Best Ice Cream in Tarrytown

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Main Street Sweets
Main Street Sweets
86/100 (765 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Cakes
Café
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"This place is excellent. I take my family there any time we are in the area. You can really tell that the ice cream is homemade. Lots of flavors to..."
Robert DePalma
"We are from Buffalo and we wanted some ice cream. We googled ice cream places and this place came up!!! We were so please with the amazing ice cream...."
Kim Konczal Eberle
"Went there after dinner and the guy was so nice letting us try different flavors before we picked! The ice cream is always good! Love going..."
Joe Rooney
"I like to call it Main sweets in the streets!! Best sweets in town, amazing customer service, great prices, and addictive! I love it..."
MC Mel
"Best ice cream in town. Treats you like..."
Paula Marques Thaler
"Although it may sac- religious to say this, being that I am a head trainer at a weight loss facility, but this place has AWESOME HOMEMADE TASTY..."
Christopher Michael
"Yummy!! Still have thoughs about..."
André Izquierdo
"Main Street Sweets have Great homemade Ice cream. You can always count on them to give back to the community!!!! Yesterday, my friend had her taste..."
Matthew Gullotta
"This ice cream spot is right in the heart of Tarrytown. They have a large selection of different ice cream flavors and toppings. The servers were..."
Najeeb Abdullah
"Very good ice cream with tons of options (20+ with 3 vegan) in lovely old school ambience and tons of other goodies like brownies, lava..."
Alan Varghese
"Don' get distract by name, they have best ice cream in town. I love it. If you near Tarrytown, this is must stop destination. Milk shake is awesome...."
V L
"Nice little ice cream shop. Plenty of flavors to choose from. & sampling.We tried the cupcake & batter & Toasted almond. Both flavors were delicious...."
Christopher
"This place is fantastic. Your quintessential neighborhood sweets shop. Enough variety to satisfy every member of the family. The ice cream is the..."
Fred Lozano
"I was up in Tarrytown this week with my mom and we decided to treat ourselves to some ice cream on Monday...and then Tuesday and twice on Wednesday!..."
Alanna Conneely
"Very busy, but the ice cream was delicious, so it makes sense as to why it was popular! We ordered quite a bit since my parents had to wait outside,..."
Donnie
"Efficient staff, tasty ice cream, and a decent variety of flavors. The line can be a little tricky, since you have to squeeze all the way to the back..."
Suzanne Weiner
"Good selection of flavors and also specialty cakes, ice cream sandwiches and..."
Carrie Gomolchak
"Cute little shop! Love the mural on the wall. Ice cream flavors were good. Staff were so friendly!!! Really impressed. Please support this business..."
Yael W
Yogurt Le Crepe
Yogurt Le Crepe
85/100 (389 ratings)
Dessert
Brunch
Breakfast
Ice Cream
Crepes
Raspberry Dream Crepe
Grilled Chicken Savory Crepe
"This is now a regular spot for my mother! Everytime she comes to visit from Savannah, she is asked to be taken here to have her Famous Crepe. So..."
Naz G
"My hubby and I went here for the first time tonight and WOW!! The crepes were delicious. Five stars all the way! I think we found our newest dessert..."
Veronica Lanni
"Ice cream and crepes were amazing and the guy working in the store is very kind and friendly! Few days after we moved in to the village, we found our..."
DimiExperience
"Good crepe. Store needs to be cleaner since it lacks space. Counter area looked messy too. A baby bottle was boiling on the counter and a woman there..."
Kay Mcleod
"Amazing ordered the the chocolate chip cookie dough crepe delicious ! And the staff their are so attentive and nice. Thank you again for having a..."
Jennifer Glen
"Cake batter froyo & nutella froyo were delicious! 10/10..."
Joumana Kaddour
"The New Yorker crepe was delicious and just as described. Amazing Sunday morning breakfast! Only slight negative factor, they were supposed to open..."
Chris Parker
"Took a trip here more than once. Worth it. Great service even when I came in so close to closing. Crepes were fresh and delicious. Would've expected..."
Google User
"Went there day after day, delicious greek yoghurt and amazing..."
Milena Tamburic
"This place was amazing. We were the only ones in the shop and ordered 2 sandwiches and 2 sweet crepes to share and the staff kept the food coming out..."
Erik Chevez
"The crepe tasted amazing and the plating was very pretty! Placed on a mini cutting board was a really pretty way of plating..."
Ngawang Kalden
"Just had the absolute BEST açaí bowl of my life here. I’ve come numerous times since moving to Tarrytown this summer and I’ve really enjoyed..."
Dasha Beniash
"Excellent crepes. Even have gluten free crepes. Potion sizes are huge and the cannoli crepe is to die for. Staff is friendly and even remembered use..."
Chris Graffeo
Capri Pizza
Capri Pizza
84/100 (1238 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Slice of Pizza
Bread Basket
Bread and Butter
Lasagne
Mushroom Pizza
Ice Cream
Cheese Calzone
Gelato
Bruschetta Pizza
Pesto
Margherita Pizza
Sandwiches
caesar salad
Gelato
Pepperoni Pizza
Bruschetta Bread
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Chicken parmigiana
Fried calamari
Shrimp Parm Wedge
Sausage Pizza by the Slice
Cajun Chicken on Broccoli Rabe
Eggplant
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Penne Alla Vodka Sauce
Pasta
Stuffed Mushrooms
Sit down
Italian
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Lunch
Dinner
Mid-range
"Hardest working owner (and pastry chef)Frank Datillo has crafted this restaurant into his ever evolving home away from home to so many area folk;..."
Stuart Oppenheimer
"There isn’t a thing that I have ate in this place that I have not..."
Rosemary Pimentel
"My favorite neighborhood Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria over many great meals and special times through the..."
Paul Weiss
"The Best Food In Tarrytown! We love everything here, Food, atmosphere, drinks But most of all that great..."
Dee Dean Tardella
"Guter Service. Das Essen dort ist sehr lecker. Leider sind die US Portionen auch hier überdimensioniert. Ein Appetizer sättigt eine Person..."
Mohn Thomas
"Very nice atmosphere! Very professional and friendly staff! Food was..."
Dion Dashnaw
"Great staff, always friendly and efficient. Perfect �..."
Billie Barthelemy
"Great variety of food, wonderful staff and..."
Shauna Quigley- Blaze
"Capri has a very tasty pasta fagioli. I also enjoy the sicilian pizza. The food always comes out steaming hot with delicious pizza bread with the..."
Susan Paolantonio
"Best Grandma Slices around!! All around amazing..."
Blaine BT Taft
"Excellent food and service. Friendly atmosphere and..."
Natalie Rearick Herold
"Love love loved it! The people and atmosphere was..."
Jennifer Patterson
"Amazing food! Amazing service! Amazing prices! This is the place to..."
Lina Sackson
"Great location for fresh pizza and salads. Their house baked bread is delicious and fresh. The decorations on the wall alone are 5..."
Ted Diaz jr.
"We took a chance on this place and it was the best food we had all weekend! We were a group of 3 kids, 3 adults, and everyone was happy. The food was..."
Gregin Doxsee
"The Philly Cheese Steak pizza is surprisingly AWESOME. The young lady working the orders and registers has great customer..."
GPK
"Great food, best pizza in westchester & great staff. You can never go wrong here. Amazing homemade..."
Bernice Rodriguez
"Great slice of pie, service was fast, you can sit down and order or order at the counter, we all had different slices and we all loved them, I will..."
Ben Cole
"A neighborhood classic. There is a restaurant in the back that has cute seating for casual eating. The portions are very large and food is very yummy..."
Rebekah S
"Pizza is a staple, quick food option. I don’t frequent many pizza places, so I can’t say I am the perfect pizza connoisseur. However, I’ve..."
Philip McEachin
"Very delicious Pizza😍 good service👍 thin crust but not too thin where it falls apart. It was perfect. The sauce was really..."
Zaina Shtaiwi
"Place was spot on. Traveling through town for work, stopped for some baked ziti for the team and it was perfect Everyone had nothing but great things..."
Stephen Smith
"Excellent pizza with generous toppings. You can order by the slice and heated in the oven. Desserts are excellent too. The options are..."
Matt A.
"Great pie. Amazing crust. Wonderful selection to choose from. Visiting for the Yankee game . By far better pizza than downtown. Selected the steak n..."
Big Fish
"I have to admit that I do only like to review great places to eat. But that is because I'd rather great food stands out. And this is some great food..."
Joe Quisgard
"In a few words, awesome food. We ordered few different pastas here and they were all very tasty. I especially like the Cajun chicken on broccoli..."
abhisek mondal
"Wide variety of pizza with some great creative options. And do yourself a favor and get a chocolate chip cookie. They’re wonderfully soft on the..."
Matthew Fulton
"Came here for lunch. We ordered two dishes and the special pizza of the day. The two dishes came out relatively quick. However, the simple pizza..."
Kay Cee
"Staff are friendly, provide suggestions, and professional! I've been eating at Capri for about 7 years. Best food in..."
Damary Gonzalez
"We're from out of town, we picked Capri because it was close to the hotel. Turned out to be a great choice. Friendly staff, great food - and lots of..."
Ian Clark
Lighthouse Ice Cream Company
Lighthouse Ice Cream Company
81/100 (212 ratings)
Dessert
Ice Cream
Gelato
Wheelchair Accessible
Outdoor Seating
Cheap Eats
"the best. this place is the best. best ice cream, coffee, soup, and..."
Ian Slakas
"I got 2 scoops in a cone with Vietnamese coffee & Coconut chocolate chip ice cream! I also tried some of my husband's blueberry & mango smoothie! The..."
Cindy Ferreira
"The best ice cream I've had a long..."
Michelle Morrison
"Just enjoyed Creamsicle & coconut--fantastically creamy and..."
Desiree Ferenczi
"Banana chocolate chip is amazing!..."
Nora Hansanugrum
"Best sorbet I've ever..."
Amy Crabill Lay
"Ummm..."
Angela Walker-Hilliard
"Very, very good gelato. I highly recommend the ginger snap and salted caramel together. Coffee is also pretty delicious. They also offer pastry and..."
GDutchess
"The staff is very friendly. I feel love when I walk through the door. My favorite ice cream place on the east coast. Me my self am a world class..."
austin velger
"It was really nice to have a good Icecream shop near the park. There were vegan options and coffee, milkshakes and baked goods. I got the brownie..."
Tania Akhtar
"My best friend and I go here all the time. The service is exceptional. It’s a small place but very cozy! The view of the tappan zee bridge is..."
Naomi Golding
"Ice cream is delicious! We had Vietnamese Coffee, Cookies and Cream, Chocolate and Vanilla. Great fountain outside and the staff was very..."
Olivia Smith
"I love this place. It's never crowded and off the street. In warmer weather on can sit outside on a lovely plaza close to the lovely trail along the..."
Susan Angst
"Very quaint, little ice cream/coffee shop. The pastries, home made ice cream and coffee are spectacular. The staff are gracious, kind and very hard..."
Laurie Ford
"First time and it was so worth it. Glad we went last night to get ice cream.the kids loved they sundae and milk shake. My husband got a chi latte and..."
Damaris Tejada
"Love the bagels with creamy butter, the coffee that is the best tasting experience, the ice cream to die for and egg creams from the fountain that..."
John Tantillo at Marketing Doctor
"Very cozy spot. There's a gas fireplace and a few seats. Customer service is great and I really enjoyed the music. Glad that they have a few non..."
J C
"Small nice place, good help and good ice cream, limited..."
Barre Flynn
"Great spot for Ice Cream after or even during a hot day in the park. Small , quaint with a comfortable umbrella eating area next to a fountain. $$..."
Sue Hu
"Reasonably priced and delicious ice cream. I had chocolate and Vietnamese coffee. Service was prompt and friendly. There's a nice fountain and..."
Justin C
"Fresh homemade ice cream. Limited selection of flavors but what they have is very good. The raspberry and watermelon sorbets were very..."
Kevin Moyer
"My favorite place for a coffee and a little pastry. Oh and their soups are banging too!! And the ice cream really makes me..."
Justin Schwartz
"Very cute ice cream shop by the water. Employees are very welcoming and friendly. Definitely will be a frequent..."
Bertha