Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in St. Marys
4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Great authentic pizza and pasta. It’s a local spot, the owner is super nice and is the only cook. Fair priced for the quality you get. If you want..."
S Wood
"The best Italian food and pizza in Camden County! They serve a really nice lunch buffet for cheap.
They also offer authentic N.Y. style pizza by the..."
Kathleen Leahy
"Why have I not been to this place the whole four years I've lived here?! This is some amazing Italian! So good! I can't believe they weren't busier!..."
April Spaniol
"Excellent food.....however the wait was extremely long. I am assuming it is a made to order restaurant. The menu or the waitress didnot say anything..."
Marla Wegrzyn
"Excellent every time. This restaurant is a hidden jewel. Perfect New York style pizza every time. Great customer service. I feel at home every time..."
LaHonda M
"Service was great and pizza was amazing. Probably my new favorite restaurant. Gotta try it if you're looking for a good local place to..."
Taylor Willhite
"This place is amazing! their pizza is delicious and the service has been awesome at all hours of the day. and everything there is super fresh. best..."
Jennifer Chandler
"Papa Luigi's a resturant that is friendly and very family friendly, the staff is great, the Owner is a compasoinate man. He's old time Italian..."
Sherry Kelly
"Food is always great. I eat here at least once a..."
John Barron
"Excellent Service & Great Food! The New Owner, Wants To Know You Enjoyed Your Experience. He's Always Willing To Accommodate. Friendly Serving..."
Johnny Buna
"Best pizza around! The owner is also the cook... you can taste the love that is put into his..."
Rick Wahl
"I MUST SAY THE PAPA LUIGI'S ITALIAN RESTAURANT IS VERY GOOD. THE SERVICE WAS GREAT, THE PIZZA WAS THE BEST I HAVE HAD DOWN HERE IN SOUTHEEN..."
Mary Moreau
"Great pizza! Love the Mom & Pop feel! Very personable. Seriously the BEST PIZZA AROUND..."
Ashley Naron
"The food here is excellent. The waitress was the only one on duty. She did a great job in spite of a few..."
"Great spot for a bite! Love the entry with deli and dessert cases. Cannolis are made fresh to order!!! Golden ambiance with soft lighting for the..."
Melissa Jedlicka
"The best Italian food I’ve ever had. The atmosphere is incredible and everybody there really cares about the food they make for their customers...."
Connor LaCava
"We were on our way to Savannah and on the way we were looking for a quick lunch spot. We searched for a place around us and decided to have lunch at..."
nishant narula
"The best restaurant in St. Mary’s if you are gluten free! Pizza and pasta all celiac safe and insanely knowledgeable staff. The food is..."
Carolyn Cohen
"the workers at the counter were welcoming and helpful, along with the man who brought out our food, i believe possibly the chef? very kind people and..."
Melani Stover
"Visited this for the first time and everything about it was wonderful. I had the Italian. It was Freshly made and delicious. I will definitely go..."
Nanette Schmader
"We had the pizza, cheese sticks, and a cheese cake today! It was all amazing! Quick and friendly service also, we will now be getting all of out..."
Curtis Renfrow
"This is my favorite place in town. Everything has been completely on point. I tried to have a different one of their panini sandwiches every other..."
Jlynn D
"Unbelievable experience at this particular establishment. The Chicken Parm was absolutely fantastic, moist and succulent! The Eggplant Parm was..."
Benjamin Gillespie
"Absolutely the best pizza and Italian food in this area! Loved the atmosphere and the staff were very friendly and welcoming! Service was top..."
J Gillespie
"The Food and service was awesome. This is my new favorite spot! We had the Chicken Parm ( no cheese) and the Papa' club both were scrumptious. ..."
RDMJ
"We loved this restaurant. We drove from Amelia Island to try it out. The food is excellent! The balcony upstairs is beautiful and overlooks a golf..."
FAWN AVANT
"Fantastic experience! Nice people, good food, clean environment, and great atmosphere! Loved it..."
Sarah Sanderson
"Delicious! Chicken Parmesan was perfection, with just the right amount of Italian spices and flavor. The Chicken and Brocolli Ziti was was served..."
Heather DuBose
"Very nice Sicilian Café. Good service, good food and friendly atmosphere. Lots to choose from on the menu. Stopped for lunch and enjoyed my..."
msw 10
"This was my first time trying this place, and it was delicious. A good variety of food to choose from, nice employees, good seating. I highly..."
Liberty Boyer
"The best sandwich I've had in years. Wonderful people. I'm the guy from Connecticut, thanks for a wonderful..."
B B
"Had the godfather and cypress paninis the food was great! The atmosphere score was because the only tables available were out front and there were..."
"Hannah was awesome as our server! Food was great and with perfect portions! Love this..."
Adventures of Ben & Amanda
"Best slice of pizza I’ve had in years! Traveling for work from Indiana to Florida and Georgia! Highly recommend to anyone in the..."
Michael S
"Just really good NY Style pizza! Quick update... I have been back many times and tried several items and everything is just delightful. The..."
Chris Manning
"First time probably one time visit just passing thru, had Lasagna and wife had mushroom Swiss burger. Did takeout and food was prepared quickly...."
Gary Landis
"The one on St.Marys is quieter and more family oriented. The one in Kingsland is a younger crowd more sports bar atmosphere. Both have excellent..."
Mi BG
"We came in about an hour before closing and they made the food fresh and it was so hot it was unbelievably good.
the garlic bread was hot and..."
John S
"I had the stuffed shells with Alfredo sauce and it was delicious! The waitress was on time and very..."
Sunny Lang
"Excellent selections - calzone (A+), lasagna (A+), pizza (A+). Dessert - try the Zep (Ops version on beignets). Don’t miss this..."
Michael Cloin
"It was pretty good. I didn't expect much, but the pizza was delicious and the staff were friendly. You can tell they use quality ingredients in their..."
Chris Dal Porto
"This place was awesome! Staff was great. Super fast and good food. Glad we went and will go..."
"Tasty food, friendly staff, & reasonable prices. We ate here twice on our visit in St. Mary's & enjoyed it both times. Offer many different options..."
Emily S
"Service was wonderful. I had the almond- crusted grouper. Holy moly! That was so delicious. Kids had a burger and chicken sandwich and both were done..."
M Lopez
"The food was brought promptly and delicious. The wait staff was friendly and..."
Closet Gremlin
"Great little place off the beaten path just make sure you have correct..."
Billie Blom BJ
"I didn't expect to find a great Italian restaurant in this little town, but Pauly's was wonderful. We had the chicken parmesan and the chicken..."
Robert H.
"Amazing, I had the twin tournedos and there are not word to describe how delicious it was. My girlfriend had the Primavera and ate every last bite...."
Mat Canix
"Polly's Cafe with quaint great customer service the food was wonderful. We both had the pasta my husband having the clam and mushroom and I had the..."
Barbara Turner
"Great place to go and unwind from work. Food is great wait staff are very friendly the customers are friendly and welcoming to visitor's. Prices are..."
Michele Nuzum
"Go see Kelly at the Tiki Hut!!! She's the hostesses with the mostess! Always in the know with the locals and keeps a great mix of convo for..."
Stacy McGill
"The food here is great, lots of flavor. Service was excellent..."
Joy Newman
"Good homemade food. Good music. Excellent staff. Friendly attentive service from Joy. Excellent food from chef, Eric. We are locals and come back..."
Greg Smith
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes