Best Lobster in Sturgeon Bay

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Kitty O'reillys Irish Pub
Kitty O'reillys Irish Pub
87/100 (2681 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Vegan Options
Irish
Pub
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Irish
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Late Night
Clam Chowder
French Dip
Grilled cheese
Beef Boxty
Chili
Hamburgers
Corned Beef & Cabbage
Mac and cheese
Cakes
Lobster Roll Appetizer
Fish & chips
Nachos
Duck
Pesto
Loaded Bloody Mary
Fish
Queso Burger
Pork
Basket of Tater Tots
Corned Beef Sandwich
Chowder
Irish stew
Shrimp
Dragon Eggs
Fish 'N' Chips
Fish & Chips
Lobster rolls
Beef
Guinness Black Beer Chili
Lobster Roll
Trailer Trash Mac & Cheese
Tapas
Fake Lobster Roll
Lobster Tacos
Fish Taco
Lobster
Macaroni and Cheese
Tacos
Pancakes
Mahi Mahi Tacos
Cod
Pasta
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Ribs
Salad
Corned Beef
Sandwiches
Shepards Pie
Fish Sandwich
Wings
Bread Pudding
Burger
Shrimp Basket
French Fries
Sit down
Bar
American
Pub
Irish
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Street Parking
Seating
Table Service
Live Music
Late Night
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"A fantastic find on the east side of Sturgeon Bay with outstanding food and great drinks. If you have a dog they are more than happy to have you and..."
Paul Berweiler
"Anyone coming to Door County should make this their first stop for food. Sit at the bar and meet other tourists and locals who are always friendly..."
David Riva
"Great time was had by all. The band let my daughter sing during their break so that was cool. The manager is super nice and, hopefully, he took..."
Faith Pristel-Miller
"Service, food, and drinks were awesome Definitely will go back, and will recommend. It was..."
Michael Miller
"Went to Kitty’s for the first time this weekend for my cousins Bachelorette Party. They made us feel right at home. Great food, live music outside..."
Jordan Mackenzie
"Love the place and personalities. Excellent food and service. A must stop in the..."
Amy Findlay
"Carter and Amanda are the best! Service is great and drinks are..."
Megan Rose Fox
"Every. Single. Time!!! Fantastic service, food and ambience!! Favorite restaurant, by..."
Marsie Hartman
"Great Food, good tunes and a friendly Staff=a Great Time at a great..."
Jim Boland
"The Lobster Rolls and Guinness Boxty were amazing! My husband and I had an wonderful experience for our first night in Door County. Our waiter was..."
Kelly Stein
"Recently stopped in to try Kitty's breakfast 🍽. My husband ordered the Irish Eggs Benedict and I tried the Tots & Eggs with Bacon (pictured)...."
Rebecca Fredrickson-LaCrosse
"Excellent place. Atmospheric, stylish, good menu selection, delicious food, courteous and quick service, fair prices. Balanced mix of Irish, Mexican..."
Dmitriy Fridlyand
"Absolutely loved this place! Gave it a try 4th of July weekend and we were seated right away. The patio is so fun and has a great atmosphere for all..."
Kelsey
"The food was amazing, we had fish and chips and some shrimps and chips. Cocktails the locals ones very good, the spicy mango one taste to much like..."
Vlad Slabu
"Nice little Irish pub. Service was great. Drink prices were quite a bit more than the other places in town we stopped..."
Ron Stone
"Great atmosphere, good food, and speed service. Waitress was really nice and our food was out fairly quickly. Great spot if you’re in the sturgeon..."
Shamoon Mian
"Loved the atmosphere, my 8 year old son loved the fact there was a stray cat hanging out around the outside area. Food was..."
kayla
"Shrimp tacos, beef boxty, chili and salad pictured. The food was good and after talking to Sturgeon Bay locals, this is one of the top restaurants..."
Mateo Nicholson
"We saw recommendations for Kittys on a Door County Facebook page, so stopped for lunch last week on our way to Ephraim. My wife had the pulled pork..."
Chad Travis
"A great Irish Pub for food & drink. Plenty of seating around the bar, dinning room & patio for outdoor seating during the warm months. They offer a..."
Pikka
"Great pub to hang out and a quick bite. Food was very tasty. We had the shepards pie, beef boxty, bang-bang shrimp and bbq pulled pork mac n cheese...."
Charlene Law
"Wonderful indoor outdoor setup. Staff was great, food was great, drinks were great. Do not underestimate their portion sizes, food or drink. The..."
Ed Li
"My family and I went here twice. The food ranged from good(at worst) to great both times. The service was fantastic the first time and good the..."
Makayla Lawrence
"Excellent place for a quick drink and snack in the middle of the day when we stopped in. It has that great small town feel, but it is still welcoming..."
Eric
Donny's Glidden Lodge
Donny's Glidden Lodge
87/100 (1942 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Steakhouse
Steakhouse
American
Soups
Gluten Free Options
American
Soups
Vegan Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Beef
Surf And Turf
Escargot
Dumplings
Cheesecakes
Lobster
Kabobs
Salad
Cakes
Clam Chowder
Lamb
Tuna
Fish
Cheesecake
Filet Mignon
Ribs
Lamb chops
Noodle
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Soups
Steakhouse
Accepts Credit Cards
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Television
Waterfront
Reservations
Seating
Highchairs Available
Table Service
Full Bar
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Mid-range
"The best restaurant in the Sturgeon Bay area.Definitely you need a reservation ,the place is always busy but worth the wait.There steak is..."
Mihai
"Best of the bunch. We've been enjoying Donny and Rita's food since they owned the Alaskan, and now they have a beautiful building and view to go..."
Luluthebeast
"Steak.. Best fine dining on the..."
Crustytrust
"We thoroughly enjoyed a wonderful birthday celebration at the Donny’s Glidden Lodge Restaurant! I particularly loved my artichoke dip with pita..."
Pam Myhra
"Recommended by a fellow at Simon's Winery. He was correct......this is a very nice place to eat out. My steak was incredibly tender as was wife's..."
Craig Ritchie
"We absolutely loved dining at Donny's Glidden Lodge. The food was absolutely amazing. The atmosphere was great. Our waiter was very sweet and..."
Katie Reagan
"Donny’s Glidden Lodge is one of my all-time favorites. Food is delish and the cozy atmosphere is unmatched. You can’t go wrong with a meal here...."
Lauren LeRoy
"Came here for dinner on a Saturday evening with a friend. The lake views are beautiful from the large dining room. I had a filet with potatoes and..."
Rochelle Didier
"Amazing, as usual. The steak was cooked perfectly, the service was prompt, and the view was perfect. The pics are of the garlic/shrimp appetizer,..."
Jeanette Fox
"A quaint rustic dining experience. Love the stone walls. Very inviting with fireplace and wreath during the holiday..."
Laurie Prince
"Several cousins got together for a weekend in Door County. Made reservations 3 weeks prior- group of 8. Our waitress was great, she told us the..."
Ann Piela
"Food was good but was surprised to hear they use a machine to cook the steaks. Sauerkraut soup was a real treat. Desserts were very good but not made..."
Sandra W
"We have always had great food here! I had the Queen Cut Prime Rib tonight, and it was a very good quality cut of beef. Not all restaurants serve this..."
Tony Rizzo
Nightingale Supper Club
Nightingale Supper Club
83/100 (2138 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Bar
Steakhouse
American
Gluten Free Options
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Fish
Beef
Pork
Lobster
Salad
Crab
Scallops
Salmon
Chowder
Cod
Ribs
Surf And Turf
Crab Soup
Cakes
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Bar
Steakhouse
Non-smoking restaurants
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Takeout
Digital Payments
Television
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Free Wifi
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Free off-street parking
Dinner
Mid-range
"This is an old school supper club, decorated in classic nautical style, complete with rope chandeliers. It’s popular and gets busy on weekends, so..."
Kristin D
"My son and I had a fabulous dinner here last night. The potato skin appetizer was like no other I have ever had, sliced skins covered with cheese and..."
Michael J
"The food was amazing, the creamy crab and asparagus soup was the best soup ive ever had, however we got sat in the corner and I think our server..."
kayla
"We had reservations for 730. Upon arrival, we were given a pager while they got our table ready. We took a seat at the bar and I ordered a Cherry..."
Jacqueline Vierbicher
"The food is fantastic, the atmosphere is perfect. Service was top-notch. They have a lounge area with a bar and plenty of seating for while you wait..."
Heather Romito
"Was in Sturgeon Bay, WI for an event last week and had the pleasure of dining at this lovely establishment our first night in - we were a 50+ party..."
Kevin Jackson
"Went for prime rib night and it didn't disappoint. Good service. Did not like the prime rib nachos. Beef would have been better. Also salsa and sour..."
Susan B
"Great food, Great Atmosphere all in all I highly recommend! Be aware when we went there, the wait was 1.5 hours on a Tuesday. It was not the..."
Robert Linz
"WOW. We are on a mission to hit ever supper club in Wisconsin, and this one blew us away. Exceptionally clean, beautiful updated decor, and the food..."
Felicia Davis
"Slight wait even with reservations. Bar atmosphere was nice though and helped pass the time. Stuffed mushrooms were AMAZING! Definitely would order..."
Natalie Seidenkranz
"The drinks were amazing. Highly recommend the door county Cosmo and the espresso martini. Food is also great. Highly recommend the bacon wrapped..."
Michelle Winson
"Firstly I would like to say the customer service was over the top, From the bar to the table every employee made sure we had our drinks , made sure..."
Jessica
"Salena provided friendly service. The pork chop and Caesar salad were delish. Old fashioneds at the bar prior were..."
Wendell L Summers Jr
"Super busy place, but service was quick and attentive. Excellent prime rib and white fish, crisp salad with blue cheese crumbles and garlic mashed..."
Mary Schaefer
"Sad that I’m not able to experience such tasty food more often, lol.. If I lived in the area this would probably be my go-to. We had a 6pm..."
Esmi
"I was very impressed by the Nightingale Supper Club. We did not have a reservation so we enjoyed the potato skin appetizer and drinks before dinner...."
Teresa Manthei