Best Sandwiches in Skaneateles

6 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Doug's Fish Fry
Doug's Fish Fry
95/100 (3167 ratings)
Quick Bites
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
French Fries
Shrimp
Lobster
Fried shrimp
Pasta
Chicken Sandwich
Wings
Po' Boys
Mac and cheese
Fish
Fish & chips
Scallops
Clams
Oyster
Salmon
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Haddock
Fried Clams
Sandwiches
Cod
Fish Sandwich
Sit down
Seafood
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Doug’s is the best! The one place I always have to go when we come into..."
Charles Spaziani
"My sister and I both had the seafood chowder and steamed clams. Both were excellent!! Bright spot of the day on a rainy day. We even had the pleasure..."
Jane Gruschow
"Best fish sandwich on the planet �..."
Andrew Hawley
"Lobster bisque was..."
Evelyn Q Jirasakhiran
"Excellent..."
Nancy Palmieri Norman
"It is always..."
Brian Christopher
"Just plan..."
Ken Wurster
"The food was delicious, and a local favorite didn't disappoint. A classic quick walk through grab, go, or dine-in restaurant. Our food order was..."
Ryan Bates
"I love Doug's! I also love that it hasn't changed in 25 years (since I left Skaneateles), other than expanding and improving. We ordered the hot dog..."
Margaret Hahn
"They have a large parking lot out back of their establishment. This place can get pretty busy. I've seen a line all the way up the street on several..."
Nicole Gabriel
"Great quality and quantity of fish and fries price was well worth this lunch item. The sitting area could use a little freshening up and care taken..."
M A
"We went over to Doug's fish fry during the Dickens In The Village. We came in a day earlier on a Friday. But since I have a mobility problem and..."
Cindy Madar
"The fish was excellent! The onion rings are perfect. And we topped it off with a delicious sundae! The service was very fast and cashier was..."
Hadeel Alabbasi
"Love Doug's Fish Fry. I bought a fish sandwitch to eat for lunch & ordered 2 more to take for dinner later to share with the family. Wish I lived..."
Robert Kraatz
"Nothing says summer like sitting by Skaneateles Lake enjoying the sunshine with a plate of Doug’s Fish Fry. This Skaneateles staple serves up..."
Dakota
"Their apple fritters (from during the Dickens festival) are hands down the best apple fritter I've ever had. It was thick, so it actually was like..."
Samantha Stanton
"The fish is fresh, the service is great. And the lobster rolls and seasonal apple fritters are all kinds of perfection. It’s a no-frills spot, just..."
Tiffany Mayer
Sherwood Inn
Sherwood Inn
90/100 (2462 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pesto
Risotto
Burger
Fish
Calamares
Salmon
Juice & Smoothies
Shrimp
Crab Cake
Beef
Cheesecake
Cod
Lobster
Chicken Sandwich
Pasta
Salad
Cheesecakes
Crab
Quiche
Scallops
French onion soup
Oyster
Cakes
Calamari
Sandwiches
Lamb
Sit down
Bar
American
Accepts Discover
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Reservations
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Seating
Accepts Visa
Table Service
Private Dining
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Live Music
Serves Alcohol
Waterfront
Wine and Beer
Brunch
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"My daughter and I decided to take a day trip up here to see how everything looked at Christmas and we were not disappointed. This place was..."
Berni Malek
"I went to The Sherwood for lunch recently. I was seated promptly by the hostess. My risotto was very good. It was a vegetable risotto with squash and..."
Katelyn Gelormino
"Just had an amazing lunch at the Sherwood Inn. Everything was perfect and the service was outstanding! Our server, Amber, was amazing and we are so..."
Kim Latko
"A true hidden gem. Great food. Outstanding water views. Exemplary service. I plan to return for a day trip to truly enjoy the ambiance. The wings..."
Nina Figgins
"Only enjoyed both restaurants. Prefer the pub food but like the ambiance on the front porch better. The menu could use an update imo. It’s a little..."
Jhanna White
"Went for dinner with co-workers. We were seated next to the fireplace. We had impeccable food and service. Loved the..."
Jacinda Forrest
"We were a large group of diners who ordered various entrée, snacks and appetisers. Everyone said their dish were perfect and it is amazing how..."
Eliza C
"I went for dinner and it was top notch all the way around! Very lively scene, the place was packed at 5:00 on a Sunday evening with live music. I..."
Holly Mosher
"Tub was entirely too high to step into unless you were 6 feet tall. No handicap access to rooms. Service and food were excellent, especially the..."
Annette Haynie
"Food was very good!! We were there when it opened at 11:30. The floor in the barroom dining area needed some serious sweeping and Swiffering..."
Mike Polito
"We had a romantic dinner by the fireplace in the dining room. Amber was fabulous and the food was outstanding! Always good food, ambience and..."
susan overstrom
"Very friendly owner! Campground was clean and quiet. Bathroom were small but good. Too cold to use the pool. Very nice off the grid..."
Shelly Harmony
Finger Lakes On Tap
Finger Lakes On Tap
85/100 (542 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Healthy
American
Bar
Pub
American
Healthy
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Pretzel
Sandwiches
Café
Healthy
Pub
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Live Music
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Awesome craft brew spot with almost 60 local beers on tap and great food. We even got a personal tour from the owner, Tom and it was very impressive..."
Johanna Bock
"Welcoming, laid-back environment. Amazing beer selection. Personable staff. Amazing food made by the best cook, ever! We will definitely be..."
Tara Dennee
"Amazing rotating taps, thoughtful flights, great seating variety, luscious food menu, and the occasional free live jazz on..."
Blair Frodelius
"Great beer selection with great prices! Fun atmosphere, loved the cheese plate. Will def be..."
Emily Whalen
"Great place and great beer. We did not eat there as we were meeting friends for the first beer of the day before the Dickens folks. We would..."
Marty Merwin
"A great spot, run by great people with one of the largest selections of New York State craft beers. A beautiful bar in a beautiful building. Great..."
Tom Pilcher
"Cozy and many choices. The bartender was very friendly and knowlegeable! Thanks to her, I paired ice cream and chocolate porter beer....yummm! I..."
Karen Lynn Visco
"Visiting from out of town and glad we did. Since we won't have a long trip up here we were looking to sample some good NY beers and this was a great..."
Kevin Auriemma
"Good beer selection to say the least. One downside is having 63 choices! Tasty roast beef sandwich,..."
Maggie Mae Hall
"Very nice place , friendly staff , nice selection of beers..."
Jim Mahon
"Excellent beer menu and the food is delightful! We will definitely be..."
Molly Meany
"Great place many choices of craft beers, staff is friendly and helpful explaining different..."
Melanie Bellerdine
"Kara is awesome, and so are Gloria and Tom, the owners! Great atmosphere and great beer. My fiancé and I have LOTS of wonderful memories that were..."
Taylor Allen Flanick
"Comfortable, friendly place with a grand choice of NYS beers and more! Always a place to stop when in..."
Carolyn Oakes
"Finger Lakes on Tap is a must when visiting Skaneateles! The staff is super friendly, very knowledgeable of the numerous craft beers, and the food is..."
Kerry O'Keefe Cotter
"Staff was SO friendly and helpful....very nice and knew a lot about the beer that was being ordered. It was nice to order your own flight of beer you..."
Kathryn Lindsay
"A perfect little spot to chat and have a drink. Immediately comfortable walking in and staff is..."
Meri-Beth Nielsen
"Food and wine was beyond delicious. ....Service was warm and welcoming. Yesterday was my first visit, and I can't wait to go..."
Melody Ladd
"Great beer; great service; great food! Worth the..."
Danna Parsons
"From concept to execution, everything about FLOT is perfect!! Thank you Tom and..."
Jim Gomez
"60 great beers, all but a handful from local craft brewers, plus great owner/hosts, Tom and Gloria-we enjoyed talking with..."
Vicky Salicondro McGarry
"What an awesome place!! Feels like home!! The beer is all amazing and..."
James Howell
"First time here. Jazz Sunday with Cookie! We had 2 flights. Very nice place. Pretzel stick were a great add on. Will be back for sure. So many beers..."
Christopher Molloy
"Great atmosphere, good beer selection! Love it every time I come..."
Natalie Curry
"I own a gym in town and every Thursday I bring my members to FLOT to unwind and have a drink. The beer is always great and the atmosphere is perfect..."
Danny Flanick
"I attended the soft opening last week and can't wait to return whenever I'm in CNY! I learned about, and tried, many craft beers from all over NYS...."
Terri Cook
"Very clean and inviting. 60 beers on tap is amazing. Fun little area upstairs to relax..."
Jay Engels
"My wife had a delicious lunch. I started out with a flight of craft beers. There were 62 to choose from so you couldn't go wrong. My wife had a..."
Jim McTague
"It was my first time visiting and Justin took great care of me. The Raspberry Wheat ale is by far my favorite. The food was delicious. Cheese pizza..."
Vanessa Rodriguez
"Loved my first time visit. Awesome beer selection, great service, tasty food. I look forward my next..."
charlie baldwin
"Great place. They have 62 different beers on tap that are constantly changing. A great variety to choose from and pretty much all from local..."
Benjaman Walter
"Great place to get some Finger Lakes beers! They offer a good variety of tasting options including curated flights with different themes, build your..."
Andy Guerriero
"We love this place and try to visit when are in Skaneateles. First of all, I'm a dark beer drinker. It is so awesome to go to a bar and actually..."
Brooke G
"This place has it right, great selection of beers much much more than just IPAs. Stop in and try new..."
Dennis Voulopos
"First time coming here. This is place is exactly what I have been looking for! They have 62 beers on tap all from the local area. It's nice finding a..."
Whitney Beaird
"So many.good beers. The Vanilla port was my favorite. The food was good we enjoyed the corn beef wrap. Everything was reasonably priced we will..."
AMOS MOCK
"Wow what a selection. Been here a few times and everytime I am amazed by their offerings. Always busy yet staff are welcoming and service is prompt...."
Mark J. Radzikowski
"Great selection of about 60 beers, mostly regional. The pretzel sticks are also excellent. There are high and low top tables plus couches in the main..."
Andrew Little
"60 different beers on tap, most from within an hours drive. Sure, a couple taps dedicated to the big box brewers, but there's got to be some..."
Chuck Bergquist
"They had lots of food choices for beer, there was about 60 choices. The ones that my group tried were all good! They have food options, we only tried..."
Attilio Lospinoso
"A fantastic selection (62 on tap!) of beers from the region. Service was excellent, as were the couple small plates we had. Definitely worth a trip..."
michael ford
"Great beer menu. Food menu is limited. The food was good but not a lot of choice. No kids menu so big loss on my picket eater who did not like..."
E Brooke Lerner
"Even though it specializes in beer, they also have some very nice Finger Lakes wine. A very good Reuben Wrap with nice sides of baked beans and..."
Judi Miladin
"this comfortable little place has 62 taps of great beers, 90% of them from NY state brewers...I'm a serious beer guy - I opened the first homebrew..."
alby tarzia
"Excellent concept, occupying the relatively untapped middle ground between a general beer bar and a full-on brewpub. A vast selection of central New..."
Neil Gregie
Johnny Angel's Heavenly Hamburgers
Johnny Angel's Heavenly Hamburgers
83/100 (1403 ratings)
Quick Bites
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Hamburgers
Beef
Salad
French Fries
Veggie Burger
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
"Great food! The prices are high which is expected in this town, but you get value for your money! I got a kids meal because I wasn't that hungry, and..."
Emilee Durkin
"Great people and great food! Menu had so many amazing choices to choose from, we didn’t know what to eat! Our picks were..."
A s-v
"Great selection of burgers and sandwiches. Tried the guacamole burger and fries. My husband got the smokehouse bbq burger with sweet potato fries...."
Deb Milligan
"Holy Mo#%÷r of %&*#st! I cant believe I never eaten here in the 8 years I've been living here. Wow wow wow!!! Awesome burgers! Super fresh and super..."
Eddie R
"I love this place. I am a lover of all burgers and Johnny Angels allows me to eat whatever burger my heart desires. They also have milkshakes and..."
Allyson Brevetti
"I am so sad to see this place close. My family and I went a few months ago and had a bit of a hiccup waiting on milkshakes. We had finished our meals..."
Jodi Prell
"Hear me: Jonny Angels has the best breakfast food in New York State. It is the best hang-over remedy, I have been told. Everything hot off the grill..."
misty schutt
"Great menu selection. A few vegetarian options. Offer gluten free buns as well. Breakfast is also..."
Nick Tubbs
"Really good burgers and shakes. Pleasant..."
Karen Breeding
"Great burgers and more! They have a salad bar like area where you put your own toppings on your burgers. Best burger in town! The prices are high but..."
Dj Krom
"Staff was patient, polite and bubbly! Enjoyable experience beginning from placing the order on the phone all the way to picking up the order! Our..."
Jessica Schroeder
"Fresh fresh food! Expect it to take a few minutes to cook your order. Everything is made to order, fresh, with fresh meats and breads. Great portion..."
Greg
"Me and the Mrs. in the village on a recent Saturday. We kayaked on the water. Beautiful day and we both got burgers and fries. They were delicious..."
Wired Paul
"The food here is so good. The service was great and I will definitely be back for another burger. Great portions and prices. I love this place,..."
Alexandra Grove
"Nice spot for burgers and sides. Prices are a bit high, but quality is very good. They have a nice fixings bar where you can load up your burger and..."
Ezra Wegbreit
"Check out $4 Thursdays. You can get a half-pound burger for $4. It's a great deal. Johnny Angels is an informal burger restaurant where you can top..."
Steve Keeler
"Type of service is quite unusual. You wait in line to put in your order and pay. Find your place to sit and wait for them to call your name, then..."
james shaver
Valentine's Delicatessen
Valentine's Delicatessen
82/100 (446 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Pizza
American
Deli
Deli
American
Fast Food
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Wings
Sandwiches
Fast food
American
Deli
Pizza
Wheelchair Accessible
Delivery
Takeout
Seating
Lunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Cheap Eats
"Best pizza and wings south of Syracuse. I spent 14 years working in pizza shops and am very picky about my pizza. I choose Valentine’s every time..."
Joe Troup
"Stopped in for lunch on a day trip - great selection, good prices, and the best tasting (and looking) calzone I’ve ever had. If you’re ever..."
Jeremy Bowker
"Love this place. The staff are always curious and helpful. The pizza here is delicious and the subs are also filling and freshly made. This is one my..."
Amberlee Guerin
"Best pizza around the area! Haven't had pizza this good (and wings & salad) in a long..."
Amber Novack Landers
"Great Service To start and comfortable setting of you have kids. Prices are great I fed six people for under 26$ ! Great bang for your buck we..."
Brian Mckevitt
"Friendly staff. Excellent selection of items to eat and drink. One of my favorite spots in the..."
Steve Rossi
"This is an outstanding place to visit in Skaneateles, right across from the lake with good food and outstanding service. If I could eat here everyday..."
Jim O'Connor
"We liked everything and will return soon. A perfect place to..."
Dorothea Bradley
"Great pizza/ food/..."
George Stella
"Pizza was overall really great and well priced. Many different types of "by the slice" were ready to eat. I would give their cheese pizza a 3 star,..."
Ryan Sanderson
"We stopped into this wonderful place during the Dickens Christmas 2023 festival and could not have left any happier. They have a great selection of..."
Norm Shea
"I love valentines for me it’s the last thing that makes this town what it is I been getting pizza here my whole life and hope I can continue to for..."
Zac
"The service was superb and the pizza is to die for. I recommend the sausage & pepperoni, buffalo wing, and waffle fries. I will definitely be back..."
Jessica Fernandez
"I moved to Skaneateles from Ohio recently. I'm a guy who feels that home isn't quite "Home" until one has found a blistering local pizza joint. Well,..."
Derrick Niese
"We had a Hawaiian pizza and chicken wings. They were very good! We ordered from the boat, hoping they could deliver to the pier (directly across the..."
Jamie H
"Ordered a large pizza July 4th evening... it was absolutely delicious and cooked perfectly! Not surprised since we always have delicious meals there...."
Midlakes Navigation
"Always a great stop for lunch. Many varieties of fresh slices always available along with hot and cold sandwiches and wraps made to..."
tyler dixon
"Great spot for pizza and wings. The sandwiches looked fantastic too but we didn't try them. We ordered and the food was ready quickly. The wings were..."
Marshall
"It's worn out but the food is really good. The pizza is more NYC style and the sammiches are very good. They also have beer in the cooler. 🤟 The..."
TheKmankman4321
Bluewater Grill
Bluewater Grill
82/100 (2790 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Seafood
Seafood
Vegan Options
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Fajitas
Calamari
Cheeseburger
Nachos
Tuna
moscow mule
Burger
Toasts
Calamares
Shrimp Tacos
Poke Bowls
Salmon
Baked Brie
Lobster Bisque
Shrimp
Build Your Own Bloody Mary
Steak and Shrimp
Beef
Cakes
Kabuki Lobster & Goat Cheese Salad
Crab Cake
Fish Tacos
Fish
Grilled Salmon Siracusa
Chowder
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Pork
Bluewater Nachos
Lobster Roll
Chicken Wings
Lobster
Poke Bowl
Tapas
Cheeseburger
Fish Taco
French Onion Soup
Salad
Clam Chowder
Tacos
Clam Chowder
Creamy Cajun Chicken Penne
Swordfish
Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich
Crab
Ribs
Bloody Mary Bar
Scallops
Chips and Pico De Gallo
Clams
Sandwiches
Sit down
American
Seafood
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Late Night
Lunch
Brunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Have been here several times and have had great food every time! Our server did a fantastic job & the Sunday Bloody Mary Bar is amazing. We would..."
Kim DeBasio Noblot
"A regular stop for us as locals...food and drink are spot on and the staff is amazing.... no disappointments ....sit, sip, and surrender to a couple..."
Susan Burch Taylor
"One of the best cocktails I've had in awhile (black cherry and pomegranate margarita) in what I can only assume was a chilled glass based on how long..."
Jen Plouffé
"Service was fast, staff was friendly and welcoming. I absolutely recommend the bang bang scallops..."
Anne Napper
"Love this place. My daughter lives nearby and come often to visit. It's becoming a tradition to come here for lunch before my flight home to Florida...."
Michelle Schlegel Jordan
"The Service and food were excellent. What a great treat to have come across this gem on our trip. My steak was perfect. Thank..."
Tim Sheridan
"Good food. Ordered the nachos and the portion was enough for 4..."
Karin Williams
"We went for my daughter BIRTHDAY lunch. Had appetizer brie with apples and candies nuts. Had lobster bisque and their sweet potatoe with roasted..."
Ginger McQueeney
"We love this place! Food is always excellent and service as well. Tried the Bloody Mary bar yesterday and what a treat! Brunch in a glass! Keep..."
Terri Lemery
"The Manager at the place we were staying for Dickens in the Village suggested Blue Water Grill to us for lunch or dinner. We appreciated it. Location..."
Cindy Madar
"We love the lobster roll, and the fries are quite good. They can be busy and don't take reservations for parties of less than six. But, they will..."
N N
"The food was awesome, especially the lobster goat cheese salad! The service was excellent,..."
Melissa V Schmidt
"We will definitely be good. I enjoyed the baked Brie and southwest sushi roll. My family enjoyed the burger, curry chicken, and Nashville hot chicken..."
Justine Phillips Heiner
"Was surprised I didn’t see any reviews of the English Pub curry. It was terrific! Basically your typical Indian style tikka masala. Mild to..."
T
"Needed a place to grab a bite and kill some time. The wait was over an hour but we took seats at the back bar that had no wait. Service and food were..."
Sarah Eldred
"Excellent grill and diner on the lakefront in Skaneatles. Good quality food and nice..."
Csaba Csaki
"Very good restaurant, overlooking the lake. Good food, good drinks and very nice service...."
Gianluca Manzoni
"Wonderful ambiance right on Skaneateles Lake. The chicken bites were wonderful and full of flavor from the honey and soy marinade. The brunch burger..."
Nikoli's Kitchen
"One of our favorite places to go every Summer/Fall. We love sitting in the outside area up top in the back looking out over the lake. Fantastic food..."
Paul Heagerty