Best Crab in Sister Bay

5 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Boathouse On The Bay
Boathouse On The Bay
85/100 (1130 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
American
Cajun & Creole
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Cajun & Creole
Bar
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Crab
Oyster
Salmon
Sandwiches
Burger
Hamburgers
Chowder
Lobster Roll
Ribs
Crawfish
Shrimp
Catfish
Lobster
Po' Boys
Pasta
Pesto
Salad
Fish
Mac and cheese
Sit down
Cajun & Creole
American
Seafood
Bar
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Seating
Highchairs Available
Table Service
Full Bar
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Street Parking
Live Music
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Had a fantastic lunch here. The bloody was perfect and the food was delicious! One of the few places I've never been to in Door County and I will..."
Dan Profio
"Big shout out to Sergio!! Way to make dining out an experience. We actually ended up eating here twice on our Labor Day weekend because it was so..."
T T
"Excellent tasting food here. Great atmosphere and service. Beautiful view of the sunset on the bay. The blackened whitefish was perfectly seasoned,..."
R Farmland
"I had the lobster roll and…. My goodness…. I couldn’t help but grin between bites. It was the absolute perfect balance between savory and zest...."
Kyla Karcz
"Nice location, overlooking the water. Great variety of menu options. I ordered a veggie burger and fries, and I was not too impressed with my..."
Nichole
"First time here. Came on a Friday afternoon. Not crowded at all for Sister Bay.. Seated right away. Had the shrimp poor boy , spouse had wedge with..."
Chuck Fell
"We make the specials trip to Sister Bay, just to dine here several times a years! Recently June 28 2023 two for lunch. Ordered our regular: House..."
P S
"Original review: We couldn’t have been any happier. The service was great, the view is excellent, and the food was incredible. Splurge on the..."
Rich McGee
"We got in right away and had a nice table outside overlooking the water, the food was good but it's the view that's why we stopped..."
Trucking With kingfish (Trucking with kingfish)
"This is the spot to get a great lobster roll without going to the East coast. It has East coast vibes with a touch of Door County. The food was..."
Ella Altreuther
Jj"s La Puerta
Jj"s La Puerta
83/100 (1207 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Mexican
Southwestern
Mexican
Southwestern
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Fish Taco
Tacos
Crab Legs
Fish Sandwich
French Fries
Burger
Hamburgers
Burrito
Tortillas
Shrimp
Fajitas
Beef
Nachos
Fish
Salad
Pork
Wings
Crab
Tapas
Sit down
American
Mexican
Bar
Southwestern
Pub
Seating
Highchairs Available
Table Service
Full Bar
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Television
Gift Cards Available
Accepts Mastercard
Parking Available
Accepts Visa
Waterfront
Accepts Discover
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
Cheap Eats
"Came here on a Friday night and we were seated right away! It was just two of us. I noticed larger groups did have to wait due to not as many bigger..."
Heather Rathjen
"Whenever I come here I order Blue Cheese Nachos w holopinios and chicken. Hands down the most awesome Nachos that I have ever had. Cheese throughout..."
Brian Fero
"Family ordered several items but the best was the ruben sandwich. The burger was small for the price. Looks like handcut French fries. Overall good..."
Mary Shadowens
"The menu is very welcoming for a large group of all kinds. The chips and salsa are a great snack option! Make sure you order a round of their..."
Lauren Brooks
"Visited the Sugar Shack to have cocktails on the dock. Beautiful day and delicious drinks. Great way to end the day after a day of exploring the..."
Nicholas
"Perfect spot for authentic Mexican food in Door County! Outstanding service, quick and accurate! Excellent Margarita and beer selections! Nice view..."
cat kegeris
"Friendly service! Tasty tacos, the creamy slaw gives it a kick...but for more try the spicy..."
Luz Burkard
"A great spot for the location, hours. And selection. The "Bernie" shot is a great deal, only $2 for rail tequila, orange slice, and cinnamon sugar...."
Lauren Brooks
"Bar Mexican food, in the best of ways. Great tacos, tasty drinks, and friendly staff. They do have corn shells (hard) if you need gluten free. Their..."
D Castle
"My new favorite Door County restaurant. The fresh hot chips and fresh made-daily salsa and hot sauce are worth the trip alone. The variety and taste..."
Kevin Brice
"They were so kind about my request for take out during peak hours, and the hostess kindly assisted with my hamfisted requests for water and such...."
Autumn Gomez-Tagle
"Excellent margaritas (as every other person has noted). Wonderful Mexican food…even though we’re in Wisconsin. The Tacos were great. I ordered..."
Steve S
"We had tacos. They were very meaty and great flavor. Salsa was mild, with cilantro and chunky..."
Terry Edwards
Chop
Chop
83/100 (6987 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Steakhouse
Steakhouse
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Cheesecake
Filet Mignon
Halibut
Lamb chops
Shrimp
Beef
Surf And Turf
Escargot
Lobster
Cheesecakes
Salad
Carrot Cake
Crab
Bananas Foster
Scallops
Duck
Cakes
Salmon
Lamb
Fish
Pork
Sit down
Steakhouse
American
Highchairs Available
Reservations
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Seating
Table Service
Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Serves Alcohol
Accepts Mastercard
Parking Available
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Dinner
Fine Dining
"We decided to end our sisters long weekend at Chop. Our server was a sweet girl who was attentive and well versed in the menu recommending her..."
Nicki Kroll
"Our waitress was on point! We never had to look for her or wait for her, but she wasn't intrusive. Love ❤️ the House Salad! I could eat that..."
Sara Jennerjahn
"Great food, excellant service!! "Bro" Jason our server was top notch and entertaining! Would definitely recommend! We enjoyed the Early Bird 3 course..."
Kari Russell
"The food was scrumptious. I had the ramen for breakfast which was a huge bowl with bone broth that was perfect. The noodles were cooked beautifully..."
Kathi Hickey
"Ate outside on roof patio which was really nice. Fantastic dinner and drinks! Ergie was a great server-we will all be..."
Kristin Lambert
"Food was delicious and the wait staff was on point. Thank you for the great meal for our first night in..."
Joshua Lenz
"Absolutely wonderful meal. Perfect place foir my daughters BFF to celebrate her birthday. Our table of 7 had 2 lobster tail dinners, 2 walleye..."
Tom Mengarelli
"Just had the one of the best dining experiences ever. Great bartender awesome service great steak. Loved every moment. Awesome place for my..."
Eric Olson
"Went there last Sunday and the atmosphere was really nice. We showed up a bit early for our reservation but the hostess was able to help seat us..."
Meghan van Ommeren
"Simply amazing! Thick cuts of tender steak and amazing specials daily! Would highly recommend..."
Quentin Hale
"I've already written glowing reviews about this place, as have many others, so I have nothing to add. But a shoutout to waiter Adam, who has served..."
Gerry Grzyb
"We had a great New Years dinner. Our steaks were unbelieveable. Our server was attentive but not a pest our deserts were perfect , carot cake and a..."
Ron Bellack
"It was an excellent meal. Had beef burgundy. Great place and they have a gorgeous new..."
Kathie Anderson Mueller
"The Old Fashion drink was excellent. The steak was done to perfection and very tasty. The carrot cake for dessert was an added..."
James Eckerle
"Not your typical DC restaurant. Modern decor, excellent service and great steak menu. Beef burgundy was a little salty, but lots of mushrooms and..."
Kristin T
"Drive by here on a nice summer day and you’ll see the entire lawn covered with tables full of happy diners, with good reason. If you want a classy..."
Kristin D
"Staff was very friendly. I liked the drink menu options, they had new things I haven’t heard of. I had the Rose Gold Drink. The food was good, my..."
Nichole M
"I've been coming to Chop since it opened many years ago up in the shops. Still amazing food, outstanding service & great atmosphere. I reccimend..."
Eli Foote
"What a great steak house. Highly recommend. Service was exceptional. Food absolutely met our expectations. Medium rare filet was delicious. The..."
Ben Bartelt
"Great service from start to finish. We had a reservation for five thirty and showed up very early. We were still seated immediately! The atmosphere..."
John Doe
"Amazing dinner! If you are wanting to have an excellent steak, cooked to order, you will not regret it. The Old Fashioned Brandy Sweet with Cherries..."
Manny
"Wow! Our first time here for dinner and found the surf and turf excellent! Josh provided outstanding service which we really appreciated. Highly..."
Brian Numainville
"Chop is a wonderful eye full of home style class and modern chic. The staff from door to table was fantastic and not a single item was required of me..."
Stuckey Stuckey
"From walking the moment I walked in this was a great experience. Hostess was polite. Server was very attentive and the food.... AMAZING! Perfectly..."
BJ Wawrzyniak
"One of the best restaurants in the area! Great ambiance, great service and great food. Best smashed potatoes I’ve ever had (and I’ve had A LOT)...."
Casey M
"A must try in door county. I had the steak dinner with lobster tail. It was absolutely delicious. Cooked perfect to medium rare. The lobster was so..."
Sonja Hauswirth
"We were lucky enough to snag a couple seats at the bar since we were lazy and didn't call ahead to make reservations. The restaurant is very nice..."
CB
"We ate upstairs and even though we came near closing time, we still received excellent service. Server was competent and friendly. Atmosphere was..."
Laura Sanderlin
"Food was one of the best meals I’ve ever had. Steak was done exactly as asked and was so good. Wine was flawless, ceaser salad was outstanding as..."
Sara Falci
"Fast and friendly service. Great menu. The food was perfectly designed and cooked. Bravo Maria was amazing The pork chop was cooked perfectly, love..."
KEN
Waterfront Restaurant
Waterfront Restaurant
83/100 (924 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Risotto
Flourless Chocolate
Shrimp and Grits
Lamb
Mussels
Fried calamari
Ahi Tuna Tartare
Pesto
Tuna
Halibut with Risotto and Broccolini
Fish
Calamares
Winter Burrata Salad
Pork
Shrimp
Halibut and Risotto
Ossobuco
Beef
Lamb Kabab and Nan
Molten Brownie
Wine
Tapas
Negroni
Lobster Bisque
Swordfish
Crab cakes
Grilled Swordfish
Halibut
Lobster
Cheese Plate
Ribs
Pasta
Bread and Butter
Lamb chops
Salad
Grasshopper
Crab
Crème Brûlée
Scallops
Surf and Turf
Bolognese
Clams
Scallops
Osso Buco
Calamari
Risotto Milanese
Carrot Cake
Sit down
Seafood
American
Accepts American Express
Waterfront
Reservations
Accepts Discover
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Dinner
Fine Dining
"Door County is filled with wonderful restaurants of every kind. Waterfront in Sister Bay remains my favorite for delicious food superbly seasoned..."
Jo Ann Ward
"The staff at Waterfront cannot be rated high enough. The food was amazing, our waitress Kaija was the most helpful and attentive. She helped with..."
Jason Vargas
"Not a cheap place to eat but worth the money! A beautiful place with a awesome view of the lake! No matter what you order you will be quite surprised..."
Mcubb Kevin
"Lovely dining room, wonderful views, excellent service, interesting menu, nice selection of wine by the bottle and glass. We are never disappointed..."
Lisa Canning
"Fine dining at its best in Door County. Food, drinks and atmosphere are excellent. The view across the bay is beautiful, especially when the sun is..."
Steve Broege
"I come here every year on My trip to Door County and its always spectacular! Chair the owner is always gracious and Kendall her daughter heads up the..."
Jill Wiley Gill
"We had our wedding reception dinner here, the family that owns his restaurant are EXPERTS in making your dinner experience extremely special...."
Jocelyn Vetrano Newhall
"Terry, our waiter, was top notch catering to our every need & making our dining experience enjoyable. The lobster bisque, diver scallops, tuna and..."
Ernie Moxey
"The cuisine is delicious and service was outstanding! I highly..."
Damian E. Constantine
"Great restaurant! Our favorite in all of Door County. We always close out our stay with a dinner there. Excellent food and a great view of the..."
Ralph Mannel
"Great service and food, our 1st together as husband and wife, Waterfront made it very special, with amazing..."
Michael Bockeloh
"Excellent food, excellent service, excellent view. Thank you Miss Debbie who really took good care of us. We'll be..."
Dave Westberg
"Wonderful dinner and great service! What you want in a dining experience! And the view, well the bay is what you come..."
Valerie Ward Druzik
"We had a wonderful time. Service was great and not rushed. We were celebrating our anniversary and enjoyed watching the sunset while sharing a bottle..."
Stortz Wellness Intentional Living
"We've had a wonderful culinary experience at Waterfront Restaurant. If you're seated outside you're practically on the water, looking over the harbor..."
A. Kramer
"Had an incredible meal here last week while my wife and I were on our honeymoon. First, the service here is excellent. No question, some of the..."
Aaron Lee
"Love this place! Great food, great service, and incredible views! Jason, our server was so great! His banter is gold and great at the job! We had the..."
Carissa Heckel
"We came right at 4:45pm to make sure to get a good seat to enjoy the sunset and got a great table. We enjoyed the special salad, marinated olives,..."
Emily Ahern
"It lived up to what you would expect. Service was good, food was good, everything was on par with the expensive price that we were paying. No..."
Nate E
"While still casual, this is one of the few restaurants in Door County where you'll need to remove your hat to dine. A nice change. My wife and I..."
David
"My husband and I are on our honeymoon and absolutely loved our dinner here. Everything was outstanding. Definitely the restaurant for a fancy,..."
Samantha Thomfohrda
"Excellent dinner, great view of the sunset. Food was perfectly prepared, fresh and creative. My Halibut was outstanding as was my husband's steak...."
Kim Williamson
"Lobster bisque! Oh my wow, best thing I've ever eaten. Wow! Half plates are nice, my wife and I shared lamb chops, scallops and the crab cakes. 2..."
Lead Sled
Lure
Lure
78/100 (1120 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Wine Bar
Seafood
Steakhouse
Seafood
Vegan Options
Wine Bar
Steakhouse
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Calamari
Beer Battered Walleye
Corn Bread
Key lime pie
Tempura
Tuna
Teriyaki Chicken
Chocolate Caramel Sundae
Summer Salad
Cakes
Calamares
Crab cakes
Shrimp
Scallops
Lamb
Salmon
Beef
Surf & Turf
Pesto
Old Bay Fries
Fish
Crab Nachos
Summer Negroni
Pork
Crab Cake
Lobster
Seafood Pan Roast
Seafood pasta
Chowder
Pasta
Blood Orange Mule
Grilled Salmon
Tapas
Salad
Crab Crusted Halibut
Tacos
Clam Chowder
Mama's Key Lime Pie
Filet Mignon
Halibut
Crab
Scallops
Clams
Lobster Bisque
Salt & Pepper Calamari
Nachos
Oyster
Cherry Pie
Steakhouse
Wine Bar
Seafood
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Private Dining
Accepts American Express
Reservations
Live Music
Seating
Accepts Discover
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Dinner
Mid-range
"What a surprising discover. We chose to dine here primarily because it was the closest nice dining experience to our hotel, and had the best meal in..."
Lisa Canning
"Such a romantic setting! It was the perfect place for our anniversary dinner. I tried my first oyster ($2 oysters on Thursdays. Raw or grilled). Our..."
Sharon Boldt
"Adult beverage selections including creative cocktails are one highlight. The menu left me wanting nearly everything on the list. But what really..."
John J Beck
"My husband and I had dinner here on out Honey moon. We had calamari as an appetizer. It was Delicious and we were pleasantly surprised with the..."
Olivia Zeman
"Like my wife already posted, absolutely wonderful. They welcomed us and our Lab, Memphis, on their patio. Very accommodating! Zack took care us!!!..."
Jeff Malkowski
"I was drawn in by the lure shaped sign off the highway right away. I was hired to play a dinner show and received a free meal. I had the halibut (for..."
Michael Bleck
"Lure is a wonderful place to bribe. The ambiance , staff and food are all amazing ! Love the 5 dollar martini nights with 2 dollar oysters thrown in..."
Holly Hill Murawski
"Exceptional food and service on a busy Saturday night. Our waitress Megan was spot on taking care of us and being friendly without being over the..."
Ben Fulcer
"Great place we stopped for their Martini & Oyster special. The grilled oysters with parmesan and garlic were fantastic. Our waitress Dalia from..."
Holly Henry
"Had dinner there tonight. The seafood pan roast was phenominal and the service was outstanding. Zac was awesome. We also took our black lab. They are..."
Julie Malkowski
"Had an excellent meal here with my mom! Started with the craft cocktails. I had the spicy cucumber gimlet that was to die for! My mom had the..."
Carrie Lueck Wotruba
"First time dining at Lure's. We have eaten at Chops and Pasta Vino and love them. We had a great diner, started with a cocktail (old fashion and..."
Richard Patek
"Our party of four celebrated New Year's Eve here with an early dinner. Surf and Turf was soooooo delicious! Our server, Jason, was top notch!!..."
Cindy Rader Gigstead
"Make sure you have reservations. Got there earlier and had a drink at the bar while we waited. Wife absolutely loved the blueberry lemon drop. We..."
Ben Bartelt
"did the early 3-course dinner, total came out to be around ~$38 post tip (they have a 4% surcharge for instability before tip?). nice atmosphere and..."
Sarah Li
"Simply amazing - down to the drinks, service, and food/dessert. My husband and I had the calamari, seafood pasta and the soy-ginger glazed halibut...."
Rachel Balestrieri
"We went here for dinner on a Sunday night after reading really good things online. It did not disappoint, with small areas for improvement. In short,..."
J Mueller
"We were seated on the porch which we loved. We chose the early three-course dinner and were very pleased. I started with the Calamari, which was..."
Julie Ferrari Beyer
"Good atmosphere. The service was great and food was good. For appetizers we order Mussels and fritters, and the crab nachos. Mussels were..."
Natalia Rasavong
"Excellent food & cocktails. Staff was attentive, friendly, knowledge, and fast! Blackened salmon was..."
Scott VandenElzen
"Star ratings. 1 bad. 2 below average. 3 average / neutral. 4 good. 5 excellent. One of the few places that has ever asked how I wanted my scallops..."
Erik Spychalski
"We thought the food was excellent. Went for my birthday dinner and loved every part of it. From drinks, apps (seriously how do you make that..."
Toula F
"Nice restaurant with great service and delicious food. We enjoyed the prompt seating and outdoor eating..."
MJ
"Absolutely love the food here. We ordered corn bread, crab nachos, lobster risotto, rib eye steak, crab cake, spicy tuna roll and seafood pasta and..."
Betsy Manak
"Amazing experience! Everything was fantastic-the food, service, drinks,and atmosphere! The seafood pasta is superb. The service was perfect. Our..."
Bob Swigert
"Great food, outstanding service and wonderful atmosphere! My tuna poke bowl was fresh and delicious. My husband's teriyaki chicken was perfectly..."
Cyndee Wilson
"I had the seafood pasta, excellent. My wife had the grilled salmon from their early dining menu also very good. Service fast and good. Prices..."
John Sobczak
"Fantastic every time! The Halibut & crab crusted halibut is outstanding. Crab nachos are soooo good! Great service and ambiance. We love this..."
Andrea C
"Enjoyed a nice dinner in Sister Bay at Lure. Nice specialty cocktails, imaginative menu options, and good service - great stop for a special or..."
Allison Sikorsky
"Lure is a fantastic option for upscale seafood and steak at the top of the hill near Sister Bay! We loved their cocktails. Service was fast and..."
Daniel Seiter