The best Restaurants in San Juan Island ranking of April 2025
63 restaurant menus in San Juan Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Delicious food. I ordered the lamb burger medium well & it was Sooo juicy, flavorful I’m actually very upset at myself for not finishing my meal..."
Danielle Aleaha Yorker
"Walked into this place being it had the best reviews... we were greeted and shown to our table where water in a bottle awaited us. We waited for a..."
Noah MacKrille
"Wow, where to start. I got the lamb burger (which was fantastic in every way) but the meatless meatballs in the vegetarian pasta were other-worldly...."
Matt Beauchamp
"2022 Update - This is still one of our favorite restaurants on the island. Due to the pandemic its been a couple years since we could dine here but..."
N Z (Scorpionfury)
"Stopped here for lunch on our whale watching tour. Two of us ordered the soup of the day, which was a seafood bisque that promised to be full of..."
Wendy Murphy
"Fun decor adds to the scrumptious experience we had at Cask & Schooner. We had a seat at the window of the bar which gave us a fantastic view. The..."
C Frantzen
"Had a nice lunch and beer here a week ago. Had chowder and a meat pie. Both were excellent. This is a good place for honest pub food in a genuine..."
William Kleiser
"It’s 4.5 for me. Really great pub food. We had the clam chowder, fish and chips and lamb burger. All really tasty. Conveniently located across from..."
Theasha G
"We stayed at the Hillside House BnB. They recommended Cask to us for dinner. This was an amazing spot with very delicious meals. We have Steak and..."
Tim S
"One of the best gluten-free meals we have had at a restaurant! We ordered the salmon chowder (definitely worth the try!), the shepherds pie, and a..."
"I am only reviewing this place for the ambience and drinks, didn’t really eat anything. I was passing by while walking through OSJ and noticed this..."
sachin rathi
"Came across this restaurant during San Juan trip. Weather was hot and restaurant had no AC but we decided to have drinks as a short break, so glad we..."
Cat HK
"Traveled from out of the country to San Juan. This is the best restaurant we visited. They offered exceptional service. It was a group of 10 of us...."
Davidson Productions
"We just experienced this restaurant and I have to say it was wonderful!!! I loved the rustic, almost cave like atmosphere. I can’t say enough..."
Beverly Rivera
"Very laid back intimate place. The food was really good but the service was a little lack luster. They brought out everyone's drinks except for a..."
Maria Fair
"Amazing food and great service. The seafood mofongo is out of this world. Fresh red snapper and the ceviche was very refreshing. Definitely a place..."
AT S
"Very beautiful place!! Walked in and was seated immediately, very calm/peaceful with nice music in the background. Highly recommend the seafood soup..."
Mindy Ramirez
"The food was good but what made our experience the best was our waitress. She was very patient in letting me attempt to order in spanish, helped me..."
Jessica Weirich
"The food was good overall. The staff was friendly and the place had a good vibe. The decor was rustic and..."
S C
"Nice food. Meet was little bit gristly - chewy. Prices are higher than..."
Dacho Pg
"Absolutely amazing here all around. The staff were all friendly, the food was amazing, and the drinks were perfect! I dined in a lot of different..."
Kyle Lawson
"TOP RESTAURANT THAT I HAVE VISITED IN 23 YEARS. AND IM ALSO A RESTAURANT FREAK. THEY HAVE A GREATT AND AMAZING SERVICE, THE FOOD DOES NOT TAKE LONG..."
Linda Jenner
"Came here for a nice dinner and loved it! I had the lobster risotto, husband had a grilled pork chop. We were seated right away at 7pm, it wasn't too..."
Gina Femia
"Delicious food and drinks! Staff was incredibly kind and patient. The interior is absolutely breathtaking. I go here every time I go to Old San Juan,..."
Lorene Pereira
"Absolutely perfect. The food and drinks were awesome. The service was outstanding. Beautiful seating areas with a masculine feel; cement and wood..."
LaVerne Madigan
"We started with the fried calamari as an appetizer. I had the Seafood Mofongo, wife had the grilled mahi mahi with lemon, and of course a delicious..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes