Amazing place! Known as the Greatest spot on Earth. The kosher dill pickle pizza is to die for. The cashier is super friendly and very sweet. The owner sings and speaks in the most Beautiful Napolitano accent. Great people great food
It's really the only decent Pizza Joint in Little Egg Harbor. If you order when they are busy, it's not as good! My food was a little undercooked but they were extremely busy so I didnt complain. But I still do recommend the pizza because it's the best in the area.
They do sell dinners and sandwiches, which I never tried before. Some things are a bit pricey, but its convenient if your in the area.
They also have delivery too.
Had a XL sausage and mushroom pizza. Crust was thinking and pizza was hot. Did dine in and pizza took about 30 mins to come out on a Friday night. It was about $20. Three of us finished it. Quite a delicious pizza. There's a reason NJ is known for its pizzerias. E
Incredibly nice staff! Stopped in on our vacation and Would absolutely recommend it and stop again if so. Thanks for your hospitality!
I have to say, this is the best pizza! I've had a lot of pizza 🍕 from different places and Mystic is the best!
I absolutely love the Italian Antipasto!!!! Highly recommend. It is different than most, as it isn't filled with lettuce and other fillers. It has prosciutto, salami, provolone mozzarella, etc. Well worth the cost in prosciutto alone!!!!! The pizza is good too!!!
Love Mystic Pizza! We always order from them...Pizza, chicken wings, subs, and dinners....everything is delicious!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes