Reviews Wild Tomato Wood-fired Pizza And Grill Sister Bay

Terrific pizza and cherry walnut salad! We liked the Mediterranean pizza on our first night and the Thai Pie was even better on our 3rd night. The salad was amazing both times. Excellent service both times. If there is a wait, you get a buzzer and there is a bar and the beach right behind the restaurant. Definitely with a try if you are in Door County.

A tad pricey but well worth it for delicious pizza and great service!! We got a half and half deluxe and fun guy and both were incredible!! Wish there was more locations outside of Door County like in GB and Fox Valley. They also have a donation pizza of the month and proceed from every purchase of that pie goes to a charity/cause!!

I’ve eaten at the other location several times over the years but this was our first time at this one. We ordered and picked up at the Sister Bay location. We appreciated this option to avoid a long wait at the restaurant. The order taker was efficient and friendly. The estimated time for pickup was accurate. There were 15 minute parking spots near the pickup door which was a wonderful surprise! Be aware that if you choose to pay with a credit card the business is going to charge 2.75% extra for this. Fortunately I had cash to avoid this charge. This seems to be happening at many restaurants recently and I am not in favor. It is sneaky way to nickel and dime customers. I’d rather just have the price be realistic. The pizza was fresh from the oven. We got a large deluxe. I saw it cut and boxed. There were plastic cups of shaved Parmesan cheese and packets of crushed red pepper flakes available (free). The box top is designed to be torn (perforated) into four “plates.” Nice touch. The pizza itself was mediocre. The crust was crisp and the toppings were fresh. The downside was the fact that the veggies outnumbered the meat toppings and they were not evenly dispersed. Two of the six toppings were meat but there was barely any meat on the pizza. I’m not sure we had any pepperoni at all. Most of all it was bland tasting. It could have used salt but unfortunately we didn’t have any. The cheese wasn’t salty either. We’ve had friends tell us how wonderful this pizza is, and having read many of the reviews here our expectations maybe were unreasonably high. It was good, but not spectacular. Overall, adequate but underwhelming.

Delicious! We had the cheese curds as an appetizer (yum) and the Green and Gold pizza for our main course (YUM). Some of the best crust we’ve ever had (we’re picky about our crust), and the overall flavor was perfection. Everyone was so friendly! It was also nice being close to the beach for a nice sunset stroll after dinner. We would definitely come back next time we’re in the area.

At Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grill Sister Bay — Wild Tomato-Sister bay- I just gotta say WOW! This place is killing it in the Pizza game. I spent a bit of the day there talking to the staff, eating in drinking beer. I’d like actually mention some staff. First Miguel from the wait staff is one of the best I’ve ever met. He had it right on, from the top. Max in the back yard beer bar was killing. He know his product and had answers for any question. Last is Julia she is learning to be a stone cold assassin. In a week she will be killing. Now, the Bread plate for an appetizer, crazy as it comes. Portion size, and sauce accompaniment is amazing. The pizza Standard, Margarita. It had some sag, and nearly no crunch on the crust but flavor was not off the chain, it was not able to be restricted by a chain from the get go. The atmosphere is starting to form the list, on near top of the list or anything. The local beer selection is amazing, more great selection than most places with Beer in the name. This place is getting top rating, but I’d like to see a little more crisp on the crust, it would be a solid 8.7. My rating - 8.5. #wildtomato #wildtomatopizza #doorcountypizza #beerandpizza #sisterbay #sisterbaywi #sisterbaywisconsin #exploredoor #exploredoorcounty #explorethepeninsula #hangoutindoorcounty

The meal was great we ate the first cooked pizza of the day. We had the Green and Gold pizza which was fantastic. The only thing that concerned me was the fact my mother asked for a lemon in her tea and they were not ready with lemons. After asking multiple times for a lemon we finally got one. The flowers outside were gorgeous and had to take some great pics!

The pizza is so good and loved all of the vegan options including vegan cheese. Service was great from beginning to end.

We visited for the first time on 10/24/22. Food was amazing! Staff was great. We ordered the Parmesan knots for an appetizer and they were so light and airy! Their marinara is excellent! For the pizza we ordered the Green & Gold pizza, it had broccoli, spinach, chicken, bacon, with cheese curds on top! So good!!

Their wood-fired pizzas are delicious! All the staff are super nice, and seem to be enjoying themselves and having a great time. Inside atmosphere is nice, a bit on the loud side (due to it being pretty packed), and there is outdoor seating available too.