The best pizza in Ybor!! I'm plant-based and our server was more than accommodating. This is definitely our go-to for pizza and other Italian cuisine!
Not only was this the only pizza place that could accommodate an 11:30am delivery for a lunch meeting, they also had great customer service, called the morning of the delivery to confirm the order and showed up in the 15 minute window I requested. And the pizza was great, too. All slices were devoured.
I've been told about this place but my youngest son I was notified about this place by another family member. I finally went the ending of September I enjoyed the slice of pizza and brings me back to Brooklyn. I went yesterday enjoyed my pizza and honestly I love the way everything is. I like the fact that there is cute little booths an upstairs and downstairs little thing awesome. I like the fact of the garlic knots I would have liked it a little bit more and garlic and olive oil, but that's my preference. I love the cheese parmesan or Romano cheese on top. I am coming back my go-to pizza place definitely �
I’m from ny born n raised. When it comes to pizza � I know first hand. Tampa does not know anything about pizza until I met this place ny ny pizza . This place bought me back home yo omg 5 Stars � all the way
The best NYC style pizza in the Tampa Bay Area! I dream about this pizza because it’s that awesome �
Absolutely the best Italian food and pizza in Tampa... Fettuccine Alfred like real Italians make... Awesome...new favorite work goto place
I wasn't ready for how good the pizza, wings, and salad were!! Definitely worth coming in for good food at a great price!!
Best Pizza place we have found in Florida. We drive over from Orlando to eat there.
I updated this review from a 1 star to a 5 star after an issue was resolved with my first delivery experience with them. We had received a pizza after ordering delivery, and upon arriving, it looked as if it has taken a spill in the back of the car on the way over. I let them know my concerns and after a few days, the manager personally reached out to address the situation. Needless to say, the food was amazing and the customer service in the end was great. We will definitely be ordering again soon.
ALSO, try the wings! �
The pizza is really good New York style thinish crispy crust. They've got a great little outside seating area with the view from my pictures. The staff were all really nice but I didn't check out if they have gendered bathrooms or not. We'll go again although parking is a little tough.
While visiting Tampa I went to #UrbanTrivia downtown and this pizza spot was across the street from the theater. $3.50 for a slice of pizza is rare and it came up quick (I was the only person there, but they were fast). It was HOT & so good.
Christopher Carlos Tesvich Salazar
+5
The BEST New York style pizza in Ebor! Cool people, great service and awesome pizza!
A very great & delicious pizza for even greater prices! Came here for the 1st time with my family a little late at night and we had a great time. The pizza & customer service were great!
Was in Tampa for work and walked over for lunch. Ordered what was recommended, fried chicken alfredo pizza, was excellent hot and later in the hotel. Thanks!
Omg..The pizza is sooo delicious! Not stingy with the toppings at all! When I come back to Tampa, this is my pizza spot!
Absolutely the best pizza in Tampa!😮😍
I’m originally from the Bronx and I haven’t taste NY pizza like this in years! So good!
The salad and zucchini was delicious as well😋
I have ate a lot of pizza in my life and WOW the slice of meat eaters pizza was perfect!
Lots of flavor with a slightly crunchy crust and perfect temp. I’ll be back
The young man who rang me up was nice an
Respectful
One of my favorite slices around. The cheese sticks are really good and the cheese steak sandwiches are some of my favorites. However, the inside needs a major remodeling as it is extremely run down and nearly hazardous. But the pizza keeps calling me back anyways!
the pizza was not quite as 'new york style' as we would have preferred, but it was pretty close. we ordered garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and a large, extra cheese pizza.
the knots were bigger than we expected, which i think compromised the flavor.
the pizza was delicious, also a little thicker than traditional new york style, but delicious. the service was very good and the prices were reasonable. only downside for us was they did not carry coke products, but that is a personal preference.
Very close to pizza like home!! If you get the pizza and want more authentic style get a large or xl pizza...or by the slice. If the oil drips down your arm when you fold and eat, it's perfection.
Mozzarella sticks were fantastic! Cheesy goodness that just oozed everywhere and went perfectly with the marinara. Ordered the four cheese pizza and was defeated by its giant cheese goodness. It had a nice crisp crust that folded well, a hint of a buttery flavor, and all that whole milk cheese? To die for. For sure. Definitely left full and happy!
Love. Love. Love. And Pizza. This pizza is exactly what I been seeking in Tampa. A true NY Style Pizza that could be right at home here in Tampa or the Big Apple. The pizza by the slice is what I'd expect if in NY and the pizza by the pie here is a pure delight. And like a good pizza. I love the straight cheese the best. Crisp foldable crus. Bold sauce. Fresh cheese. Simple yet perfectly made in a proper pizza oven. This is Love and Pizza. Eeyore shall return.
Really enjoy their food. Buffalo chicken sub is delicious. Walkup window is great for a quick bite to eat. Slices and drink combos. Give them a try!
Really great pizza place we found in Tampa. the food lives up to the review hype. Crispy almost buttery tasting crust and plenty of sauce and its amazing. We ordered the four cheese pizza which is actually an overwhelming amount of cheese but we got what we asked for.
True not sent it to New York style pizza. Absolutely worth the trek to find them bear in mind not all locations serve alcohol.
we got fried mozzarella sticks to that because her and that cheese was amazing as well.
Fonzo Afre (Mr. Real Reviews)
+5
Classic NY slice 🍕 Simple grab and go or dine inside. More than pizza, menus got subs, pastas and wings!! Location is prime on west end of Ybor strip, can't miss it 👌🏾
Happened to stumble on this place! Service was great and fast. Food was awesome!
Ybor in Tampa has many pizza 🍕 places. When we talk about New York Style pizza, there are only a few places that make the cut. New York New York is one of those pizza places. Whether you are with some friends after a night out, or with family taking in the sights is a good place to grab a bite. There are a few beers on tap, not really a craft beer spot but there are a few popular choices. You can pretty much create your own pizza, everything from cheeses and meats are at your disposal. Plenty of diner style seating, a bit worn and dated but are you there to admire the seating or eat? The decor is what you would find at most pizza places. The staff was very friendly, and checked on us often. All in all, great place to get some pizza.
Pro tip : Military Discount
If your short in time, they have a walk up window..
This is the best pizza I’ve ever ate. I just wish they weren’t 30 miles away from where I live or I would order much more often. The pizza is amazing. The employees are friendly as well.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes