3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Outstanding lunch stop!
Delicious fresh seafood rolls (sandwiches) - we had a Casa Mar (local catch) and a calamari roll. Flavorful and tender! The..."
Eva Cagwin
"Simplicity at its best! Cool spot with outdoor seating (covered, so no worries if it's rainy), friendly staff, and fresh fish. Pretty view, too!
We..."
Anna
"What the Fish - best place to eat near key largo. A the hidden gem. The owner has the best costumer service I’ve ever seen. He explained the..."
Hector Pina
"Came here after a long day on the boat. Very hungry, and the food was highly recommended. Parking was easy to find as we were in between meal times...."
CMB Caspanello
"Beautiful fish restaurant on the water with incredible fresh food.
Came last year so wanted to try again. We had the catch of the day ceviche and..."
Sarah Aylward
"This place is great when you are taking a break from a day of kayaking or really in general. The crab cake roll was AMAZING and the sauce on top was..."
Laura M
"The lobster roll is insane!!! If you’re eating anywhere in Islamorada (or anywhere near for that matter) you’ve GOT to come here. The service is..."
Valentina Tross
"Great food that was served quickly. A great find… why would any one eat McDonald’s over fresh food like this. I recommend it and will be coming..."
Sabina B
"I grew up on the water, so in six decades I've become a pretty discriminating seafood eater. I have to say that this little place more than lives up..."
mikeaustin1
"This was a fun little place tucked between shops on the docks overlooking the water. Outdoor casual seating only. The fish rolls are excellent,..."
"Excellent Cuban cuisine with a cozy atmosphere right on the water. The staff went out of their way to cater to..."
David Fletcher
"The mahi mahi wrap had a different twist. It was also stuffed with rice, black, beans, plantains and pico de gallo. The fried snapper was delicious..."
maribel
"Best meal we’ve had thus far. Great to watch the fish and the boats come by your table as you eat really fresh fish tacos and cracked..."
Jennifer Koon
"This place is a hidden gem and a must see. It tucked away on the water by the back of the marina. 3 tables are outside and right on the water. ..."
Joe J
"DELICIOUS food!! Such friendly staff and excellent service! We loved stopping here on our way down to Key West. Beautiful area to dine by the water...."
Morgan Perdue
"We stopped here after a dive and it was beyond good!
The Conch Fritters have a great balance of Conch and veggies. They're crispy on the outside and..."
Taylor Walker
"A little place off the water. Come here every time we visit the keys! Plantain nachos are phenomenal! The staff is awesome, and the atmosphere is..."
Ang T
"We decided to stop for lunch while driving in the Keys. The burger was very tasty and the Cuban sandwich was huge. Good value for money. The service..."
Born to travel
"Easy getting there by land or the creek. Great service & excellent Cuban food. Menu changes daily so it is all..."
Eliana Poveda, JD
"Excellent food! Excellent service! Excellent view! Had the Cuban sandwich. It was a good sized portion that filled me up. I left happy with a smile..."
"In the Keys for business and came in as suggested by a friend. Parked in the back with plenty of space and entered via the rear entrance. Looks like..."
Netmoe
"We drove along Highway one to see the Florida Keys before they disappear one day. We stopped for lunch after looking up a few places online. And boy..."
Rafi Setrak
"Going on a road trip down the Florida Keys and, luckily, chose to stop for lunch at Captain Craig’s. The tacky nautical decor and fishing videos..."
Maya Setrak
"We had dinner with friends. Food was good and fresh..."
Lo Ja
"What a great lunch and dinner spot in Tavernier Key, in the FLORIDA Keys! The Fish Dip is excellent, and the famous blackened fish sandwich is one..."
Drive Boat Ride
"Stopped here for lunch with a small group and it was fantastic food. They are in midst of renovating the restaurant but it's 90% done and looks nice!..."
Josh Preissner
"Nice stop between Miami and Key West. The fish was cooked perfectly and tasted..."
Mitch Little
"Enjoyed the famous fish sandwich with fries. Delicious! This was also the best key lime pie we had on our recent trip to the Keys. The merengue..."
Eric Virgil
"Omg!!! This place is the best hidden gem in the keys! Saw the sign for the “world famous fish sandwich“ and turned around and came back and got..."
Robert Greene
"Great service! So glad we stopped in for lunch. The Mahi (grilled) sandwich was very good with the green beans. My husband has potatoes and they we..."
Tia Thompson
"Not a very big place but the food is great. The staff was very nice and attentive. We had fish dip appetizer and I had to fight my kids for it, so..."
Jonathan Russell
"Best meal we've had in the keys. From Largo down to West over the last 7 years - this is the best stop for a truly local fish sandwich and key lime..."
Zachary Wagner
"Staying a week at the beach and we normally cook all of our meals, but towards the end of the trip we decided to eat out. The reviews were pretty..."
Tiffany Hill
"We brought in our own catch (Tuna, freshly caught) and the chef there really knew her stuff. She cooked our tuna 2 different ways both were amazing...."
Dennis Jindrich
"Great place we had like 20 people in a short notice. Kids and adults got fed nicely. Great service. Fried food though but kids like it. Pricing was..."
Ilona Nesterova (ILONA_TRAVELONA)
"Family visit to the Key West and had to make a stop at the Craig's. The staff was great, very friendly and had dad in had to counter mine! I was..."
Aleksandr L.
"All three times we have been there has been just right and worthy of a 5 star review for this hidden gem. The last time I sat down for lunch, decided..."
Schmoe Joe
"My wife had the Reef and Turf and I had the Captain's Chicken. Both were excellent! My wife steak was cooked to a perfect medium rare and her shrimp..."
Arturo Reyes
"The food and atmosphere were phenomenal!! Best Mahi sandwiches ever!! The bar waitress was rude and haughty. Kept giving us annoying looks otherwise..."
Stephanie Sandels
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes