My family went for Thanksgiving dinner this year, and it was the best Thanksgiving dinner we’ve had at a restaurant … I think ever? Most of us didn’t order the turkey or anything, but those who did enjoyed it. The food was high quality and wasn’t rushed. None of our plates were dry or cold when they got to us. Every dish seemed like it had gotten the attention it deserved.
Don't let the outside fool you...this looks like a hole in the wall but it is delicious and a pleasant surprise! Shared appetizers that were fantastic and our waitress was so sweet! Sit outside and check out the big boats docked. Great place!
We went here 3 times out of our 6 day trip. We loved the food and the staff!!! Our two waitresses were extremely friendly and remembered us and made us feel at home. The good was excellent. We tried a little bit of everything. Their espresso martini is amazing and highly recommended. I suggest sitting in the dining area as the bar area can be loud. Reservations are recommended but we didn't get them 1 night and only waited a few mins.
Loved the food (especially antipasto), background music, and their famous delicious espresso martini. Tracy is very nice, caring, and welcoming. We enjoyed our time there.
Wow!! Excellent restaurant,
the crew were very kindly 😌
And the price be fair 🫶🏼
Awesome experience! We forgot to make a reservation and they were still kind enough to accommodate us on a Saturday night. Food was fantastic, so we're the desserts (tiramisu especially, as well as the chocolate chocolate cake). Strongly recommend... also, Brandy was a great server!
Dinner was great outside on the balcony until the two old women next to us started smoking. This restaurant is on the top floor. The inside is very loud. The outside is very romantic. Food and drinks were excellent. Don't be confused by all the other restaurants in the building.
Kat our server was amazing and personable! The eggplant Parmesan was really tasty! Food was great and tasted home made. Would recommend 💕
Does not disappoint. Eggplant parmesan was amazing. Excellent service from Sandy. Well run establishment. Great service and food. Made reservations to be safe. We will definitely come back. Oh, and the coconut cake was delicious.
We were there for an 80th birthday celebration and it was wonderful. The staff was exceptionally accommodating and the service was outstanding. We were a party of 10 and everyone was pleased with their food, still complimenting the restaurant the next day ! I would definitely recommend this restaurant for dinner and especially a celebration.
Wonderful finale to our stay in the Keys. Food was exceptional and our waitress Tracy was super helpful. Each dish was unique
Great food. Scallops were excellent. Awesome drinks. Efficient service. Outside deck for eating has a view of the canal. They extensive specials each day. If fresh yellowtail is one of the specials you can't go wrong in getting that dish. The 3 cheese filo appetizer was outstanding. The key lime for dessert was delicious. They have bottles of wines available at various price points.
Very pleasant outdoor seating available, by a small marina, not ocean view. The waiter, Mike, was outstanding. The fresh catch, yellowtail snapper, was fresh, delicious, and expertly prepared (grilled). Veggies were good, rice so-so. The mixed seafood dish (first item on menu) was delicious.
Took hubby for his birthday. The food and service were awesome. He even got a huge piece of coconut cake 🎂
The staff here is just as excellent as their food. IMO they have the best pizza in all the upper keys. All of their dishes is 5 star quality. The environment is great, the lighting is perfect. I had their Mediterranean style yellow tail snapper. The fish is so fresh it taste as if it just came out of the ocean. Whether you are a visitor or a local that hasn't gone for some reason, You have to stop by here. They have vast menu and no dish is a miss.
This was the best meal in the keys!! We have been coming to the Keys for more that 10 years, and this meal is without a question the best. We had appetizers and a lobster thermodore and finished with desserts. Everything was perfect. We even had some of the best martinis in many years. Our Server Nicky was fantastic and provided a great experience... I would give more that 5 stars if I could.
Only two times in my life of my 60 years have I enjoyed the cuisine more! That's quite a statement as I LOVE food and The Old Tavernier Restaurant provided an amazing venue and an amazing menu of gastric delight!
My family and I visit the Florida Keys almost every year and we love the vast selection of restaurants available, But after trying The Old Tavernier, we made it a point to eat there almost every day. The staff always greeted us with a cheerful welcome and honest delightful service!
After my first bite, I had to meet the Manager Andreas Kouskoulas and offer my sincere enjoyment of such a wonderful meal. The Greek Heritage of both the restaurant and most of the staff sweeps you off into a distant and wonderful world of Greece and her surrounding Islands for such a tasty and inviting dining experience you'll never forget and will always want to go back!
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
+4
Old Tav is one of the staple places to eat at when in the Upper Keys, however, I feel as though their quality of food and service has gone down the past few years. Don’t get me wrong the food is still delish - I finish everything on my plate but for the price I would think they could maintain the quality and give free bread with every meal. Service is on the slow side but your on an island - keys time is a real thing! Just relax and enjoy yourself. Make sure to stop in and try the food yourself!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes