My wife and I have made this our favorite place to start or end a night and all in between. Great staff, great food, great music.....especially if Josie (Jody) is serving.
My first time here was for lunch, "comfort food" on a cold day. The chicken pot pie was delicious!!! Portion size was huge. Will definitely go back..
Food is amazing and staff is even better! Love our neighborhood place~
Kristen Mancarella-Healey
+5
We love McColley’s! We have never been disappointed with our food or the service. The Guinness Beef Stew is my husbands favorite and the French Onion Soup & Chicken Spiedie Hoagie is mine.
The food and service is amazing. I need to come back each week to try the burger of the week. They never disappoint. Worth the trip to Spencerport.
We went on a whim when the other restaurants we wanted to go to were closed, but are happy that we ended up there! It was small and had a smaller menu, but both entrees were excellent and the service was great. It was a Monday night, so it was a quiet cozy atmosphere. We will go back!
Great wait staff. Beef stew was delish, lots of variety in beer, nice atmosphere. Good place for girls night!
I absolutely love the bit of Irish in our little burb! We ate there when they were just beginning & their Ruebens are better each time we faire.
We just had a beer and bar food. The food was great and the staff was even better
Awesome food, drink and service! Thank you for a wonderful dining experience! The PB&J burger was to die for!
Fabulous food & drinks, friendly attentive staff & warm welcoming atmosphere!! First time there last night with the Mr... We will definitely be back!
I'm thrilled mussels are back on the menu. The food is so good there and I love the friendly atmosphere.
Little hidden gem! Place looks tiny from the front and it's like Narnia inside! Keep walking through and you'll find more rooms and more treasure! Lovely back bar that opens to the outside area! Food is incredible staff is friendly and knowledgeable. We drove 1300 mi around Ireland last October and visited many pubs, Atmosphere here is reminiscent of true Irish pub! A Must visit!
Great food, have tried many of the dishes there. Have yet to be dissatisfied. The BLT is amazing. Chicken bacon apple salad was great fresh and gluten free. The gluten free options are minimal but helpful.
Went there today for lunch. Very first time vowing and will for sure return. Service was the best! Food was great and a large menu. Loved the atmosphere as well. Our waitress Jenna was perfect. Best lobster bisque and BLT around. Tons of bacon and huge sandwich.
Delicious food and cold drinks! My burger was cooked to perfection! The Reuben balls are also amazing!
We've been there twice, and even on a Friday night the wait isn't very long. The wings are great- just the right level of being crispy and evenly coated with sauce (instead of it being in a puddle at the bottom of the basket). I had the chicken pot pie. It is a huge serving & I took home a good portion of it. My husband had the Bison burger & was very happy with it. This place is a gem in Spencerport.
The bar area was a little claustrophobic for me but once we got seated it was very nice. Excellent service and I really enjoyed the fish frey. Good beer selection as you might imagine...
Great food! It is very rare to go out to a restaurant and have everyone enjoy their meal! I had the Turkey Club and house made Potato Salad, everything was perfect! Cozy atmosphere & wonderful service. I will definitely be going back!
Amazing local pub. The best burger around and fantastic wings. The wings are actually sizable and flavorful unlike most other places these days. Staff is friendly, the bar is very small, but really small town feel and still comfortable. They have nice indoor and outdoor seating and its right on the canal. Highly recommend if you want takeout or dine-in in the area! There is also ample public parking in the lot by the canal.
I've eaten here a few times and the service and food is great, had burgers and they were perfectly flavorful and delicious.
I loved the food and drink I had I went with friends this past Sunday it was very good and our waitress was very patient and nice
Went for lunch with my mom today, and the food was amazing as well as the service! New favorite spot!
One of my favorite places to go😃! The food specials are always superbly created and the regular menu is very good as well. The fish fry is huge! I always appreciate a nice beer selection that covers various beer styles and breweries and my wife is entertained by their creative cocktail list.
Had BLT and soda at lunch. Other party had a salad.
Both lunches were very good.
It was a hot day and they had fans running to supplement the AC.
Great food, delicious food. Huge portions. Our waitress was fabulous.
Good american-irish food. Though not truly a traditional Irish pub, the atmosphere is Irish and the menu reflects an Irish flair.
We only ordered a salad and the Reuben Fritters. The salad was fresh and tasty. The Reuben Fritters are a rare and special treat.
Wonderful service. Server helped us navigate around menu/wine list . Food is great too !
Foid was amazing! Burger was cooked to desired specs perfectly.
By far, the best corned beef sandwich I
have had. Service great.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes