Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Tuckerton
6 restaurant menus in Tuckerton, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Closed for the winter, opening on Valentine's Day was a treat.
The Cavatell Country Style was excellent.
Madelyn, as always, was super efficient and..."
randall h
"Looking forward to another great season visiting Panini Bay - ❤️❤️❤️❤️. My father is in love with the pork chop which is the best..."
Lisa Shanahan
"Kim B. Was great, food was awesome! What more can you ask for?
Mussels weren't the best...tasted a bit fishy. Presentation was great in them though...."
Timothy Shane
"Loved it! Food was fantastic. Ambiance was great. Our server James couldn't have been nicer. Will definitely..."
Christian T
"Very nice family run business artichoke and calamari appetizers were wonderful, spicy sausage and clams were excellent , pork chop asks a great..."
Brian Dean
"This was a superb restaurant! The view of the bay is beautiful as you sip the wine from the local vineyard. The menus were beautiful, the plating,..."
Kyle Lennon
"Great place! Everything was delicious - oyster po' boy, bruschetta, soup. And the view and atmosphere are spectacular. I want to go..."
Liza Davis
"Pretty cute place, very nice location and view! We came between lunch and dinner but stuff was very accommodative - Madelyn was our awesome waiter!..."
"Amazing place! Known as the Greatest spot on Earth. The kosher dill pickle pizza is to die for. The cashier is super friendly and very sweet. The..."
Paul Cerminara
"It's really the only decent Pizza Joint in Little Egg Harbor. If you order when they are busy, it's not as good! My food was a little undercooked but..."
charlie delaney
"Had a XL sausage and mushroom pizza. Crust was thinking and pizza was hot. Did dine in and pizza took about 30 mins to come out on a Friday night. It..."
Phillip Chapman
"Incredibly nice staff! Stopped in on our vacation and Would absolutely recommend it and stop again if so. Thanks for your..."
Vanessa Evenson
"I have to say, this is the best pizza! I've had a lot of pizza 🍕 from different places and Mystic is the..."
Anne Distefano
"I absolutely love the Italian Antipasto!!!! Highly recommend. It is different than most, as it isn't filled with lettuce and other fillers. It has..."
Lisa Pelton
"Love Mystic Pizza! We always order from them...Pizza, chicken wings, subs, and dinners....everything is..."
"Little on the expensive side for this town, my salad + pasta + cannoli came to $53. But they make up for it with HUGE portions. One pasta plate..."
David Moyer
"I love that they have a pepperoni cheesesteak on their menu! It's my fave! Food is always piping hot when you eat in! Hasn't disappointed me yet!..."
Lisa Sauer
"This place is the best pizza around! The service is terrific, all great local people working here!
Frank always asks if I am happy when I leave and..."
Dave Allen
"Very good pizza. Perfect undercarriage. No flop...."
Rob Uss
"Fantastic food at reasonable prices! I’ve been going to this restaurant for years and they never disappoint! Their food is always excellent and..."
Sandra Healy
"Great place! Love the pizza. They even offer a vegan cheese pizza which is great! Prices are average. Def gets crowded on popular pizza nights. But..."
"This is our family's go to place to eat. Portions are huge and drinks are great. A mix of American, surf and turf and many Italian dishes. I got 3..."
Will Salmons
"You don’t know Tuckerton? You don’t even know the Jersey shore. Heck, agreed, nothing is known until you step forward into the Light. Life so,..."
Michael “Newmie” Newman
"Not sure what is better...the food, the staff or the entertainment!!! Been there a few times now. Food has been perfect and crazy large portions...."
Christian T
"If you miss this spot it is your loss! Great service, great food & great entertainment. We simply can’t wait to return! Order the flatbread, it was..."
"Since new owners to over the service and food have improved greatly. People wanna complain about stupid things like waiting an hour for food. If you..."
Katilyn Modrak
"Just Wow ! Glad we tried this place. Got very tired of mystic island pizza and all the same food placed in little egg. The baked ziti tastes like..."
Aleks Kap
"On June 22 roughly 5:20 pm, i called about our order that was missing our bread for both my wife's and I dinner's. I spoke to the little girl who i..."
"We moved to town a few months ago and just tried this pizza today.
I'm very hard to please when it comes to pizza and mozzarella sticks.
And it's..."
Stephanie Minichini
"Still our go to place for local take out and eat in Italian food. Love their pizza, cheese steaks, wings, egg plant and meatball sandwiches. ..."
Jim Malone
"Real nice place to dine. Food was great.service was great.very relaxing. Will be..."
john rebimbas
"First time at Brothers Pizza and I got a large Cheesesteak hoagie that was fresh made and delicious. The place is very clean and the people were..."
Raymond
"Always wonderful food and service!! The slice app they use makes the entire ordering process soooo much easier and quicker than having to call and..."
Lisa Cranmer
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes