Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Sag Harbor
6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Our server Carla was AWESOME from beginning to end..
We arrived around 2:30pm on Sunday, 11/04/23 & we weren't sure if we were going to stay since we..."
Henry Bradley III
"Great italian restaurant in Sag Harbor. We had a take out on the weekend - the place was busy with a well stocked bar. The staff/manager was..."
Sa Sh
"Excellent food and super service
We were delighted with our choices. Had a honey calamari for starters super and we shared it between four. My..."
Gerry Sinnott
"It's a mix of a place, with a bright fluorescent lit front for takeout and a nice setting by the bar. If the front was made less "pizza pickup" the..."
David Fischer
"This is the second time that I’ve gone here .. they did not disappoint! I had a specially made sandwich of grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella,..."
Joanne Jarvis
"Amazing Italian restaurant! The food and staff were wonderful. The portion size is great. I had a tough time finishing my half-plate order of pasta...."
Taylor Royal
"Been here twice. Once to dine in and once for take out. Service is excellent and great little spot with good food. 💝 The manager/server/owner...."
bex de
"My first real lobster roll... tons of meat and awesome fries! Hubert's lemonade was..."
Wendy Base
"Excellent restaurant I like it, it has a very calm..."
Venancio Dubon
"Wow! This is the best Italian food I’ve had on Long Island! Everything we ordered reminded me of the meals my Italian great aunts and my..."
Dina R.
"New Years Eve…… we placed a takeout order. My husband picked up the order, take out area was very busy. The young lady wished my husband happy..."
Carol DeGregorio
"EXCELLENT FOOD!! It’s a very casual and fairly priced restaurant. First of all, the food is just great, please try the homemade lasagna and the..."
Dr77 777
"The waitress was exceptional. Friendly and efficient, anticipating our every need. The food was scrumptious. The calamari were among the best I have..."
Sayre Swarztrauber
"It's a friendly place with a friendly vibe. As well as good food with generous servings. In the heart of the Hamptons but not of the Hamptons--if..."
Lorraine Dusky
"Great food with great people 👌 👍 😀 ill never forget it..."
D&K RECK (LIVE FREE OR DIE)
"The time has come.
After eating a thousand amazing dinners, lunches, desserts…I need to step up and write a review.
People…this is one of last..."
Charles Forthofer
"Reasonably priced menu especially for the Hamptons...surprised by the huge focaccia sandwiches, absolutely..."
"My favorite restaurant in the Hamptons! Maurizio is the best, and he hires and trains his staff to be the best! I would highly recommend this..."
David Noto
"We have been here several times and have nothing but rave reviews! Great service, great view, great location, and even better FOOD! They always..."
Nicole DT
"Amazing burrata, branzino, and any one of the pasta dishes. Fantastic Great vibe. Outdoor patio..."
Jill Infantolino-Hajjar
"Incredible food, attentive, knowledgeable and personable staff in a cozy and picturesque..."
Claas Abraham
"Great food and fast service. Great view of the..."
Anam Pineda
"Outstanding and friendly service beginning with Eric's warm greeting. Ravioli is exceptional and our tile fish and halibut were presented beautifully..."
David Dweck
"Lovely, pick a sunny day and sit outside and relax, great wine, friendly service, delicious food. The portions for me were more American and less..."
Cadria Hibbert
"Our favorite spot in the Hamptons (and..."
Scott Ziegler
"Always a delight, great food & excellent wine..."
Christina Chapman
"Amazing food, service and ambiance. And now, a second..."
Maryann Aiello
"Very nice atmosphere and delicious dinner and appetizers and excellent attentive..."
Mike Haslett
"Sempre al top, non vedo l'ora di passare da quelle parti.
Qualità e buon gusto non mancano..."
Emilio Amodeo
"Our favorite restaurant! Delicious homemade pasta, fresh fish and great..."
Dana Post Adler
"Obviously . The italian bald guy is excellent and..."
Maurizio Marfoglia
"Beautiful restaurant, we got lucky with a seat at the bar, excellent food and atmosphere. Felt so comfortable! The squid ink pasta and rigatoni with..."
Richard S
"The menu differed from what I had seen online, which was more extensive. However, the food and service were truly outstanding. Our waiter was..."
Shuma M
"EXCELLENT: 10/10: My family and I (party of 4) cannot say enough great things about this restaurant. We had the BEST candlelit table in the house...."
Lauren Sharkey
"Absolutely wonderful! Every staff member was fantastic and every drink and plate was delicious! Marianne was an absolute dream couldn't have asked..."
Sabrina Valle
"Unbelievable atmosphere and authentic food. Went there for New Year's Eve and the service and food were amazing. Small and quaint atmosphere with a..."
Ken Kohler
"Needless to say wonderful ambiance, the menu is lush with great choices, service is pleasant and professional. Dog friendly but only for lunch...."
Barry Downs (FABS)
"Had dinner on Friday night that met all of my expectations and more.
The food was fantastic. We were a party of eight and have some picky eaters,..."
Laura Paro
"Love the staff, George the barte der is spot on, quick & eficiente. Ania the Manager was so accommodating, & outside patio with heat lamps!!! The..."
John Diamond
"Excellent Italian food, great menu, and service is outstanding..."
Jillian Phillips
"This is some of the best Italian food I’ve had, period. I’ve been here like 4 times. I like the rigatoni with vodka sauce and sausage as well as..."
Christopher R Roth
"Food was really good. Service was pretty good. Outdoor patio section was great - with heating lamps that worked. The only drawback from a 5 star..."
Brett Goffin
"Very fun little place with a friendly staff. Music plays while you dine. The food is very, very good. I recommend the tuna tartare with flatbread...."
tomnoddy1
"This cozy, divine restaurant tucked away on the waterfront is absolutely adorable. This ambiance of this restaurant is perfect. Outside is a cozy..."
mybeneteau brian
"So wonderful. Our waiter was fabulous. So on top of everything. We sat outside and the heaters provided the perfect temperature. And last but not..."
marianna belz
"Fantastic environment, lights, heater, staff and the fish was as good as it meant to be. Fresh and healthy with spinach. Pricy but at least the fish..."
"We had a quick meal at the bar during the film festival. Our waiter was efficient and super nice. Garlic bread/balls were fantastic. Very reasonable..."
Y O
"I dropped my husband at the door to check-in to go park our car since there were no available handicap parking spaces and the restaurant is in a very..."
Cara Moore
"Delicious food! My husband enjoyed the Salmon salad and he is very picky. My seafood was delicious and I got enough portions of the shrimp, clams,..."
Pahola Tene
"We had a great time at the bar for dinner! Atmosphere and service were amazing. The food was very tasty as well. Whatever they put on that garlic..."
amanda bonfanti
"The bread was incredible, it’s not usually the highlight of my meal but last night it was. The eggplant parm was top notch as well as the little..."
Jordan Glick
"Great experience here just last night. Cozy restaurant, excellent food and service. Had requisite garlic rolls, bottle of wine and entree was..."
James Devine
"Cappuccino has been around forever, and there is a reason. The food is delicious. The garlic knots are to die for. A little taste of classic Sag..."
Stacey Brown
"The garlic rolls are addictive, I had 3!! The split pea soup, yum but the codfish special was ok, great piece of fish, not knocking that but it was..."
The Mid Life Traveler Lexie Lee
"Had a great dinner here, from the garlic knots to the burrata to the fettuccine Alfredo. Have to take off a star, though, since even with a..."
Melissa O'Connor
"A Sag Harbor stalwart. Always a favorite for residents and visitors. I have always enjoyed going. The garlic knots alone are worth the visit. Prices..."
Rich Bernstein
"The bread was EVERYTHING, the salmon was juicy and the sauce on top was fire! The 2 veges they could've kept and the zucchini was undercooked 😒..."
C'mecca Campbell
"If you're looking for a restaurant with amazing garlic bread, II Capuccino should definitely be on your list. The garlic bread here is simply..."
Summer Yale
"There's literally nothing bad on the menu. Everything is delicious and the atmosphere is amazing. Nothing compares to how good the garlic knots are...."
Ryan Davidson
"outstanding food. just wish there were more vegetarian pastas and..."
Will Edwards
"Nice Italian restaurant with very good food and service. They do take..."
"We were in Sag Harbor on a moderately cold March afternoon and walked by this place which was yet to open at around 3 pm. After getting a drink from..."
Ameya Bhakay
"My favorite restaurant in all of the Hamptons. Excellent restaurant all around. The food is incredible especially the spaghetti “scarpariello”...."
Gina
"Great Italian Restaurant in Sag Harbor.. Tutto il Giorno offers indoor and outdoor dining. The restaurant has a nautical theme. and a boutique. We..."
Rosario S. Cassata (Batman)
"There is no other restaurant in the Hamptons as reliable and consistent as Tutto Il Giorno, Sag Harbor. From the food, to the wine, to the service,..."
Jennifer Silvestri
"It is a wonderful dining space, with knowledgeable affable staff. The food was on time and perfectly prepared. The Cioppino was very good but the..."
David Mangiameli
"Best restaurant in Sag Harbor. The chef Agostino is just amazing! Fresh tasteful ingredients prepared to perfection are the..."
Grace Garcia
"Thank you for an absolutely magical experience again! Amazing all around, and we were a party of 8, on a gorgeous Saturday night....service was..."
Leon Katselnik
"What a wonderful place to dine. Each room and area is impeccably decorated. The staff are efficientl and pleasant. Can't wait to..."
Harper Voyages
"Are you really in the Hamptons if you don't get Tutto il Giorno?! Definitely the spot to go if you want a delicious filling meal. I honestly had this..."
Gloria Lau
"Most delicious food from Naples is not far away, chef Agostino and the tutto il giorno team will take you there with an unparalleled hospitality!..."
Peter Young
"This was easily the best pasta we’ve had in the Hamptons (and maybe ever!). We got the mushroom/spinach fettuccine special and the rigatoni. It’s..."
Kaylynn Gunzy
"I’ll start with the positives: the food is spectacular- the tricolore, rigatoni and bolognese are a must
Moving on to the negatives: the cocktails..."
"Okay okay...We've been a sleep on Sag Pizza and regret ever overlooking this gem.
Adorable inside and the outdoor seating area was lovely the night..."
Michael Godley
"We ordered the #1 San Marzano, #2 Soppressata and #9 the Vongole. We all agreed that the Soppressata was the best. The Vongole would have been my..."
Kelly M. Mueller
"The brick oven pizza is the best in the area by far. Dough is italian..they must have the ingredients to make it so authentic. They crank them out..."
Martin Kelly
"Easy place to eat especially with a large group. Food was good and prices..."
Connie Sarvanandan Toronto Realtor
"Sag Pizza was a great place! The only thing I would warn people about is that they are not known for their full-size pies as their main dishes are..."
Alden Sykora
"Came in on a late friday afternoon for a pie. Pretty tasty and only waited around 7 to 8 mins for the pie to arrive piping..."
Jean Ng
"The restaurant has a very cool personality. The pizza was burnt on the bottom and edges but still edible and tasty. Potential customers are required..."
Whatsa MyName
"so i be slitherin my way down this road and this African American guy named Tyrone now says to me “broski come down here and I’ll give you some..."
EmojiFtw
"The new Sag Pizza is great. We had several pies that were quite good and the outdoor setting was very pleasant on a nice summer day. The pepperoni..."
Traveling the World
"I had high expectations for this pizza, especially since they used a wood fire stove. The crust was crispy and bubbly, but I was disappointed in the..."
Markey Pappalardo
"I've never dined in but have always grabbed slices to go. The closest to a NY slice of pizza one can find in Sag Habor. Pizza always had a crispy..."
Tony del pino
"Best pizza spot in town - wood fire pizza that tastes great. Pretty busy during lunch but there us usually a couple of spot at the bar where you can..."
Stuart Smith
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes