Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Reynoldsburg
12 restaurant menus in Reynoldsburg, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"First time at Pizzaroni's tonight and we will definitely be back. Everyone there was incredibly friendly and the smell coming from that building is..."
Carrie Acosta
"☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ ☆ this local homemade pizza shop is a fantastic job with each order they take their time and make the pizza right it's very good..."
John D. Zarlino
"Delicious pizzas, would definitely recommend! New favorite local pizza..."
Ashley Krichbaum Shroyer
"I highly recommend the Italian sub with home-made sausage. Pizza was great. Used all high in ingredients. I don't know what took me so long to try..."
Rick Chrysler
"The pizza was really good! The staff was nice. When you dine in... you get a free ice cream treat from the cooler... this lemon ice was..."
Kathleen Garner
"Had Pizzaroni's for the first time this week. It is excellent pizza! The crust is outstanding. Generous toppings. Excellent flavor. Will..."
Brian Burd
"Great tasting pizza!!! Will definitely be back. The pepperonis awesome and the crust is the..."
John Hurt
"Great pizza and subs but even better are the people that work there, great service always and with a smile. My favorite pizza place by..."
Mike Beesler
"Well, a friend from Youngstown posted, and compared it to our Famous Belleria Pizza, So we came from Youngstown and tried it, its totally different..."
Gottamakeithappen Marilyn
"Just left there. I do believe we found a favorite pizza place. Awesome pizza, staff very friendly. The way it's supposed to be!..."
Ralph Opa Portier
"Amazing crunchy crust and the bacon and onion pizza was delicious! Meatballs were tender and the marinara I wish could make like that. Service was..."
Rose Mast McKay
"What can I say wrong about this place, the food is always great, hot and fresh, when in there for the first time to dine in last night and it was..."
Johnny White
"Tried a pizza bowl and a 16 inch pizza tonight for the family.. We absolutely loved everything and will be back to try more menu..."
Paula Mosblack Carpenter
"Pizza connoisseur here of course, this is another awesome pizza spot right outside of the city. Came here multiple times and haven't had a bad..."
Zac W
"Went to Pizzaroni's this evening with the family, my second time there. First time was 1-2 years ago. Very good, just as I remembered. 🙂 Got a..."
Christopher Gray
"If you are looking for the best pizza in Columbus, look no further than Pizzaroni’s. The pizza toppings are plentiful and tasteful. Italian sub..."
Mike Pacifico
"First visit 👍perfect in every way. Friendly staff.
The Italian sub was great! Not too much bun.plenty of good quality meat and excellent..."
Jeff Rettinger
"****CLOSED DUE TO "LEASE" ISSUES
Just closes and walks away to find new building?? Huh...odd to just walk away until ya find a new brick &..."
Jason Morse
"The pizza is really good here. It's a family friendly business and the staff is great. They put the pizza in the roller oven and then the brick oven..."
Tiffany Red
"Pizza was really good! Loaded with toppings! This was our first time trying it and it was really good. Customer service was great! Danielle is so..."
"Best pizza in Reynoldsburg! The price is spot on, fresh ingredients (grown in front of the shop), and great people! Not really a place to dine in..."
Stacievans2016
"Very good!. Cheese danish on croissant dough? Yes Please! Very happy with my..."
Amanda Reno
"This was my first try at Tyler's. I ordered a regular pepperoni pizza. No extras. It was fantastic! The wood fired oven along with the very fresh..."
Rjw
"Excellent!. The pizza was delicious,i'm italian and i was a pizza cook,so i know what i am talking about.The dough is made daily,the tomato sauce is..."
FabK
"Service was outstanding got to try out some bread while I waited for my pizza defiantly the friendliest people I have ran into since I have been in..."
Dxwr3k
"I discovered Tyler's Pizzeria and Bakery back in March. At that time I was simply in love with the atmosphere, friendliness and quality of food. 6..."
Dani Tolkendorf
"Awesome Pizza & Baked Goods. I visited Tyler's for the first time yesterday, and was very impressed with the service and the food. They cook..."
"The new location has added a lot to what Vick's has to offer - more room, a nice beer selection and some more options on the menu. The pizzas are..."
Jim Ellison
"Raider Rules!. If you are feeding a small army order The Raider. It will not disappoint. It is a large, backspace, backspace...giant pizza! And the..."
Lisa Myers
"We were driving through and I found this place online, we were not disappointed. The gut-buster is fantastic and the deluxe Italian sub wad amazing...."
Lauren Pascoe
"Great pizza. I love Vick's. Quality toppings, and a fair price. You pay for what you get, and you get quality. My only complaint is that parking is a..."
Drew
"I found this place on Yelp and decided to give it a try. I ordered a 10” Buffalo Chicken Pizza ($14.50) and Loaded Fries ($5.99) . The person on..."
tyann amos
"Great outdoor space! Older brick building done up very nicely! I had the calzone- I LOVE their crust! My hubby had a sub sandwich- he said it was 1..."
Diana Otto
"We love this place! Every time we go we have to get our own piece of desert- which they all are just AMAZING! And usually a pizza. Simple order but..."
Heather Kehrle
"I love Vick’s Gourmet Pizzeria and have enjoyed dinner and a great night of entertainment by Guitarist/Singer/Songwriter Eric Solomon for several..."
Cheryl Holbrook
"Good cheesy pizza and nice crispy crust. The best pizza I had in a while. Don’t hate the service because it’s hard to find good help these days,..."
George Klotz
"Great local restaurant. Delicious thin crust pizza that is much better for dine in than delivery. Always get the battered fries as an app. The..."
j s
"I can’t say enough about Vick’s Gourmet Pizza! The NEW patio and live music just adds to the atmosphere. Great pizza, great beverages, and GREAT..."
"Massey's never fails to impress anyone I take there. This trip included my son and one of his friends. We all enjoyed the pizza, and this is one of..."
Lee Offenberger
"We live a little outside of the delivery area. When we get close enough while at the local bar, we order a pizza to take home. You never disappoint..."
Jo Mo
"Delicious 12" Supreme pizza with pineapple topping Wait time was a little longer than normal, but to be expected on Supre Bowl..."
Aldrick Gore
"The owners are awesome and the pizza is great. I go at least once a week and have tried almost everything. The location in Reynoldsburg serves..."
Fred Mendes
"First time ordering delicious pizza and sub was good..."
Justin McClanahan
"I ordered online and it was my second time ever ordering from Massey's and the guy who answered was extremely friendly very patient and walked me..."
"Great pizza. Family owned. For those who don't eat pork... Their sausage, ham, bacon, and pepperoni is not pork. It is either beef or turkey. And it..."
Tamara Hill
"Everything we've ordered has been delicious! Gyros and stuffed grape leaves were amazing, shrimp is the best I've had. I love how the breading is..."
Lori Jones
"Got the regular medium 1/2 pepperoni pizza and fried mushrooms. Pizza was great. Mushrooms were as expected, nothing fancy. I was only in there for a..."
Eve Beeler
"Pizza is delicious! Buttery crust. No pork restaurant. They use turkey pepperoni. Wings are good but sometimes over..."
Wendi Turner
"Ordered a Chicago style thick crust. It was not as thick as others I have had, but very tasty. Great flavorful crust, lots..."
Steven W. Hicks
"Tuna sub is so delicious! Cheese sticks yummy too! Customer service is..."
2 Medium 1 Topping Pizzas Cheezy Bread and 2 Liter Hot Deal
Pizza
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
"When i ordered for the first time i want to say 4-5 month’s ago they would never give me my extra cheese on my pizza like requested and paid for...."
Marguerita Rucker
"I recently moved back to Columbus from Georgia a week ago. I seen this location and wanted to see if the taste was the same. Oh My it was the same..."
Aleshia McBroom
"After several bad experiences with other pizza chains, Marco's is my new go to. The app was easy and the tracking option was fantastic. Our delivery..."
Elizabeth Rector
"I wish I took pictures of our food but WOW is this some really good pizza. They have amazing deals (we ordered a large pizza, with cheesy bread and a..."
Madison Doughty
"I enjoy Marco's....
Is it a chain....sure
But you get a consistent pizza each time and I'm a fan of that.
Big thing for me was pizza cut like a..."
Jason Martin
"Really good Pizza. Orders are delivered very fast and the food is excellent. They are always running specials and I think they are priced very..."
Shawn Tolbert
"We've been here many times and the pizza was ok. Tried the thin crust and were thoroughly satisfied! More pizza and less bread..."
"I hired Sextons food truck for my sons 1st birthday party! They were amazing! Everyone raved about the pizza the whole party! Jamey was so..."
Chrissy Thayer Espaillat
"Literally just got my first pizza 10 min ago and it is BY FAR the best pizza in Florida! Beyond stoked to have finally found awesome pizza down..."
Dustin Pentz
"Awesome pizza. Quick and exceedingly friendly service. Shared a full pie - Pie Napple Express (pepperoni & pineapple) and the 614 (pepperoni, bacon,..."
Bobby Fitts
"Great pizza. I’m not usually a pizza fan but who can resist MAC an cheese or banana peppers on a pizza. Whatever you are looking for they have it..."
Ivy Crowell
"Damn good pizza!!! The Pineapple Pizza was too good to pass up! Definitely a must..."
Cameron Pape
"Had superb pizza tonight when Sexton's was at circa 1949. Wonderful pizza and great service definitely going to keep an eye out for this food truck..."
Monique Devroeg
"I have tried tons of pizza places and nothing could even come close to what I had here. This is what I have been missing since I moved to Florida ...."
Chris Seeley
"Perfect balance of dough, sauce, meat, and cheese!! Highly..."
Jay Tran
"Wonderful pizza! The smoked provolone really makes it! And the charred crust was..."
Melane Nelson
"I️ love Sexton Pizza! ��Wish they could be at 3 daughters more cause I️ love having a slice after yoga on tap! Seriously though, this pizza..."
Stephanie Snelson
"Had your amazing cheese and mini pepperoni slices at the FSU alumni event at Green Bench Brewery last night. Just wanted to leave a quick review that..."
Renee Killian
"Some of the best pizza I've ever had!!! Definitely check it out if you're in the..."
Lucas James
"INCREDIBLE pizza! Hand made in the food truck! We watched ‘em!
Ours looked just like their pepperoni pizza in the photo! Smoked provolone cheese!..."
Lynne Motejaitis Knight
"It's awesome pizza, seasoned just right with a well-baked crust, plenty of cheese, and exquisite pepperoni. I buy a pie or two for the office every..."
Douglas Phillips
"The Kevin Bacon never disappoints. The house salad is also delicious! The pools in the pepperoni are hot honey. Not grease! Perfect..."
Regina Hunter
"Best Pizza in Columbus. Hands down. Owners are great people. Staff is always friendly and kind. Never..."
Wes Anders
"We have finally found our favorite pizza! The Kevin Bacon pizza is unbelievable. We tried it for the first AND second time this weekend!
You can't..."
Tiffany Dalton
"I am telling everyone my family has lived in the Reynoldsburg area for 30 years we go everywhere for pizza. We've gone to Chicago, just all over but..."
tina staton
"Alright Frankie....
We found Sextons by accident when walking out of Hobby Lobby, the smell in the air was incredible, looked right then left and..."
Ryan
"This is some of the best pizza I've had in awhile. I went in for pickup, but looks like a decent place to dine in. The staff was friendly, got our..."
"Omg the new pan �.... Loving the taste of this crust... Super fast delivery. Pizza was still..."
K.S. Lee
"15 minutes for delivery...definitely a record. Everything is..."
Angelic Stidham
"I’m not gonna lie !!! Great experience!! I did delivery last week and they did phenomenal the only thing is they were probably slammed cause I..."
Lydia Smith
"I love Pappa Johns. The packaging is cool too. Pizza is fast. Please tell your stores to turn off the Open sign at night if it is delivery..."
Ms Essence Bailey
"You might end up waiting in line a little longer than you expected but the pizza was absolutely delicious if you are going in for the new york-style..."
"Very friendly staff, food was excellent! Karlie took care of my order and we were in and out in no time..."
Jennifer Lynn
"Ordered 2 meatlover pan pizza with extra cheese , and I was very happy with my order. I understand some people may have had a different experience, ..."
"Ive personally never had a problem at this location like I have at others. The employees are always nice.
One time they messed up my order and kindly..."
K Noen
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes