Best Sandwiches in Sag Harbor

9 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cappelletti's
Cappelletti's
90/100 (366 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Shrimp
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Lobster Roll
Focaccia
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Reservations
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Our server Carla was AWESOME from beginning to end.. We arrived around 2:30pm on Sunday, 11/04/23 & we weren't sure if we were going to stay since we..."
Henry Bradley III
"Great italian restaurant in Sag Harbor. We had a take out on the weekend - the place was busy with a well stocked bar. The staff/manager was..."
Sa Sh
"Excellent food and super service We were delighted with our choices. Had a honey calamari for starters super and we shared it between four. My..."
Gerry Sinnott
"It's a mix of a place, with a bright fluorescent lit front for takeout and a nice setting by the bar. If the front was made less "pizza pickup" the..."
David Fischer
"This is the second time that I’ve gone here .. they did not disappoint! I had a specially made sandwich of grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella,..."
Joanne Jarvis
"Amazing Italian restaurant! The food and staff were wonderful. The portion size is great. I had a tough time finishing my half-plate order of pasta...."
Taylor Royal
"Been here twice. Once to dine in and once for take out. Service is excellent and great little spot with good food. 💝 The manager/server/owner...."
bex de
"My first real lobster roll... tons of meat and awesome fries! Hubert's lemonade was..."
Wendy Base
"Excellent restaurant I like it, it has a very calm..."
Venancio Dubon
"Wow! This is the best Italian food I’ve had on Long Island! Everything we ordered reminded me of the meals my Italian great aunts and my..."
Dina R.
"New Years Eve…… we placed a takeout order. My husband picked up the order, take out area was very busy. The young lady wished my husband happy..."
Carol DeGregorio
"EXCELLENT FOOD!! It’s a very casual and fairly priced restaurant. First of all, the food is just great, please try the homemade lasagna and the..."
Dr77 777
"The waitress was exceptional. Friendly and efficient, anticipating our every need. The food was scrumptious. The calamari were among the best I have..."
Sayre Swarztrauber
"It's a friendly place with a friendly vibe. As well as good food with generous servings. In the heart of the Hamptons but not of the Hamptons--if..."
Lorraine Dusky
"Great food with great people 👌 👍 😀 ill never forget it..."
D&K RECK (LIVE FREE OR DIE)
"The time has come. After eating a thousand amazing dinners, lunches, desserts…I need to step up and write a review. People…this is one of last..."
Charles Forthofer
"Reasonably priced menu especially for the Hamptons...surprised by the huge focaccia sandwiches, absolutely..."
A.H Shehadeh
Dock House
Dock House
86/100 (484 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Soups
Seafood
American
Soups
Seafood
American
Lunch
Dinner
Tacos
Fried Soft Shell Crab
Fried Clams
Sandwiches
Fish & Chips
Clams
Shrimp
Fried Shrimp
BLT
Lobster
Panini
Shrimp Tacos
Waffle Fries
Salad
Lobster Roll
Oysters on the Half Shell
Fish
Clam Chowder
Fried Fishermans Net Flounder Shrimp Scallops
Fresh Seafood
Lobster Roll Market Price
Crab cakes
Crab
Hot or Cold Cracked 1 1 4 lb Lobster Market Price
Scallops
Swordfish Sandwich and Waffle Fries
Grilled Tuna or Salad
Clams
Flounder Fillet Baguette
Oyster
Lobster Bisque
Tuna
Fried Clam Strips
Lobster Roll
Tapas
Grilled Salmon Salad
Fish Taco
Fried Scallops
Soups
Seafood
American
Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Really really good NE clam chowder, especially after a long day of being outside. One bowl ran me about $9.75 +tax. The food came very fast. Very..."
Victoria Bayevskiy
"This hole in the wall seafood spot in Sag Harbor offers delicious lobster rolls, classic, bisque. Take it to go and grab a seat at the picnic tables..."
Roxanna Castillo
"Had lunch here, food was fresh. The lobster roll was good, a little pricey but what isn't in this area? New England clam chowder and lobster bisque..."
Daniel Antoniazzi
"Incredible casual dockside location with accommodating staff, great service and delicious and not overproced food. The only reason for 4 stars for..."
Marie De
"Excellent kitchen staff; they get my food exactly how I want it every time. Had dinner from them several times and have never been disappointed...."
Maximillian Ward Osborn
"Tiny place with big character and flavor. Staff could have been more friendly. Order your meal, then find a seat. Choose between a few inside or a..."
Colleen LaRock
"Lobster roll was good but expensive. The crab cakes were good, but not fantastic. Lobster bisque was disappointing. The soup itself is fine but only..."
Matthew Tsou
"Fairly priced classic seafood shack. Both clam chowders were excellent. Steamers were ok although would like be better eaten there. Salad with..."
Roger Merel
"Average-tasting food for sky-high prices. Paid $42.10 for 1/4 pound of lobster salad and one fried soft shell crab. I get a better deal at the..."
Gail Melisa
"Great stop for a bite to go! REALLY liked the way they charr the skin fat on the salmon, however the charr on the burger was overpowering. Would go..."
#SmartHomeSecurityNY
The American Hotel
The American Hotel
86/100 (644 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Dinner
Oyster
Tuna
Salmon
Sandwiches
Burger
Crab Cake
Lamb chops
Shrimp
BLT
Porterhouse Steak
Bananas Foster
Lobster
Lamb
Fish
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Clams
Duck
Sit down
American
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Reservations
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Fine Dining
Jimmy Jims Deli
Jimmy Jims Deli
85/100 (151 ratings)
Restaurants
Mexican
Deli
Deli
Mexican
Breakfast
Lunch
Sandwiches
Fast food
Mexican
Deli
Breakfast
Lunch
"In Sag Harbor, I usually like to go here if I want a bagel sandwich. They give you simple, solid food, that really doesn't have anything mind..."
Enzo Esteruelas
"Not my favorite but I like this..."
Hilario Alvarez
"Quality sandwich every single time. At other south fork delis you might get that motivated employee who does good, or you might get a ball of..."
Joshua Tyte
"Very good sandwiches. Diverse and interesting menu. Everything we ordered was excellent and prepared quickly. Prices are quite reasonable as well...."
Tony Badalamenti
"The bacon,egg and cheese sandwich on a roll with a hot coffee is the perfect way to start you day! Also please try the smoothies! I would have a..."
Wil Lyles
"Smoothies & açaí bowls are fresh made on the go !!..."
Gabe Geovanny
"Legit best sandwich in the Hamptons - #36 w Bacon. Not your average..."
Will Shapiro
"Best Acai Bowls I’ve ever..."
Michael Arocho
"I come to the hamptons every summer and Jimmy Jims is by far one of my favorite spots. Great food, greats service and friendly..."
John Moran
"Delicious food, quick and efficient service and friendly staff :) Inexpensive prices..."
E. M.
"This is my new go to place for food and drinks. Wing night is..."
Jason Volini
"Best Acai Bowls around. Our office gets them daily. truly the..."
Cynthia Capalbo
"Food is good and prices are fair. Will stop in more..."
Kevin Lucas
"Nice small deli with good coffee and great home baked..."
John Edvardsen
"Great food...original...sweet cream bear claws are..."
NY 360 East
"Love the steak Burrito Bowls my..."
Luke Rogers
Corner Bar
Corner Bar
85/100 (700 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Chili
Crab
Clams
Sandwiches
Fish & chips
Mussels
Burger
Hamburgers
Crab Cake
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Shrimp
French Fries
Beef
Fish
Lobster
Salad
Clam Chowder
Sit down
Bar
American
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Takeout
Television
Lunch
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"Loved this place. Has a locals feel yet updated and hip like you would find in your NYC neighborhood. Can't beat their chili ..mmm! And oddly, I..."
Whatsa MyName
"For bar food this place is great. The spinach salad was delicious (we added chicken and feta) and the bar burger hit the spot. If you’re looking..."
Jaclyn O'Day
"Small casual place to eat with great service and big, delicious hamburgers. We also ordered a lobster roll without the bun. Nice size portion of..."
Carol Cooper
"Casual eatery and bar with good burgers. It’s a great spot for beers and appetizers and usually has space for a party of 4-5 even on a weekend..."
Jay Lankau
"Love this place when everything in sag is feeling way too pretentious. Probably the most down to earth restaurant in town (aside from buddha berry of..."
Jack Clayton
"My husband ordered the burger and I ordered the cajun chicken salad. Both were good. The balsamic vinaigrette was excellent. The entire restaurant..."
Julie Sparkman
"Restaurant bar to go alone or accompanied, good..."
Jonathan Reyes
"The steamed mussels in garlic and white wine broth are DELICIOUS! Their fries are also really..."
Lara Jansen
"Preface: We literally came here from Manhattan to hang at this bar for 3 hours. Tucked (conveniently) in the far corner of Sag Harbor at the end of..."
Aaron Platts
"Great food. Everything was delicious and satisfying. Very friendly staff. One of our favorites for many..."
