Best Key lime pie in Tavernier

4 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Old Tavernier
Old Tavernier
90/100 (1683 ratings)
Restaurants
American
International
American
Italian
Gluten Free Options
Italian
International
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Seafood
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Late Night
Clams
Key lime pie
Calamari
Lamb
Risotto
Pesto
Tuna
Fish
Calamares
Oysters Rockefeller
Ossobuco
Scampi
Beef Carpaccio
Greek salad
Lasagna
Espresso Martini
Shrimp
Minestrone soup
caesar salad
Eggplant Parmesan
Beef
Coconut cake
Salads
Wedge Salad
Lobster thermidor
Chocolate cake
Filet Mignon
Jumbo Shrimp
Lamb chops
Veal Piccata
Lobster
Pasta
Eggplant
Chicken Parmesan
Pasta
Alfredo
Chicken Piccata
Salad
Escargot
Sauteed Escargot
Scallops
Osso Buco
Sit down
American
Seafood
International
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Television
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Waterfront
Late Night
Dinner
Mid-range
"My family went for Thanksgiving dinner this year, and it was the best Thanksgiving dinner we’ve had at a restaurant … I think ever? Most of us..."
Remy Stevens
"Don't let the outside fool you...this looks like a hole in the wall but it is delicious and a pleasant surprise! Shared appetizers that were..."
Rachel Seidensticker
"We went here 3 times out of our 6 day trip. We loved the food and the staff!!! Our two waitresses were extremely friendly and remembered us and..."
Jeep Cherokee
"Loved the food (especially antipasto), background music, and their famous delicious espresso martini. Tracy is very nice, caring, and welcoming. We..."
Iryna Poinsette
"Wow!! Excellent restaurant, the crew were very kindly 😌 And the price be fair..."
רועי שחורי
"Awesome experience! We forgot to make a reservation and they were still kind enough to accommodate us on a Saturday night. Food was fantastic, so..."
Alejandro Gajano
"Dinner was great outside on the balcony until the two old women next to us started smoking. This restaurant is on the top floor. The inside is very..."
Maria Hidalgo Dolan
"Kat our server was amazing and personable! The eggplant Parmesan was really tasty! Food was great and tasted home made. Would recommend..."
Courtney Morris
"Does not disappoint. Eggplant parmesan was amazing. Excellent service from Sandy. Well run establishment. Great service and food. Made..."
Lisa D
"We were there for an 80th birthday celebration and it was wonderful. The staff was exceptionally accommodating and the service was outstanding. We..."
Debra Manning
"Wonderful finale to our stay in the Keys. Food was exceptional and our waitress Tracy was super helpful. Each dish was..."
Mary P
"Great food. Scallops were excellent. Awesome drinks. Efficient service. Outside deck for eating has a view of the canal. They extensive specials each..."
James Quinn
"Very pleasant outdoor seating available, by a small marina, not ocean view. The waiter, Mike, was outstanding. The fresh catch, yellowtail snapper,..."
Schultz Family
"Took hubby for his birthday. The food and service were awesome. He even got a huge piece of coconut cake..."
Stasia Horvath
"The staff here is just as excellent as their food. IMO they have the best pizza in all the upper keys. All of their dishes is 5 star quality. The..."
Joseph Feliciano
"This was the best meal in the keys!! We have been coming to the Keys for more that 10 years, and this meal is without a question the best. We had..."
Tom Heideman
"Only two times in my life of my 60 years have I enjoyed the cuisine more! That's quite a statement as I LOVE food and The Old Tavernier Restaurant..."
Ron Wilson
"Old Tav is one of the staple places to eat at when in the Upper Keys, however, I feel as though their quality of food and service has gone down the..."
Taylor Engel, FL Keys Realtor (South Florida Realtor)
Captain Craig's
Captain Craig's
83/100 (1755 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
American
Bar
Seafood
American
Soups
Soups
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Salad
Key lime pie
Crawfish
Scallops
Catfish
Calamari
Grouper Sandwich
Chowder
Sandwiches
Cakes
Pesto
Tapas
Burger
Fish
Fish Taco
Grilled cheese
Tacos
Fish Sandwich
French Fries
Shrimp
French Toast
Toasts
Fried shrimp
Pancakes
Omelette
Pasta
French Dip
Sit down
Soups
Seafood
Bar
American
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Dinner
Brunch
Lunch
Mid-range
"In the Keys for business and came in as suggested by a friend. Parked in the back with plenty of space and entered via the rear entrance. Looks like..."
Netmoe
"We drove along Highway one to see the Florida Keys before they disappear one day. We stopped for lunch after looking up a few places online. And boy..."
Rafi Setrak
"Going on a road trip down the Florida Keys and, luckily, chose to stop for lunch at Captain Craig’s. The tacky nautical decor and fishing videos..."
Maya Setrak
"We had dinner with friends. Food was good and fresh..."
Lo Ja
"What a great lunch and dinner spot in Tavernier Key, in the FLORIDA Keys! The Fish Dip is excellent, and the famous blackened fish sandwich is one..."
Drive Boat Ride
"Stopped here for lunch with a small group and it was fantastic food. They are in midst of renovating the restaurant but it's 90% done and looks nice!..."
Josh Preissner
"Nice stop between Miami and Key West. The fish was cooked perfectly and tasted..."
Mitch Little
"Enjoyed the famous fish sandwich with fries. Delicious! This was also the best key lime pie we had on our recent trip to the Keys. The merengue..."
Eric Virgil
"Omg!!! This place is the best hidden gem in the keys! Saw the sign for the “world famous fish sandwich“ and turned around and came back and got..."
Robert Greene
"Great service! So glad we stopped in for lunch. The Mahi (grilled) sandwich was very good with the green beans. My husband has potatoes and they we..."
Tia Thompson
"Not a very big place but the food is great. The staff was very nice and attentive. We had fish dip appetizer and I had to fight my kids for it, so..."
Jonathan Russell
"Best meal we've had in the keys. From Largo down to West over the last 7 years - this is the best stop for a truly local fish sandwich and key lime..."
Zachary Wagner
"Staying a week at the beach and we normally cook all of our meals, but towards the end of the trip we decided to eat out. The reviews were pretty..."
Tiffany Hill
"We brought in our own catch (Tuna, freshly caught) and the chef there really knew her stuff. She cooked our tuna 2 different ways both were amazing...."
Dennis Jindrich
"Great place we had like 20 people in a short notice. Kids and adults got fed nicely. Great service. Fried food though but kids like it. Pricing was..."
Ilona Nesterova (ILONA_TRAVELONA)
"Family visit to the Key West and had to make a stop at the Craig's. The staff was great, very friendly and had dad in had to counter mine! I was..."
Aleksandr L.
"All three times we have been there has been just right and worthy of a 5 star review for this hidden gem. The last time I sat down for lunch, decided..."
Schmoe Joe
"My wife had the Reef and Turf and I had the Captain's Chicken. Both were excellent! My wife steak was cooked to a perfect medium rare and her shrimp..."
Arturo Reyes
"The food and atmosphere were phenomenal!! Best Mahi sandwiches ever!! The bar waitress was rude and haughty. Kept giving us annoying looks otherwise..."
Stephanie Sandels
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory
Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory
83/100 (5170 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
American
Whole Pies
Key Lime Pie with Whipped Cream and Meringue
Key Lime Cookies
Chocolate Dipped Key Lime Pie
Pretzel
Key Lime Pecans
Key Lime Pie with Chocolate on Top
Key lime pie
Key Lime Pie with Key Limeade
Limeanaid
Coffee Cookie Limeade
Meringue
Texas
Gift Basket
Candy
Key Lime Cheesecake
Frozen Key Lime Pie
Café
American
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Street Parking
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Mid-range
"Best Key Lime Pie on the Keys. We tried so many this week and last year. This has the very best smooth and firm texture. Packaging is very nice for..."
Egirl Kalamanani
"If you love key lime pie (like I do) you definitely should check this awesome place out when in the area. The pies are tasty and fresh. Staff is..."
Leidi Chavez
"On our way down to the keys we saw the "Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory". Lots of goodies inside. You can have a slice or a whole pie. The..."
once upon a design
"This is a happy place, everything on the menu is delicious, well presented and fresh. As you walk in you are surprised with so many choices is Key..."
Mk van Dalen
"Great pie! Great outdoor seating. Definitely would stop again. Ownership clearly has a lot of rules for guests, signs all over specifying various..."
Kamie Roesler
"This is one of the best key lime pies I’ve had. Oftentimes pies from other places are fake lime tasting but not these, these were light and just..."
Shawna Summerfield
"When I stopped for key lime pie I was not expecting to find this gem on the way to the restrooms. It was magical. Great for pictures. We also had key..."
Jenny Martinez
"Such a fantastic place to stop by on your trip to the keys. All types of key lime flavored products, like from cookies to hot sauce, you name it...."
Daniela Anaya
"I have lived in Florida for 6 years and this is the best key lime pie I have ever eaten. Even better than any place in Key West. It was very..."
Arash Yunesi
"I enjoyed a slice of key lime pie with a cup of iced coffee in the backyard garden. Very quiet and enjoyable space. Hope to come..."
Jenna Becker
Chad's Deli Grill Pizzeria
Chad's Deli Grill Pizzeria
75/100 (1595 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
Vegetarian Friendly
Soups
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Lasagne
Wings
Carrot Cake
Clam Chowder
Key lime pie
Crab
Cobb Salad
Tuna
Sandwiches
Burger
Chowder
Beef
Ribs
Dumplings
Lobster
Roast Beef
Pancakes
Omelette
Pasta
Meatloaf
Corned Beef
"I consider this the best deli in the Florida keys. Located right off us1 on the first key it is quite easy to find. The place is unassuming on the..."
Sam Root
"The food was so good that I'm going back after I finish posting this review. The bread was freshly made. Half the sandwich was already wrapped up to..."
Anthony C.
"Stopped in for lunch. Delicious sandwiches and friendly staff. They wrap the second half of your sandwich up so you can take it with you which I..."
Rob Chagnon
"I had a BLT sandwich and was thinking when I ordered it if that would really be enough for me. Well when my order came I was surprised the there..."
Patrick Stitt
"The food was great! But the calzones are HUGE!!! It was super busy and they still got all of our orders..."
Hailey Weston
"Really Fast Service and great sandwiches!! My first time to try them and will definitely try them..."
Gabriela Caparroz
"We were staying near Chad’s & decided to give it a go for take out. Our expectations were far exceeded. The sandwiches are huge! We had the Fresh..."
Amy Hunter
"My boyfriend and I were discussing what we would like to eat for lunch. We decided that we wanted Chad‘s Deli because they have delicious chili and..."
Ashely Jernigan
"Recently had lunch at Chad's. The women who took our order as well as served us was exceptional. Greeted us with a smile, was very personable. ..."
Derek Kramer
"Stopped in for a cookie! Workers seemed stressed out.. probably wouldn’t get the cookie again but i can’t speak for the..."
Natalie P
"This place has the best sandwiches and pasta salad in the area. I have had several sandwiches and my favorite so far is the chicken salad on french..."
Joseph Feliciano
"Under new management but still exceptional food. Regular size feeds 1.5 but large feeds a family of..."
Tony Allen
"Literally couldn’t ask for better food. After eating so heavily all week, this was a wonderful change of pace. Best club sandwich and pasta salad!..."
Nicole Giese
"I love the Keto option of the Pan Fry at Chad's. Thanks for keeping it on the..."
Danielle Harrison
"If you are riding down to the keys and need to stop for lunch or dinner, hit this place up. Great sandwiches and pizza(try the calzone🤤). I got an..."
Kevin Jameson