Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Sheboygan
16 restaurant menus in Sheboygan, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Went to Rotrovo because I was feeling a little bit of Italian pizza and food and oh boy it did not disappoint! The restaurant is a LITTLE cramped but..."
MistahZ
"Busy place attached to a store downtown. Lucky we got there at 4:30 on a Saturday afternoon. We ended up getting a table right away. After 5 pm..."
Ms.Z
"Great pizza with huge selection. The toasted bread is a fondue and then the tiramisu !!!! I keep returning for more👍👍👍👍 it's just like..."
kelly
"Pizza was great from the wood fire oven. We also had halibut that was very tasty and cooked..."
Brian Ladd
"The Best
My son and I had two pizzas here Friday night and they were the best pizzas we have ever eaten. We go out of our way to taste good pizzas..."
enzo raymond
"A family friend recommended this place and I’m sure glad I followed the suggestion! From the decor and beautiful hand painted ceiling, to the..."
Dustin Milbrath
"Nice restaurant. Excellent services. We loved the pizza and each had a different..."
Gunnar Larson
"Hands down best Italian food in all of Sheboygan. I live outside of the USA and travel frequently so I've had a lot of Italian food....this place is..."
"A great small place with delicious food.
Service was slow and we felt rushed and forgotten. The atmosphere had character and was pleasant.
The only..."
thisis hybrid
"Went to Harry's because two other Italian restaurants were booked amd I did not regret trying it out! It's a very nice scenic restaurant, homely and..."
MistahZ
"This will be one of my forever favorite places to eat! The food is great and the staff is always attentive. Must tries: Chipolte pasta, spicy beef..."
Kaylene M.
"Had an amazing experience and our Server Heather was extremely nice, friendly, polite, and very courteous. We definitely recommend and we will be..."
Kyle Brazil
"Our server was very nice. I asked which wine she will recommend and that wine she served me was good. I ordered calzone with salad and it was..."
Girlie Westphalen
"Super amazing dinner spot with a fantastic wine selection. We tried the pizza, and some pasta dishes all of which were awesome! The gnocchi was sooo..."
Adam
"Cute place with indoor and outdoor dining on the river. We are outside and the view was lovely. We ordered olives and bread, Burrata and a doc..."
R OC
"Even while insanely busy the service there was still very quick and efficient. I sat at the bar and the bartenders were very helpful and quick. The..."
"Well, Googled Pizza, went to little ol Faye’s while passing through. Never have I had more cheese on a pizza. Deep dish supreme minus anchovies..."
Douglas Davis
"First time we stopped at Faye's and I loved the pizza. The manager on duty was very friendly and I was delighted when I saw him take time to thank..."
Seranya Artwear
"Picked up some frozen pizzas but haven't tried them yet. Waited in car until they opened at 4:00pm. Other customers that I walked in with and were..."
Deborah Roush
"Faye's Pizza definitely has the best Hawaiian Pizza in Sheboygan, WI!!
We usually have our cheese pizza delivered, but we ate there today and enjoyed..."
Patricia Brendel
"This is a nice little place to eat in, order to go or delivered. I was impressed and satisfied. Stopped in while on a business trip. The pizza was..."
"Went here for dinner with friends on a whim. The food was very good. I had pizza and some Sausage and Peppers Soup. The soup was literally worth the..."
Joshua McClain
"Was in the mood for some pizza and Luigis really delivered! The restaurant itself is pretty nice, a little small but easy to move around in and very..."
MistahZ
"Being Italian, I really appreciate the food at Luigi's. The pasta is always perfectly done, and the sauces are like my grandma showed me how to..."
Candy Girl
"Nice place! Friendly staff! Great food, healthy..."
Mike Young
"I ordered the 12 inch meat lovers Chicago style pizza. I'm not from the area so I don't know how it compares to deep dish from Chicago but I did..."
Michael Bloom
"All of the food was delicious. The pizza in the picture is their deep dish..."
Eric Rasmussen
"Went to dinner around 4:30pm. Wait staff was absolutely wonderful. Eager to please. The food is pretty good for small town Sheboygan. A little high..."
"It was surprisingly very good. The pizza was piping hot and so was the chicken wings and cheese bread. Might have to do this again soon to make sure..."
Paul Chapa Sr
"Always a great place to order pizza from. So far have never had a problem. Foods hot and the delivery drivers are..."
Jeffrey Oberst
"Ordered from here half a dozen times now. No issues, always get what I ordered, and the people working there are polite and..."
Aaron VT
"In my experience, Domino's has always been delicious pizza and BBQ chicken delivered fast and hot. Very pleased with..."
"Bartender was extremely friendly and attentive. We had boasted chicken dinner and a ribeye sandwich. Everything was cooked perfectly and very..."
Janet Sly
"Nice,clean,cozy home town bar. Good food. Cold beer. Nice bartenders. Great atmosphere...."
Jaime Rappolt
"The food is amazing as well as the service! This bar has a welcoming atmosphere and a homey feel. Karaoke on Fridays is also quite the experience...."
Meggie Songz
"Ordered via EatStreet. Delivery was very fast and food was delicious. Highly recommend the broasted chicken, cheese curds, and cherolls. Keep up the..."
Bryan
"Traditional bar food, lots of burgers, wings and broasted chicken. Fish fry is top class. Food is always cooked to perfection, we have never been..."
Edlog
"Free tacos on Tuesday nights!? Definitely returning and make sure I pop in there more than once a month for..."
Robert Henschel
"Cute little place. Jamie is a great bartender! Always remembers what I drink and it's friendly. She always checks up on you and rarely is your glass..."
"I like Rocky Rococo pizza. The working crew there is just great. They help you with anything. Great pizza and great atmosphere. I recommend it to..."
Cory Schwengel
"Great Pizza,
I called in my order over the phone for takeout and they were able to provide me my food on time.
Looking forward to eating here..."
John Thrapp
"Made a trip to Sheboygan and it was lunch time. Was in the mood for something different. Google maps showed a local Rocky Rococo and I have not had a..."
Brett
"Absolutely delish! The staff was super kind, helpful, and very attentive. Great..."
jeremy smith
"I had a large order and depleted their supply of pepperoni slices. So they were kind enough to turn a cheese slices into a pepperoni slice with no..."
Matt Widup
"Always a great location. Right off of i43. The staff is polite and the usually have most stuff ready to eat, if not in a few minutes wait. Even with..."
"First, I'm from New England where real pizza is made. So, cheese heads, pay attention!
This is probably one of the best and closest thing to east..."
Christopher O'Brien
"As a new member of Sheboygan I got this recommendation to visit Peabody's from a friend and I called tonight and this restaurant is the only place..."
Rachel Lederer
"Absolutely delicious! Amazing prices for the amount of food you get. Will definitely come back whenever we are in town!! Oh and the nachos are..."
MaKenna Murray
"Don't let the storefront fool you. What they lack in seating (there is none...it's takeout only) and pretty colors they make up in the most amazing..."
Matthew Brulla
"Taco Pizza...Enough said. LOL Peabodys has the best taco pizza in the area. Not feeling taco? get their BLT..."
"Delicious food and reasonable prices! Definitely would recommend to..."
Sarah Shepard
"Ordered the "Chicago"... Wow, huge pizza and delicious! My new favorite pizza..."
Dean Mink
"My favorite Sheboygan pizza for over 25 years! Always..."
Stephanie Herman
"Omgoodness.... What awesome pizza salad and bread delivered to my daughter Shelbey and friends. You all did an amazing job. Thank you from Sussex...."
Yvonne Zywicki
"Friendly environment, good food. Nice to know they use locally sourced..."
Jacob Berdyck
"Had your 12 pc chicken dinner with family this evening, was awesome! Very, very good! Your pizza is awesome too! Keep making good food. :) Thank..."
Christine Voland Burri
"Love � there � n the service there always when i come from Puerto Rico � need to stop for pizza � yummy..."
Luz E Calixto
"First time ordering from Nicky's and wasn't disappointed. Pizza was hot and very good!
Delivery on time. Will order..."
Lisa Scholler
"Love this place! It’s a great little hole in the wall with impeccable service and really tasty food! The Holy Moly Mushroom pizza is so damn good!..."
Shann Maddox
"The pizza was excellent and Rull was great company. Thanks for the great service. I appreciated..."
Chelseeann Walloch
"I was in town on business and mapped out local pizza places. I don’t consider myself an expert, but I’ve eaten pizza in lots of places. The crust..."
Eric Childs
"I had a surprisingly good experience with our order from Nicky's. I say surprising only because when I asked around if anyone had ordered from here..."
Jill O'Sullivan
"We just had one of the best thin crust pizzas that we have ever tasted!! Not only was the pizza amazing the staff is just as amazing. The young man..."
"By far the best pizza I’ve had thus far and only because it was made by Ethaniel(General Manager for this location)*Sorry if I misspelled your..."
Meng Yang
"I ordered a large pizza, those great toppers sticks, dipping sauce and the monkey bread. There was a short delay- but it gave me a chance to unwind..."
nanobanano
"Upset That I have lived in Sheboygan for so long, and have never had Toppers until just recently. My first time trying Toppers, and I was immediately..."
M and D Builders
"Not only is Toppers pizza off the charts delicious but they are only super late for deliveries ! You have try their TopperStix which come in lots of..."
BRIANJEFFERY FORSS
"Nathaniel (the Sheboygan GM) is wonderful! They have such a variety of uniquely delicious pizzas. I always snag the toppers sticks! The mac n cheese..."
"Our family LOVE Sheboygan Pizza Ranch! Great pizza, wings, and cactus bread! Beyond the food, the customer service is incredible. Today I ordered..."
Yoshi Ono
"We have been going to Pizza Ranch in Sheboygan for at least 5 years. We have never had a bad meal there. The people are very friendly and..."
Kathleen Jones
"Great buffet, chicken was delicious, macaroni pizza, never had it before, ..."
Rich Linzmeier
"I have been to many Pizza Ranch restaurant's and this one has the best tasting..."
Gary Hernet
"Good food good service Anthony burnt his lip on the pizza so the manager have me $500 towards out next..."
Jamie Jovanovich
"Wonderful food! Wonderful service! Thank you Pizza..."
Alanna J. Feddick-Goodwin
"This is more a review for 'the country's best chicken' delivery since they and pizza ranch are one and the same! It was some good chicken and waffle..."
MistahZ
"I love pizza ranch. Food is usually decent. Did take out tonight and everything was great -- the fries chicken did taste a bit of old oil which can..."
Thomas Kelly
"Fending for yourself….
The chicken is so good and juicy. Fake potatoes and gravy but they are fine.
The pizza is very good and they will cook..."
Keith Elkins
"I enjoyed the food. It was very good. Food was hot, excellent salad bar. The only thing I didn't care for was when I opened the soup container as..."
Deb Hoganson
"Very nice place, great food, chicken, salad bar and if course pizza. Staff is really great too,I go out of my way to eat here. update: still good,..."
Doug Duensing
"Very decent buffet! More than just pizza here. Will return. Overall place pretty clean and relaxed..."
"Customer service is great. Food nice hot and fresh. They did a great job on the..."
Timothy Stevens
"My experience with this Pizza Hut was not bad! I git a delivery order so I cannot comment on the establishment or service itself but my order did..."
MistahZ
"Dined in, had an excellent pan pizza and a double order of yummy bread sticks with my hubby tonight. Great food, lovely updated decor & the manager..."
Jamie M
"Pizza is great, but I was so surprised at the great traditional wings! I had Parm Garlic and they were so delicious! They were crispy, cooked..."
sandra howard
"Happy to be able to sit inside the restaurant to eat instead of driving 30 mins home and having to rewarm the pizza.
Its also easier for my dad who..."
"Great pizzas at low prices. It's very good when you can feed a family of 4 for less than $20. We've even been able to eat for less than $10 when we..."
Tony
"5 dollar pizzas...you get what you pay for. Good for parties with a limited..."
Sarah
"Good pizza. $5 hot & ready. What you'd expect from a place such as this. Still, it's not bad at all. I've had better but I've also paid more for..."
Johnny Darko
"Cheap and delicious pizza made quickly; great option for a quick dinner on a busy day, and you can feed a group without breaking the..."
Joe Z
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes