This was my second time to have their delicious pizza. We wanted to try the lasagna but were sold out, so we had the rigatoni baked pasta with a meatball at extra charge and a regular size Italiano pizza. The serving of the rigatoni was generous and came out hot out of the oven. It had just the right amount of melted cheese on top. The pizza soon followed, the crust was crunchy and not soggy. The service was very friendly and prompt. We will definitely come back for the pizza and lasagna!
I've lived in Seattle for 13 years and am just learning about this place?! Where have I been?! This is THE best pizza in Seattle! Super friendly service, great atmosphere (love all the family photos ❤️), beautiful pies. There is a lot of love going into the food and it shows. Can't wait to eat my way through the menu & bring my family and friends for parties!
I believe I just ate the best pizza I've had since I can't remember when... the crust, sauce, cheese and meatball toppings sent me over the moon!
Can't wait to get back there and try the white pizza, stromboli and lasagna etcetera.
I love this place! The little bit of carbon on the crust from the fire and the stretchy-chewy-crisp dough always satisfy my pizza craving.
Friendly service pizza was very large and supremely cheesy I never had Brooklyn style pizza before, but this is very much what I imagined it to be.
Best pizza in Seattle. Hard to find Boren and Madison. Comfortable friendly good service and enormous large size pizza. Good wine and beer. Had the lasagna special. Great for kids.
Will be back regularly.
Great customer service.....amazing pizza. It's the small stuff that counts our waiter was awesome. We got there at 11 am......doors still closed, we were the 1st ones there....around 11:05 AM the entire place was jammed packed!! Oh did I mention the Giant Pizzas!!!!
The margherita pizza was bomb. Fresh outta the oven, great NY style pizza. You know this place is legit if they’re speaking Italian in the back. 😁
Born and raised in Jersey this is the first pizza that tastes like home. The crust is the key. Thin crisp perfection. Huge slices but still foldable. This is an East Coast transplants dream.
The pizza was awesome and our waiter Chris was such a nice guy. Save room for the cheesecake because my mom said it was the best she has ever had.
Awesome pizza. Completely size appropriate for the happy stoners or a REALLY giant seagull! 10/10 would devour again
Amazing pizza!!! Huuuuge pizza! Everyone working there was friendly and the owner had the whole restaurant singing.
This is the best pizza that I've had since moving from NYC!
Exactly what a neighborhood pizza joint should be. Super nice staff, good atmosphere and great pizza
Was on my way from Fish Maarket in seattle going up to my hotel walking in a rainy Day .. This Huge pizza Caught my eye ... and decided to buy one .
Went with two options pizza .. And when I had to take ot over to the Hotel .. I was The media Talk .
Got into my room .. hardly fits the door .. and tfied this tasty pizza .. took me two days to finish it .
This became my Favorate Pizza .. I never stay in seattle without having this pizza on my priorty list
Literally stumbled upon this place and SO HAPPY I DID. Amazing NY STYLE pizza for incredible prices. I was waiting on a friend who had an appointment down the street, and walked past and just had to try a pie. Super quick, made to order, NY pizza. They use the nice little pepperonis that get a bit crispy when cooked, and the dough has the perfect amount of give when you bite in and savor the deliciousness. 10/10 will be back! The service was great and they were super nice when I walked in. Family joint knows how to treat a patron well! The cannoli's looked amazing as well. $11 for a more than 12" pie! WHAT A DEAL! They had real NY accents, so you know its gotta be legit.
Wow. This is great pizza. The sauce is intensely garlicky, but not offensively so. Deliciously so. The pepperoni imparted just the right amount of salt, and the crust was crispy and flavorful. Very close to the unattainable ideal of the "perfect pizza."
![Zomato]( "Recensione")
Largest Pizza I Ever Had. Finally - good pizza in Seattle! We all know how difficult it is to find good pizza here. Well, I went online and read reviews of Italian Family Pizza and just had to try it. It's the best pizza I've ever had in Seattle. It's not perfect (the bottom of the crust doesn't get that nice crispiness). However, it was darn tasty and everything else about it screamed of authentic Italian.. But be warned: They offer 2 sizes only...small (standard 10") and large (so big it wouldn't fit in the passenger portion of my car...had to put it in the trunk!). They say the large is 23", but I really think it's bigger than that. Anyway, if you appreciate good pizza, you must check this place out. It's right by the SAM so parking can be an issue. And if you get the large for carry out and have to walk a couple of blocks to your car (like I did), you'll get plenty of galkers enroute. Also the folks who run the place are super nice. It's very much a family business which is exactly the kind of place I love to support. Also, the sign outside says they have $1.00 Bud drafts. I don't drink so didn't read the fine print (only during certain hours?). Enjoy!
Best pizza in town, hands down. Don't miss it.
Amazing!!! This place offers cheap great food in the busiest dirtrict in Seattle. A 23 inch pie could feed 4 people for 23 bucks. With dollar buds and 4 dollar wine!! Great ny style pizza and great service! This place is a must for quality good pizza and the price is absolutely unbelievable.
Classic pizza & a fun, homey atmosphere. I visited Italian Family Pizza for the first time tonight. I've eaten at literally hundreds of restaurants in Seattle but this place actually stood out to me because of how unapologetically simple and straightforward it is - they serve pizza, beer, salad, and that's about it. The restaurant is red checkered tablecloths with family photos on the walls. I liked the pizza, it was not fancy at all but still incredibly satisfying. I went with a group of 4, we shared a 22" pizza for $11 and had $1 Buds because it was happy hour. The servers are also friendly and attentive. I'd come here again for sure.
The pizza was alright, I've had better slices but the size is definitely a highlight. Got a 23 inch pie and it is definitely a lot of food, enough to feed four people.
We went with a Tomato sauce pizza with olives and anchovies. It really captures the corner parlor taste. Their large is really large. The two of us should have stopped at 50% but could not resist 2 more slices.
I can’t believe the flavor, the size, the service!! AMAZING!! Multiple options to choose from! Our favorite is the New Yoker and the Italiano!! Amazing flavor, melts in your mouth delicious!!
They do one kind or even half and half!
Worth stopping in for sure!!
This place is amazing! The lasagna was delicious, salad was yummy.
The white pie pizza was amazing!! If i could i would give it 10 star's. The servers were amazing. Really nice young gentlemen!
A very solid meal for the family or date night for an incredibly fair price in First Hill! Is it the best pizza in the area? No. I personally thought the sauce needed a little more seasoning, but the dough is hand stretched to order, the staff was incredibly nice, and you can't find a better deal on a 12 inch pie (excluding Domino's). 12/10 would recommend the cannolis and the garlic knots were DIVINE!
Really good pizza. Best New York style pizza in Seattle area, best you'll find besides Brooklyn Bros in Everett. In New York this pizza would get 3 stars, but it's the best you'll find here. Delicious, chewy thin crust, a little greasy (tons of grease on the bottom of the crust though... weird), tomato sauce was good. Pizza char was not done right. Pizza from here is best eaten right away, if you wait longer than 15-20 minutes throw it in the toaster oven for a few minutes at 500 degrees.
Order the large (24"), not the small (12"). It's worth it.
They serve cannoli's, it was on point and so delicious!
Didn't have to wait longer than they estimated but I also ordered my pizza at 3pm on a Monday when they're not busy.
Area is a little sketch. Hard to find free parking. Paid parking lot just behind the restaurant.
Roommate and I went here for lunch. They have two main pizza sizes: a 12 inch one and a 23 inch one. We went for the 23 inch pizza.
The crust was slightly thinner than my personal taste but that doesn't change the fact that the pizza was well proportioned and tasty. We couldn't finish it though so the staff brought us a pizza box so we could take the remaining home. Definitely recommend the 23 inch pizza for a whole family, and the free refills was a plus as well.
Fantastic restaurant. Authentic as it gets. Pizza is obviously great. The sauce is REAL DEAL. As traditional as pizza can be. And you can’t go wrong with their cannoli. Can’t recommend this place enough if you’re in the area.
Great NY style pizza for even better prices! Love the thing crust and perfectly cooked soft but crunchy pepperoni. The owners were very nice and really care about you and your experience.
This is an excellent Italian pizza place. I come to Seattle every few months, and I always make it a point to come here. They really know how to make pizza! Their new location (Madison & Boren) is quite the uphill walk from their previous location downtown, but definitely worth it!
This was the best cheese pie I've ever had! The salad was so fresh. Like, it came straight from the garden. Service was top notch!! Great family business. Thank you, from a Texas resident.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes