Best Lobster Roll in Stonington

7 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Stonington Ice Cream Company
Stonington Ice Cream Company
92/100 (147 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Restaurants
Fast food
Seafood
American
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Ice Cream
Lobster Roll
Fast food
American
Seafood
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Go for the lobster rolls! Stay for the ice cream ! And don't miss the gallery next..."
Jan Nekola Watson
"Lobster rolls are fantastic! The view is out of this world..."
Marcia Nadeau
"We discovered this hidden gem 8 or so years ago when we stopped in for an ice cream. Their ice cream is excellent but we soon learned that they had..."
Tom Hains
"Came for the lobster roll but ended up loving the smoked haddock sandwich even more! Everything was delicious. We also came back a second time and..."
Kateland Oakes
"This place is always there when you're hungry, whether it's for food or ice cream. The ice cream always draws a crowd and the sandwiches are..."
Timothy Greiwe (Bet ha_Khaiim)
"Hands-down, the best lobster roll in the entire state of Maine. I dream about these all..."
Philomena Mattes
"Great food, quick service, good selection of sandwiches, lobster rolls, and ice..."
Seth M
"Smoked salmon sandwich and Lobster roll were both..."
Justin Stumpf
"Great sandwiches - we had the haddock and the roast tenderloin. The sauce on the haddock is so ridiculously good that if you put it in a napkin,..."
Nina Arnold
"This ice cream was a perfect afternoon snack, while waiting for Stonington restaurants to open. The blueberry ice cream was delicious! I loved being..."
Marissa Zane
"Excellent ice cream, loaded lobster..."
Bill Hong
"This is my go-to place for take out lobster rolls. It's a very small walk-up shack with a few outdoor dining tables. They have a fairly exttensive..."
Judi Glenn Jacobs
"Best lobster roll in the state! Everything is good. Reminder that do few things but do them well is a great model! Man they just nail..."
Jonathan Hearn
"Excellent lobster rolls and a very lovely proprietor..."
Carrie Pena
"Delicious lobster roll! Definitely one of the freshest I have eaten! Only complaint would be the bread was a little to soft and didn’t hold..."
Andrew T.
"Five stars for this life saver, bc, in case you don't know, no restaurant in Stonington is open on Mondays, except this place, which had lobster..."
Scott Pactor
"Hands down, one of the best places to get a lobster roll! Great location, super ice cream and really tasty lobster rolls. This place is a..."
Frederick
"Real nice place, the young girl working there very pleasant. The icecream was Delicious, no other word to describe it. Well worth the Stop. You will..."
Donald Flynn
"Got the Deer Tracks ice cream, which was espresso coffee with fudge and chocolate candy bars... it was delicious. Not overwhelming with coffee flavor..."
MF16
"Super casual counter service, high quality lobster roll served promptly with outdoor seating in downtown..."
Randy Greenberg
Stonecutters Kitchen
Stonecutters Kitchen
87/100 (395 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Seafood
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Fish Taco
Fish & chips
Tacos
Haddock
Fried Clams
Lobster
Salad
Fish
Clam Chowder
Scallops
Clams
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Sandwiches
Tapas
Burger
Sit down
American
Bar
Seafood
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Wheelchair Accessible
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"I've never eaten a whole 12 inch pizza by myself, but am well on my way. We ordered 3 tonight for the family and all voted that your our new pizza go..."
Cathy McGuire
"Fried clams are the best! First time lobster pizza ! Yummy! Crabmeat roll delicious! We sat outside on the deck. Awesome view .Listening to tourists..."
Robin Larson-Clarke
"Arielle worked alone tonight and made my pizza and Pats sandwich and they were both the best we ever had! The chips were warm, his roll was toasted..."
Emily Elizabeth
"Went down tonight to the new and improved stonecutters kitchen. The food was phenomenal. The service was great. 5 stars all the way great job to the..."
Justin Kyle Betts
"What's to say...Outstanding food/ excellent beer choices (and very cold) and great staff with a view that goes beyond go smacked jaw dropping..."
Marse Amory
"Went in for lunch today. I had the haddock burger and my friend had a lobster roll and we had onion rings with them. The food was excellent and the..."
Nanita Hardie
"Have to say, pretty impressed. My dad n I ordered two small chef's club's sandwiches. They were loaded. You got my appoval...."
Tom Simmons
"The food is delicious and they know how to make a great pizza amoung other yummy food...."
Sarah Betts
"Love this place. The food is great, waitress was wonderful and the owner Tony was awesome. Thanks for always making our visit one we always have..."
Susan Shurig
"The people are friendly and the food is great. It boosts a very comfortable..."
Keith W. Stillwagon
"Excellent! fast and efficient and the food was wonderful! Keep up the good..."
Megan Rae
"Great food and very clean. Wonderful greeting when we walked in and great view. Very good service and great..."
Greg Day
"Love the variety of foods offered and the food is..."
Deena Staples
"We always enjoy our food and service at Stonecutters. The greek stonecutter pizza is always my go. We also throroughly enjoyed our breakfast there..."
Monica
"Great place for standards and unique dishes. Super friendly staff - fish tacos are really good - The pizzas have quite imaginative toppings (like..."
Cory Whitney
"Fun pub with friendly service, great views, and yummy fried seafood. Cook was accommodating for request for grilled, not fried, fish. Chicken Caesar..."
Valerie Flanagan
"July 2023 visit- Hammer and Chizel Pizza was good, could have used more sauce. (I asked for a container of sauce and I received it. Still needed a..."
Heather Hinrichs
"We ate here twice on a recent trip to Deer Isle. Fun casual place with good food. Service was good. The fish sandwich was very good. So were the..."
Tammy Craig
"Really enjoyed the lobster roll! Our server was very friendly and accommodating. We ate lunch in and then ordered to go clam chowder and peanut..."
Katy Overbay
"We loved this place, beautiful view of the harbor, table of 4 got in right away. Good draft beer selection. Very generous portions, the food was..."
David Jackson
"Excellent spot on a beautiful island. Great views from the patio. The waitress was very good and nice, and service was fast even when busy. Decent..."
Jessica Benedict
"Best fried clams ever. I am from Maine so know a bit about clams. These were literally the best ever. The veggie pizza is amazing too. Great staff..."
Dennis Harris
"Service was great,nice atmosphere right on the water. Food was good, but a little pricey.$25 for the seafood chowder. Only $15 for the haddock tacos..."
Mike Kyzer
"Take out was a little rough. We didn't get our full order twice. Breakfast option was brand new. Expected a seafood breakfast option and there..."
E J
"Dude this place’s pizza blew me away. I was not expecting that. They over did it on my wife’s toppings, but mine was incredible. I got some bbq..."
Mattthew Luffred
"Was in Stonington for three nights recently, had pizzas from Stonecutters Kitchen the first night. They were so good, went back again for takeout the..."
Ed V
"Awesome spot, sat on deck. Make a reservation so you don’t have to wait. Summer salad with spinach goat cheese etc is so good. Very big. Fried..."
Barry Witham
"Had takeout here last night. My family had haddock bites and onion rings they said were delicious. I had a sandwich on gluten free bread bc of an..."
Tricia Connors
"Thank you so much for an amazing food, service And atmosphere!!! After kayaking all morning. It just felt so relaxing to enjoy a meal on the porch...."
Leanna Tucker
"Great place to eat and hangout on the island. I visited there recently and loved it. Food was great cant wait to go..."
t
Breakwater
Breakwater
87/100 (1495 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
American
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Salmon
Pesto
Shrimp
Fish
Chowder
Fish & Chips
Lobster
Lobster Roll
Tapas
Pasta
Fish Taco
Salad
Tacos
Clam Chowder
Cod
Scallops
Fish & chips
Swordfish
Clams
Oyster
Calamari
Mussels
Bread Pudding
Tuna
Burger
Ceviche
Calamares
Bruschette
Sit down
American
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Seating
Accepts American Express
Table Service
Waterfront
Wheelchair Accessible
Accepts Discover
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"What a wonderful, wonderful place to eat. We had a party of 12 that was accommodated so well, with such ease and professional manners. The Breakwater..."
Paula Muir Casey
"Beautiful sunset view on the water with so many sail boats to look at! Service was impeccable, our server was Kimmy. Very attentive! � Food was..."
Lisa Bronx Malverty
"Stayed at the inn this past weekend and loved that this restaurant was in walking distance! Service was great and the food was incredible!! The sun..."
Amanda Fenner
"Excellent all around. We had a large graduation party, and the staff was wonderful. Service drinks and food were excellent, and you cannot beat the..."
Holly Potter
"Great atmosphere! Delicious food and our server Justin was a delight! Can’t wait for out next sunset..."
Maureen Thayer
"Love this place! Great food, service, ambiance, etc, etc! We highly recommend..."
Karen Horan-Silva
"Amazing views as you dine on the water, delicious food...Oysters, Calamari, Lobster mac'n'cheese, Apple Crisp. Timely and friendly staff and service,..."
Danny L. Reyes
"I love this place! I go every time I visit my mom. It is surrounded by water. It has an outside deck for dining too. The service has always been..."
Heather Polony Argenio
"Great food and loved the location. We came for dinner and did the prix fixe menu and it was delicious! The butternut squash soup was amazing, and..."
Vivian P
"We always enjoy going to Breakwater! This restaurant is always consistent with its food, cocktails and service. The wife and I have found that one..."
Kevin Haggerty
"Great, friendly service. Yummy drinks. Delicious food. We ordered Hot Buttered Lobster Roll and Grilled Shrimp Tacos. Highly recommend..."
Christine Newton
"First I must comment on its location, driving through the beautiful historic town of Stonington you will find this beautiful restaurant on the water..."
Armie P
"Excellent food and we enjoyed the entire time we were there! The salads were fresh and crispy, we asked for extras (anchovies, dressing) because it..."
Deb
"So Stonington is terrible at parking for handicap and the parking lot was full at 4:30. This restaurant is totally about the ambiance. Absolutely..."
T H
"Excellent food and service with an outstanding water view. The server was so personable and she accomadated a few special requests required by my two..."
Mike Pedraza
"Great lobster roll and swordfish wrap. They make their own potato chips too. Staff was very friendly and..."
Joe DeLisi
Dog Watch Cafe
Dog Watch Cafe
87/100 (3607 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Soups
Bar
Vegan Options
Asian
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
American
Soups
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Burger
Cod
Crab
Swordfish
Scallops
Fish Sandwich
Clams
Oyster
Calamari
Noodle
Surf And Turf
Mussels
Shrimp
Tortillas
Tuna
Fish & chips
Nachos
Calamares
BLT
Salmon
Lobster
Kale Salad
Bouillabaisse
Pasta
Cakes
Crab Cake
Salad
Wings
Pesto
Fish & Chips
Clam Chowder
Fish
Lobster Roll
Mac and cheese
Sandwiches
Fried Clams
Sit down
Soups
Seafood
American
Bar
Takeout
Television
Live Music
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Waterfront
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"We had a great evening. Staff was wonderful, even with a dinner crowd on a Friday. A comfortable wait for a table, good drinks, bar was quick and..."
Peter Dion
"What a great place! The outside bar was the coolest, the food inside was amazing! We loved it! Service was excellent by all staff. Great..."
Brittany Paladino
"Outstanding.. wonderful evening out...loved being by the water, the wait staff was friendly and attentive and my lobster roll was stuffed to the..."
Mary Cochran
"Food was amazing. Waitstaff was just the right amount of helpful. Atmosphere was perfect and the view from our table spectacular. I can not wait to..."
Lynette Marie
"Dog Watch Cafe was our kinda place! Great food and great atmosphere!! Would highly recommend it! Lisa at the bar was so friendly and..."
Maddie Jenkins Ouellette
"Absolutely delightful! Wait staff were friendly efficient and accommodating. Food was excellent as was the atmosphere ... and you can’t get a..."
Nat Griswold
"The location and atmosphere is wonderful. Perfect place to stop on our trip to Rhode Island. The service from Sydney was also perfect. It is a very..."
Carol J. Evans
"Good food, great service and just the perfect view of the yacht club and harbor. Parking just across the street (lot) and close to all shops in the..."
Ray Poirier
"We discovered Dog Watch last summer and have been there 3 times . We positively love the atmosphere, the service , and the food is just amazing . It..."
Eileen Sullivan Taylor
"Great food, fast service and a view of the water to die..."
Jeffrey Kagan
"This place is fantastic, everyone is very friendly, great energy and it's right on the water. The food was fresh and flavorful. I stopped in for..."
B.J. Evans
"Excellent meal as usual here.....they have one of the best bouillabaisse in the area. Service is always top notch, friendly and efficient. My wife..."
Kenneth Nogacek
"Came out to the area for a little getaway. Great relax bar restaurant. Food was great and service was fantastic. Looks like it would be very popular..."
Ash Ley
"Celebrated Father's Day a day early at the Dog Watch in Stonington, CT. First things first make sure you make reservations, that will save you a lot..."
James Fox
"Was there last night. Arrived early for our 7:30 reservations and they seated us right away.....at our special date anniversary table❤ We ordered..."
Cheryl Miller
"This is such a great little spot! I went for the second time yesterday, and introduced it to another friend. We ate out on the patio, right on the..."
Stacey
"Always stop here when in the area. Love their baked scallops and soups (Roasted Red Pepper with Gouda). Great location in a historic..."
Steven Vega
"Stopped in here thanks to "Food Lovers' Guide to Connecticut" and the recommendation was well deserved. The calamari with chorizo and banana peppers..."
Leah Good
"Another delightful seaport eatery this time in Stonington. Staff could not have been friendlier and food was delightful. We sat outside and enjoyed..."
Cathy Busick
Stonington Pizza Palace
Stonington Pizza Palace
86/100 (751 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Salmon
Lobster Roll
Pesto
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Television
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Aggies Special is the..."
Kelsey Wetherell
"Great food, esp. Field green salad & pizza. Never had a bad meal. Nice people w/ great personalities. Makes me look forward to coming..."
Pat
"This is a takeout review. All food is eaten fresh in the vehicle. I ordered the Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls and a pepperoni pizza. The Eggrolls were..."
Bruce Provencher
"The loaded fries were great. Full strips of bacon and tons of scallions. The pizza was also really good. My son and I enjoyed our lunch here and even..."
Justin Whalen
"Great pizza, some of the best in the area. Good buffalo wings too. Inside is nice with enough tables so there is never a long wait and the place is..."
Matthew Bilodeau
"Friendly, good price, and great food. We ordered a Cobb salad, chopped pasta salad, and baked ziti. We wanted to order a few slices as well, but they..."
Tyler Hespeler
"The bacon scallop pizza is over the top delicious! We get it with marinara instead of the white sauce, but either way, it's..."
Nichole Neill
"Very good food all around. I personally love the stuffed shells. Good friendly service and a clean..."
Haley Jensen
"Pizza joint in Old fashion New England village... We passed by this place so many times, but this was our first time to stop in and had lunch..."
Credible Critic
Harbor Cafe
Harbor Cafe
85/100 (843 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Cafe
American
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mussels
Grilled cheese
Cakes
Pesto
Fish
Fish & chips
Mussel
Chowder
Shrimp
Fish & Chips
Lobster Roll
Onion
Haddock
Lobster
Lobster Stew
Steamers
Pancakes
Brussels Sprouts
Fried Clams
Haddock Fish and Chips
Pasta
Eggs Benedict
Fish Sandwich
Salad
Lobster Roll
French Fries
Clam Chowder
Clam Chowder
Toasts
Crab
Haddock Sandwich
Omelette
Scallops
Sandwiches
Maine Blueberry Pie
Corned Beef
Clams
Burger
Twin Lobster Dinner
BLT
Sit down
Seafood
Café
American
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Love eating at the Harbor Cafe when we drive up from NY to see family. The food is really good and portions are large. My favorite is the homemade..."
Aleta Beltzer-Frost
"Great breakfast and dinner. Friendly service and reasonable price. Very generous portions. It was also a quick walk across the street from our hotel..."
Maria Michelina
"Always great Reviews. Great night to head over for Suppahah. We lost or propane stove line when a tree fell on it this morning. No stove until..."
Stephen Johnson
"The food was a Excellent and the people very..."
Marie de Armas
"My family and I were visiting from out of town for the first time and the Harbor Cafe made us feel so at home. The chowder, which had smoked fish and..."
Daniel Perry
"We ate lunch at this restaurant and our food was delicious. We shared a meal of Seared Scallops and a bowl of Smoked Haddock and Clam Chowder- they..."
Norma Guyot
"I have eaten here while camping. I was waiting for a ferry to Isle Haut island. The food was very good. I can recommend the cornedbeef hash. The..."
Moving on with Old man river
"The lobster is super fresh and tasty! The room is decorated with beautiful oil paintings . Waited a while for the food and the..."
Yifanova
"Went for breakfast while we were camping in town. Had the western omelette with the blueberry muffin griddled. Muffin is a must try and so good! Iced..."
Courtney Elizabeth
"The lobster dinner for $20 is a steal. The shrimp basket was also great. Fresh and delicious. It's a friendly place, but understaffed like everyone. ..."
L Sproat
"Go for breakfast, and it’s a good breakfast with great coffee. Go for dinner and you’ll keep coming back and make it date night! Surprising..."
Otter Adams
"The corned beef hash was great. It’s not the canned version that is mushy, overly salted, wet, and cut with added fat. It’s scratch cooked and..."
Jonathan Shepard
"Unbelievable friendly staff and great service. Awesome lobster. Market prices were the best here by far. But the best thing was the home made onion..."
Shawn Surma
"The Haddock is fresh and amazing, the chowder is first rate, and for a treat you can get up early in the morning and listen to the locals gossip..."
Ron Day
"Quaint little place with delicious lobster rolls! We like to rate our lobster roll experiences while traveling and this one rated pretty high. I..."
Anthony Passaro
"Vacationing in the area from NJ and came here for lunch on a Sunday! This place sure is busy, and you can tell this is a popular place with the..."
Sarah J. Daudelin
"We ate dinner and lunch while visiting. Chowder, lobster roll, haddock platter delicious. Salads need a little work but in all very good. Coffee..."
Dave MacLeod
"The charming town of Stonington is a major fishing town on Deer Island There is still a shortage of staff so many of the restaurants still..."
Kathy Condon
"I went here in 2019 but want to leave a review - absolutely wonderful and quaint and if I am ever in the area again I will be back. So beautiful and..."
Molly Cooper
"We had the clam chowder, lobster chowder, fried whole belly clam roll and pound and a half of steamers (takeout order) and it was easily some of the..."
Ryan Bliss
Dog Watch
Dog Watch
84/100 (965 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Barbecue
Barbecue
Seafood
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Mac and cheese
Clams
Calamari
Lobster Roll
Ribs
Kale Salad
Fish
Pork
Burger
Lobster
Barbecue
Seafood
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Seating
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"We were there for a 60th birthday party and everything was great! The food was delicious and the wait staff did a great job keeping the buffet..."
Kathy Gladu Connor
"I ordered the brisket, my step daughter ordered the pulled pork. It was the best barbecued food I have had in Connecticut. The baked beans and..."
Ruth Wing-Losen
"Like a backyard BBQ at your best friends house! Wait staff was welcoming and accommodating even when they were being slammed. Good BBQ and seafood...."
Mike Mattei
"Charming hang out, great place to relax enjoy friends, fun food and a menu with a lot of variety! Highly recommend it for anyone looking for a great..."
Bill Williams
"We sat our butts on bar stools! What a blast we had visiting with our server during the Red Sox playoffs! We stuffed our faces with delicious salmon..."
Richard Ward
"My son wanted a relaxed spot for his rehearsal dinner. In spite of the rain, It couldn’t have been better. The food was delicious. We had the..."
Lorraine Orbon
"We love this place! Our food is always delicious! Today I had a salad with crisp lettuce and a lobster roll which was overflowing with lobster. My..."
Diane Montone
"It was such a nice place to have dinner and to bring our dog. Food was awesome! Employees were super nice..."
Stefania Incandela
"Really enjoyed my fish and chips. The staff was very friendly. Our Puppy was welcomed and will definitely be..."
Bob Hamernick
"We love coming here. Excellent hot lobster roll and my husband loves the pizzas. They have been a bit short staffed since COVID. Very dog..."
Melissa N
"The food at Dog Watch was very good - panko crusted tuna and fish tacos. And it arrived quickly. Our server Mallory was knowledgeable, attentive and..."
Steve Bellmont