Best Oyster in Sag Harbor

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Bell And Anchor
Bell And Anchor
87/100 (1281 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Ice Cream
Bouillabaisse
Burger
Pesto
Fish
Pork
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Oyster
Mussels
Tuna
Salmon
Sit down
American
Seafood
Full Bar
Waterfront
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Mid-range
"Our first time this evening for my birthday and it was a spectacular dinner. Coincidentally, it was ramen night and I had to try it…delicious! The..."
Alina Sanders
"My husband and I are big fans of Bell and Anchor. The food is always solid, the service is impeccable. They always treat us like family, and it’s..."
Robyn Nicole
"Call a day before for patio seating weather permitting. Great atmosphere. Drinks were great. Fluke and oysters..."
Peter M
"Great from start to finish. The drinks all the way through to dessert were delicious. Opted to sit at the bar. Our bartender, Carl, was great. His..."
Christopher Diaz
"Where do I begin? This is hands down one of the best restaurants I’ve eaten at since I’ve started coming the Hamptons when my wife and I started..."
Nicholas Mrnarevic
"When it is February on the East End of Long Island, the restaurant is not on Main Street, and you still have trouble finding a parking space, you..."
Jacqueline Vita
"We come here all the time and are never disappointed! Food always very good, service friendly and professional - it’s one of our go to restaurants..."
Jennifer Boden
"Came for bouillabaisse night but tried most of everything. Solid seafood place for the area. All the host and staff are very friendly and..."
Alek Cohen
"Have been here a few times. Great place. The atmosphere is cute and relaxed with a pinch of fancy. My family and I even went here for Christmas..."
Tate B
"Dinner here was fantastic. Strongly recommend to anyone in Sag Harbor looking for a good dinner out (the cocktails are great..."
Gabriel Motola
Dock House
Dock House
86/100 (484 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Seafood
Soups
American
Soups
Seafood
American
Dinner
Lunch
Fish Taco
Fried Scallops
Tacos
Fried Soft Shell Crab
Fried Clams
Fish & Chips
Sandwiches
Clams
Fried Shrimp
Shrimp
Lobster
BLT
Panini
Lobster Roll
Salad
Shrimp Tacos
Waffle Fries
Fried Fishermans Net Flounder Shrimp Scallops
Clam Chowder
Oysters on the Half Shell
Fish
Lobster Roll Market Price
Fresh Seafood
Hot or Cold Cracked 1 1 4 lb Lobster Market Price
Crab
Crab cakes
Swordfish Sandwich and Waffle Fries
Scallops
Grilled Tuna or Salad
Clams
Flounder Fillet Baguette
Oyster
Tuna
Lobster Bisque
Lobster Roll
Fried Clam Strips
Tapas
Grilled Salmon Salad
Soups
Seafood
American
Takeout
Seating
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Really really good NE clam chowder, especially after a long day of being outside. One bowl ran me about $9.75 +tax. The food came very fast. Very..."
Victoria Bayevskiy
"This hole in the wall seafood spot in Sag Harbor offers delicious lobster rolls, classic, bisque. Take it to go and grab a seat at the picnic tables..."
Roxanna Castillo
"Had lunch here, food was fresh. The lobster roll was good, a little pricey but what isn't in this area? New England clam chowder and lobster bisque..."
Daniel Antoniazzi
"Incredible casual dockside location with accommodating staff, great service and delicious and not overproced food. The only reason for 4 stars for..."
Marie De
"Excellent kitchen staff; they get my food exactly how I want it every time. Had dinner from them several times and have never been disappointed...."
Maximillian Ward Osborn
"Tiny place with big character and flavor. Staff could have been more friendly. Order your meal, then find a seat. Choose between a few inside or a..."
Colleen LaRock
"Lobster roll was good but expensive. The crab cakes were good, but not fantastic. Lobster bisque was disappointing. The soup itself is fine but only..."
Matthew Tsou
"Fairly priced classic seafood shack. Both clam chowders were excellent. Steamers were ok although would like be better eaten there. Salad with..."
Roger Merel
"Average-tasting food for sky-high prices. Paid $42.10 for 1/4 pound of lobster salad and one fried soft shell crab. I get a better deal at the..."
Gail Melisa
"Great stop for a bite to go! REALLY liked the way they charr the skin fat on the salmon, however the charr on the burger was overpowering. Would go..."
#SmartHomeSecurityNY
The American Hotel
The American Hotel
86/100 (644 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Duck
Oyster
Tuna
Salmon
Sandwiches
Burger
Crab Cake
Shrimp
Lamb chops
BLT
Porterhouse Steak
Bananas Foster
Lobster
Lamb
Fish
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Clams
Sit down
American
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Fine Dining
Baron's Cove
Baron's Cove
83/100 (649 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Brunch
Lobster Roll
Burger
Toasts
Shrimp
Pesto
Fish
Pork
Lobster
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Duck
Oyster
American
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Live Music
Reservations
Seating
Waterfront
Table Service
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
Page At 63 Main
Page At 63 Main
81/100 (2615 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Gemelli Pasta Sausage & Broccoli Rabe
Octopus
Calamari
Steamed P E I Mussels Meunier
BLT
Risotto
Smoked Turkey Club
Bolognese
Egyptian Spiced Chicken Sandwich
Mussels
Sandwiches
Coconut Layer Cake
Ice Cream
Tuna
Burger
Allen Brother's Prime 12oz NY Strip
Gelato
Cheese Burger and Fries
Calamares
Skin Charred Farm Raised Salmon
Kale Salad
Mediterranean Salad
Salmon
Shrimp
Burrata Salad & Turkey Club
Cakes
Crispy Fried Calamari
Pesto
Lemon Tart
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Crab Cake
Lobster
Charred Spanish Octopus
Chowder
Lobster Roll
Pasta
Vanilla Bean Panna Cotta
Tuna & Artic Char Tartare
Halibut
Salad
Garganelli Pasta Bolognese
Clam Chowder
Local Peeko Oysters on the Half Shell
Crab
Fish
Baby Arugula Salad
Omelette
Scallops
Pork
Lacinato Kale Salad
Bass
Oyster
Sit down
American
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Always have the best time at Page Food is the best and so is the wait staff and bartenders. Wilson our waiter was great last night and the food..."
Theresa Reeve Andrew
"Our best meal in Sag Harbor!! Great food, great atmosphere and superb service!! Highly recommend. Do..."
Jo Ann Marzullo- Pepe
"Fabulous food and service! Our server was on spot from drinks to..."
Brenda Fitch English
"Music at bar was chill. Loved it. Bartender was engaging abd friendly. Loved it. The wings on appetizer menu. to die for. Loved it. The burger meat..."
Marcelo Marrero
"Fantastic food, good wine selection, attentive wait staff. One of the best restaurants here on the East..."
Tom Oleszczuk
"Had an outstanding meal with my husband! We will definitely go back here next time we venture to the south fork :) keep up the good work. Main chef..."
Karen Palmer Ormond
"Never had a bad meal here. Not one of the 5 of us was disappointed with our three course price fixe last..."
Jordan Federico
"Great food and friendly service. It was fancy enough for adults to feel like they are somewhere nice and the menu had food that the kids loved as..."
Sara Green
"Delish!! The fish is so fresh and prepared so well. And those veggies in their hydroponic glory really shined. And remember to have a dessert!..."
Robin Riback
"Great food. Fabulous service! Was a really great dining..."
Geri Schuman Lipschitz
"Lunch was great, nice reasonable priced place with great service! Foods good..."
Sarah Kearns Sulzinski
"We had brunch for Mother's Day. All of the food was delicious, the service was great and the ambience in the restaurant is very..."
Jeanne Marrin Stewart
"Lovely restaurant with amazing food & great..."
Bronna Canaan
"Food was phenomenal & the service was superb! This restaurant comes highly recommended by my daughter & I. Menu was generous, which made it hard to..."
Christine Cavanagh
"The food is fresh and delish! Excellent service and wonderful outdoor dining area in the village of Sag Harbor..."
Larry Salovin
"Went for the late seating on New Year's Eve; we had a great meal with friendly and fluid service! The ambience, food, and drinks were perfect. We'll..."
Kal Kel
"Bring back the chopped salad. A bit disappointed about changes in..."
Cynthia Walker
"Excellent food, Great Service. Hope to return..."
Page Barnes
"I loved the Calamari Salad I had tonight. Perfect with a glass of Pinot..."
Jeanine Edington
"Food is good,excellent service. Great atmosphere. Love to be on the..."
Esmin Forrest
"Always a pleasure... I feel like I'm home when I'm at Page!..."
Michelle Niles
"Excellent seafood right in the heart of Sag Harbor's Main..."
Tina Mazze Costa
"The service was excellent & the short ribs were..."
Bari Cohen
"Oysters , Octopus and Mahi mahi oh my. Loved this place by reading the first few menu items on the street, I had found another place but a parking..."
Garrett Nuttall
"I had the most delightful experience at Page 63 restaurant in Sag Harbor, Long Island! Brunch was simply wonderful, and I can't stop raving about..."
William Jacobs
"Great location, decor, and a diverse menu. The bolognese tastes as amazing as it looks. The sangria is not a true sangria though... a few pieces of..."
Dr. Abby
"Cute restaurant! Highly recommend sitting in the back outdoor seating area, was a really nice vibe. Food was just ok, nothing special. Service was..."
Lauren Silverstein
"The food was amazing. Sean, our waiter was very friendly. He made our first-time experience an incredible one...."
Carlesha Ferguson
"Great atmosphere. We opted to take their outside seating though they have a patio seating at the back of the restaurant. Lots of crowds to watch..."
She Rie
"This is a beautiful restaurant in Sag Harbor, New York. Both the indoor space and the outdoor patio are casual yet elegant. The food was excellent..."
Jim Reisman
"I cannot stop thinking about my dinner here a few weeks ago! The bolognese was to die for, oysters were incredible, and the rabbit with carrot..."
Leah Kellenberger
"What a great restaurant! It’s very nice inside and out. We sat out front and the flowers were a really nice touch. Food wise, the tuna tartare is..."
Danny Chong
"Happened upon Page at 63 Main while visiting Sag Harbor and looking for a special place for our anniversary. The menu and atmosphere seemed like a..."
Kevin Simms
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
77/100 (1294 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Seafood
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Grilled Spanish Octopus
Lobster Roll
Grilled Whole Branzino
Whole Grilled Branzino
Burger
Seafood Towers
Octopus
Topneck Clams
Fish
Burger and fries
Shrimp
Big-Eye Tuna Tartar
Grilled fish
Skirt Steak
Espresso Martini
1lb Whole Lobster
Roasted Cauliflower
Trufa Pizza
Lobster
Fish & Chips
Mussels
Salad
French Fries
Oyster
Oyster
Burrata Salad
Mussels
Macarons
Macaroni and Cheese
Seafood
American
Gift Cards Available
Street Parking
Parking Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Serves Alcohol
Accepts American Express
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great food and restaurant! One of the best cod fish we ever had, a very flavourfull burger..."
Nicole D.
"With out a doubt, the best restaurant in Sag Harbor! Chef Philippe is a culinary genius, and the staff is so knowledgeable and courteous. I highly..."
Lauren Jahoda
"One of the best meals we’ve had in a long time. The cauliflower is an absolute must try. This should be a 3 star rating because all the tables were..."
Ken Poulton Jr.
"We had the ultimate dining experience at Lulu. They’re always busy especially during summer season so I’d highly recommend a reservation. From..."
Donald C.
"Incredible experience and extremely friendly staff. Delicious food and warm high energy atmosphere. Open later than most restaurants in the area. One..."
Charly Hillman
"Very delicious food. I also love the environment and especially the table in front of the kitchen. I love to see the cooking activities...."
Setpheap
"Very cool and happening spot in Sag Harbor. We ordered a couple of pizzas start with the octopus and the "main" shellfish tower. Not a big fan of..."
Michael Sinensky
"Best mussels I've had on LI. The whole branzino was cooked to perfection served with a roasted tomato with balsamic drizzle. For dessert espresso..."
Arielle Grunin
"Trendy atmosphere, extremely friendly, courteous and efficient t staff, delicious food and presentation was well done. Loved the elegant..."
Debbie Helmke
"Great place and really nice staff. I would recommend the steak and tuna tartar. The bread tastes amazing and the service is very fast. In addition..."
Harry Robinson
Dockside Bar & Grill
Dockside Bar & Grill
74/100 (1135 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Fish
Calamares
Salmon
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Chowder
Lobster
Lobster Roll
Salad
Fish Taco
Clam Chowder
Steamers
Crab
Cod
Swordfish
Scallops
Ribs
Clams
Oyster
Calamari
Paella
Mussels
Cakes
Tuna
Burger
Sit down
Bar
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Television
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Street Parking
Waterfront
Accepts Discover
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Mid-range
"Stacey, Elizabeth and Linda run this restaurant flawlessly. The drinks are delicious. The bartender uses all my favorite ingredients Fresh orange..."
Maximilian F
"There was a line here on a Monday afternoon for lunch! We waited maybe 10-15 minutes. It wasn’t bad at all. Definitely get the lobster spring..."
Danny Chong
"The lobster and avocado rolls were delicious. The cod was also spectacular. But even more impressive was the service! Danielle was excited to tell us..."
Meylin Mota
"I had the lightly breaded cod with mash and Spinach, yum!! My friend had the roasted poblano pepper stuffed with pork, I had a bite, WOW, so good!..."
The Mid Life Traveler Lexie Lee
"Excellent service by friendly crew (waiters) and very tastefully prepared food item. Look forward to go there..."
Allirani Arumugam
"Great food, great service, great views, great cocktails! Nice and calm ambience! Always want to..."
Vasillis Stoimenos
"Some of the best food in Sag Harbor and a nice view to match. GO: if you want one of the best lobster rolls this side of Maine. PASS if you're in the..."
Johanna Somerville
"Lovely outdoor restaurant by the harbor with a great view of the water. Amazing great tasting food as well as dessert and appetizers very friendly..."
Jordan Paredes
"Very friendly staff. Non beer options on tap, including June shine, which is nice for gluten free..."
Kristina Markovitch
"Dockside Owners Elizabeth and Stacey run their restaurant flawlessly. The food is excellent Fresh fish prepared and cooked to perfection. I had the..."
Maximilian France
"Great food and excellent service. Great take on seafood with a Spanish..."
Kuo Fung
"Always my favourite place to have dinner when are here visiting family for the summer. The menu has a little of everything. Crab cake were my choice..."
Colleen Bolin
"Excellent lunch! We had the crab spring rolls and an order of guac with fried plantains for apps...lunch was a lobster roll and tuna. Drinks were..."
ken johnson
"Been comming here for years and my parents (locals) must eat here a few nights a week through the summer and winters. Get the WINGS!! And Lobster..."
Jonny D
"Great chicken pot pie, cod and other fish dishes. NE clam chowder was better last year. Friendly bar and wait staff. Before or after, go for a..."
Larry
"The restaurant is the place we hangout for social and dinner. We love the service and quality of food. Do not miss if you visit our..."
Parekh Amit
"This is all around best in Sag Harbor. Food is always good. The owners and staff are truly competent and kind people who care about the customers...."
Penny Moser