Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza in Salt Lake City

2 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
The Pie Pizzeria - Underground
The Pie Pizzeria - Underground
89/100 (4902 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Bar
Vegan Options
Pizza
Dining bars
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Meat & Veggie Toppings
Veggie Extreme
Mountain of Meat Pizza
Pesto
12 in Meat Monster Pizza
Greek pizza
Bacon Berry Pie
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Custom Pie
Root Beer
Cheese Zappi with Added Bacon & Sausage
Hawaiian Pizza
Cheese Zappi with Bacon
Slice of Pizza
Pasta
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Salad
Chef Salad
Wings
Great Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Cheese Pull-A-Part
BBQ Chicken Cilantro
The Thai Pie
Sit down
Bar
Pizza
Italian
Dining bars
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Street Parking
Gift Cards Available
Live Music
Free off-street parking
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"This pizza place was definitely interesting. It’s a whole vibe inside! The pull apart was the all around favorite! The pizzas were all extremely..."
Mariana Carmichael
"Fun to walk down this place, kind of a hidden feel (hence the "underground" . This is around the corner from the other Pie that you can get takeout..."
Lindsey Ballard
"Pizza is so cheesy and good. Great garlic and cheese bread. Love the salads, they're always crisp & green as they should be. They have a monster..."
Trisha Alarid
"What a cool concept! Atmosphere is great, pizza off the hook! My son had the 12 inch meat monster, I had the 12 inch cheese thin crust and cheesy..."
lucy hochevar
"The location itself adds to the overall charm of the experience. Descending into the underground setting feels like entering a secret pizza lair...."
David Griffinf
"Great pizza! Nothing too fancy and full of flavor. Crust is super good too! Great vibes inside, food takes a while to come out but its overall a good..."
Daniela Reyes
"Perfect pizza and beer spot. Cheap beer and good pull aparts and pizza. Glad they use washable plates and cups and the beer selection is..."
Jon Schwindt
"Amazing menu! Fast service, very sweet staff. Was a little concerned that the women’s room had no soap. I offered to change it myself since they..."
Sarah Jochum
"This place was freaking DELICIOUS. Hands down this was the best pizza I have had in years. The flavors were phenomenal and my buddies agreed that it..."
Benson Lee
"Great pizza place. You order at the counter and they call you to collect when it's ready. They do bring the beer to the table though. $3.99 beers are..."
Daniel Harris
"Love it! We tried 2 different locations and 2 different pizza . This location was much better than the other one. We loved “The Greek” pizza...."
Elçin Koyuncu
"Best pizza in SLC. Very cool atmosphere as well. Staff is..."
Cooper Willoughby
"The classic original. Nothing else comes close. I've been coming here since the mid 80's,my name is on the wall in various locations, now buried..."
M Weston
"Had the Spicy Thai Pasta and friends all got different pizzas. Everything was very good. Great portion sizes, quality ingredients, and lots of fun..."
Taia Joy Flake
"The pizza we had was great but wasn't cut well. Lost 90% of the toppings off my first slice, went back up to get it cut and was met with a bit of..."
Joshua M.
"First time back to this location for 30 years. Pizza is good not great but the vibes are still amazing. Service is meh like most places underpaying..."
Dan Benshoff
"Great pizza, during the weekdays get it by the slice around lunch time. I don't visit this location often, but it probably has the most character...."
Jared Jones
"Was told this was Utah Pizza!!! Man they didn't disappoint!!!! One of the best Pizzas I have ever had!!! Awesome atmosphere and cool entry......."
George Flores
"This is a cool place.. Guy at the front that took our order was very friendly and helpful. Pizza was pretty good not amazing. Very filling crust. I..."
Sterling Montierth
Wild Pepper Pizza
Wild Pepper Pizza
76/100 (9582 ratings)
Restaurants
Pepperoni Pizza
Spicy wings
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Lemon Pepper
Bread Sticks
Garlic Cheese Bread
Chicken Wings
French Fries
Pepperoni Hawaiian Pizza Super Supreme
Halal Pizza
"I liked the pizza so much they have pepperoni and beef “halal” and I liked cheesy bread with garlic and the fries and wedges are very good, the..."
Mariam El Mougy
"We're so glad that we stopped in for some delicious pizza. The people were so friendly and really cared about making good food that people will like..."
Melissa Mahan Lindbloom
"I've been eating here since it 1st Opened 4 months ago but I've been working here for 3 months. I've made good friends and met some cool Customers..."
ShaMikey Helm
"Friendly staff working hard to make good food, what more can you ask for? Good prices and interesting choices made for a great lunch! It's businesses..."
Andrew D. Lindbloom
"Wild pepper always has the best pizza and the nicest employees. All for a fair price too, with halal options. The owners help support the local music..."
Local Guide
"Nice little drunkies/ munchies food vibe! Pizza mozzarella sticks, wings all that!! Tastes good and on top of it I went to get some with my friend..."
fun bun Funbun
"Since moving to the area about a month ago, Wild Pepper Pizza has become our go-to restaurant for pizza. Not only are the popular and most common..."
Tyler Smith
"This was our second time at Wild Pepper Pizza. They serve Halal meat options and we always stopover eith friends whenever we are visiting Salt Lake..."
Tahira Najm
"I put 3 stars for atmosphere simply because I haven't been in the actual location. Everything else, I firmly attest to it's goodness. I'm from NYC..."
Andy Nick
"Placed an order online, and it wasn't ready. But what a treat it was to sit in here and wait while they made it fresh. The owner is oldschool and..."
Ian Dae
"This place is very slept on. I’ve always avoided it because the outside of the building isn’t very pleasing but once I gave it a try it’s the..."
Cheerio maria
"Pizza was cooked to perfection. Seriously some of the best pizza I have had in a while. We got the bbq chicken, butter curry and pepperoni. Bbq was..."
Abby Marsing
"Good pizza for a good price. Sometimes people are a little grumpy over the phone but if you are patient you get your order correct. I always get the..."
Garrett Wall
"We were visiting Salt Lake and we’re hungry so we decided to order pizza to our hotel. Wild Pepper was delicious! The sauce had good flavor and I..."
April Bergstresser
"Ordered our bachelorette party a large cheese pizza after a night out in downtown SLC. It arrived fast through UberEats even at 2am, and was really..."
Karin M
"Super nice people! The food was great and reasonably priced. I cannot wait to try the halal pepperoni..."
Logan Carstensen
"Loved the pizza because it tastes like it was cooked by someone who knows what they're doing, the service was pretty good as well and the staff was..."
Jimy Mendoza (SaintJimyz)
"Staff was very nice. Pizza tasted way better than it looked. I enjoyed the spicy unique sauce. Crust was thin and very pleasant. A little..."
Mary Werner