Maureen Frances
"Great nachos and beer in a cozy location near the..."
T.R. Ellis
"Great local bar and restaurant! French onion soup is top notch! Good food and some of the more affordable prices you can find in..."
Robert Havey
"Food is phenomenal and great staff and I've been going there since I was 11 and I always see alot of people I know. I lived in Sag for a good portion..."
Bryan Rizzo
"Best fish and chips I have ever had! Super flavorful beer batter and delicious tartar sauce. My dad loved the Reuben. Absolutely recommend this..."
connie anderson
"Stopped in for lunch on the way to Shelter Island. Had the Corner Bar Burger. It was excellent and cooked to just the way I wanted. Was greeted as..."
Ray Roc
"Best place to eat n drink in town. The original small town feel. Great staff food always great. Drinks FANTASTIC.Everone there treats you like old..."
leslie cafiso
Bagel Buoy
Bagel Buoy
82/100 (259 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Sandwiches
Burger
Ribs
Bagels
American
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"fantastic bagels, and their egg sandwiches are among the best. the place is expensive for a bagel store..."
Jeff
"Excellent homemade bagels, really good, decent sized egg sandwiches, and some healthy bagel varieties, such as the pumpernickel everything and the..."
Stuart Hecht
"My favorite place to get a bagel! They also have great wraps and sandwiches if it's later in the day and you need lunch. There is very little seating..."
Ann Marie Blodorn
"The omelet was great. Very busy place so you know it's good. I didn't have a bagel because I can't have wheat but they looked delicious. Only a few..."
Leilani Hammock
"This place is pretty nice, the workplace looks clean enough and the staff is friendly. I was pretty happy with my meal that I ordered, my only..."
Christian Acevedo
"The Bagel Buoy is a traditional bagel shop offering freshly made bagels and prepared foods and sandwiches every day. Try the fresh squeezed orange..."
Christian Haerter
"Love the bagels at the Bagel Buoy. We love being able to order on the phone in advance, so that we don't have such a long wait time in the store...."
Melissa Ann Mitchell, PhD
"I love Bagel Bouy. The food and variety are great, the service is fast, of course depending on foot traffic, but they are very convenient with how..."
Mariah Moskowitz
"This is THE spot to go for bagels in the Hamptons. Be prepared to wait a bit but well worth it. They serve bagels any way you want them and are..."
Charlie Bryan
"A favorite in my family across generations! Amazing breakfast sandwiches (the bacon, egg, and cheese is my go-to) and bagels. The bread here just..."
Jay Lankau
"Delicious Breakfast options. Very little wait time here in the off season, will be longer in the summer cause higher volume of people but still a..."
John Lapczynski
"The smell of fresh baked bagels always draws a crowd. The lines in the summer are well worth the wait...everything's fresh and right out of the..."
The Corcoran Group
"One of the best,"chewy" bagels that I have had! Bonus! Was sitting at front window and Christie Brinkley walked by on an errand next door.(still as..."
Rick “RickyMoe” Moessner
"Fantastic breakfast sandwiches. Can't speak to other things, because I have only tried the breakfast sandwiches, but I hear great things and..."
Cord Tocci
"Highly recommended for bagels and breakfast sandwiches. I love their different variations of everything bagels - egg everything, spinach everything,..."
Anna Dunworth
"Best Bagels! Always fresh. Light and airy with crisp chewy..."
Loureen Finnie
"Good, inexpensive, loved my spinach everything bagel, but super..."
Amelia Harris
Page At 63 Main
Page At 63 Main
81/100 (2615 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Lunch
Dinner
Steamed P E I Mussels Meunier
Risotto
BLT
Smoked Turkey Club
Mussels
Sandwiches
Bolognese
Coconut Layer Cake
Tuna
Burger
Ice Cream
Gelato
Allen Brother's Prime 12oz NY Strip
Calamares
Cheese Burger and Fries
Kale Salad
Skin Charred Farm Raised Salmon
Salmon
Mediterranean Salad
Cakes
Burrata Salad & Turkey Club
Crispy Fried Calamari
Shrimp
Pesto
Lemon Tart
Crab Cake
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Egyptian Spiced Chicken Sandwich
Chowder
Charred Spanish Octopus
Lobster
Lobster Roll
Vanilla Bean Panna Cotta
Pasta
Halibut
Tuna & Artic Char Tartare
Salad
Garganelli Pasta Bolognese
Clam Chowder
Fish
Local Peeko Oysters on the Half Shell
Crab
Pork
Omelette
Baby Arugula Salad
Scallops
Oyster
Bass
Lacinato Kale Salad
Calamari
Octopus
Gemelli Pasta Sausage & Broccoli Rabe
Sit down
American
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Always have the best time at Page Food is the best and so is the wait staff and bartenders. Wilson our waiter was great last night and the food..."
Theresa Reeve Andrew
"Our best meal in Sag Harbor!! Great food, great atmosphere and superb service!! Highly recommend. Do..."
Jo Ann Marzullo- Pepe
"Fabulous food and service! Our server was on spot from drinks to..."
Brenda Fitch English
"Music at bar was chill. Loved it. Bartender was engaging abd friendly. Loved it. The wings on appetizer menu. to die for. Loved it. The burger meat..."
Marcelo Marrero
"Fantastic food, good wine selection, attentive wait staff. One of the best restaurants here on the East..."
Tom Oleszczuk
"Had an outstanding meal with my husband! We will definitely go back here next time we venture to the south fork :) keep up the good work. Main chef..."
Karen Palmer Ormond
"Never had a bad meal here. Not one of the 5 of us was disappointed with our three course price fixe last..."
Jordan Federico
"Great food and friendly service. It was fancy enough for adults to feel like they are somewhere nice and the menu had food that the kids loved as..."
Sara Green
"Delish!! The fish is so fresh and prepared so well. And those veggies in their hydroponic glory really shined. And remember to have a dessert!..."
Robin Riback
"Great food. Fabulous service! Was a really great dining..."
Geri Schuman Lipschitz
"Lunch was great, nice reasonable priced place with great service! Foods good..."
Sarah Kearns Sulzinski
"We had brunch for Mother's Day. All of the food was delicious, the service was great and the ambience in the restaurant is very..."
Jeanne Marrin Stewart
"Lovely restaurant with amazing food & great..."
Bronna Canaan
"Food was phenomenal & the service was superb! This restaurant comes highly recommended by my daughter & I. Menu was generous, which made it hard to..."
Christine Cavanagh
"The food is fresh and delish! Excellent service and wonderful outdoor dining area in the village of Sag Harbor..."
Larry Salovin
"Went for the late seating on New Year's Eve; we had a great meal with friendly and fluid service! The ambience, food, and drinks were perfect. We'll..."
Kal Kel
"Bring back the chopped salad. A bit disappointed about changes in..."
Cynthia Walker
"Excellent food, Great Service. Hope to return..."
Page Barnes
"I loved the Calamari Salad I had tonight. Perfect with a glass of Pinot..."
Jeanine Edington
"Food is good,excellent service. Great atmosphere. Love to be on the..."
Esmin Forrest
"Always a pleasure... I feel like I'm home when I'm at Page!..."
Michelle Niles
"Excellent seafood right in the heart of Sag Harbor's Main..."
Tina Mazze Costa
"The service was excellent & the short ribs were..."
Bari Cohen
"Oysters , Octopus and Mahi mahi oh my. Loved this place by reading the first few menu items on the street, I had found another place but a parking..."
Garrett Nuttall
"I had the most delightful experience at Page 63 restaurant in Sag Harbor, Long Island! Brunch was simply wonderful, and I can't stop raving about..."
William Jacobs
"Great location, decor, and a diverse menu. The bolognese tastes as amazing as it looks. The sangria is not a true sangria though... a few pieces of..."
Dr. Abby
"Cute restaurant! Highly recommend sitting in the back outdoor seating area, was a really nice vibe. Food was just ok, nothing special. Service was..."
Lauren Silverstein
"The food was amazing. Sean, our waiter was very friendly. He made our first-time experience an incredible one...."
Carlesha Ferguson
"Great atmosphere. We opted to take their outside seating though they have a patio seating at the back of the restaurant. Lots of crowds to watch..."
She Rie
"This is a beautiful restaurant in Sag Harbor, New York. Both the indoor space and the outdoor patio are casual yet elegant. The food was excellent..."
Jim Reisman
"I cannot stop thinking about my dinner here a few weeks ago! The bolognese was to die for, oysters were incredible, and the rabbit with carrot..."
Leah Kellenberger
"What a great restaurant! It’s very nice inside and out. We sat out front and the flowers were a really nice touch. Food wise, the tuna tartare is..."
Danny Chong
"Happened upon Page at 63 Main while visiting Sag Harbor and looking for a special place for our anniversary. The menu and atmosphere seemed like a..."
Kevin Simms
Cromer's Country Market
Cromer's Country Market
81/100 (407 ratings)
Specialty Food Market
Deli
Deli
American
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Salad
Sit down
American
Deli
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"A nice market for necessities. Their meat is very good as are their baked goods. The store, while not large, is well stocked, organized and clean...."
R Mac
"Convenient small grocer nestled in a residential area close to Long Beach, Noyak, and Sag Harbor. Fresh produce, good deli counter with prepared..."
Jacqueline Vita
"Great place. A long time institution out here. Been coming here for 40 years. Outstanding Butcher (best out here) that supplies many of the better..."
J M
"I stopped in as they were closing for some ice cream and they stayed until I made my purchase. Very nice..."
Rich Tucci
"Best kielbasa ever...do t miss..."
Judith Grimaldi
"Everything looked good!!! Good roast beef and rare!! Rotisserie chicken super. Everything we bought was excellent!! All employees in all departments..."
Lorrie Mitchell
"I've been here many times, and it never fails to please. The meat that they sell here is great, I've grilled countless burgers, steaks, and kielbasa..."
Enzo Esteruelas
"Great little store that can fill your big stomach with quality foods and refreshments. Great coffee :) Has good kombucha..."
Jason Elmer
"Had a few surprise guests show up for the weekend . What better way to show our hospitality, then rib eye steaks? Cromer’s butchers carved some..."
B. Fish
"Omg this place always has the best sausage egg and cheese is the cheapest around town that you can find! Even their sandwiches are amazing and again..."
Kerry m
"Expensive but they do make great food and sandwiches. But they are also the only market like that for a long while. So the extra couples dollars..."
Jonathan Curtis
"We buy all of our holiday foods at Cromer’s. there is nothing that compares on the East End. It’s nearly an hour drive from our home, and worth..."
Jonathan Yellen
"This is a small market with a deli and butcher. They have fresh produce and your usual essentials like dairy, meat, dry goods and some extra stuff...."
Beatriz Santiago
"Great Thanksgiving day and every day of the year. Their Meat Dept. is phenomenal, helping customers and restaurants in the area get the best cut..."
Salvatore Lantiere
Lt Burger
Lt Burger
77/100 (839 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Bar
American
American
Lunch
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
BLT
Fried pickles
Sandwiches
Waffle Fries
Burger
Veggie Burger
Hamburgers
Turkey Burger
Beef
Salad
Wings
Clam Chowder
Chili
Tuna
Chowder
Sit down
American
Bar
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Drinks
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The Margaritas are great, a lot options in flavors. The pork belly tacos are my favorite, the corn tortillas are made there,the salsas and chips are..."
Xavier Sata
"Delicious food they currently have Bay Scallops! The service was excellent and really enjoyed the interaction with the..."
Adam Bundy
"TL;DR: Tiny tacos, big prices, great drinks and vibe. I was tempted to give this place three stars, but the decoration and vibe pushed it to four..."
Quentin Hodges
"Delicious tacos! Salsa and guacamole are also very good. Love the street corn and spicy cucumbers. The churros are also delicious. Service was great...."
Michelle Madonna
"The food here is killer. Burgers, shakes, sides all great. Chicken sandwich with smoked Gouda was awesome! 7/11/22 just had another great burger at..."
Jeffery Hyde
"Nice decoration and good selection of burgers and desserts. The place is very nicely decorated in a white tiles, post industrial fans and lamp and a..."
philippe gabulon
"Their Burger and everything was 5 stars, but the hostess (or the owner) was rude enough to not even try to help us when we asked them if we could..."
Rana Ece Ertem
"Delicious food, solid veg/vegan options, nice staff, we’ll prices for quality and portions, great covid protocols. Would love to come back next..."
Sarah G P
"Food was very tasty — got the fried pickles and beyond burger (slightly modified to have a real bun and dairy cheese). Taking off a star since we..."
Melissa O'Connor
"LT Burger is the best place to stop have a yummy breakfast or brunch. The staff are friendly and efficient. Definitely try the..."
Nicole Constant
"The food was delicious & fresh The place is nice & clean Jessica, our waitress, was so pleasant & very informative *** A little pricey for..."
Theresa Gibbs
"Service was very slow, had to ask for a waiter, for my food then for my bill. The food was delicious..."
A A
"So glad I ran into this place. Delicious burgers and shakes. Great selection of beer. Lovely view of the harbor right up the road. Ingredients were..."
George Jimenez
"Good burgers and also great for breakfast - the French toast almost gave me a heart attack - in a good way. Nice styling all around. Gets very busy..."
Jonathan Heawood