have great pizzas and subs :) wide variety of very delicious foods , I highly recommend it ; the best place on PIB to eat &..."
Mina Aiad
"Best pizza on the island bar none hands down. If your looking for quality over quantity then you'll go to this place. This place is definitely the..."
Justin Frye
"Best pizza on the island!!!!! Local delivery was offered but we picked up for the..."
Mark Mathys
"Best place where you can have food !..."
Aldo Balla
"The pizza was excellent! Staff was friendly an courteous I would visit again and recommend to..."
"The best place to go when on the island! Great entertainment, amazing staff, and good food! Can't wait till we visit again! You have been..."
Amy Rasmussen Carter
"Great food, great prices, great service. Our waitress was amazing. The chicken chunks were a very generous portion. The bacon maple Mac and cheese..."
Michelle Adams
"This mr.eds place on put in bay is one of the best bars I have ever been to, the staff is super friendly and the atmosphere is..."
Andy Lavigne
"Great bartenders and staff! Always feel..."
Andy Mohn
"Spent everyday of our mini vacation here food is great good service to be so busy great music and..."
Teresa Amburgey
"Have eaten here several times. Very clean, great food & awesome service. One of our favorite places on the..."
Bridgett Streacker
"Best food, and entertainment on the island. Period. I had grouper, and it was..."
Heather Bonham Pope
"Great... great bands great service.. airy and great selections of..."
Joe Morales
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes