Best Oyster in Sumter

2 restaurant menus in Sumter, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Palmetto Oyster House
Palmetto Oyster House
85/100 (1143 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Bar
Seafood
Bar
Seafood
American
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Salmon
Crab Cake
Cheesecake
Tapas
Fish Taco
Sandwiches
Tacos
Burger
Crab Legs
Swordfish
Fried shrimp
Cheesecakes
Shrimp
Key lime pie
Lobster
Shrimp and Grits
Salad
Tilapia
Po' Boys
Crab
Cakes
Scallops
Fish
Oyster
Sit down
Bar
American
Seafood
Reservations
Serves Alcohol
Seating
Parking Available
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"We ate there several times while we lived in Sumter. Reliably good food and service. They get busy from time-to-time, but handle the rush. The..."
Paul O'Daniel
"Been here several times with family, out-of-town guests, and just the girls. I have NEVER had bad service - always impressed by servers' knowledge of..."
Kelsey Baldwin Reed
"Great beer selection and the food's good too!. Always the place to go for great beer, they have several locals on tap and a huge selection of bottled..."
Gsander0793
"Driving from Florida to jersey stop here. Dine outside since I had my small dog with me. Service was excellent as well as the food. Very..."
Olga Rivera
"Food was awesome. Great prices. Their only bad thing was the waiter told my husband he would give him a sign then did not give it to..."
Geri Mcgee
"Great, fresh seafood, with a friendly staff. Service is usually pretty good, but they do have their "off days". All in all it's a good place to go...."
Jennifer Bowen Rogerson
"The food was pretty good for the most part. Their crab chips were just store bought chips with minimal spice and the corn was frozen. The strawberry..."
Lisa Moberg
"Very good. Oyster are aways..."
Jim Howell
"By far, POH is the best place to eat in Sumter. The alligator cheese cake is unbelievably delicious. I am in town for just a week but have eaten at..."
Klaryce Bell
"Crab Tacos. The soft shelled crab taco was unique and outstanding! Not hard to find and great staff. Full bar and great beer..."
Dan
"Simple seafood for a reasonable price. Great beer selection with a chill atmosphere. Its no Red Lobster, thank goodness. You guys are doing great..."
Ricky Schoolcraft
"I has flounder tacos excellent slaw and sauce on the tacos and served with homemade potato chips. Hubby had flounder Reuben on an amazing marble rye..."
Michelle Van Der Wal
"Great beer selection. Good atmosphere. Seafood is good. Try aligator cheesecake (not a..."
Kent
"Great atmosphere with very interesting decor. We took the outside seating so we could get seated immediately without having to wait. Glad we did as..."
Al E. N. Lampoon
"Christian was a great waiter! Lots of fried seafood on the menu, but you can request grilled instead. Shrimp Grit-Cake appetizer was absolutely..."
G. Oakden
"DELICIOUS!!! We ordered the pacific island tacos, fried oysters, chicken tenders and fried shrimp. I took a picture of my broccoli side because it's..."
Al C
"My family and I celebrated my mother’s birthday at Palmetto Oyster Bar. The food and service was excellent. We had to wait for a little while, but..."
Robin MK
"The prices are great. Our waitress Darien was awesome! The food was lacking in the season]ping department but I couldn't complain because the drinks..."
Hillary Browne
Simply Southern Bistro
Simply Southern Bistro
82/100 (1044 ratings)
Restaurants
American
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Oyster
Salmon
Crab Cake
Seafood Platters
Sandwiches
Waffles
Burger
Waffles & Crepes
Hamburgers
Fried pickles
Shrimp and Grits
Pimento Cheese
Shrimp
Cakes
Fish
Pasta
Salad
Mac and cheese
Crab
Duck
Sit down
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Takeout
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"I would give this 20 stars if I could !! This was the BEST restaurant We’ve ever had! My boyfriend and I came down to Sumter for my grandmother’s..."
Shakieria Berry
"My first time here, the bistro was clean, with a spacious atmosphere and the staff was great with service and masking! 😷 We ordered the fried..."
Sandra E
"Visited Sumter and stopped fir lunch with some friends. Th food was great, with a blend of regular meals, and some specialty. Service was fantastic..."
Alan Szablewski
"Excellent food and service! I will definitely recommend and be back for more comfort..."
Krystal T
"We had a great experience here! The pimento cheese was tasty...we could have used more pita to scoop it up. We both got a special the ravioli with..."
Amie Holko