This pizza place was definitely interesting. It’s a whole vibe inside!
The pull apart was the all around favorite! The pizzas were all extremely cheesy. Sauce tasted great. We didn’t get to try the dessert pizzas because they forgot to put them in & after we waited 20 minutes, we got a refund.
My one, and biggest, complaint is that the seating area is not really made for large parties- which there were so many when we went! We had to shove several tables together for our party of 11 people. We were also surrounded by others having to do the same so we were pretty tightly shoved in one corner of the restaurant.
Fun to walk down this place, kind of a hidden feel (hence the "underground" . This is around the corner from the other Pie that you can get takeout from. Loved the vibe, fun decor that you can add. We got gluten free pizza and cheese sticks. They were alright, gluten free crust isn't always great but I was still mid about this one. Overall pretty great meetup spot for a group though.
Pizza is so cheesy and good. Great garlic and cheese bread. Love the salads, they're always crisp & green as they should be.
They have a monster size is your have a large group. There open late, evident is good if you're a late night eats person . Parking is not always great, but it's all worth going. The atmosphere and vibe is fun, lots of college kids since it's on campus. You can go and be loud, and enjoy the vibe while you eat. Being your marker so you can write on their walls 🧱.
What a cool concept! Atmosphere is great, pizza off the hook! My son had the 12 inch meat monster, I had the 12 inch cheese thin crust and cheesy pull apart we shared. Yum!!
The location itself adds to the overall charm of the experience. Descending into the underground setting feels like entering a secret pizza lair. It's cozy and intimate, with dim lighting and brick walls giving it a rustic, old-school vibe. I loved the underground atmosphere—it's definitely a departure from your typical pizza joint.
Great pizza! Nothing too fancy and full of flavor. Crust is super good too! Great vibes inside, food takes a while to come out but its overall a good time and worth the wait.
Perfect pizza and beer spot. Cheap beer and good pull aparts and pizza. Glad they use washable plates and cups and the beer selection is decent
Amazing menu! Fast service, very sweet staff.
Was a little concerned that the women’s room had no soap. I offered to change it myself since they were moderately busy, but an hour went by and no soap was replaced. There was handsantizer so survivable.
We also needed to unfortunately to send back my friend’s gf pull apart bread because the garlic was so burned that the bitterness rendered it inedible. Hate sending things back but it was big money and they were going to not east anything if we didn’t. Recommend asking for no garlic on gf stuff to avoid this issue. The staff remade the order no problem.
Loved my pizza and pull apart bread.
This place was freaking DELICIOUS. Hands down this was the best pizza I have had in years. The flavors were phenomenal and my buddies agreed that it was an experience straight out of heaven. The underground aspect is super cool; the place is dimly lit and has the coolest vibes. The walls are covered in writing and oldie pictures. Overall this place absolutely blew my mind. I cannot describe how awesome it was.
Great pizza place. You order at the counter and they call you to collect when it's ready. They do bring the beer to the table though. $3.99 beers are good value too! Seating is comfortable in a dive styled setting. Worth a visit if you are by the university in Salt Lake City.
Love it! We tried 2 different locations and 2 different pizza . This location was much better than the other one. We loved “The Greek” pizza. Highly recommended
Best pizza in SLC. Very cool atmosphere as well. Staff is awesome.
The classic original. Nothing else comes close.
I've been coming here since the mid 80's,my name is on the wall in various locations, now buried under decades of white out and sharpie.
The Pie never let's me down. This last time I took my 15 year old daughter, it was time she experienced the joy that can be found in a basement underneath a pharmacy.
My meat Zappi was perfection. The crust, cheese and pepperoni combine to replicate the special magic that only the Pie can create. And it still tastes exactly as I remember.
Had the Spicy Thai Pasta and friends all got different pizzas. Everything was very good. Great portion sizes, quality ingredients, and lots of fun options.
You order as you walk in which is in a tiny hallway and it was kinda awkward as people were trying to leave. They call your name and you pick up at the window so not a lot of 'service' to rate. However there is only one way to order so if you forget to order a side of ranch you have to wait in line again. Which isn't convenient.
I'm not a fan of the underground speakeasy feel, but I get others are.
Not wheelchair accessible as it is at the bottom of a staircase.
The pizza we had was great but wasn't cut well. Lost 90% of the toppings off my first slice, went back up to get it cut and was met with a bit of attitude from the cook. Not a big deal but for $40 I was a little disappointed that they couldn't even get it right the first time. Would still recommend it though because the food was worth it.
First time back to this location for 30 years. Pizza is good not great but the vibes are still amazing. Service is meh like most places underpaying their staff and hiring teenagers. Wings are actually delicious. In the 10 start scale it’s an 8.5.
Great pizza, during the weekdays get it by the slice around lunch time. I don't visit this location often, but it probably has the most character. Navigating to this location by Google maps will not get you here. It will take you to the pick-up & delivery location about a block away. We just let them know we were going to walk to the underground dine in spot and they were okay with us leaving the car there.
Was told this was Utah Pizza!!! Man they didn't disappoint!!!! One of the best Pizzas I have ever had!!! Awesome atmosphere and cool entry.... Underground Place so cool.... Very glad was recommended to us!!!
This is a cool place.. Guy at the front that took our order was very friendly and helpful. Pizza was pretty good not amazing. Very filling crust. I do recommend.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes