Best Pepperoni Pizza in Seattle

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Ballard Pizza Company
Ballard Pizza Company
89/100 (1240 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pepperoni Slice
Spicy Italian Pizza
Pepperoni and Mushroom
Caesar Salad with Anchovies
Veggie Bomb Pizza
1 2 Parma 1 2 the Troll
Dynamite Wings
Whole Hog House Pizza
Mushroom Pizza and Daily Garlic Pizza Slices
1⁄2 Margherita Pizza & 1⁄2 Carbonara
Salad
Chocolate Rice Crispy Treat
Pizza & Beers
Calzone
Dough
Pepperoni Pizza
Great Wine
Salsiccia
Greek salad
Pizza Margherita
cheese pizza
Sit down
Pizza
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The BIG MOSES did not disappoint. Ballard bridge, pepperoni and basil and bird were also delicious. Will come back..."
Ben Johnson
"Delicious pizza in a super fun space. The ambiance is very casual and a lot of fun. The service is attentive and always friendly....and did I say the..."
Mark Fitzsimmons
"Was in the mood for pizza after Sunday’s Ballard farmer’s market. Found this place close by. It was a quite casual pizza place. They have an..."
Sindu
"This restaurant serves amazing pizza and provides very good customer service. The entire pizza was very flavorful to include the crust, and the..."
Derrick Grant
"As someone who isn't the biggest fan of the trend toward "artisan" pizzas, with toppings like arugula and figs and honey, I will say, I really liked..."
Luke L
"Brianna (at the Seattle mariners stadium) was great. I had I minor issue with getting charged too much for my pizza (I was charged for mine and..."
Brandon Faieta
"If you are looking for a restaurant that both delivers in customer service and creativity, Ballard Pizza Company is the place. Nestled on an amazing..."
Inna Te'o
"Great food and the goat curry pizza off the speciality menu was delicious! The owner was fabulous and made sure everything was fixed to perfection...."
Sheba
"Really good simple pizza with awesome decor, red bricks exposed with industrial metal and wood blend. The oven is right there and the service is..."
miniqooper
"Pizza is on the expensive side ($25 for medium, $32 for large) but I'd say it's worth it. Nice crust with high quality toppings. Lots of fun and..."
Trey Harnden
"Pizza slices that are comparable to any pizza parlors that you’ll find in NYC. I should know since I grew up and lived in NYC for the past 45..."
Daniel Au Yeung
Tutta Bella
Tutta Bella
88/100 (2227 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Garlic Knots
Lasagna Napolitana
Beet Salad
Tiramisu
Tiramisú
Lasagne
Cannoli
Ice Cream
Margherita Pizza
Gelato
Burrata Appetizer
Minestrone
Takeout Pizza
Pesto
Roberto Pizza
Neapolitan pizza
Neapolitan Meatballs
caesar salad
Pasta
Marinated Beets
Affogato
Salad
Burrata with Peperonata
Pepperoni Pizza
Neapolitan Lasagna
Pizza Bianca
Spaghetti alle vongole
Filomena's Tiramisù
Artichoke Dip
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Nifty pizzerias come and go in Seattle - as do pizza trends. Thick crust, thin crust, no crust, ingredients only from producers within a 25 mile..."
Jeffrey Lemkin
"It's hard to know where to start with this restaurant's sheer awesomeness. Okay, first, the happy hour, happy whether or not you drink. Delectable..."
Colleen Hinkle
"This is the best pizza I've eaten outside of Italy. Totally authentic. The real thing. I can't wait to go back again. The tiramisu is off the charts..."
Linda Thomas-Carrier
"Lovely atmosphere, before we even ate we knew it was going to be good, place was packed, and our wait staff was fast and accommodating, and......"
Noreen Carlson Sievertson
"It’s always a delight at Tutta Bella...whichever location you go to you can be assured of the same excellent food and service. I like to have one..."
Deanne Jensen Harker
"Great pizza! I have been there 5 or 6 times in the past 3 weeks with my son. Great happy hour also. The wallingford location is great since it is..."
Aaron Ko
"Awesome place. Came from Texas and was shocked at the amazing service and extremely good..."
Larry Boss
"My son took me out to eat here and we had a lovely dinner. Everything was cooked perfectly! The staff were all very nice and helpful too. I can't..."
Georgia Wilder
"Great atmosphere, amazing pizza, great service and wine..."
Jaime Yazzie
"Such a great little place. We are visiting from California and was out on a stroll and happened across it. Awesome food and customer..."
Lanée Jones
"I've been to T B several times. Each time is a new experience and excellent food and service. One of my..."
Donna Hudson
"Love the pizza here. it's my style. Flavorful and light on the toppings. Very much like pizza I've had in Italy. And the jewel box bar is a great..."
Susan Garrett
"Great food. Great people. Great service. Great prices. Live Music too. If you want authentic, go..."
Jim Romano
"Great location and awesome atmosphere. They had a fall special that was a fig pizza. Let me tell you it was great. Crispy fluffy not chewy but melty..."
andy a
"Wow!! Great service, food, and the house wine- so good!! We were well informed of how special this place is and what it serves. We were gifted..."
Ottie S
"Nice pizza spot! Especially liked the pear gelato - it’s so different than other flavors. We had the beets salad, spaghetti and tutta bella pizza -..."
Connie C
"We loved the food. We had a large group and got seated quickly! Prices are good..."
Kristyna Wickline
"Tutta Bella is a date night staple for my partner and I. We both order our own pizzas and have leftovers for the following day. You can expect..."
Andra Tuttle
"Love love love this spot for an elevated pizza dining experience. The restaurant is always buzzing and feels cozy. The outside patio seating on a..."
Michelle Valentino
"Our favorite Neapolitan pizza in Seattle ❤️Tasty, thin, with quality ingredients! Totally..."
Lena Korzhevska
"The food and service was good. I got a Margarita pizza and I thought it tasted very good. If I had to say something bad it would be that it was very..."
Jonah Vimont
"This is our favorite place to go. It’s a bit far from our location but we come here once in awhile. The service is great, the food as well. My..."
Marcel
"Awesome pizza napoletana -- we had tutta bella, the namesake dish. The beet salad with pistachio was marinated -- really good as well. Wine list..."
Ash Roy
"Rainy Easter 2023. My buddy, Shahab and I craved pizza and I should say we picked the spot right on. Ambiance : fantastic, cozy, string lights,..."
M Noamouz
"As soon as we walked in and you see a restaurant packed that's a good sign! It had a good vibe to the place and it was large inside so it's good for..."
Holly
"Amazing food, super service. This place is..."
gülseren ünlüel
"Delicious food, their summer menu was a treat especially their peach salad, and very glad that they still had the Maui fundraiser pizza which was..."
Julia Oishi
Humble Pie
Humble Pie
85/100 (1087 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Bacon Happy Hour
Prosciutto Egg Argula Mozzarella Tomato Sauce
Apple & Walnut
Pulled Pork Pizza
San Pellegrino
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Slice
Mexican Coke
Small House Salad
Happy Hour Margherita
Beer
Pepperoni Pizza
Apple & Spiced Walnuts or Bacon Pizza
Prosciutto Egg Arugula Pizza
Half Roasted Eggplant and Half Soppressata
Pulled Pork Pickled Onoin
Spire Hard Cider
14 Roasted Garlic Pizza
Whole Hog Pizza
Pizza
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Prefer margarita and the apple spiced walnut pies. They are 14 inch pies cut into 6 slices. This place offers tap bear and an amazing dine in..."
Ricky K
"Absolutely an amazing hidden Gem worth the drive and wait. Friendly atmosphere and amazing staff . since I’ve been going here, this has been my go..."
Brandon Stewart
"A lovely place to be. Must eat the Whole Hog pizza and drink the organic prosecco. talk to Chan, Don Rogelio, suseli… the Karen who is not the..."
XiaoMing Gmail
"Love the atmosphere of local community, many families eating there. Love the many vegan/vegetarian options as well. The food is AMAZING!! Never know..."
Dian Dian
"I loved everything about this place. Delicious pizza! Interesting menu! Wonderful, casual, outdoor atmosphere! Friendly..."
Felicia Pullam
"Amazing pizza but suggest to bring it home. We were cold. definitely not a place to find in during the winter. If so wear a warm jacket. But the..."
randy richardson
"Easy to find, Easy to park, Excellent Pie! Nice and friendly staff and our pie was ready in 5 minutes. We ordered the 14” Margarita the crust was a..."
Arien Rarey
"If you're looking for a casual pizza and beer, then this is the place to go. Humble Pie makes pizza with a crispy crust that's on the thinner side..."
Vanessa A
"Nice place with a very friendly staff. I ordered a roasted garlic pizza with chicken and it was quite good. The crust was good and well baked and..."
Binit Banerjee
"First night in Seattle and walked down to this little pizza shop. We ordered the pulled pork pizza, and let me tell you! So good! New York style..."
Brittney Porterfield
"Nice garden location. Easy parking. Pizzas came out fast. Staff was really nice. Very kid friendly with garden and pizza making to look at. Pizzas..."
Caitlin Sadowski
"I don't know what my favorite is. I'm tied between the vegetarian apple walnut and the mushroom with chicken sausage added. In a perfect world they..."
Jeff K
"Great NYC style pizza in the PNW. Had to order take out during COVID times, so the pizza was not as hot and crispy as I would have liked. A little..."
Justin Anderson
"Cute little spot with good wood fire pizza. Happy hour is a great deal. They have a chicken coop and get fresh eggs from there! Outdoor seating..."
Violet Tsuchida
Sopranos Antico
Sopranos Antico
84/100 (1660 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Lunch
Breakfast
Greek Salad Yumm
Pesto and Artichoke Penne
Delivery Wine
Spaghetti Pavia
Gnocchi in House Marinara Sauce
NY Cheesecake Raspberry
Caprese Salad
Spaghetti carbonara
Diavola Pizza
Calzone
Spaghetti Meatballs
caesar salad
Eggplant Parmesan
Salads
Flatbread Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Homemade Tiramisu
Pepperoni Rolls
Garlic bread
Meatballs Marinara
Italian
Pizza
Reservations
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"This is by far the best Italian restaurant I've ever eaten at. This is a must try restaurant. Everything about the meal was amazing !! Cheese bread..."
Matthew Shawman
"We LOVE Sopranos! It’s the best pizza in the area. True Italian style pizza. My 7-year-old son and I have very different pizza styles and we both..."
Taryn Longhurst
"Had a birthday dinner here. The pizza was so good. Crust and toppings cooked perfectly. We also had wings for appetizers...also really good. The..."
Stephanie M.
"I'm the sports nutritionist for a professional soccer team and chose to place a large catering order from Soprano's when we were in town for a match...."
Gabbie Ricky
"I ordered a sausage pizza. I eat pizza all over Seattle. This is one of the best places to go. I lived in Philadelphia and New York for years before..."
Patrick Martin
"Beautiful place, great & friendliest help in a pizzeria! Oh by the way their pizza is the best & tastiest! We come from Renton and now you know why!!..."
Timothy Zetterwall
"Genuinely feels like you stepped out of Seattle. The food is great, fresh and delicious. But quite greasy. Once you can ascertain if they are open or..."
McKayla Kinsworthy
"It was a pleasant meal in a surprisingly spacious setting, with good service, and I'd come back again. I ordered the eggplant parmesan ($16) which..."
Victor Cannestro
"I went here the other night with my partner and had an amazing experience! Our waitress was so sweet and took my allergies very seriously which was..."
Nina Nodland
"This place has such delicious, wholesome, fresh food. They have one the best calzones I've ever tasted and this is coming from someone who doesn't..."
Sabriya Zep
"Sopranos is underrated at 4-stars. At least the delivery is. It was here fast and the food is REALLY good - WAY better than I expected based off the..."
Echo Mike
"One of our favorite places to dine in West Seattle. Looking forward to when you add a full bar menu. Pasta dishes are..."
R James
"Nice cozy place with variету of delicious pizza and pasta prepared on place. You will be welcomed all time by smiling..."
Trifon Hadzhiyski
"Stumbled upon Sopranos Antico randomly and loved the experience. Great food, great atmosphere, great service. Highly..."
lauren abuali
"This is my all time favorite pizza place. Everything you order is delicious. The pizza crust is crunchy and never greasy. The desserts are all..."
Nicole Grimaldo
"Real Italian restaurant that's a cut above the rest. Quality wood-fired pizzas and fresh, homemade pastas, generous portion sizes, including the..."
R H
"Cozy atmosphere and amazing..."
Richard
"The low carb chicken Parmesan was Soo..."
Kasha Inouchi
Domino's Pizza
Domino's Pizza
84/100 (351 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Deluxe Pizza
Alfredo Pizza
Chicken Wings
Pretzel
Tater Tots
Handmade Pan Pizza
Barbecue Chicken Pizza with Italian Sausage Onion Garlic and Extra Cheese
Pepperoni Pizza
Lava Cake
Sit down
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
"I donated plasma right down the street from Domino's and every time I do, I check the Domino's apps coupon tab. I found a coupon for 50% off my..."
Brian Morseburg
"The lady was really nice I love dominos anyway for the chocolate lava cakes but the lady was real nice got me some water when I was really thirsty..."
Jillian Mcwhorter
"Quick turnaround time. Tasty pizzas on par with other dominos stores. Limited..."
Ganesh Kumar
"Dominos best thin crust pizza I've had. This time I got double pepperoni on each pizza. GOOD! You can actually get the flavor of the pepperoni. ..."
L. HOT H2O
Pagliacci Pizza
Pagliacci Pizza
83/100 (400 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Pepperoni Pizza
cheese pizza
Cheeseburger Pizza
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Gluten Free Margherita Pizza
Dinner
"Atmosphere rating shouldn't really count for a pickup/delivery location but since its there and we needed to eat in the location before hitting the..."
Ariel Driver
"Absolutely fantastic pizza. The best crust I've ever had. Light but chewy and strong enough to hold the load of toppings they pile on top. It's worth..."
Amy D
"Ordered the Chicken primo pizza and I absolutely loved it. Although price was little expensive compared to Big Marios and dominos, pizza has a..."
Sai Manudeep Gadde
"I'm visiting and needed a quick dinner delivered. I generally don't like pizza and am lactose intolerant so when I saw that they had vegan cheese I..."
Kae Zenisek
"got a cheese and a Hawaiian mushroom pizza, super friendly staff pizza was made quick and delicious, got it hot and ready to eat just town I asked it..."
TerpsTalk
"A spartan location with no seating, focused on delivery and take-out. The pizza is worth going for. Useful for nearby hotel..."
Patricia Weigand
"Great, large, NY style pizza! The delivery was fast and hot. The delivery person and the person on the phone were both very..."
Melody W.
"If you didn’t already know Pagliacci is on of the two best pizzas in town. We stopped in here as a walk in, bad choice the place is for pickup..."
Cameron Griffin
"We ordered the south Philly and loved. I’d recommend if you’re a meat lover. I’m particularly a fan of hand tossed style pizza over others..."
Geoffrey Hill
"Writing my review after my 8th or 9th time having Pagliacci's from all over town. Every pizza is great, they are so consistent, and ordering for pick..."
Brandon A
"Great pizza. It's really takeout only. They have a very small counter where you can wait, but it's not set up for dine-in, so keep that in..."
Anna Justis
"Huge pizzas. Crazy Seattle prices. But overall very good. I felt mine needed a bit more salt, which is odd for me, but overall a great meal and..."
J Chase
"We ordered the pepperoni pizza and wow it was delicious! The crust and the sauce were all on point. And the driver was very nice. Will order again..."
Sheah Brown
"This is the best pizza I have had on the west coast. The highest quality ingredients i’ve ever seen on pizzas and they’re pretty down to make a..."
Matthew Keating
"Good taste, good flavors. Higher price relatively - bigger the pizzas the cheaper it gets. Not 5 stars because I have had pizza that is phenomenal..."
N Dani
"I normally love their pizza, but I didn’t realize that the phone number went to a call center. I thought I was calling the Valley St location. So..."
Julia Lawlor
Magnolia Pizza & Pasta
71/100 (401 ratings)
Restaurants
Dinner
Lunch
Peppers
BBQ Chicken Sub
Tiramisú
Buffalo Wings
Create Your Own Calzone
Tortellini Special
Low Carb Addict Pizza
Half Gorgonzola Guru Half Veggie Special
caesar salad
chicken strips
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic bread
Greek salad
cheese pizza
Dinner
Lunch