Best Bagels in Stillwater

3 restaurant menus in Stillwater, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Bruegger's Bagels
Bruegger's Bagels
85/100 (121 ratings)
Bakeries
French
French
Bagels
French
"My fiancés brother had nothing but pleasant things to say about his cinnamon bagel with cream cheese. He couldn’t get over how perfect the cream..."
Ben Schwarz
"My go-to place for a quick breakfast. Always friendly and fast. Not sure how long they can keep up the free coffee with online ordering, but it sure..."
Roger Williams
"Stopped in today for bagels and jalapeno cream cheese. They have the best( believe me, I've tried them all over town). Received the best customer..."
rose lindell
"I think this place is fantastic! Since reopening it's a whole new crew but great to see familiar faces! Ellie is the friendliest and most hip worker..."
Gus Bradley
"The app was very buggy when we stopped by a few weekends ago. My fiancé was getting so frustrated trying to redeem a couple offers. We just went..."
Steph Komorouski
"I live in Wisconsin and I’ve yet to find better bagels than here. They are delicious and the service is fantastic. Emily is the best. Very helpful..."
Cheyenne Lindell
Old School Bagel Cafe
82/100 (633 ratings)
Quick Bites
Bakeries
Fast food
Fast Food
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Bagels
Fast food
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"We used to have a bagel place right by our house and it closed down, so I got jealous visiting this restaurant in Stillwater. Lots of different..."
Eat To The Beat
"Great Food & Service. One of my favorite spots in town! The Pioneer Bagel is a must! Family friendly, clean and quick..."
Ashley Smith
"My favorite sandwich shop in town, by far!! Worth every penny. They let you modify any way you want. Always fast and friendly..."
Brittany Dilley
"Very fast good service. Very clean. Tasty menu selection! Servers are very..."
Simberleigh
"Super!. Great coffee, best in town! I wish you sold the coffee grounds, I would buy them! I also like how you don't skimp on the cream cheese, LOVE..."
Pete
"4 Cheese goodness. I cannot stop eating the 4 Cheese bagel sandwich. It's like a ooey-gooey grilled cheese sandwich on an awesome selection of fresh..."
Krisl_33
"Quick service, even during the busy lunch hour. Not a fan of bagel sandwiches so I get mine on a croissant and I love..."
Lolly
"LOVE, LOVE, LOVE this place. Clean, cozy, and the staff is incredibly nice. These sandwiches are hands down the best in town. Their bagels are always..."
Lauren
"Wish I had tried it sooner!. I had the Mile High sandwhich on an Everything bagel with a side of baked potato salad. It was delicious! Then I a went..."
Toni
"The bagels are great! And it's very well..."
Clay
"They're Back!. Real bagels the right way! Love..."
Claire
"This bagel cafe.......I'm from New York, and all I can say is, it tastes like home again. One of the only things I miss about ny is the food. And now..."
Amanda Meddley
"Decent food, meets standards in service. This place isn't nothing to WOW over but for a delicious breakfast bagel or a pass by lunch it's a nice..."
Ivan Gafiltha
"The counter service was excellent. Very nice staff. Also prices seemed very reasonable. My reason for taking a star off is this, they dont have plain..."
Taylor W
"I was surprised to find such a good bagel shop! Different cream cheeses and bagels of all sorts to choose. I was surprised to find the bagels and..."
Joseph Prater
Panera Bread
Panera Bread
75/100 (927 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Soups
Cafe
Soups
Cafe
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Salad
Bagels
Sit down
American
Soups
Café
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Well it’s a Panera… The food seems to universally be the same. Usually somewhat tasty, but a bit on the cafeteria food side of things. Reheated..."
Michael Teicheira
"this place serves healthy food, friendly staff, so accomodating.. i ordered the thai soup! its really really..."
princess laranas
"I like Panera breads, especially their sourdough and basil-tomato bread and croissants. Breads are relatively expensive but worth it. Staff is..."
Indu Bala Grover
"The ambience is lovely and comfortable for working or studying (if you can find the 3-4 tables near the charging socket). I worked for hours there..."
Tonmoy Paul
"Good seating available, large parking lot, variety of choices, multiple combo options, good coffee. Curbside pickup orders for beverages is sometimes..."
Milind Sali
"Panera Bread is a nice, and clean store, with great employees. Stopped for a coffee and a pastry. Coffee, and pastry were good. They have a to choose..."
Monte H
"I really like Panera, it’s cozy and a good place to work. I like the foods and beverages too but I don’t know why my last two visit went wrong. I..."
Sahel Zaboli