Great pizza, ambiance, music and love that you are open till 1 am with a full menu and bar �! Finally, great late night eats in Puyallup! � Thankful you have gluten free crust as well for my wife who has a gluten allergy (you should put that on the menu �) We'll be back!
Went here last Monday at lunch. Husband loves pizza, travels to New York, Chicago, etc for pizza excursions. Grows his own tomatoes, makes his own sauce & sausage, & has perfected his 3 day cold rise dough. So after almost 30 years of marriage, I've had a ton of different pizzas, and can appreciate dough cell structure & the underskirt.
This being said, the Pepperoni pizza we had here was the best New York style pizza I have ever had. Literally, not figuratively. My husband puts it in his top few, but best in this area.
The pizza was so good that I called back later in the week to see who made it. Charlie, you are amazing! I am going back today with some friends to eat there again. Can't wait!
Excellent food and service. The staff is friendly and remembers repeat customers. This place has become a Sunday ritual with my wife. The best pizza in Western Washington!
Your employees must remember everyone you come in contact with is a possible customer...i was treated so crappy that I will never come to your place to eat...
One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Great drinks. Service isn’t 100%, but none the less, food and drink make up for it. REALLY great happy hour choices as well! My mom and I love coming here for a night out on the town! Highly recommend for the local pizza lovers!
The food was delicious and our server was all over it. Loved that it was 21 and over, too. No annoying kids AND good pizza? Perfect.
La'Toya Lowery Warrior
+5
I absolutely enjoyed their Gluten free pizza! The atmosphere is perfect with great music and delicious hard cider called Gumption! Monica was our awesome server. She was attentive and absolutely awesome!
I enjoy coming in. The pizza is exactly the type of crust I enjoy, great selection of toppings, and always good people behind the bar!
Great salads, great pizza and great service! If you haven’t tried this place yet - you should! You won’t be disappointed!
Hands down 5 Stars!!! Great pie. Great drinks. Great service. Cool old building with tin ceiling, this place put me in mind of Pioneer square in Seattle. We will DEFINITELY return! New favorite pizza place!!!!! Check it out!!!
This is the best pizza I've had in a very long time... maybe ever. The crust is perfect, just how I'd imagine it would be getting pizza in NYC! Prices seem pretty average for pizza not from a chain... right around $25 for a large... and SO WORTH IT. Almost can't wait to go back! ���
Great place to eat in downtown Puyallup!! As many others have said, their bread-sticks are to amazing, service is fantastic, and their pizza is delicious.
I’ve sat down and ate here 4 or 5 times and I’ve ordered for pick up over 10 and the pizza is consistently delicious and always ready quickly. The staff is also friendly and inviting. What more can you ask for?
Great pizza and beverages! Emily our server was awesome as well! ���
Excellent food from the appetizers to the pizza,s, and friendly service, can’t wait to go back.
Fun, fun place. The pizza is really good....The Chosen One is our favorite. Very friendly people....Emilee is awesome!
We enjoyed our 2 pizzas, vegetarian style , our serving staff had a wonderful sense of humor, definitely go back, maybe even pick up one for dinner in front of the TV, snuggled up with my lady. Thanks Wicked, you're a real gem.
Great service, Food,atmosphere,Drinks unimaginative Super❗️Desserts Yum,pie is thin crust just perfect to taste, Decor is probably low ambience at nite good Date place too💥5💥👍🏼😃🍷🍹🍸🍺🥤 Will be back Again CHEERs🙋🏻❤️
Amazing atmosphere, amazing food, and amazing staff! Highly highly recommended!!!
Great pizza and nice staff the pizza was cooked perfect and tons of toppings
Love their sauce, the calzone and pizza we had were delicious and so was the Bodhizafa beer.. !
Mari Wetmore Ostermann
+5
Great service!! Great wine!! Great pizza!!! We will be back!!
Great authentic margarita pie. Very tasty very traditional
Loved everything about it, great food, service and
Atmosphere. With so many restaurants for kids, it's
nice to have one for adults only⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
I usually don't eat the crust it's either to hard or to thick this was awesome, the Bloody Mary wasn't to shabby either. When I'm back up to see my kids hopefully we'll be back.
Had a wonderful (tipsy) review written. It apparently it didn't post before. This place is awesome. Been here 5 or 6 times since it opened, keep expecting a less than stellar experience only because that's what seems to happen to so many restaurants but everytime we walk out more than happy. Food is amazing, price is right, drinks are perfect and service is always so genuine and just plain excellent. Our bartender said they wouldn't change and by God, they better not!! Thanks for being a bar with more than "bar food" to offer! Also, chicken bbq flatbread is my new favorite food group thanks to you guys. <3
Great people.. great food. Fun atmosphere. My favorite place!
This is the best pizza in South Sound by far! In a not so veiled way a previous reviewer claimed racism because they were unhappy with the service. I too am a "darker shade of brown" and allow to remind you...It's not a perfect world out there, it is possible that your service was poor due to any number of factors. Don't be so quick to play the race card people. The food was amazing the service was good. If you go on a Friday night there may be a bit of a wait though.
Restaurant is pretty good. I struggled with a 3 or 4. Nothing overly impressed me to give it a 4, but nothing was bad enough for a 3. Solid 3.5!
The staff is attentive and the food is good. They have a decent selection of food to chose from; a little something for everyone!
For 1 Sicilian margarita and 1 small “Mother Earth”, add sausage, pizza the total bill was $40 (not including tip). They use locally sourced ingredient which is nice, but overall still kind of expensive based on similar places prices.
Keep in mind, it’s 21 and over, so kids are not welcome. Staff wore masks, but there was no signage encouraging patrons to do so - at least none I saw.
Overall, I would say no to going back, but it might not be my first choice.
Tasty 21+ oven pizza place with a very chill vibe. Pizza flavors are really creative (recommend "Say It Ain't So!") and the service is phenomenal. It's definitely one of those "if I were to die after this meal, I'd be in a happy place" kinda places. A huge fan of the flatbread, also the thin crust to sauce to cheese to toppings ratio is perfect. Absolutely divine and classy place for a date night.
The food was absolutely excellent (and not too slow) and the portion sizes were huge. The server was friendly and attentive, and the environment was very clean.
The prices weren't too high, but we were glad to have visited on Sunday, when Wicked Pie Pizza has an all-day happy hour.
I highly recommend their meatball calzone and the cheesy bread appetizer.
(More sensitive visitors should know that the interior is quite dark and the music is loud, but we loved that!)
Don’t skip the appetizer! Cheesy bread was so so good. The pizza options and calzones are all excellent as well. This is a fun adult atmosphere (no kids or teens under 21) that’s chill and quaint.
Prices are comparable to other local pizza shops.
First time ever to this gem and it did not disappoint! Flavorful pizza and interesting cocktails. I had an amazing vodka and lavander drink that was so delicious! Sorry I cant remember the name of it. The live entertainment was fun and added to a great atmosphere. When you visit request to be seated in Destiny's area, what a fantastic waitress! Her quick service was spot on! We will be returning soon!
This may be the best pizza in Washington State, this place is incredible! Reminds me of NYC pizza which is so hard to find here! The staff is super nice and the Bloody Mary literally comes with a little mini slice of pizza in it lol. For pizza options, there are so many awesome combos to decide from and the cool thing that you can do is get half half on pies. We went with the Mob Boss (omg so good with the meatballs) and Flying Pig on one and then Say It Ain't So and the Puyallup on the other. Plenty leftover for us to enjoy again the following day for pizza breakfast :)
This place is WICKED GOOD! The cocktails are absolutely out of this world cool and delicious....and the pizza is too with very high quality ingredients. The vibe here is also very hip and relaxing and the service is top notch! Great food. Great drinks. Cute place. Perfect date or hang out spot. Love this addition to downtown Puyallup. Rustic, modern and mega tasty. Thank you wicked pie pizza for a great experience every time!
This place was excellent. Tasty Bloody marry and very good classic calzone. Delicious 😋 The young lady that waited on us was very nice and helpful.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes