EXCEPTIONAL!!! Super clean, super fresh, flavor on another level! I grew up going to Long John Silver's in Manhattan across from Madison Square Gardne at least once a month with my family right before we'd watch the Rangers play. The memories. Well Arthur Treacher's Selden brought those memories back. I'd pay a million dollars to go back my childhood. Thank you Arthur Treacher's for giving me and my mom priceless memories back. Your food is so delicious, light and great prices. Service is always exceptional. I can't say it any better. The best of the best of the best. Just go!
So hard to find Pudgies out here. I think it's the last one left. I love their food and the people were very friendly.
Worth every dollar you spend!! I enjoyed coming here since I was a 10 year old and now I'm 21 and still go here 😀
Always the best here. Negative reviews are done only by idiots who don't get the point of this place.
I have been coming here for almost a year. I either get the hot dogs or chicken, but I got curious of the bad reviews of the cheeseburgers. So I ordered a cheeseburger with fries. The cheeseburger and fries were delicious. I find everything about this place worthy of 5 stars, from the food to the customer service.
Pudgies has great fried skinless chicken, in my view the best in Suffolk County. I was impressed by the young owners dedication to making sure the quality of the food and the service his staff provided was excellent. The young lady manager was also considerate and it’s clear how hard working she is, and wanted to know how I felt about the food and the service. You certainly don’t see this kind of attention to detail in most food service establishments. I recommend Pudgies Selden and it’s nice to report Suffolk County still has a great fried chicken take out restaurant!
Tried this place last weekend for the first time and was taken back by how clean and fresh the food was. The hot dogs were great and I enjoyed how friendly the staff was. If you're in the LI area I suggest you check this place out. 10/10 would recommend.
Local own spot. Ppl that work there are solid
The fish and chips were cooked to perfection on both occasions I ate here. The staff is super friendly, patient and helpful. The corn on the cobb was big, soft and juicy and they give you butter. They have Nathan's fries! It's a smorgasbord! You'll love it. Go today! Go now! lol
I must say , Sebastian, Gianna , Zac, Danielle, Ava , Jeremy, James and Bill are like a part of your family . They go out of their way to over do it . It's clean, quick service, good food and there delivery time is superb. I love Pudgies as I worked at the East islip location as a kid , they stand up to everything i remember. Their smiles at the counter make my day . We go weekly and stay to have a quick chat cause they always ask how your day is. Pudgies/ Nathan's either way , they do their absolute best . I highly suggest that you give them a try , you will not regret it !!!!
This place is awesome authentic Pudgies 🙌
rare find ~ such nice people. When they are busy, the owner personally makes deliveries.
Five stars for this place.
If you want to support small a family run business, this is it.
This is like Pudgies of days past~you just don’t see that anymore. 5 stars, awesome authentic Pudgies 🙌
Haven't had pudgies in years. The chicken still had the same great taste and it was fresh. The sizes of the pieces were good also and the portion of the sides.
I live in Nassau County but always visit the Selden location in Suffolk County. I like Pudgies chicken so much more than KFC. This location does a very good job 90% of the time.
I haven't had Pudgies in years, and thought it would be gross because most of them closed. But oh my god! It's REAL fried chicken, not that KFC and Popeyes BS. Absolutely amazing! The chicken was juicy and the outside was nice and crispy. Even the chicken nuggets are great.
Highly recommend!
Best chicken tenders around! Tender meat, not too much breading. Love the honey mustard dipping sauce too. Rare to find!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes