Sluurpy > Restaurants in Reynoldsburg > Hickory House Restaurant

Hickory House Restaurant - Reynoldsburg - Photo album

Exceptional Dining Experience From Beginning to End. We arrived at peak dinner hour. The establishment was prepared with plenty of seating for the hungry folks waiting. The hostess was extremely friendly and gave us a waiting time of only 15 minutes. Quite surprised, and unsure they would be able

Ordered carryout from here for the first time. The restaurant looks very inviting and clean. Certainly would like to eat there sometime. Food was excellent tasting but ribs were not hot, not even warm. Feel like they boxed them first then took time to cook other items. Would have been 5 stars if i

My wife and I don't get to this side of town often, but when we do, we always try to get to the Hickory House. We've had a variety of items off their menu, but I recommend that everyone go with the ribs. They are delicately delicious.

Came here a while back now, hadn’t had the opportunity to review this location sooner. The food was satisfactory, the steaks were cooked to order and sizable. Quality was toward the top end of choice options, which was responsible for the pricing. The broccoli and mac and cheese were great! The food

Service outstanding, food inconsistent. Bread not good at all but ribeye delicious. Steak not cooked properly but remedied quickly. No butter for mashed potatoes which I thought a bit odd.

Very good food and welcoming atmosphere. The fillet and shrimp were perfectly prepared. The side salad was large and the house sweet and sour dressing with onion is a perfectly reproduced classic dressing. Our server, Nancy, was one of the best and friendliest serves I've ever had. She welcomed our

Will not return. Based on the menu and reviews I truly looked forward to the visit. We stopped for dinner, the restaurant was not busy at all, and rightfully so, as we soon found out. The best part of the meal were the onion straws for appetizer, we should have stopped with those. The ribs I had fo

This is a gem.....staff was amazing.....food was delicious. Porterhouse steak cooked to order perfectly. Baby back ribs fell off the bone and sauce was very good too. Recommend this place.... we're for sure coming back.