Best Cheese Curd Grilled Cheese in Sister Bay

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Door County Creamery
Door County Creamery
89/100 (1875 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
European
American
European
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Lamb Gyro
Pinot Noir Wine
Torte
Lemon Cookie Gelato
Hot Honey Sandwich
Baguette
Hazelnut Gilato
BLT
Cheese Curd Grilled Cheese
Prosciutto
Honey Ham Sandwich
Gelato
Sandwiches
Cheese Sampler Platter
Pesto
Charcuterie Plate
Coffee Ice Cream
Pasta
Dark Chocolate Gelato
Salad
Warm Bread
Raclette
Chicken Sandwich
Sit down
American
European
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Visa
Highchairs Available
Accepts American Express
Digital Payments
Street Parking
Free Wifi
Playgrounds
Accepts Credit Cards
Accepts Discover
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I could not say enough about this place. We came here for lunch, and it was SO good! We got the Turkey, brie, and cranberry sandwich which was out of..."
Emily Bichler Dornburg
"A must stop on our yearly visit! The homemade soap is my yearly must have! It's the only thing I have found that keeps my eczema away year round!..."
Candice Marie
"Love this place! The Gelato is to die for.....always yummy goat cheeses and sandwiches.....and even outstanding cookies! Can't stay..."
Carol Schalla
"This spot has the best goat cheese I have ever had. Delicious sandwiches, wonderful staff and fabulous space. Make sure to check out the farm..."
Debbie Singer
"Loved it! Had a delish meatball sandwich and salad. Fiancé had the mozzarella sandwich. Then we finished with gelato. I'll be counting down until I..."
Emily Schram
"We stopped here yesterday after walking by and seeing people eating fabulous looking food on the patio - and raving about it! So we ordered..."
Laurie Schimek
"This is an amazing place. Stop in for lunch and grab the mozerella sandwich and a cup of gelato. Yum! They also have luxurious hand made soaps that..."
Jennifer Gurske
"Take the tour! As soon as you are on the short shuttle to the farm you get gelato! On the farm you get to sample cheese while you watch/pet the..."
Sara Wiles
"I don't have the words to describe the deliciousness of their gelato. I was totally blown away. The best hands down!! I tried the salted caramel and..."
Carissa Collins
"Cheese curd sandwich and lemon cookie gelato were..."
Jennifer K Marchinowski
"The best place for lunch in sister bay. Excellent cheese and knowledgeable..."
Monte Priske
"The #1 place that I must stop at when I'm in Door County. I love their cheeses and they are extremely nice people. They are artists in their own..."
Michael Malosh
"Seriously amazing food!! The BLT was like none I've ever had and all the cheese was fantastic! I must stop anytime your in door..."
Regan Mengel
"This creamery is so delicious and both nights we went (because it was sooooo good) Rachelwent above an beyond to make our experience incredible! ..."
Brittani Antoine
"Whenever you go, make sure you get the lamb gyro, the best thing you'll ever put in your mouth! When you're all done get some..."
Georgina Saunderson Hatch
"Hot Honey...seriously one of the very best gourmet sandwiches I've ever eaten!! Thai salad absolutely scrumptious as well! House made Arnold Palmer..."
Lori
"Very cute shop with fantastic food. The brie turkey sandwich was the best turkey sandwich I've had in my life (my picture does not do it justice) I..."
Darrin Rogers
"I never miss a chance to eat at The Creamery. The Goat and honey motifs are charming and homey, and everything is done with a level of..."
Cecile Lindell
"We grabbed take-out lunch here and got a burrata salad, green veggie wrap and a lamb gyro. The burrata salad and lamb gyro were great, the green wrap..."
Sheetal Shedbalkar
"My brother and I were in town for the Door County Century bike ride. Every flavor I sampled was very good, but lemon cookie was unbelievably good...."
Ben S.
"I've had ice cream here before but never eaten. I had the meatball sandwich and it was awesome. Toasted bun/bread, fresh jalapeno, lettuce, cheese..."
Bill S.
"My happy place! I’ve been going to Door County Creamery for years. I loved it when they opened and it just keeps getting better. The mozzarella..."
Casey M
"The sandwiches were so excellent!! Some of the best we’ve ever had! We had the French Ham and Meatball sandwiches and would definitely eat them..."
Emily Ahern
"Love this place, all the seating is outdoors but it’s in the heart of Sister Bay! I recommend the mozzarella sandwich and their Arnold Palmer...."
Brittney G
"My favorite lunch spot in Door County, by far. They do everything well: fresh ingredients, interesting menu, great vibe, friendly staff, terrific..."
The Accidental Hero
"Ended up getting the gyro. It’s was hands down one of the best I ever Eaten. Outdoor seating very nice as..."
Noah Smith
"The turkey & brie sandwich is my favorite sandwich to get up in Door County. The charcuterie is also good. We always stop there at least once for..."
Liu
"I highly recommend this place. Workers have a great attitude. One of the best sandwiches I’ve ever enjoyed. They also make a wicked charcuterie..."
Jude Rake
"No trip to Door County is complete without stopping here, for a sandwich and scoop of delicious goat’s milk gelato, and a cooler full of fresh goat..."
Kristin D
"Little country store. Have a wonderful selection of goat and sheep cheeses. Only place around that someone with a milk allergy can enjoy a..."
Deb Christian
"The food is AMAZING! The staff is enthusiastic, friendly and helpful. Love the music too. Highly recommend this hidden..."
Laurie Ann Mosher
"This may be the best place in DC to grab a bite! Incredible flavor and large portions!..."
Jeannine