Your average tavern and food. Not much atmosphere. Service was good. Food was good. I had the elk burger medium with American cheese, was excellent and flavorful. Waffle fries were awesome. Onion rings were ok. Prime rib sandwich was good but huge. Cheeseburger was fine. Burger and brat patty was good as well.
The wife and I stopped by this place for a bite to eat and a few beers while in Sturgeon Bay.
We had the prime rib sandwhich and the onion rings as well as a few beers.
The onion rings were great! Awesome crunch and flavor.
The prime rib on the sandwich was cooked perfectly rare, and the aus jus was flavorful.
We'll be coming here again the next time we're in Door Co.
We were recommended this place and im so glad we did! It was great food, decently priced. Service was great for how busy they were. Still have leftovers for lunch today. The homemade breaded mushrooms were the bamst fried muahrooms I've had. 🤤
Nice environment, friendly staff.
They were very busy, so out food took long to got serve.
Cheese curds wit beer are delicious.
Steak sandwich was more flavorful than the prime sandwich. Steak sandwich one person eats and the prime sandwich is good for two, there is a lot of meat!
Hands down the BEST prime rib I have ever had and the amount of prime rib you get for the price is an absolute steal! While it might look like a hole in the wall from the outside, don't judge the book by the cover! If you are looking for an absolutely amazing prime rib dinner, you NEED to come here. I also highly recommend their cheese curds, some of the best ones I had in the area.
My only negative was it took a while to initially get our menus and drink orders in. That being said, this was a Friday night and they were pretty busy with one waitress that appeared to be running the show both at the bar and in the dining area. Once we were able to get our menus and orders in though, everything else came out quickly, warm, and tasted great!
I would HIGHLY recommend this place for their prime rib. There burgers also looked absolutely amazing and will without a doubt be coming back here again!
With a little confused about how to get service here when we walked in, because this place is a bar. It is not a castle, and we knew that, but it's also not really a restaurant until you sit down and get served. When you walk in it's definitely a local bar. The food was really good. I would recommend the burger here all day, to anyone. Once we got service and figure it out how it worked (you have to go grab menus yourself and then sit down and someone will come over to you), things were great. We did not have the most attentive server, but it was very busy and when we needed something she did bring it. Overall I can definitely recommend the food but the environment was just not what we were looking for that evening. It is a local bar, it's busy, it's loud, and the game will be on in the background. If that's what you're looking for this is the spot for you!
Yes, you can talk about the mouthwatering food (love the prime rib sandwich, soups, fish fry) and excellent drinks. Yes, you can talk about the exceptional service and fair prices. But what makes the Greystone extraordinary is the people who gather here- the employees, the old friends, and the strangers who become new friends. This is a gathering place where you feel a strong sense of community, where you feel welcome, and where you feel like you belong.
Great food at an affordable price with friendly and prompt service.
Ashley was our server and was quick to meet us and take our orders. Steak and stuffed shrimp was flavorful and only $20 which came with a side salad and choice of potatoes (wedges shown here). I also ordered a veggie burger with a salad on the side with a raspberry vinaigrette which wasn't overly sweet. Total cost of the food with water was $31 not including tip. The ambiance is laid back with a bar up front, but don't expect to be seated, it's kind of like choosing your own table. The decor is cool with a wilderness/sports bar feel. Large TVs displaying a movie in the back and sports in the front. Only downside to this place is the booths are creased in BIG TIME from over use, so be careful not to fall into it haha. However good value, friendly service from Ashley and Jessica, and enjoyable food. Definitely worth coming back.
Their prime rib sandwich is phenomenal. The service was good but our waitress had too many tables at once and was way overloaded. The atmosphere was great.
If their scrumptious Prime Rib sandwich is too much for you, you NEED to try their Peel and Eat Shrimp Plate. Jumbo shrimp cooked perfectly to order, I had mine served warm but they will chill if you want them cocktail style.
I order them almost every time we stop in now and I have never been disappointed.
I only gave 4 stars for service as they are always very busy and usually are short staffed. It is definitely worth the wait, but if you are in a rush, you may be disappointed.
Ample parking in the rear of the business. Even room for trucks pulling boats!
Had a great time with friends. Bartender Luke was full of jokes and fun. Food was really, really good. Our friends are there Friday night and wanted to come back. Thanks to all the staff. Wonderful group of people working together.
This is a great "no frills, no thrills" old fashioned pub. Lots of delicious food but the atmosphere is for an older bar crowd. There are meats here not offered anywhere else including boar, elk, bison, and venison and you are surrounded by their stuffed corpses which makes it tastier in my opinion.
Overall, been here twice and love it.
I forgot to take photos ughhh. Anyway hubby said burger was pretty good . I had chicken tenders with a salad that was good. It’s definitely a bar/restaurant style. Nothing fancy. Would probably return when visiting the area.
Definate dive bar which is great. Everyone suggested the prime rib sandwich. We had already ate so we didn't get a chance to try it.
Great food and friendly staff. The tenderloin sandwich is huge. The breaded mushrooms are the biggest I have ever seen! The mini corn dogs ate delicious, not sure what they put in the batter but it
makes them awesome!. Definitely be back here again next trip to Door County.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes