Best Garbage Plate Pizza in Rochester

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Sylvio's Pizzeria
Sylvio's Pizzeria
84/100 (324 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast Pizza
Beer Battered Fish Fry
Garbage Plate Pizza
tr Bomber Hot Sub
Buffalo BBQ
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"A superb performance from customer service. The food was fantastic. Great deals all around. I would highly recommend this place to friends and..."
Brendan Walsh
"This place has the best food ever!Speedy service! Clean..."
Christina Andressi
"The best food by the best people!! How do I know you ask. Because I’ve known them for..."
Matt Cantiello
"I put my review in the wrong spot but to sum it up, this is a great pizzeria with awesome people working there. I had to place a huge order for 125..."
Jeff Lootens
"Hands down best pizza and steak subs in Rochester. Service was awesome too. Both guys working were very..."
Jacqueline Cianca
"Great food. Great people. Can't go wrong. Definitely worth every..."
Roy Bertolino
"Delivered on time, pizza and wings were delicious but the hit has to be the fried dough. Would order from sylvio's again and what is nice is that..."
Nico Calabrese
"Best pizza around. All their other dinners are amazing..."
Derek Bailey
""The best fried dough and cupped pepperoni in..."
Debra Calabrese
"Excellent food and customer service nice guys..."
Bev Colon
"Just ordered the most delicious eggplant parm from there!! My boyfriend and I order from here at least once every 2-3 weeks. They are ALWAYS taking..."
Jessica Yuan
"Best Mac salad in the rochester area...must try..."
Will Cardona
"Tried their pepperoni pizza and sweet & sour wings! Will definitely try their fish fry, subs, and French bread pizza! It’s a little travel for me..."
Todd Elkins
"3rd time ordering-big wings, great toppings and options, top notch customer service and friendliness. Above all, spotless shop-owners should be..."
Tim McAvoy
"This place is a charm! I had the eggplant parmesan sub here, and their food is so warm and fresh. They also have pizza and cannoli here that's made..."
Vocaloid_Victrix
"What a great dinner! Pizza and boneless wings were fantastic and the service was even..."
Patti Mancabelli
"Amazing pizza , wings and subs !!! I’ve tried most of the menu everything is always..."
Steve Brongo
"Got a flyer on the mail and learned that Sylvio's has fish on Friday. Ordered a beer battered for me and Cajun broiled for the Mrs. Both were..."
Steven Oller
"Very good pizza, my first visit, easy to order online with extensive menu. More to come when I update my review after my next..."
Mark Nicastro
"We’ve been DYING for Sylvio’s to reopen. Every time my husband and I would drive by, he’d be upset they were still closed since it’s our..."
Jessica B
"Sylvio's Pizzeria is our new favorite Friday night pizza spot for my wife and I. Thank you so much for the excellent customer service and warm family..."
Gozycode Academy
"While the sandwich was actually quite good (chick parm) it was a little..."
Phil Ng
"First, I absolutely love the pizza… second, these guys are amazing and know what service is about! I ordered through the new (to me) “slice”..."
Sarah Wesley
"Recently grabbed 4 sheets for my daughter's party. Excellent pizza phenomenal. Everyone wanted to know where it was from. Went extra effort to make..."
Ninja Turtles
"If I were to award a shop ‘best chicken finger sub’ in Monroe County, this place is it. Not only do they use the correct type of bread, they make..."
Jordan Butler
"What can I say about Sylvio's besides the eggplant calzone is AMAZING!!!! that's right! I said AMAZING!! I tried finding something about it that..."
Amirs Sittu
"One of my favorite pizza places in Charlotte! It's a little pricey, but it's my go-to place for carry-out Italian food. Definitely worth it. They..."
Redria
"Excellent! Setting up a second residence on the Lake, used Google to find a local pizza establishment and Sylvio's did not disappoint! Homemade pizza..."
Josh Alri
"Very friendly staff, quiet location with outdoor seating. The food is pretty good..."
Justin Chase